Players Marks: CHARLTON v COVENTRY (closes Friday teatime)
Comments
-
KAMINSKI: 7 makes me nervous, but seems to get away with it
BELL: 7.5 looks like a Prem player for 70 mins, then tires
JONES: 8 as usual
BURKE: 6 still not fully fit? I expect more
COVENTRY: 6.5 works hard, but needs to acquire some passing skills
CAMPBELL: 7.5 as usual starts most of our attacks (but rarely finishes them)
BREE: 6 still not fully fit? I expect more
BERRY: 4.5 with anyone else there, we might have won. If we get a good LWB, JRC can play as a 10, otherwise Carey or Fullah
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 7.5 everything he does is good. He does not get involved enough but hopefully that will come as he trains more with the first team. Never want to see Docherty again
KELMAN: 6 tries hard but lightweight
LEABURN: 7 will improve if Rankin-Costello plays regularly. They both understand movement and disguise
Referee: 7 one of the best we have had, admittedly a low bar
Subs; KNIBBS: 5 If he isn't scoring, he is doing nothing useful. Has no ball control
CAREY: 5 took off a mark for an unforgivable 5-yard pass near the end, which should have put our man clear
2 -
KAMINSKI:6.5 Really wish he would come for the ball more
BELL:7.5
JONES: 7.5
BURKE: 7.5
COVENTRY: 7.5
CAMPBELL:7.5
BREE:6
BERRY:4 Tried, and failed, large responsibility for their goal
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 9 Just what we have been missing at 8
KELMAN: 8 Made the goal from nothing
LEABURN: 7 Won lots of headers
Referee:4
Subs; KNIBBS:5
CAREY:5
0 -
KAMINSKI:8
BELL: 7
JONES: 7
BURKE: 6
COVENTRY:6
CAMPBELL: 6
BREE:5
BERRY: 6
RANKIN-COSTELLO:8
KELMAN: 8
LEABURN: 7
Referee:3
Subs; KNIBBS: 6
CAREY: 6
Gillesphey: n/a
Olaofe: n/a
0 -
KAMINSKI: 7 some great saves, tendency to palm right into danger thoughBELL: 8JONES: 7BURKE: 7COVENTRY: 6.5CAMPBELL: 6 grew into it but very poor at both ends in the first halfBREE: 5 set pieces are killing usBERRY: 4.5 one of his worst in the shirtRANKIN-COSTELLO: 8.5 fantastic second halfKELMAN: 7.5LEABURN: 7
Referee: 4Subs;
KNIBBS: 6CAREY: 50 -
Kaminski 7
Bell 7.5
Jones 7
Burke 7
Coventry 7
Campbell 6.5
Bree 6
Berry 6
Rankin-costello 8.5
Kelman 7
Leaburn 7.5
Knibbs 6
Carey 6
Ref 50 -
KAMINSKI: 7.5
BELL: 7
JONES: 7.5
BURKE: 7.5
COVENTRY: 6.5
CAMPBELL: 7
BREE: 5
BERRY: 5
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 8
KELMAN: 8
LEABURN: 8.5
Referee: 5
Subs; KNIBBS: 6
CAREY: 5.5
0 -
KAMINSKI: 9 - some important stops
BELL: 8 - has so much time
JONES: 8 - another good game
BURKE: 8 - always looked to be positive
COVENTRY: 8 - worked hard
CAMPBELL: 7 - hard to judge as was playing out of position
BREE: 6 - weirdly seems to have gone backwards the longer he’s been at The Valley
BERRY: 6 - not his day
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 8 - grew into the game
KELMAN: 8 - did well
LEABURN: 9 - led the line well
Referee:
Subs; KNIBBS: 7
CAREY: 7
Gillesphey: n/a
Olaofe: n/a
0 -
KAMINSKI: 7.5
BELL: 8.5
JONES: 7.5
BURKE: 8
COVENTRY: 7.5
CAMPBELL: 7.5
BREE: 6 he played alright but set pieces were shocking again
BERRY: 5
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 9 Criminal it’s taken this long to finally play him Brilliant performance
KELMAN: 7.5
LEABURN: 8.5 caused havoc and ran himself into the ground
Subs; KNIBBS: 6.5
CAREY: 6
1 -
KAMINSKI: 9 MOM without his saves another defeat no matter how well others played ..
BELL: 7
JONES: 7
BURKE: 8 Been excellent last two games considering time out injured
COVENTRY: 7
CAMPBELL: 4 at fault for the goal completely fell asleep lost his man , plus again 5/6 excellent chances to get a telling cross in and failed
BREE: 7 much better defensively just needs to calm down with his final ball
BERRY: 6 never stops running , pressing
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 8.5 .. excellent
KELMAN: 7 leads the line excellently causes defenders major problem
LEABURN: 6 can’t fault his effort but does not win enough 50/50 headers for his height or hold the ball up well enough
Referee: 3 shocking missed a certain hand ball
Subs; KNIBBS: 6
CAREY:5
1 -
Sponsored links:
-
Ref 7 … what about the pen ?wolfgang said:KAMINSKI: 7 makes me nervous, but seems to get away with it
BELL: 7.5 looks like a Prem player for 70 mins, then tires
JONES: 8 as usual
BURKE: 6 still not fully fit? I expect more
COVENTRY: 6.5 works hard, but needs to acquire some passing skills
CAMPBELL: 7.5 as usual starts most of our attacks (but rarely finishes them)
BREE: 6 still not fully fit? I expect more
BERRY: 4.5 with anyone else there, we might have won. If we get a good LWB, JRC can play as a 10, otherwise Carey or Fullah
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 7.5 everything he does is good. He does not get involved enough but hopefully that will come as he trains more with the first team. Never want to see Docherty again
KELMAN: 6 tries hard but lightweight
LEABURN: 7 will improve if Rankin-Costello plays regularly. They both understand movement and disguise
Referee: 7 one of the best we have had, admittedly a low bar
Subs; KNIBBS: 5 If he isn't scoring, he is doing nothing useful. Has no ball control
CAREY: 5 took off a mark for an unforgivable 5-yard pass near the end, which should have put our man clear
1 -
KAMINSKI: 8
BELL: 8
JONES: 8
BURKE: 7.5
COVENTRY: 8
CAMPBELL: 7
BREE: 7
BERRY: 6.5
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 9
KELMAN: 8.5
LEABURN: 7.5
Referee: 4
Subs; KNIBBS: 6
CAREY: 6
0 -
Train with the first team?wolfgang said:KAMINSKI: 7 makes me nervous, but seems to get away with it
BELL: 7.5 looks like a Prem player for 70 mins, then tires
JONES: 8 as usual
BURKE: 6 still not fully fit? I expect more
COVENTRY: 6.5 works hard, but needs to acquire some passing skills
CAMPBELL: 7.5 as usual starts most of our attacks (but rarely finishes them)
BREE: 6 still not fully fit? I expect more
BERRY: 4.5 with anyone else there, we might have won. If we get a good LWB, JRC can play as a 10, otherwise Carey or Fullah
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 7.5 everything he does is good. He does not get involved enough but hopefully that will come as he trains more with the first team. Never want to see Docherty again
KELMAN: 6 tries hard but lightweight
LEABURN: 7 will improve if Rankin-Costello plays regularly. They both understand movement and disguise
Referee: 7 one of the best we have had, admittedly a low bar
Subs; KNIBBS: 5 If he isn't scoring, he is doing nothing useful. Has no ball control
CAREY: 5 took off a mark for an unforgivable 5-yard pass near the end, which should have put our man clear
Has he been with the U21s?1 -
KAMINSKI: 8
BELL: 8
JONES: 7.5
BURKE: 7
COVENTRY: 7.5
CAMPBELL: 6.5
BREE: 6
BERRY: 6
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 8.5
KELMAN: 7
LEABURN: 7
Referee: 5
Subs; KNIBBS: 6
CAREY: 6
0 -
KAMINSKI: 7.5
BELL: 7.5
JONES: 7.5
BURKE: 7
COVENTRY: 7.5
CAMPBELL: 7
BREE: 6.5
BERRY: 5.5
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 8
KELMAN: 6
LEABURN: 7.5
Referee: 4
Subs; KNIBBS: 7
CAREY: 6.5
0 -
KAMINSKI: 7
BELL: 8
JONES: 8
BURKE: 7
COVENTRY: 8
CAMPBELL: 5
BREE: 5
BERRY: 5
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 9 MOM
KELMAN: 7
LEABURN: 8
Referee: 6
Subs; KNIBBS: 6
CAREY: 6
0 -
lancashire lad said:
marks 0.5 to 10.0 please
KAMINSKI: 7.5
BELL: 8
JONES: 8
BURKE: 8
COVENTRY: 7.5
CAMPBELL: 7.5
BREE: 7
BERRY: 6
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 9
KELMAN: 8
LEABURN: 7.5
Referee: 5
Subs; KNIBBS: 7
CAREY: 7
Gillesphey: n/a
Olaofe: n/a
0 -
KAMINSKI 10, MOM, Fantastic display
BELL:9, He was our best player first half, didn't let them boss him
JONES: 8, Outstanding second 45,
BURKE: 8, As above
COVENTRY:7, Once Rankin Costello started to pull the strings he got to grips with it
CAMPBELL:7, A threat
BREE:7, Better performance but is he suffering from a knock on his crossing foot
BERRY:5, Didn't get at it after a slow start
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 9, He drove us forward second half and deserved his applause when subbed
KELMAN: 7, One of those who had a much better second half
LEABURN:9, Absolutely won everything in the air and run himself into the ground
Referee:6,
Subs; KNIBBS: 7, Decent and I always fancy him to score when given a chance
CAREY:6, Could have done better when we broke on them
Gillesphey: n/a
Olaofe: n/a
0 -
KAMINSKI: 8 probably 3 or 4 class saves including a double save. Doesn’t parry the ball out into safe positions but the saves helped us get a point today
BELL: 7.5 solid throughout. So calm on the ball
JONES: 7.5 solid again
BURKE: 7.5 solid again. Got into dangerous positions
COVENTRY: 7 improved as the game went on. Does that dirty work so well. Covers positions
CAMPBELL: 7 first half kept getting caught so high up the pitch. They exploited that space well and scored from it. Made a recovering tackle which sparked him into life. Second half, decided to take his man on and got the better of him
BREE: 6.5 set pieces still not great. Defensively better than Campbell. -0.5 for so many wasted set pieces
BERRY: 6 worked hard but just off the pace a bit. Had that bicycle kick of gone in, I would have given him a 10
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 9.5 MOM. Worked so hard all game to the point where he was dead on his feet. Got the winning goal… that run must’ve been so painful. Front footed, calm and composed. His spot to lose
KELMAN: 7 took a while to grow into the game but end of the first half/second half he was chasing lost causes and causing them issues
LEABURN: 8 thought he was superb again. Ran a lot, won every header. Performance deserved a goal
Referee: 2.5 missed a certain penalty. In real time I thought that should have been a 2nd yellow for Kitching on Leaburn and that was a naughty challenge on JRC. Extra 0.5 given for stretching JRC’s calf when he had cramp
Subs; KNIBBS: 6.5 picked up a good yellow card. Feel like he can always do more though
CAREY: 5 was running like he had played 180 minutes in the space of 3 days when he hasn’t. Had the chance to put Knibbs through and fluffed it
Gillesphey: n/a
Olaofe: n/a if I could score him, I’d describe his performance as the exact same as Carey
0 -
At the game
KAMINSKI: 7
BELL: 7
JONES: 8
BURKE: 7
COVENTRY: 8
CAMPBELL: 7
BREE: 6
BERRY: 6
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 8.5
KELMAN: 7
LEABURN: 7.5
Referee:
Subs; KNIBBS: 6.5
CAREY: 6
0 -
Sponsored links:
-
marks 0.5 to 10.0 please
KAMINSKI: 6.5
BELL: 8.5
JONES: 8.5
BURKE: 7.5
COVENTRY: 7.5
CAMPBELL: 7.5
BREE: 6
BERRY: 6
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 9
KELMAN: 8
LEABURN: 8
Referee: 3
Subs; KNIBBS:
CAREY:
Gillesphey: n/a
Olaofe: n/a
0 -
KAMINSKI: 7.5
BELL: 8
JONES: 7
BURKE: 7
COVENTRY: 7
CAMPBELL: 7.5
BREE: 6
BERRY: 6
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 8
KELMAN:7
LEABURN: 6.5
Referee:6
Subs; KNIBBS: 6
CAREY:6
0 -
KAMINSKI: 7
BELL: 8
JONES: 8
BURKE: 6
COVENTRY: 8
CAMPBELL: 7
BREE: 5
BERRY: 6
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 9
KELMAN: 8
LEABURN: 7
Referee: 3
Subs; KNIBBS: 6
CAREY: 6
0 -
KAMINSKI: 7.5
BELL: 8
JONES: 8
BURKE: 8
COVENTRY: 6.5
CAMPBELL: 6
BREE: 5.5
BERRY: 5.5
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 8.5
KELMAN: 7.5
LEABURN: 7Referee: 3
Subs; KNIBBS: 7
CAREY: 60 -
KAMINSKI: 7
BELL: 8.5
JONES: 9
BURKE: 8
COVENTRY: 7.5
CAMPBELL: 6 please pass to a red shirt
BREE: 4 still good bye he now bottles corners has to go soon beginning to resllly hate the dude
BERRY: 5 hard work but he isn’t a 10
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 9.5 great gams Joe
KELMAN: 8 good game created lots of problems
LEABURN: 7 worked hard but can’t seem to link okay
Referee:5
0 -
KAMINSKI: 7
BELL: 7
JONES: 7.5
BURKE: 7
COVENTRY: 7
CAMPBELL: 7
BREE: 6 worked hard but set pieces were mostly terrible
BERRY: 5
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 8
KELMAN: 6.5
LEABURN: 7
Referee: 5
Subs; KNIBBS: 6
CAREY: 6
0 -
KAMINSKI: 8
BELL: 8
JONES: 8
BURKE: 8
COVENTRY: 8
CAMPBELL: 8
BREE: 7
BERRY: 7
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 8
KELMAN: 8
LEABURN:9
0 -
lancashire lad said:
marks 0.5 to 10.0 please
KAMINSKI: 8
BELL: 7.5
JONES: 8
BURKE: 7
COVENTRY: 7
CAMPBELL: 6
BREE: 5 will he ever take a decent cross
BERRY: 6
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 8.5
KELMAN: 8
LEABURN: 7
Referee: 5
Subs; KNIBBS: 6
CAREY: 5
Gillesphey: n/a
Olaofe: n/a
0 -
KAMINSKI:8.5 some great saves to keep us in it
BELL:8.5 cool head and turns against players well
JONES:9 absolute Warrior
BURKE:8.5 very good game
COVENTRY:7.5 some good play 2nd half, needs to study Steven Gerrard a bit
CAMPBELL:7.5 Grew into the game especially 2nd half was good.
BREE:7.5 some good work and play but his corners are suspect
BERRY:6 thought he should have been subbed earlier but pity that bicycle kick wasn't on target
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 10 MOM what a great performance, Coventry can learn a lot from him
KELMAN:8 grew into the game and became a 2nd half menace
LEABURN:8.worked very hard but needs some goals
Referee:1 should have worn a sky blue top
Subs; KNIBBS:6.5 took a yellow for the cause
CAREY:6 sort yourself out
Gillesphey: n/a
Olaofe: n/.
0 -
KAMINSKI: 8
BELL: 7.5
JONES: 7.5
BURKE: 7
COVENTRY: 7
CAMPBELL: 7
BREE: 6.5
BERRY: 6.5
RANKIN-COSTELLO: 8.5
KELMAN: 7.5
LEABURN: 6.5
Referee: 3
Subs; KNIBBS: 6
CAREY: 6
0
