Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

PLAYERS MARKS: Championship: Charlton v Watford, 9th August 2025 (closes Sunday teatime)

124

Comments

  • Shrew
    Shrew Posts: 5,749
    edited August 9
    KAMINSKI: 6.5
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 7.5
    APTER: 7
    CAREY: 7.5
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 5
    EDWARDS: 7
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 6.5
    Referee: 6
    Subs:LEABURN: 7

    Knibbs 8
    Gillesphey 6.5
    Olaofe 7
  • last_line
    last_line Posts: 574
    KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 7
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 9
    APTER: 7
    CAREY: 7
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 4
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 4
    CAMPBELL: 4
    Referee: 4
    Subs:LEABURN: 7

    Knibbs 9
    Gillesphey 7
    Olaofe 7
  • stop_shouting
    stop_shouting Posts: 3,680

    KAMINSKI: 5
    RAMSAY: 7
    JONES: 7
    BELL: 8
    APTER: 9
    CAREY: 8
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 7
    EDWARDS: 7
    KELMAN: 5
    CAMPBELL: 6
    Referee: 4
    Subs:LEABURN: 6
    Knibbs 7
    Gillesphey 6
    Olaofe 7
  • Jdredsox
    Jdredsox Posts: 534
    KAMINSKI 6
    RAMSAY: 7
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 7
    APTER: 8
    CAREY: 8.5
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 6
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    KELMAN: 6.5
    CAMPBELL: 6.5
    Referee: 4
    Subs:
    LEABURN: 7
    Knibbs 8
    Gillesphey 7
    Olaofe 7
  • killerandflash
    killerandflash Posts: 69,857
    KAMINSKI: 5.5
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 8.5
    BELL: 7.5
    APTER: 7.5
    CAREY: 7.5
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 5
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    KELMAN: 5
    CAMPBELL: 6
    Referee: 5
    Subs:LEABURN: 6.5
  • AddicksAddict
    AddicksAddict Posts: 15,794
    KAMINSKI: 7.5
    RAMSAY: 9
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 7.5
    APTER: 7.5
    CAREY:  7.5
    COVENTRY: 6
    DOCHERTY: 5
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL:  6.5
    Referee: 6
    Subs:LEABURN: 8

    Knibbs
    Gillesphey
    Olaofe
             



  • Covered End
    Covered End Posts: 52,013
    KAMINSKI: 6 Fell asleep, but got away with it. Not much to do apart from that.
    RAMSAY: 9 Excellent.
    JONES: 8.5 Excellent.
    BELL: 8.5 Excellent.
    APTER: 7.5 Very good debut.
    CAREY: 8 Superb 2nd half.
    COVENTRY: 7.5 Decent.
    DOCHERTY: 6 He's average & the others are all better than average. Nice guy but not good enough for The Championship.
    EDWARDS: 8.5 Excellent, what a battler.
    KELMAN: 6 Pushed off the ball too easily & a quietish league debut.
    CAMPBELL: 7.5 Played well.
    Referee: 5 He was poo.
    Subs:LEABURN: 7 Played well and looked totally fit which is great news.

    Knibbs 8 What can one say.
    Gillesphey 7 Did very well
    Olaofe 7 Him & Leaburn caused them problems.
             



  • Weegie Addick
    Weegie Addick Posts: 16,527
    edited August 9
    KAMINSKI: 5
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 7.5
    APTER: 7.5
    CAREY: 8.5
    COVENTRY: 5.5
    DOCHERTY: 6
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 5
    CAMPBELL: 7.5
    Referee: 4
    Subs:LEABURN: 7.5
  • NabySarr
    NabySarr Posts: 4,290
    KAMINSKI: 6
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 7.5
    BELL: 8
    APTER: 8
    CAREY: 8
    COVENTRY: 7.5
    DOCHERTY: 6
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7

    Referee: 4
    Subs:LEABURN:  7
  • Killarahales
    Killarahales Posts: 1,057
    KAMINSKI: 6.5
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 7.5
    APTER: 7.5
    CAREY: 8.5
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 7
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 6.5
    CAMPBELL: 7.5
    Referee: 6.5
    Subs:LEABURN: 7.5
  • Sponsored links:



  • StreekDerek
    StreekDerek Posts: 352
    KAMINSKI: 5
    RAMSAY: 9
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 8.5
    APTER: 7.5
    CAREY: 8
    COVENTRY: 6.5
    DOCHERTY: 6.5
    EDWARDS: 7
    KELMAN: 4
    CAMPBELL: 6
    Referee: 5
    Subs:LEABURN: 7
  • GetYerCoreyOut
    GetYerCoreyOut Posts: 301
    KAMINSKI: 6
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 7
    BELL: 7
    APTER: 7
    CAREY: 8
    COVENTRY: 6.5 
    DOCHERTY: 6
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7 
    Referee: 6
    Subs:LEABURN: 6.5

    Knibbs 8
    Gillesphey 7
    Olaofe 7.5
  • stackitsteve
    stackitsteve Posts: 12,105
    KAMINSKI: 5
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 7
    APTER: 8
    CAREY: 8.5
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 6
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7
    Referee: 
    Subs:LEABURN: 7
  • charente addick
    charente addick Posts: 3,810
    lancashire lad said:
    marks between 0.5 and 10.0

    KAMINSKI: 6.5
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 7.5
    BELL: 7.5
    APTER: 7
    CAREY: 7.5
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 6.5
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7
    Referee: 5
    Subs:LEABURN: 7.5

    Knibbs
    Gillesphey
    Olaofe
             



  • robinofottershaw
    robinofottershaw Posts: 1,921
    KAMINSKI: 6
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 8.5
    BELL: 7.5
    APTER: 8
    CAREY: 8
    COVENTRY: 7.5
    DOCHERTY: 6.5
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 6.5
    Referee: 5
    Subs:LEABURN: 7

    Knibbs
    Gillesphey
    Olaofe
  • Amos on the wing
    Amos on the wing Posts: 1,802
    KAMINSKI: 7.5
    RAMSAY: 7.5
    JONES: 7.5
    BELL: 7.5
    APTER: 7
    CAREY: 8
    COVENTRY: 6.5
    DOCHERTY: 6.5
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    KELMAN: 5
    CAMPBELL: 6
    Referee: 
    Subs:LEABURN: 7.5

    Knibbs
    Gillesphey
    Olaofe

  • altrinchamaddick
    altrinchamaddick Posts: 935
    KAMINSKI: 5.5
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 8.5
    BELL: 8.5
    APTER: 8
    CAREY: 8.5
    COVENTRY: 8
    DOCHERTY: 7
    EDWARDS: 8.5
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 6.5
    Referee: 7
    Subs:LEABURN: 7.5
  • bertpalmer
    bertpalmer Posts: 1,774
    KAMINSKI: 6
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 7
    APTER: 7
    CAREY: 8
    COVENTRY: 6.5
    DOCHERTY: 8
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 6.5
    CAMPBELL: 7
    Referee: 6
    Subs:LEABURN: 7

    Knibbs7.5
    Gillesphey7
    Olaofe7
  • AnonymousAddick
    AnonymousAddick Posts: 19
    Kaminski 6
    Ramsay 8
    Jones 8
    Bell 7
    Apter 8
    Carey 9
    Coventry 6.5
    Docherty 5
    Edwards 7
    Kelman 5
    Campbell 4.5
    Referee 5

    leaburn 7
    Knibbs 8
    macca 6
    Tanto 7.5

  • msomerton
    msomerton Posts: 2,975
    KAMINSKI: 5
    RAMSAY: 7
    JONES: 7
    BELL: 6
    APTER: 8
    CAREY: 7
    COVENTRY: 5
    DOCHERTY: 7
    EDWARDS: 7
    KELMAN: 5
    CAMPBELL: 6
    Referee: 4
    Subs:LEABURN: 6
    Knibbs 6
    Gillesphey 6
    Olaofe 6
  • Sponsored links:



  • Covered_End_Lad
    Covered_End_Lad Posts: 5,725

    KAMINSKI: 6
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 7
    BELL: 7
    APTER: 7
    CAREY: 8
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 6
    EDWARDS: 7
    KELMAN: 5
    CAMPBELL: 6
    Referee: 
    Subs:LEABURN: 6

    Knibbs 7
    Gillesphey 6
    Olaofe 6
             



  • Nicholas
    Nicholas Posts: 7,631
    KAMINSKI: 6.5
    RAMSAY: 8.5
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 7.5
    APTER: 7.5
    CAREY: 7.5
    COVENTRY:7.5 
    DOCHERTY: 7
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL:7
  • BertieB
    BertieB Posts: 846
    KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 7
    JONES: 9
    BELL: 7 
    APTER: 7
    CAREY: 8
    COVENTRY: 6
    DOCHERTY: 5
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 6
    Referee: 3
    Subs:LEABURN: 7
  • Buglehorn
    Buglehorn Posts: 1,003
    Kaminski 6
    Ramsay 8
    Jones 8
    Bell 8
    Apter 7.5
    Carey 7.5
    Coventry 7
    Docherty 6
    Edwards 8
    Kelman 6
    Campbell 7
    Leaburn 7

    Ref 5
  • king addick
    king addick Posts: 3,702
    KAMINSKI: 5 not much to do but awful decision making at the end.
    RAMSAY: 7 solid as per
    JONES: 7 as above.
    BELL: 7.5 looks very comfortable on the ball
    APTER: 8 bag of tricks. Looks a good buy.
    CAREY: 8 hard working and will drag you up the field.
    COVENTRY: 6.5 tidy with some wayward passing.
    DOCHERTY: 6 personally felt he didn't do much wrong but wasn't massively involved either.
    EDWARDS: 8.5 thought he was excellent against a good winger.
    KELMAN: 6 isolated but worked hard.
    CAMPBELL: 5 no end product and if he had it, we could have won by 2-3
    Referee: 5 missed 2 clear pens, maybe 3.
    Subs:LEABURN: 6.5 looks lean and fit. 

    Knibbs 7 for the goal and proper limbs!
    Gillesphey 6.5 tidy when he came on, which is encouraging to show our depth.
    Olaofe 6.5 is going to be a menace and im here for it
  • Peter_G
    Peter_G Posts: 839
    KAMINSKI: 6
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 8
    APTER: 8
    CAREY: 9
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 6
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 7
    CAMPBELL: 7
    Referee: 6
    Subs:LEABURN: 7

    Knibbs 8
    Gillesphey 7
    Olaofe 7
  • Orpingtony
    Orpingtony Posts: 280


    KAMINSKI: 5
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 8
    APTER: 7
    CAREY: 8
    COVENTRY: 7.5
    DOCHERTY: 6.5
    EDWARDS: 7
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 7
    Referee: 5
    Subs:LEABURN: 7

    Knibbs7
    Gillesphey7
    Olaofe7
             



  • SteveACS
    SteveACS Posts: 376
    edited August 10
    KAMINSKI: - 6 I am only marking him this low, as he had so little to do. The mistake at the end was as much to do with Macca, as Kaminski. Poor communication between two players, who've hardly played together...

    RAMSAY:  - 7.5 Made the step up seamlessly. One of the best one v. one players I've seen in a Charlton Shirt. Ideal to guide Apter in his new role.

    JONES: - 8 Another who made the step up look nonchalant. Absolutely dominant in the air in both boxes. Nearly scored twice, and got an assist.

    BELL: - 7.5 Ramsay mk. 2. People getting the heebeejeebees over him doing the exact same thing that Kayne does. A quality addition, especially as he seamlessly slotted into wing back after Josh was substituted.

    APTER: - 7 The kid's good. Sure, defensively not as good as Small, but offensively much better. When he hit the shot in the first half that just drifted wide, I said to my mate, if that had been Small, a Watford fan would have got it in the face. The shot he hit in the 2nd half, the 'keeper had given up on. He was just hoping it was going to miss. Also, as a new signing, it was great seeing him geeing up the AC Stand late in the game.

    CAREY: - 8 MotM. Now, that's my idea of competition for Berry! Led the press from the front, harrying and hassling the Watford back line. Some brilliant through balls, particularly to the raptor. Ran himself into the ground. A big unit, too. An excellent debut.

    COVENTRY: - 7 Quiet to start, as the pace of the game was high, but, as always, his fitness levels brought him more and more into the game. Dominant after about 75 minutes.

    DOCHERTY: - 7 Game passed him by at the start, but kept working, getting more and more into it. People underestimate how good a captain he is. Cajoling, directing and demanding. Helped us to maintain our shape in the few times we were under the cosh. Best captain we've had since Johnnie Jackson.

    EDWARDS: - 8 Very close to MotM. We started calling him 'the shepherd' in the first half, he handled Baah so well. And still got forward plenty of times. Another who made the step up seamlessly.

    KELMAN: - 6 Not his day. Needs to play alongside a big man, I think. Needs to learn from Matty Godden how to drift off his man. Not concerned, as I believe he will learn.

    CAMPBELL: - 6.5 A bit of a curate's egg performance. Some great runs, but also lack of anticipation a concern. Summed up, in the second half by a fantastic run to get free, and then hitting a relatively simple pass so far in front of Apter, Usain Bolt couldn't have caught it...

    Subs:LEABURN: - 6 Looked sharp and dangerous when he came on. Much better as a focal point than Kelman.
  • Addickted4life
    Addickted4life Posts: 7,467
    KAMINSKI: 6
    RAMSAY: 8.5
    JONES: 9
    BELL: 8.5
    APTER: 8
    CAREY: 8
    COVENTRY: 7.5 
    DOCHERTY: 7
    EDWARDS: 8
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 6 

    Referee: 4

    Subs:LEABURN: 6.5
  • eastterrace6168
    eastterrace6168 Posts: 22,541
    edited August 10
    KAMINSKI: 7
    RAMSAY: 8
    JONES: 8
    BELL: 8
    APTER: 8
    CAREY: 8.5
    COVENTRY: 7
    DOCHERTY: 7
    EDWARDS: 7.5
    KELMAN: 6
    CAMPBELL: 6.5
    Referee: 4
    Subs:LEABURN: 6

    Knibbs  7
    Gillesphey  6
    Olaofe  6
       

Categories

“Marketplace”