Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Charlton v Swindon - Player ratings
Comments
-
Elliot - 7 - solid without having to really make many saves, showed safe hands, distirbution a bit iffy, but he did only have 8, spread out people to aim at
Omozusi - 7 - Possibly his best game for us, not a grwt fan of his but he's doin a job
Llera - 8 - MOM, great at the back and superb finish when we needed it
Basey - 7 - solid, not much wrong, some wsted long balls but again everyone guilty of that
Shelvey - 7.5 Great finish, and could have scored goal of the decade, if after goin past 8 swindon players had put the goal in the net,
Semedo - 7 - wouldnt mind him diputising in centre defense with llera, not great in th air mind
Spring - 6.5 - just dont get him but he worked hard
Bailey - 7.5 Captain fantatstic
A Sodje - 8 - Ran himself tirlessly and scared the shit outa their defense, a genuine threat
Burton - 1 - stupid red card and should have lost us three point, luckly we got point0 -
just read back ppls votes, unbelieveably high marks, yes they worked hard and tirelessly but lets not forget swindon were truley awful yes we had 9 men and was a herioc 2nd half and last second equaliser but if that had been a half decent side it wouldve been a cricket score against us.0
-
Elliot - 8
Omozusi - 8
Llera - 8.5
Basey - 8
Shelvey - 7.5
Semedo - 8
Spring - 8
Bailey - 8.5
A Sodje - 7.5
Burton - 60 -
Not read all the other posts. Very hard to score the players given the circumstances. Can't blame the 9 for what the 2 did so going to score the 9 left on the pitch on their effort, application and skill in the game that was played.
Elliot - 8.5 as we allowed them to have the wings a lot of crossed into the box which he dealt with and one great save from a deflection early on.
Omozusi - 8.5 Gets better every game. Often there with a clearing header
Llera - 9 For that goal and the extreme effort at all times
Basey - 8.5 Solid and worked very hard
Shelvey - 8.5 In the first half seemed a little disjointed perhaps as we were playing a new formation and then two spells with 10 men. 2nd half he was fantastic. Holding the ball, running at them and of course a great goal (in the first half)
Semedo - 9 Great job a CB. Can't really fault him for the second
Spring - 8 If you want to be harsh his normal excellent passing wasn't quite top notch. Great chance to send Bailey away which he didn't complete and a couple of other times gave the ball away cheaply but an assist for the second.
Bailey - 9 energy and leadership all game
A Sodje - 8 For his effort alone. Won a lot of the ball and if only he'd had a partner to feed off the situations he created with his running. Big part in the first goal.
Burton - 4 Set up the first and was playing well even if he had missed what for him was a gimme. But for a player of his experience to get sent off in that was is unforgivable. With 10 men I believe we would have won that game.
McKenzie, Waggy and Dickson all did well. Great ball from Dickson to send Waggy away and nearly led to a goal
S Sodje. Reckless and stupid. Looked bad at the time and even worse on TV.
Parkinson - 9.5 Got everything right. New formation (is that plan D or E?), Was brave and right to keep it 4 - 3 - 2 after the first sending off and then 4 - 3 - 1 after the second.
Then had the brains and the guts not to go for damage limitation at 1 - 2 down but went 3 - 4 - 1 to try and get something and it paid off. Also put Dickson on when he had other options. So not the poor man manager that he has been labelled perhaps.
Swindon 4 We could have buried them with 11 or even 10. We were creating chances throughout. I would love to read Swindon Life's take on it all. Very ordinary team and terrible defence.
Ref - 5 got both sending offs right. Then seemed to not do anything else that might look like evening it up.
The Crowd 9 Really got behind the team when they needed it.0
