Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Movie ratings - what do you use?

2»

Comments

  • shine166 said:

    Just checked what I would consider one of the best films ever 'dead mans shoes' on imdb it has 7.8 and on rotton toms it's a 58% rating. Just shows wtf so called critics know.

    Looking at the user reviews on rotten tomatoes it has 91%. Doesn't that agree more with you than IMDB?
  • Ha, no, I'd give it 4/5. It's an excellent thriller but I don't like some of the ad-libbed stuff in it. I thought meadows relied on a cast that wasn't quite talented enough. Maybe a little harsh I know, cos it's so low budget, but it did bother me.
  • colthe3rd said:

    shine166 said:

    Just checked what I would consider one of the best films ever 'dead mans shoes' on imdb it has 7.8 and on rotton toms it's a 58% rating. Just shows wtf so called critics know.

    Looking at the user reviews on rotten tomatoes it has 91%. Doesn't that agree more with you than IMDB?
    Again, I was replying to a previous post that mentioned trusting rotten toms critics reviews.... Hence 'wtf do the critics know'. At the end of the day it's movies, not cancer cures... I can deal with watching a poor flick every now and then
  • Huskaris said:

    I just look at the ratings on pornhub and go from there.


    It's always a 'toss up' between ratings and relevance
  • shine166 said:

    JiMMy 85 said:

    shine166 said:

    Knuckle dragging imdb using member of public here, rather that than some '' in the know' twot that I have nothing in common with.

    I'm a reviewer and we both support charlton....

    If you gave 'dead mans shoes' 58% you need your head testing :)

    Fact!

    I don't really care for most critics opinions. I feel that far too many are just there to throw a curve ball review to stick out.
  • JiMMy 85 said:

    Ha, no, I'd give it 4/5. It's an excellent thriller but I don't like some of the ad-libbed stuff in it. I thought meadows relied on a cast that wasn't quite talented enough. Maybe a little harsh I know, cos it's so low budget, but it did bother me.


    Has that film4 vibe though which I love. Cant beat the charm of British production, although it's probably the same thing that leads a show like Utopia to be pulled after 2 series... I think that would have been more of a late bloomer like breaking bad
  • Still, Utopia. I always thought they'd struggle to get even one series about Todd Rundgren's old band.
  • I only use Charltonlife's film thread. All the rest are just bollox
  • I only use Charltonlife's film thread. All the rest are just bollox

    The Christmas TV thread Beds does is the sofa bible for the festivities
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!