Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Options

Players Marks: Charlton v Hull

245

Comments

  • Options
    Pope ... 6.5 : Good performance, shame about the slight mistake, thankfully it didnt cause any issues, good at coming for crosses (no pun intended)
    Cousins ... 6.5 : As mentioned, he got sucked in giving Robertson too much space at times
    Fox ... 7 : Linked up well with Bergdich, do believe the heat caused him problems (as he's mentioned it on Twitter)
    Bauer ... 8.5 : Best Defender in the Division, complete Hreidarsson moment with the finger
    Diarra ... 7.5 : Led by a Captains example
    Gudmundsson ... 7.5 : Disappointing to begin with, his hesitancy to shoot or pass in the First-Half meant we went in 0-0
    Ba ... 8 : He's someone who can be invisible on the pitch yet when he's off it, its only then that you realise he isnt there, that happened today when he was subbed
    Kashi ... 8 : First Midfielder on the team-sheet for me, must have a free role in the middle as he's everywhere, you'd think it would dis-organise the Midfield but doesnt
    Bergdich ... 7 : Linked up with with Fox, his presence meant that Odubajo couldnt get forward
    Ahearne-Grant ... 7.5 : Caused Dawson (an England International) problems to no end, a more experienced Karlan would have scored twice today
    Makienok ... 9 : First Half he seemed frustrated from the Forest match, 2nd Half, Luzon must have calmed him down and he was everywhere for us
    Charles-Cook ... 6 : Did he touch the ball apart from a wayward shot?
  • Options
    Pope - 6.5, one big hash for the goal, but the player should have been closed down
    Cousins - 6.5
    Fox - 6.5
    Bauer - 8
    Diarra - 8
    Gudmundsson - 7
    Ba - 6.5
    Kashi - 7
    Bergdich - 6.5
    Makienok - 9
    Ahearne-Grant - 7
    Charles-Cook - 6
  • Options
    edited August 2015
    Pope 7 did everything astoundingly aside from one half spill that cost us a goal (we were too deep at that point and left him exposed), boo boys were ready to pounce. thank god for our winner.
    Cousins 7 was solid out of position.
    Fox 8 this guy has come on strides, very good performance.
    Bauer 8 imperious, what a player and still only 22. hard as nails.
    Diarra 8.5 some forget he's a midfielder playing at centre back. won everything against Jelavic, Akpom and Hernandez
    Gudmundsson 7.5 silky stuff from Johann and what a feeling when his header went in. a few stray passes and not scoring a 1v1 knocks off .5
    Ba 9 what a performance, no coincidence the game changed when he left the pitch. has legs made of elastic
    Kashi 8.5 composed, always in position to receive a pass and times his tackles excellently
    Bergdich 6.5 not an out and out winger but caused problems on occasion. can see why we need a proper winger.
    Makienok 8.5 admittedly wasn't too impressed first half but boy did he make up for it in the second. we wouldn't have won today without him.
    KAG 7.5 did the little stuff really well, held the ball up and made the right passes. a little eager to shoot but once his first goes in he'll calm down and be a real threat
    RCC 6.5 was a bit overwhelmed in central midfield and was no surprise that he and Jordan swapped places after the Hull goal went in.

    Luzon 9 bizarre man but we are all growing to love him, not least the players
    The fans 9.5 half a point off for the berks behind me.
  • Options
    Pope - 7.5 apart from the goal was an absolute rock, wow how he has improved this season
    Cousins - 6.5 solid as always but wasted at right back
    Fox - 5.5 improving and getting more comfortable on the ball but his crossing needs to be improved and a few times missed the tackle in bad places
    Bauer -8 left Jelavic unmarked in the box at one point, but otherwise a rock, complete legend carrying on with dislocated finger
    Diarra - 8.5 oozes class at centre back
    Gudmundsson - 8 missed a one on one, but even when he was knackered in the second half still came away with a goal and assist, great player
    Ba - 8.5 dominated the midfield, left us very vulnerable when he came off
    Kashi - 7.5 lacked a bit of defensive steel later on but great in possession and alongside ba or cousins plays very well
    Bergdich - 5.5 does a job for the team, but lacks the physicality or confidence to make it in this league right now it seems, still time for him to settle in however
    Makienok - 8 First half he was out of touch, but grew into the game, put in a great shift, and towards the end he was too much for the hull defense to handle
    Ahearne-Grant - 7 worked bloody hard and used possession well, but his chance conversion wasn't great
    Charles-Cook - 5 just lacks the physicality or mentality to make it at this level it seems, left our .midfield and defense very exposed
  • Options

    WOW!
    for those of you watching the match today your marks please, just copy and paste the list:

    Pope - 6.5
    Cousins - 8
    Fox - 8
    Bauer - 9
    Diarra - 9.5 MOM - faultless
    Gudmundsson - 8
    Ba - 7.5
    Kashi - 8.5
    Bergdich - 7
    Makienok - 9
    Ahearne-Grant - 6.5
    Charles-Cook - 6.5

    Ceballos n/a
    Harriott n/a

  • Options
    Pope - 6
    Cousins - 7
    Fox - 7
    Bauer - 8
    Diarra - 8
    Gudmundsson - 7.5
    Ba - 7.5
    Kashi - 9
    Bergdich - 7
    Makienok - 8
    Ahearne-Grant - 7
    Charles-Cook - 6.5
  • Options
    RedChaser said:

    Pope - 5.5 (minus 1 for spilling shot to let them back in game)
    Cousins - 7
    Fox - 6 (not up to the level people have been raving about)
    Bauer - 8 (Immense)
    Diarra - 8 as above
    Gudmundsson - 7 (extra point for scoring winner after missing 1 on 1)
    Ba - 7
    Kashi - 9 outstanding and then put the cross in for Big Mac to set up JBG
    Bergdich - 6
    Makienok - 7.5 ( first half 5.5 second half 9.5 game changer with goal and assist)
    Ahearne-Grant - 7
    Charles-Cook - 5.5

    This!

    Makienok was awful 1st half. I'll openly admit I was fuming at half time as I just didn't see what he brings to the team & I thought we'd bought another dud.

    2nd half he was phenomenal, won everything, was the game changer and put in a match winning performance . I'm man enough to admit I was wrong and very happy to be proved wrong!
  • Options
    At the game.......

    Pope - 7. Not seen a replay, but though he was unlucky with the goal, considering.
    Cousins - 7.5 Didn't look out of place at RB. Great player and our new Stevie Brown
    Fox - 7. Really seems much more composed this season and worthy of his place in the team
    Bauer - 8. Quality defender with good feet and composure
    Diarra - 8. See above
    Gudmundsson - 8. Good performance. Really should have tucked away his earlier chance, but made up for it in abundance
    Ba - 7. Decent workman like performance
    Kashi - 8.5 Ran the middle of the park
    Bergdich - 6.5 For all his effort, didn't seem to influence the game as much as he should have
    Makienok - 9. An average first half, followed by an explosive 2nd half
    Ahearne-Grant - 6. Ran at the back 4 all game, but lack any end product
    Charles-Cook - 5. Clearly not yet ready for this level


  • Options
    Pope - 6
    Cousins - 6.5
    Fox - 7
    Bauer - 8
    Diarra - 8
    Gudmundsson - 7
    Ba - 7
    Kashi - 7.5
    Bergdich - 6.5
    Makienok - 8.5
    Ahearne-Grant - 6.5
    Charles-Cook - 6

    Ceballos n/a
    Harriott n/a
  • Options
    Pope - 6.5
    Cousins - 7
    Fox - 7
    Bauer - 8
    Diarra - 8
    Gudmundsson - 8
    Ba - 7.5
    Kashi - 8
    Bergdich - 6.5 started well but faded 2nd half
    Makienok - 8
    Ahearne-Grant - 7
    Charles-Cook - 6 Played better once moved to right back

    Ceballos n/a
    Harriott n/a
  • Sponsored links:


  • Options
    Pope - 6
    Cousins - 7
    Fox - 6
    Bauer - 8.5
    Diarra - 8.5
    Gudmundsson7.5
    Ba - 7.5
    Kashi - 8
    Bergdich - 6.5
    Makienok - 8.5
    Ahearne-Grant - 6.5
    Charles-Cook - 5
  • Options
    edited August 2015
    Pope - 6.5 Remember folks he's only conceded 2 goals in 4 games.
    Cousins -7 Had to start at RB, great team man.
    Fox -7 had better games but what a battler.
    Bauer - 8.5 The man is awesome, he finger licking good. class.
    Diarra -8.5 Can see why he won so many caps for France. Class.
    Gudmundsson -7.5 didn't want to score the 1st chance, so waited till 98 mins !
    Ba -8. Sublime pass for Kag, and strong game, missed him when he went off.
    Kashi -8 This fella is mustard, was out on his feet in last ten. class.
    Bergdich -7 control was hit and miss but needed the minutes.
    Makienok -9.5 2nd half, scored, assist for winner,won headers in defense, won
    flick on's in air, lay ball off for 2 chances for Kag,run 30 yards to make tackle in defence, ran with ball and did countless passes. Other than that what did he do !
    Superb.
    Ahearne-Grant -7.5 Only 17, a bit more composure with final ball or shot,
    Charles-Cook -6 i Made it clear before game, that it's too early for him but we were short on numbers and we just got away playing him. only 18 well done.

    Luzon 10. what passion, the crowd love you fella.
    This team reflects your drive,

    The Crowd 9. lose 1 point for a few tossers who don't understand that a 6ft 7in
    forward will sometimes lose a ball.
  • Options
    Pope - 6
    Cousins - 7
    Fox - 7
    Bauer - 7
    Diarra - 8
    Gudmundsson - 7
    Ba - 8
    Kashi - 9
    Bergdich - 5
    Makienok - 9
    Ahearne-Grant - 7
    Charles-Cook - 6

    Ceballos n/a
    Harriott n/a
  • Options


    Pope - 7 no problem. His reaction to the fumble was to come aggressively for the next high ball and gave the Hull forward a right clattering into the bargain.
    Cousins - 7 never badly troubled
    Fox - 7.5 continuing to progress
    Bauer - 8 dominant throughout

    Diarra - 9 absolute class. Great fitness for his age. A captain's performance.
    Gudmundsson - 7.5 and he hasn't got his shooting boots on yet
    Ba - 8 everywhere and it showed when he went off
    Kashi - 8 breaks up opposition play constantly
    Bergdich - 7 solid job
    Makienok - 8 match winner
    Ahearne-Grant - 7 looks promising. Needs composure
    Charles-Cook - 6 looked lost when he came on but sorted it out.

    Ceballos n/a not marked but I thought it was a shame when he got injured as he started well.
    Harriott n/a
  • Options
    Pope - 7 (yes, 1 point deducted)
    Cousins - 7,5
    Fox - 7,5
    Bauer - 7
    Diarra - 8,5 MOTM
    Gudmundsson - 7
    Ba - 7
    Kashi - 7,5
    Bergdich - 6,5
    Makienok - 8
    Ahearne-Grant - 7
    Charles-Cook - 6
  • Options
    Pope - 5 won plaudits for doing the frankly basic stuff well but horrible late error
    Cousins - 7 looked totally comfortable - terrific energy in the heat
    Fox - 6 quiet but largely untroubled by disappointing Hull side
    Bauer - 8 commanding and hard as nails but importantly with control
    Diarra - 9 fast becoming my favourite player - the culture to Bauer's brawn
    Gudmundsson - 7 horrid one-on-one miss but still the player you want on the ball
    Ba - 6 his ungainly style is offputting - room to improve hopefully
    Kashi - 9 - immense - superb combination of disciplined positional sense, tackling and accurate passing
    Bergdich - 6 hard working with hints of skill but struggled to make a real impact
    Makienok - 8 6 for the first half and 10 for the second - can the boo boys kindly shut up now?
    Ahearne-Grant - 8 very impressive - terrific first touch and intelligent running
    Charles-Cook - 6 tough way to make debut but got stuck in
  • Options
    Pope - 7
    Cousins - 7.5
    Fox - 7.5
    Bauer - 8.5
    Diarra - 9 MOM
    Gudmundsson - 8
    Ba - 7
    Kashi - 8.5
    Bergdich - 6
    Makienok - 8
    Ahearne-Grant - 7.5
    Charles-Cook - 6

  • Options

    Pope - 6 -bad spill
    Cousins - 6 - didn't have much to do
    Fox - 5.5 - hoof ball down the line - opt stats showed 47% pass success rate not good enough
    Bauer - 7 - solid
    Diarra - 8 - total beast
    Gudmundsson - 7.5 quiet by his standards - obviously still smashed the winner and assist like a boss
    Ba - 7 solid
    Kashi - 8 what a player
    Bergdich - 6 ran the ball out of play quite a bit - still adjusting
    Makienok - 9 wow. You smashed it my son
    Ahearne-Grant - 6 bang average but young
    Charles-Cook - 5 didn't look very good to be fair again still young
  • Options

    Pope - 6.5 sorry he did have a good game apart from the mistake, but could have cost us big.
    Cousins - 7.5 did a job asked of him. Shame he didn't move to mid when ba went off.
    Fox - 7 not 100% sure on him but have to admit he is getting better.
    Bauer - 8.5 The Wall. What a defender!!!
    Diarra - 8 good in the air, good tackler and good on the ball.
    Gudmundsson - 8.5 always trying something. Set one up scored winner.
    Ba - 7.5 midfield was in control till he went off.
    Kashi - 8.5 ran everywhere, won everything totally bossed it. Had too much to do when ba went off.
    Bergdich - 7.5 good pace and backed up fox well.
    Makienok - 9 mom. won the game. Showed so much emotion after goal and at end of match, which shows this guy cares and wants to do well. Unselfish work will definately benefit this team this season.
    Ahearne-Grant - 7.5 gave 2 quality defenders a few problems. Will definately get better.
    Charles-Cook - 6.5 should never have been thrown into cente mid at such a time.

    Ceballos n/a
    Harriott n/a
  • Options
    Pope - 6.5
    Cousins - 8
    Fox - 7
    Bauer - 8
    Diarra - 8
    Gudmundsson - 8
    Ba - 8
    Kashi - 8
    Bergdich - 7
    Makienok - 9
    Ahearne-Grant - 7
    Charles-Cook - 5

  • Sponsored links:


  • Options
    edited August 2015
    Pope - 6 done well but looked like his fault fo their goal
    Cousins - 7
    Fox - 8 must admit his getting better and better well done foxey
    Bauer - 8
    Diarra - 8
    Gudmundsson - 7.5
    Ba - 7.5
    Kashi - 8
    Bergdich - 7.5
    Makienok - 8 well done son
    Ahearne-Grant - 6.5
    Charles-Cook - 6.5
  • Options
    Pope - 6
    Cousins - 8
    Fox - 8
    Bauer - 8.5
    Diarra - 7.5
    Gudmundsson - 8
    Ba - 7
    Kashi - 9
    Bergdich - 7.5
    Makienok - 8
    Ahearne-Grant - 7.5
    Charles-Cook - 7.5
  • Options
    Pope - 7
    Cousins - 7.5
    Fox - 8
    Bauer - 9
    Diarra - 9
    Gudmundsson - 8
    Ba - 8
    Kashi - 9
    Bergdich - 7.5
    Makienok - 9
    Ahearne-Grant - 6.5
    Charles-Cook - 6.5
  • Options

    WOW!
    for those of you watching the match today your marks please, just copy and paste the list:

    Pope - 7
    Cousins - 7.5
    Fox - 7
    Bauer - 8
    Diarra - 8
    Gudmundsson - 7.5
    Ba - 7
    Kashi - 8
    Bergdich - 6
    Makienok - 8.5
    Ahearne-Grant - 7
    Charles-Cook - 6

    Ceballos n/a
    Harriott n/a

  • Options

    Pope - 6.5
    Cousins - 6.5
    Fox - 7
    Bauer - 7.5
    Diarra - 7.5
    Gudmundsson - 6.5
    Ba - 6.5
    Kashi - 7
    Bergdich - 7
    Makienok - 7.5
    Ahearne-Grant - 7
    Charles-Cook - 6


  • Options
    Posting without eating a cheese and cucumber sandwich.. or reading!

    LL it's up to you whether you include my marks or not as I only got in to watch the stream with 35 mins on the clock!


    Pope - 7.5 will get pelters for the goal (which was a difficult shot to deal with. And he didn't have a clear line of sight! And should really have been dealt with by the defense..I thought he was absolutely class dealt with crosses really well and was not flustered at all!

    Cousins - 8 looked absolutely class at RB. Think time out wide has helped hime. He overlapped well got forward with purpose and defended solidly! Would rather him in CM but am more than comfortable him covering for solly!

    Fox - 7 a couple of shakey moments but overall a solid game!

    Bauer - 8 class in both boxes.. not sure whether it was him Diarra or Kashi who should have closed down quicker for their goal but overall very good!

    Diarra - 8 as above! Led well! A leader in the jacko class! He was key in keeping our heads up after the goal went in. Grabbed the game by the scruff of the neck and that run into midfield got our momentum going!

    Gudmundsson - 8.5 created problems for them all game! Cousins overlapping made a real threat down the right hand side! Could maybe have done better with the one on one keeper did very well so we will let him off for that moment at the end!!

    Ba - 7 impressed me.. ran midfield and kept things moving! Has a bit of flair going forwards.. ball over the top for Karlan just be for half time was sublime! There is little to choose between him and cousins but only one of them can play CM each week..

    Kashi - 7 very good! Like the way he drops in almost as the third CB when needed and covers the fullbacks when the get forward! A proper defensive mid in that respect.. but he also has a great range of passing (as good as that of buyens imo). Ball to find big maks head for the winner was class!

    Bergdich - 7 they couldn't handle his pace kept their fullback and winger busy! Looks more of a winger than fullback to me..

    Makienok - 9 MOM goal and an assist! Unbelievable! Held the ball up well and his flick ons came off more often than not..

    Ahearne-Grant - 7 pace caused them problems and created plenty of chances.. will be a very good player!

    Charles-Cook - 6 tried hard but came on at a tough time!! Didn't give us the control we had in midfield with Ba but will get better for the experience.

    Ceballos n/a had gone off before i tuned in..

    Harriott n/a used his pace well and tried to make things happen! Didn't always come off but played with intensity. If he plays like that I wouldn't be too worried with him being a back up winger in the squad!

  • Options
    Pope 7
    Cousins 7
    Fox 7
    Bauer 9 - Heroic
    Diarra 9 - Top Class
    Gudmundsson 9 - Match Winner
    Ba 7
    Kashi 9 - The Algerian Nobby Stiles
    Bergdich 6
    Makienok 9 - Proper CF play - Headed goal & a knock-down at the far post to set up the winner.
    Ahearne-Grant 8
    Charles-Cook 7
  • Options
    Pope ---7 ---tempted to give him 10 after reading some of the total bolllox on here
    Cousins---7
    Fox---7
    Bauer---7
    Diarra---8
    JBG---7
    Kashi--7.5
    Bergdich---7
    Makienok---8
    Ahern Grant---6
    Charles Cook ---6
  • Options
    Pope - 6 - Was doing well until the spillage. Shame as that could well knock his confidence.
    Cousins - 7 - Done ok.
    Fox - 6.5 - Has been better this season.
    Bauer - 7.5 - Very impressive
    Diarra - 7.5 - Oozes quality.
    Gudmundsson - 7 - So dangerous. One assist, one goal. Denied the one-on-one by an excellent save.
    Ba - 7 - Lovely chip in 1st half to set up Ahearne-Grant.
    Kashi - 8 - Superb....hard in the challenge....good passing with both feet. A great signing already.
    Bergdich - 6.5 - Control lets him down at times.
    Makienok - 8.5 - Much better from the big Dane. You can tell he wants to do well. The goal will help him settle.
    Ahearne-Grant - 7 - Done ok, but has lots to learn.
    Charles-Cook - 6.5 - Looked a little overawed in the middle.

    Ceballos n/a - Hope he's ok.
    Harriott n/a - Tried hard....was pleased to see this.

Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!