Henderson - 8 Looked very assured Solly - 7.5 Immaculate as always. Real quality Wiggins - 6.5 Energetic Bikey - 8 Terrific performance in the second half and the type of player we have been missing Ben Haim - 6.5 Overshadowed by Bikey but still a good debut. Gudmundsson - 8 Very impressed with his speed and skill. Going to be a big threat this season. That through ball!! Jackson - 7 Did ok and showed some quality Buyens - 6.5 Not sure what to think. Only his debut so I am sure he will improve. Cousins - 7.5 Thought he did really well on the wing with some driving runs. Would be great to see him in the middle where he can really be a box to box performer. Vetokele - 8.5 MOM Excellent debut this guy is going to be a class act. Tucudean - 5 Wasn't impressed at all. Seemed slow and unable to hold the ball up. Only his debut so probably nervous but needs to improve.
Harriott - Thought he added energy and an outlet but should have scored as he will know.
I am out of the loop a bit but wasn't BP talking up Gomez a few weeks or so ago ? Any particular reason why he was not starting ?
Mainly because he's only a kid and especially in a game like this one you are far better off going with bigger, more experienced defenders. Gomez is by no means ready to be a guaranteed starting player, his breakthrough may well come this season but it will be gradual. I imagine we may well see him play or even maybe start on Tuesday.
Henderson 5 difficult to judge as had little to do Solly 6 Wiggins 5 Bikey 6 Ben Haim 5 Gudmundsson 5 Jackson 5 Buyens 5 Cousins 6 Vetokele 7 got an point for the goal. Tucudean 5
Harriott 5 Thought a an average performance from players, Brentford like us will be looking over their shoulders trying to avoid relegation.
Funny to see how all these ratings vary, and we all saw the same game, for some players i guess how they are evaluated also depends on their history for your club and individual like/dislikes of certain players. As a Charlton live virgin i watched the game on my telly and these are my ratings.
Henderson 7 - looks solid enough as a goalie, a bit more accuracy in passing would be welcome Solly 7 - good reading of the game Wiggins 5.5 - looks shaky to me Bikey 7 - very commanding 2 nd half Ben Ham 6.5 - experienced and calm, decent passing Gudmundsson 6 - at first looks like an exiting player with silky touches but doesnt really do anything with it Jackson 5.5 - quite surprised by him in a negative sense, looks like he needs a lot of support to cope with the intensity Buyens 6 - quiet but effective, knows his game very well. He's a buffer and a fighter Cousins 7 - talented but positioning was disastrous (app he's not a winger) and badly timed runs/decision making Vetokele 8.5 - no guts no glory should be tattooed on his back, courage and determination Tucudean 4 - my gran is faster than him, looks like a player from the old days.
Harriott 5.5 - what a miss, hope this guy has a strong mentality because that will ve haunted him.
Henderson 6 flappy Solly 7 Wiggins 7 Bikey 6 Ben Haim 4 scarey - morrison must be ill or injured Gudmundsson 6 not much end product for all the show pony stuff Jackson 6 Buyens 5 passing is poor Cousins 6 did for well for one so out of position Vetokele 8 without him we were sunk Tucudean 4 bad miss, lacked effort, pace and passing
Harriott 1 his sole contribution was to shank an absolute sitter!!
Stig Thundercock has history here. Tal Ben Haim could have scored a hat-trick and maybe scraped a 7. If you've already chosen to give ridiculous, petty and biased marks before kickoff, what's the point? I can't believe I'm the only one who's been flagging his pathetic player marks. A browse through his previous flags will prove instructive - lots and lots of fairly arbitrary-seeming 1s and 2s, clear biases, no sense of having watched the game
Comments
Solly 6.5
Wiggins 6.5
Bikey 7.5
Ben haim 7
Gudmundsson 7
Jackson 6
Buyens 6
Cousins 7
Vetokele 8
Tucudean 6
Harriott 6
Solly 7
Wiggins 6
Bikey 7.5
Ben Haim 6.5
Gudmundsson 7.5
Jackson 6
Buyens 6
Cousins 6.5
Vetokele 9
Tucudean 6
Harriott 6
Fox n/a
Moussa
Henderson 7
Solly 7.5
Wiggins 6
Bikey 6
Ben Haim 6
Gudmundsson 7.5
Jackson 7
Buyens 6
Cousins 6.5
Vetokele 7.5
Tucudean 6
Harriott 6
Solly - 7.5 Immaculate as always. Real quality
Wiggins - 6.5 Energetic
Bikey - 8 Terrific performance in the second half and the type of player we have been missing
Ben Haim - 6.5 Overshadowed by Bikey but still a good debut.
Gudmundsson - 8 Very impressed with his speed and skill. Going to be a big threat this season. That through ball!!
Jackson - 7 Did ok and showed some quality
Buyens - 6.5 Not sure what to think. Only his debut so I am sure he will improve.
Cousins - 7.5 Thought he did really well on the wing with some driving runs. Would be great to see him in the middle where he can really be a box to box performer.
Vetokele - 8.5 MOM Excellent debut this guy is going to be a class act.
Tucudean - 5 Wasn't impressed at all. Seemed slow and unable to hold the ball up. Only his debut so probably nervous but needs to improve.
Harriott - Thought he added energy and an outlet but should have scored as he will know.
Solly-7
Wiggins-7.5
Bikey-7.5
Ben Haim-7.5
Gudmundsson-8
Jackson-6
Buyens-6
Cousins-7
Vetokele-8
Tucudean-6
Harriot-5
Solly - 6.5
Wiggins - 6
Bikey - 7
Ben Haim - 7
Gudmundsson - 6.5
Jackson - 6.5
Buyens - 6
Cousins - 7
Vetokele - 8.5
Tucudean - 7
Harriott - 6.5
Solly 7
Wiggins 6
Bikey 7.5
Ben Haim 6
Gudmundsson 7
Jackson 6
Buyens 6
Cousins 6.5
Vetokele 9
Tucudean 6
Harriott 6
Solly 7
Wiggins 7
Bikey 7
Ben Haim 6
Gudmundsson 7
Jackson 6
Buyens 7.5
Cousins 7.5
Vetokele 8
Tucudean 6
Harriott 6
Solly - 6
Wiggins - 6
Bikey - 7
Ben Haim - 7
Gudmundsson - 6.5
Jackson - 6
Buyens - 6.5
Cousins - 6.5
Vetokele - 8
Tucudean - 6
Harriott - 6
Henderson 8
Solly 7
Wiggins 5.5
Bikey 7
Ben Haim 6
Gudmundsson 7.5
Jackson 4.5 (not himself)
Buyens 5
Cousins 7
Vetokele 8.5 mom
Tucudean 7
Harriott 6
Solly 6
Wiggins 5
Bikey 6
Ben Haim 5
Gudmundsson 5
Jackson 5
Buyens 5
Cousins 6
Vetokele 7 got an point for the goal.
Tucudean 5
Harriott 5
Thought a an average performance from players, Brentford like us will be looking over their shoulders trying to avoid relegation.
Solly----7.5
Bikey---6
Wiggins---6
Gudmun----7
Jackson---6
Buyens---6
Cousins---7
Ventokele---7
Tucudean---5
we will get better ---happy with the performance
Solly 6.5
Wiggins 6
Bikey 7.5
Ben Ham 6.5
Gudmundsson 7.5
Jackson 6
Buyens 7
Cousins 7
Vetokele 8 MOM
Tucudean 6
Harriott 5.5
Henderson 7 - looks solid enough as a goalie, a bit more accuracy in passing would be welcome
Solly 7 - good reading of the game
Wiggins 5.5 - looks shaky to me
Bikey 7 - very commanding 2 nd half
Ben Ham 6.5 - experienced and calm, decent passing
Gudmundsson 6 - at first looks like an exiting player with silky touches but doesnt really do anything with it
Jackson 5.5 - quite surprised by him in a negative sense, looks like he needs a lot of support to cope with the intensity
Buyens 6 - quiet but effective, knows his game very well. He's a buffer and a fighter
Cousins 7 - talented but positioning was disastrous (app he's not a winger) and badly timed runs/decision making
Vetokele 8.5 - no guts no glory should be tattooed on his back, courage and determination
Tucudean 4 - my gran is faster than him, looks like a player from the old days.
Harriott 5.5 - what a miss, hope this guy has a strong mentality because that will ve haunted him.
stats after lunch
Solly 7
Wiggins 7
Bikey 6
Ben Haim 4 scarey - morrison must be ill or injured
Gudmundsson 6 not much end product for all the show pony stuff
Jackson 6
Buyens 5 passing is poor
Cousins 6 did for well for one so out of position
Vetokele 8 without him we were sunk
Tucudean 4 bad miss, lacked effort, pace and passing
Harriott 1 his sole contribution was to shank an absolute sitter!!