Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Loan Signings - From Crap to... Brap?

Chunes
Chunes Posts: 17,594
edited March 2011 in General Charlton
Following on from that David James column thread, who in your opinion is the best loan signing we ever had, and who was the worst?

Comments

  • CAFCsayer
    CAFCsayer Posts: 10,295
    Best: East... Jorge Costa
    Worst: Harder... Scott Sinclair?
  • cafcdan18
    cafcdan18 Posts: 3,664
    Jorge Costa- best and favourite closely followed by Carson and Song
    Worst- Neil Etheridge*



    *actually most of Pardew's but Cook and Sinclair stand out.
  • PaulCAFC
    PaulCAFC Posts: 857
    [cite]Posted By: cafcdan18[/cite]
    Worst- Neil Etheridge

    Thats a bit harsh - his manager was being a twat and recalled him!
  • cafcdan18
    cafcdan18 Posts: 3,664
    [cite]Posted By: PaulCAFC[/cite]
    [cite]Posted By: cafcdan18[/cite]
    Worst- Neil Etheridge

    Thats a bit harsh - his manager was being a twat and recalled him!

    Yeah I wasn't being serious, hence the real answer just below.
  • RedArmySE7
    RedArmySE7 Posts: 5,407
    Neil Heaney deserves a mention.
  • Shrew
    Shrew Posts: 5,758
    While thinking about the whole best and worst charlton loan I found this list of transfers http://www.neilbrown.newcastlefans.com/charlton/charlton.htm
  • Oggy Red
    Oggy Red Posts: 44,990
    [cite]Posted By: RedArmySE7[/cite]Neil Heaney deserves a mention.

    Can't agree there, Red Army.

    Heaney wasn't a spectacular stand out player, but his midfield graft and team ethic really tightened up our amazing playoff winning run-in at the end of season 97-98.

    Along with Sasa Ilic, Danny Mills and Eddie Youds, Heaney was a valuable member of the side that Curbs rebuilt with 10 matches of the season remaining. That's why Curbs picked him.
  • ShootersHillGuru
    ShootersHillGuru Posts: 50,676
    Best - Jorge Costa by a mile

    Worst is hard. Carlton Cole was a lazy arrogant player.
  • Starinnaddick
    Starinnaddick Posts: 4,396
    Omosuzi must be in the running for worst loan.
  • seth plum
    seth plum Posts: 53,448
    Costa...it will take something really really special to oust him as our best loanee of all time.

  • Sponsored links:



  • sam3110
    sam3110 Posts: 21,602
    [quote][cite]Posted By: Starinnaddick[/cite]Omosuzi must be in the running for worst loan.[/quote]

    Actually, he got better as the games wore on and wasn't that bad

    Best had to be Costa, but Smertin was decent, and Song too

    I would have to put Sinclair as my worst, but I didn't think Butterfield was a good call, that man stunk of Palace!
  • golfaddick
    golfaddick Posts: 34,332
    Smertin & Song run Costa pretty close.........and Carson was POTY that season, so wasn't a bad loanee either.

    Lee Cook must give Cole & Sinclair (2 Chelsea boys........makes you think, Doesn't it) a run for their money too !
  • Danny Addick
    Danny Addick Posts: 3,949
    [cite]Posted By: Oggy Red[/cite]
    [cite]Posted By: RedArmySE7[/cite]Neil Heaney deserves a mention.

    Can't agree there, Red Army.

    Heaney wasn't a spectacular stand out player, but his midfield graft and team ethic really tightened up our amazing playoff winning run-in at the end of season 97-98.

    Along with Sasa Ilic, Danny Mills and Eddie Youds, Heaney was a valuable member of the side that Curbs rebuilt with 10 matches of the season remaining. That's why Curbs picked him.

    Agree with that totally
  • Ormiston_Addick
    Ormiston_Addick Posts: 8,818
    Best: Alan Kernaghan

    Worst: Mike Small
  • Leroy Ambrose
    Leroy Ambrose Posts: 14,494
    Best: Costa
    Worst: Cook

    BTW - WTF does 'brap' mean?
  • RedArmySE7
    RedArmySE7 Posts: 5,407
    [cite]Posted By: Danny Addick[/cite]
    [cite]Posted By: Oggy Red[/cite]
    [cite]Posted By: RedArmySE7[/cite]Neil Heaney deserves a mention.

    Can't agree there, Red Army.

    Heaney wasn't a spectacular stand out player, but his midfield graft and team ethic really tightened up our amazing playoff winning run-in at the end of season 97-98.

    Along with Sasa Ilic, Danny Mills and Eddie Youds, Heaney was a valuable member of the side that Curbs rebuilt with 10 matches of the season remaining. That's why Curbs picked him.

    Agree with that totally

    I meant a positive mention, he was in the team that gave me my best ever day as a Charlton fan, that's good enough for me.
  • Clem_Snide
    Clem_Snide Posts: 11,807
    edited March 2011
    Best: Song or Costa

    Worst: Lindsey Hamilton, Chris Wilder and Iain Ferguson
  • Richard J
    Richard J Posts: 8,040
    A bit unfair Clem Rangers nbr three Goalkeeper Lindsey Hamilton only ever played in Steve Gritt's Testimonial and never let in a goal V Spurs . I think he even saved a penalty.
  • creepyaddick
    creepyaddick Posts: 6,152
    I thought Murty done us OK but would have to go for Carson & Song

    Worst def Cook
  • Friend Or Defoe
    Friend Or Defoe Posts: 18,182
    Best: Carson or Costa
    Worse: Butterfield

  • Sponsored links:



  • McLovin
    McLovin Posts: 2,307
    Best: Costa
    Worst: Butters
    [cite]Posted By: Starinnaddick[/cite]Omosuzi must be in the running for worst loan.
    After a shakey start wasn't that bad and wasn't really on loan
  • I-SAW-POUSO-PLAY
    I-SAW-POUSO-PLAY Posts: 4,619
    Best: Omar Pouso

    Worst: Jon Spector
  • uie2
    uie2 Posts: 4,596
    best:alan kernaghan

    worst:tom hovi
  • Oggy Red
    Oggy Red Posts: 44,990
    Best: The club's overdraft from the Bank Manager. It kept us alive as a club.

    Worst:     The club's overdraft from the Bank Manager. They gave, they taketh away.
    We could have gone into administration.

Categories

“Marketplace”