Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Charlton 1 - 0 MK Dons - Player ratings

edited September 2010 in General Charlton
For those at the game, ratings out of ten, half marks allowed. Copy and paste the below:

Worner -
Francis -
Doherty -
Fortune -
Fry -
Wagstaff -
Semedo -
Racon -
Jackson -
Martin -
Benson -

n/a Abbott -
n/a Reid -
«13

Comments

  • Worner - 7.5
    Francis - 7
    Doherty - 7
    Fortune - 7
    Fry - 7
    Wagstaff - 5
    Semedo - 7.5
    Racon - 8
    Jackson - 7
    Martin - 7
    Benson - 7.5

    n/a Abbott - 7
    n/a Reid - 8
  • Worner - 7
    Francis - 7
    Doherty - 7
    Fortune - 7.5
    Fry - 7
    Wagstaff - 6
    Semedo - 7.5
    Racon - 8
    Jackson - 7
    Martin - 7
    Benson - 7.5
  • edited September 2010
    Worner - 7 untroubled
    Francis - 7 one of his better matches
    Doherty - 7 solid
    Fortune - 9 his presence made up for Daillys absence
    Fry - 7 looks comfortable
    Wagstaff - 5 consistantly inconsistant. little contribution since wonder show at Orient
    Semedo - 7 solid
    Racon - 7 starting to look a lot more influential
    Jackson - 6 personally would like to see him played in midfield
    Martin - 6 unquestionable workrate, questionable end product. needs to use brain more when presented with final ball option
    Benson - 7 first glimpse of John Stills words "put the ball in front of him and he will score"

    n/a Abbott - 6 not really involved
    n/a Reid - 8 great little cameo and cross for goal
  • Worner - 7
    Francis - 5
    Doherty - 6
    Fortune - 7
    Fry - 7
    Wagstaff - 6
    Semedo -7
    Racon -8
    Jackson - 7
    Martin - 7
    Benson - 7
  • Worner - 7 - No mistakes
    Francis - 7 - continues to improve
    Doherty - 6.5 - steady, looks sluggish at times though
    Fortune - 6.5 - nothing spectacular, solid and dependable, calm on the ball
    Fry - 6.5 - Solid defensively, useful going forward
    Wagstaff - 6 - worked hard, quiet game though
    Semedo - 7.5 - Best performance of the season, looked more like the Semedo of last season
    Racon - 7.5 - Hopefully finally ready to realise potential
    Jackson - 6.5 - Looking like a consistent performer
    Martin - 7 - A bit more confidence and composure and he will win matches for us
    Benson - 7 - Neat touches and good movement, tidy finish

    Abbott - 6 - worked hard and put himself about
    Reid - 8.5 - Changed the game, set up the goal, created more in ten minutes than the rest of the side managed in the previous 80.

    Referee - 0 - Should have sent off Dons defender for cynical first half foul on Martin, missed strong penalty shouts, foul on Charlton player = MK Dons freekick, foul on MK player equals Charlton freekick. Rubbish.
  • Worner - 7 looks assured
    Francis - 6 not great again.
    Doherty - 6.5 not bad
    Fortune - 7.5 great to have him back. Looked very comfortable will get better - the answer to the leaking defence.
    Fry - 7 good solid game
    Wagstaff - 6 could not get into the game, rightfully substituted
    Semedo - 7 solid as usual
    Racon - 7 looked great first half and thought we had our old Racon back but faded in the second half. Still encouraging
    Jackson - 6 Not involved much
    Martin - 7 I have never seen someone run so much as he does. End product could be better but a threat
    Benson - 7 Makes intelligent runs and works very hard. Delighted he scored the goal and hope the confidence will now flow. He's no Mendonca but could be valuable at this level.
  • Worner - 7
    Francis - 5 Distribution is woeful
    Doherty - 7
    Fortune - 7
    Fry - 7.5
    Wagstaff - 6
    Semedo - 7.5
    Racon - 8 MOM. I think Racon and Semedo will always play better with two more defensively minded wide players. For those who want Reid and Martin out wide beware the effect on the central midfield players.
    Jackson - 7
    Martin - 6.5
    Benson - 7
  • Worner - 6.5 Clean sheet, good shot stopper but is he too small to catch the ball?
    Francis -6 He looks awkward, not sure if he starts if Solly is fit
    Doherty - 6.5 They didn't score so he did his job
    Fortune - 6.5 As above, better than Llera though
    Fry - 7 Gets forward a bit more than Jackson as full back
    Wagstaff - 5.5 Offered nothing
    Semedo - 6 Did okay, lost it a few times but also won the ball a few times, should've scored his first Valley goal
    Racon - 7.5 Been getting involved and making things happen, also broke up the play and got us attacking a few times
    Jackson - 6.5 Okay
    Martin - 7 Tried hard never stopped running, has a good touch just needs to look up more as theres usually a pass available to him
    Benson - 7 Worked hard and won us the game in the end

    n/a Abbott - 6.5 Did okay, gets an extra half mark for the tunnel jump
    n/a Reid - 7.5 Changed the game with his pace.
  • Worner - 6.5
    Francis - 6.5 - some good headed clearances and battling on the right.
    Doherty - 6 - fine defensively but distribution poor; Semedo and Racon need to come short to collect the ball from him.
    Fortune - 7.5 - stuck tight to the strikers and didn't put a foot wrong really. Would be a higher mark, but he wasn't tested much.
    Fry - 6 - remain unconvinced. Can't tell if he's a left back or centre back.
    Wagstaff - 5 - anonymous.
    Semedo - 6.5 - good closing down and got forward more than normal. Should've done better with his one on one but a good drive from distance just before that chance.
    Racon - 7 - much strong in the tackle compared to normal. Excellent swan dive in the first half.
    Jackson - 7 - surprised he was substituted. Would've taken off Fry and moved JJ back to left back.
    Martin - 5 - so involved in the play yet constantly made incorrect decisions. Cut out the pointless Cruyff turns and keep it simple.
    Benson - 7 - some nice touches, some bad ones, but good closing down and a nice finish. Had 3 chances, took 1 of them- think that ratio will improve over time.

    n/a Abbott - 5.5
    n/a Reid - 8
  • Worner - 6.5 cut the flapping out and you'll be our no.1
    Francis - 6
    Doherty - 6.5
    Fortune - 6.5
    Fry - 6.5
    Wagstaff - 5.5
    Semedo - 6.5
    Racon - 7
    Jackson - 6.5
    Martin - 6.5
    Benson - 7
  • Sponsored links:


  • Worner - 7
    Francis - 6
    Doherty - 6.5
    Fortune - 7
    Fry - 6.5
    Wagstaff - 5
    Semedo - 7.5
    Racon - 8
    Jackson - 6.5
    Martin - 6.5
    Benson - 7

    n/a Abbott - 6
    n/a Reid - 8
  • Worner - 6.5 not tested
    Francis - 5.5 makes an 'easy' position look hard
    Doherty - 6.5 comfortable
    Fortune - 7 had a cuban on all game
    Fry - 6.5 decent
    Wagstaff - 5 poor, never got in game.
    Semedo - 7 excellent without the ball, sloppy at times with it
    Racon - 7 first half an 8, second a 6
    Jackson - 6.5 decent but for me a better left back
    Martin - 6.5 in and out
    Benson - 7 worked hard, took goal well, service is shite

    n/a Abbott - 6 not long enough
    n/a Reid - 8 game changer. only player in the squad that can do what he does
  • Worner - 6 - very little to do. Lack of presence a slight worry. Flapped at a couple again.
    Francis - 6.5 - steady and getting better.
    Doherty - 6.5 - rarely troubled
    Fortune - 6.5 - as above
    Fry - 6.5 - as above
    Wagstaff - 4.5 - weak link. Totally anonymous.
    Semedo - 7.5 - much improved
    Racon - 8 - best game of the season
    Jackson - 6.5 - looked better balanced with him on the left.
    Martin - 6 - frustrating night. Worked hard.
    Benson - 7 - hopefully first of many.

    Abbott - 5
    Reid - 7 - good cameo.
  • Worner - 7
    Francis - 6
    Doherty - 7
    Fortune - 7
    Fry - 6
    Wagstaff - 6
    Semedo - 8
    Racon - 8
    Jackson - 7
    Martin - 6
    Benson - 7

    Abbott - 6
    Reid - 8
  • Worner - 6
    Francis - 6
    Doherty - 6.5
    Fortune - 7
    Fry - 6.5
    Wagstaff 5.5-
    Semedo - 7.5
    Racon - 7
    Jackson - 6.5
    Martin - 6.5
    Benson - 7

    n/a Abbott - 5
    n/a Reid 7.5
  • Worner - 7 thought the "high catch" in 2nd half was a bit of quality
    Francis - 6 Not sure what he brings to the party, but steady enough.
    Doherty - 6 looked a lot more relaxed with a proper centreback alongside
    Fortune - 8 I am biased, but his positioning was spot-on for the whole game
    Fry - 7.5 lots of contribution, a decent game for him.
    Wagstaff - 6.5 a bit quiet, by his own recent standards
    Semedo - 7.5 never stops competing
    Racon - 6 takes too many unnecessary touches and runs into dead-ends.
    Jackson - 6 played ok but didnt create much
    Martin - 7.5 lots of effort, no complaints.
    Benson - 7 thought he should have scored earlier, but can't fault his work rate.

    n/a Abbott - 6 looked a bit out of touch with the game, yet I expected him to be itching to get on the pitch.
    n/a Reid - 7.5 what a difference when he came on, defence couldn't handle him
  • Worner - 6.5
    Francis - 7
    Doherty - 6.5
    Fortune - 7
    Fry - 7.5
    Wagstaff - 5
    Semedo - 7
    Racon - 6.5
    Jackson - 7
    Martin - 6.5
    Benson - 6.5

    n/a Abbott - 6
    n/a Reid - 7
  • Worner - 7 flappy on a couple but distribution was largely good and his reflexes and general agility are excellent
    Francis - 7 solid and in the right place when needed. Thought his distribution was good last night barring a few wayward ones. Some people will never like him but I actually think he's a very good player and offers us a lot
    Doherty - 6.5 can look clumsy but he does a good job
    Fortune -7 Took it all in his stride but sometimes looks too laid back for my liking
    Fry - 7 Couple of moments that worried me but bearing in mind he is only 19 he is most impressive. Nice work for the goal too - great awareness
    Wagstaff - 5 not a good day for him. His eye for goal is very useful but he doesn't have a trick so isn't effective enough as a winger
    Semedo - 7 rock solid. always chasing and harrying and worked well with Therry. Impressed at him in the 92nd minute when he broke up an attack - ran 60 yars forward with the ball, laid off a simple pass then turned around and sprinted back to a holding position. Awesome fitness
    Racon - 8 Best game in a long time - maybe in our shirt. Got a fair few tackles in and looked interested all game.
    Jackson - 7 I really rate him as a player and having him in midfield give us balance. Not the quickest but a very good brain and a sweet left peg make up for that. Excellent delivery on a few occasions
    Martin - 6 frustrating. Has a really exciting running style but the ball seemed to stick under his feet too often.
    Benson - 8 MOM ran his knackers off last night. Glad he got the goal (you could sense the relief in his celebration) and thought he closed down all game really well too.

    n/a Abbott - 6 didn't do much IMO
    n/a Reid - 8 game changing stuff from the little man. Just need to get his fitness sorted and he'll be awesome.

    Parky - 7.5 Got it about right with the subs and tactically we clearly knew to get in their faces and close them down. Their strikers were nullified and there was no real threat anywhere else. Would like to see us a little more open and expressive but a win is a win
    Ref - 0 I know we say this most weeks but that was the single worst refereeing performance I have ever seen. SO many wrong decisions. Should deffo have been a red card for their defender and numerous free kicks & throws given the wrong way.

    MK Dons - Very surprising how poor they were. Their midfield were woeful allowing Racon and Semedo to dominate them and pull the strings. Keeper looked proper dodgy when chased down and their strikers were shocking.
  • Worner - 6 Nothing to do.
    Francis - 7.5 Nothing got past him. Didn't get forward much but maybe was acting on instructions to keep the shape.
    Doherty - 7.5 Won most things.
    Fortune - 7.5 Always in the right place and never looked in trouble.
    Fry - 7.5 Positionally sound for such an inexperienced player. Won headers and tackles. Great future.
    Wagstaff - 5 Didn't get much of the ball. Woked hard to close dwn defenders but didn't shine.
    Semedo - 7.5 Never allowed MK Dons to get any sort of foothold in midfield.
    Racon - 7.5 Carried on from Saturday. Looks fit and strong. Also made up the numbers in the box when attacking. Didn't do that last season
    Jackson - 6 Not his best game but was disciplined.
    Martin - 6 Not much end product for all of his efforts. Worked so hard for the team though in a tight match.
    Benson - 7.5 Worked hard all game and showed that he can get on the end of chances. Nearly scored with a decent glancing header in first half.

    n/a Abbott - 5 We'd started knocking balls into channels by time he came on....not is game.
    n/a Reid - 8 Did well for the goal and helped drive MK back late on with his runs.
  • Worner - 7
    Francis - 6 Done ok, needs to cut out the long balls to no one
    Doherty - 7 solid
    Fortune - 8 looked much better with him at the back rather then Llera
    Fry - 7 done well looks more comfortable the Jackson at left back
    Wagstaff - 5 didnt get into the game at all
    Semedo - 7 solid
    Racon - 7 done well some nice passes
    Jackson - 7 looks more at home in the midfeild
    Martin - 4 He seems to be a poor mans Ambrose. his decision making and final ball is so poor. he did look a good player when he first came but I think were starting to see why Roy Keane doesn't rate him. hopefully he proves me wrong and comes good.
    Benson - 7 finally got the service he craves and scores

    Abbott - 6
    Reid - 8 hopefully he can play this well when he starts next
  • Sponsored links:


  • Worner - 6 Standard
    Francis - 6 Ok defensively, poor distribution
    Doherty - 6 Standard
    Fortune - 7 Good to have him back
    Fry - 6.5 Nothing spectacular but sound
    Wagstaff - 5 Not so good. As others have said, better as an impact player
    Semedo - 7.5 Why can't he play like that every week instead of strolling about in front of the back four?
    Racon - 8 Played in the middle with Jose and they looked like a decent pairing. Plenty of involvement. Good all round game.
    Jackson - 6.5 Nothing wrong, just not the attacking threat that Reid is.
    Martin - 7.5 worked his nads off, closing down with Benson and always trying to create. Can over elaborate at times.
    Benson - 7 plenty of graft and a goal at last. Some nice touches too.

    n/a Abbott - 6 I still think he has a part to play in our season
    n/a Reid - 7 Must start if fit.
  • Worner - 7 but just doesn't look big enough
    Francis - 7 best game yet
    Doherty - 6 his pace worries me
    Fortune - 8 won £20 on his selection - positioning is everything
    Fry - 7 solid
    Wagstaff - 5 poor Scotty, I just don't think he has it
    Semedo - 7 he still doesn't totally convice me
    Racon - 8 this is the difference between finishing 6th and winning the league
    Jackson - 6 solid
    Martin - 6 works hard but faded
    Benson - 8 I am starting to like this fella

    n/a Abbott - 6 came on too late
    n/a Reid - 9 unplayable
  • edited September 2010
    Worner -7 Didnt really have a great deal to do but done good enough when needed
    Francis -7 Good soild game
    Doherty -7 no pace but still quite soild
    Fortune -8.5 has the lot, good game and more great games to come
    Fry -7.5 very soild
    Wagstaff -5 just a ghost all game really.
    Semedo -7.5 good soild game
    Racon -8 *played really well for me tonight in my eyes, won alot of balls and worked very hard
    Jackson - 6.5 soild
    Martin -6.5 worked very hard but trys to much
    Benson -6.5 finally a goal, but still will not amount to much (5 goals MAX all season) Not good enough.

    n/a Abbott - 6 Meh
    n/a Reid - 9 showed hes got alot to show as always, him coming on changed the game not just because of the goal.
  • Worner - 6
    Francis - 6
    Doherty - 6
    Fortune - 6
    Fry - 6.5
    Wagstaff - 4.5
    Semedo - 6
    Racon - 6
    Jackson - 6
    Martin - 6.5
    Benson - 7

    n/a Abbott - 6
    n/a Reid - 7.5

    Salad Shuffler Ref: 2
  • Worner - 7 One good save little else to do distribution ok.
    Francis - 6.5 The odd overhit ball but improving and the back 4 looks reasonably solid
    Doherty - 6.5 sound performance nothing outstandingly good or bad
    Fortune - 6.5 looked assured and comfortable at this level. Not tested for pace so reserve judgement
    Fry - 6.5 As Doherty
    Wagstaff - 6 learning curve for him last night against one of the best full backs at this level. Stuck to his task and didn't go missing which bodes well for the future. Helps Francis out which is often overlooked.
    Semedo - 7 shame his well struck shot was straight at the keeper!
    Racon - 7.5 One of the best if not the best match I've seen from him
    Jackson - 7.5 worked hard and helped Fry out well.
    Martin - 8 Gets my MOM by a short head from Racon for his workrate. He really did put it in for 90 minutes even if the end product wasn't always there.
    Benson - 7 Much improved. Clinical finish for his goal
  • [cite]Posted By: Nicholas[/cite]
    Martin - 4 He seems to be a poor mans Ambrose. his decision making and final ball is so poor. he did look a good player when he first came but I think were starting to see why Roy Keane doesn't rate him. hopefully he proves me wrong and comes good.

    Wasn't there last night so can't comment on his performance in this match, but Martin has put in more effort in every match that I've seen him play than Ambrose did in 4 years with us.
  • edited September 2010
    Worner - 7
    Francis - 7.5
    Doherty - 7
    Fortune - 8
    Fry -7
    Wagstaff - 5
    Semedo - 7.5
    Racon - 7.5
    Jackson - 7
    Martin - 6.5
    Benson - 7.5

    n/a Abbott - 7
    n/a Reid - 7.5
  • Worner - 6.5
    Francis - 7
    Doherty - 6.5
    Fortune - 7
    Fry - 7
    Wagstaff - 5
    Semedo - 6.5
    Racon - 7
    Jackson - 6.5
    Martin - 6
    Benson - 7
  • Worner - 7
    Francis - 7
    Doherty - 7
    Fortune - 8
    Fry - 7
    Wagstaff - 6
    Semedo - 6
    Racon - 6
    Jackson - 6
    Martin - 6
    Benson - 7

    n/a Abbott - 6
    n/a Reid - 7
  • Worner - 6
    Francis - 4.5
    Doherty - 5.5
    Fortune - 6
    Fry - 6
    Wagstaff - 5
    Semedo - 6.5
    Racon - 7
    Jackson - 6
    Martin - 6
    Benson - 6
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out!