Grand National, Aintree, 2016 - Race horse Death watch
Comments
-
Time to win loads of money lovelyyyyy1
-
Which one am i?ValleyGary said:Feel like I've been told off by my mum and dad. Sorry.
Or am I the rebellious cousin?
0 -
Did I mention you're grounded?ValleyGary said:Feel like I've been told off by my mum and dad. Sorry.
3 -
You're the strange uncle with the wierd photos.Off_it said:
Which one am i?ValleyGary said:Feel like I've been told off by my mum and dad. Sorry.
Or am I the rebellious cousin?
;-)0 -
Well done Anna1
-
.0
-
Agree with this.suzisausage said:From what I've read, he posts about a horse death, gets abuse from people who don't agree he should post about horse deaths and then retaliates. He has done what he was asked by avoiding the main race meet betting thread so doesn't deserve abuse. Just let him do his thing and avoid his threads.
Find it weird how it makes people so angry1 -
So much for the sentiments regularly expressed on CL that we should respect other Lifers opinions.
I'm very disappointed by some of the "respected" posters' comments on here today. Shame on you.
I too posted on a similar thread a while back( probably this time last year) stating my abhorrence of this "famous" race and others like it. Cheltenham definitely fits that profile. And, like today, my views were greeted with derision.
Before I'm accused of singling out steeplechasing as being cruel to horses, you only have to look at my Facebook page to see that I sign & share umpteen petitions each week in an effort to bring Government attention ( both here and overseas) to animal cruelty in our world.
I also donate monthly to the RSPCA & Dogs' Trust and support Battersea Cats & Dogs Home, SPANA ( yes, horses' welfare) and adopt a donkey from the Sanctuary in Sidmouth each year for our grandkids.
OK - a very minor way of supporting those innocent creatures who do not have a voice of their own. But these are the charities I care about & I put my money where my mouth is.
Please don't patronise me by trying to justify the so called sport that most of you seem hell bent on supporting - nothing will alter my view. And I have every right to hold it and express it here .
Enjoy watching this annual "festival" tomorrow if that's your bag...some of us will be at Loftus Road or on our way home.
Please don't expect those many animal lovers in our midst to whoop & cheer with you as your horse romps past the finishing post.
But consider whether you will feel a pang of remorse should tragedy befall your chosen nag ....or whether you will merely feel that's life .
I know how I shall be feeling.
6 -
Im not angry and why avoid the thread when it needs a balanced response3
-
Sponsored links:
-
We had an extensive discussion about this during Cheltenham. Anna-Kissed stayed off the sport of kings thread and made a separate one, and it is the same this time, there is a Grand National thread and this one.
I participated in the Cheltenham one, and learned stuff I wasn't aware of about horse injuries, I also involved myself in the discussion as to whether horses actually liked what they were obliged to do.
The previous discussion was by and large interesting, and it is as appropriate as having two threads about the horse racing meetings, and two threads about horse deaths. To abuse Anna_Kissed, as he has been on this thread, is to avoid any developed discussion and to personalize things.
There is a certain fascination to be had from reading Peanuts Molloy's reasoning about how to choose a horse, but on those threads Anna_Kissed does not come on with personal abuse, which seems to be the (previously?) unstated but agreed position.
It looks to me like once folk sniff out they're in a majority in an argument it almost becomes carte blance to bully the minority rather than to discuss, which is a great shame.
The discussion on the Cheltenham thread at least made me better informed, although it barely shifted my overall viewpoint, and it was nice to have such a discussion without personal abuse.7 -
Heartless bastard though I apparently am, I too sign all of those petitons, support numerous animal charities, at home and abroad, and have 2 rescue dogs as loved members of our family.Fanny Fanackapan said:....
I'm very disappointed by some of the "respected" posters' comments on here today. Shame on you.
.... I sign & share umpteen petitions each week in an effort to bring Government attention ( both here and overseas) to animal cruelty in our world.
I also donate monthly to the RSPCA & Dogs' Trust and support Battersea Cats & Dogs Home, SPANA ( yes, horses' welfare) and adopt a donkey from the Sanctuary in Sidmouth each year for our grandkids.
........
I respectfully suggest you refrain from being judgmental and condescending about a subject and other posters you know nothing about Fanny.3 -
-
To clarify, PM, my comments concern the posters who have told AK to " feck off " and call him a WUM , NOT their views. Hence, I repeated the much used phrase of respecting others' opinions.PeanutsMolloy said:
Heartless bastard though I apparently am, I too sign all of those petitons, support numerous animal charities, at home and abroad, and have 2 rescue dogs as loved members of our family.Fanny Fanackapan said:....
I'm very disappointed by some of the "respected" posters' comments on here today. Shame on you.
.... I sign & share umpteen petitions each week in an effort to bring Government attention ( both here and overseas) to animal cruelty in our world.
I also donate monthly to the RSPCA & Dogs' Trust and support Battersea Cats & Dogs Home, SPANA ( yes, horses' welfare) and adopt a donkey from the Sanctuary in Sidmouth each year for our grandkids.
........
I respectfully suggest you refrain from being judgmental and condescending about a subject and other posters you know nothing about Fanny.
Please tell me where I have been judgemental or professed to know it all about the given subject or the posters themselves ? I have little knowledge of either but that doesn't prevent me from expressing what I feel.
Like AK, I haven't posted on the Grand National thread expressing my view - I have no wish to read it either.
As I stated earlier, please don't patronise me. I have my view, you have yours and never the twain shall meet.
Finally, I fervently hope that there are no equine deaths or serious injuries tomorrow as I'm sure you and others will agree with whatever you feel about the merits of the race itself.0 -
I could be wrong but I think this thread has hit a nerve with @smiffyboy5
-
Don't see why this needs
Another thread when we've been through all this over Cheltenham. We get it some people don't agree with horse racing each to there own. But why you would go on a football forum looking for reactions is beyond me. We got first time round that your against it. So stop boring us all again with the same argument as 3 weeks ago3 -
I suggest you re-read your first post Fanny. It reeks of judgmentalism.Fanny Fanackapan said:
........PeanutsMolloy said:
Heartless bastard though I apparently am, I too sign all of those petitons, support numerous animal charities, at home and abroad, and have 2 rescue dogs as loved members of our family.Fanny Fanackapan said:....
I'm very disappointed by some of the "respected" posters' comments on here today. Shame on you.
.... I sign & share umpteen petitions each week in an effort to bring Government attention ( both here and overseas) to animal cruelty in our world.
I also donate monthly to the RSPCA & Dogs' Trust and support Battersea Cats & Dogs Home, SPANA ( yes, horses' welfare) and adopt a donkey from the Sanctuary in Sidmouth each year for our grandkids.
........
I respectfully suggest you refrain from being judgmental and condescending about a subject and other posters you know nothing about Fanny.
Please tell me where I have been judgemental or professed to know it all about the given subject or the posters themselves ....".
I have my view, you have yours and never the twain shall meet.
..........
You know absolutely nothing about the totality of my views. Yet you presume to set yourself as holier than all of us when it comes to supporting animal welfare and being opposed to animal abuse because we don't share your "abhorrence of the famous race" .
Now that's patronising.4 -
Thanks everyone, I've enjoyed this.5
-
Come on people is there really any need for swearing
8 -
Does this mean that only those opposed to horse racing donate to animal charities ?Fanny Fanackapan said:So much for the sentiments regularly expressed on CL that we should respect other Lifers opinions.
I'm very disappointed by some of the "respected" posters' comments on here today. Shame on you.
I too posted on a similar thread a while back( probably this time last year) stating my abhorrence of this "famous" race and others like it. Cheltenham definitely fits that profile. And, like today, my views were greeted with derision.
Before I'm accused of singling out steeplechasing as being cruel to horses, you only have to look at my Facebook page to see that I sign & share umpteen petitions each week in an effort to bring Government attention ( both here and overseas) to animal cruelty in our world.
I also donate monthly to the RSPCA & Dogs' Trust and support Battersea Cats & Dogs Home, SPANA ( yes, horses' welfare) and adopt a donkey from the Sanctuary in Sidmouth each year for our grandkids.
OK - a very minor way of supporting those innocent creatures who do not have a voice of their own. But these are the charities I care about & I put my money where my mouth is.
Please don't patronise me by trying to justify the so called sport that most of you seem hell bent on supporting - nothing will alter my view. And I have every right to hold it and express it here .
Enjoy watching this annual "festival" tomorrow if that's your bag...some of us will be at Loftus Road or on our way home.
Please don't expect those many animal lovers in our midst to whoop & cheer with you as your horse romps past the finishing post.
But consider whether you will feel a pang of remorse should tragedy befall your chosen nag ....or whether you will merely feel that's life .
I know how I shall be feeling.
I love horse racing, have co-owned a horse and attend races regularly.
Oh, I also donate to an equine charity in deepest Sussex.
From villain to hero eh.5 -
Sponsored links:
-
I like cats.2
-
I apologise for my bad language1
-
I hate them. You must be a WUM.stonewallpenalty said:I like cats.
0 -
shall we get rid of the cycling thread because I'm sure that's boring for a lot of people ?cafc4life said:Don't see why this needs
Another thread when we've been through all this over Cheltenham. We get it some people don't agree with horse racing each to there own. But why you would go on a football forum looking for reactions is beyond me. We got first time round that your against it. So stop boring us all again with the same argument as 3 weeks ago
If you're not interested don't read it.
I find these threads interesting as it is a subject i don't know much about.2 -
I vote for scantly clad women.suzisausage said:I think Anna Kissed has every right to raise awareness to something that gets barely any coverage compared to the drunken scantily clad women that rock up every year. What's more important?!
If you don't agree then don't read it. It's tragic this thread has to exist in the first place. Surely you would agree it would be best to have no deaths in horse racing.
I have been to plenty of horse racing events and have enjoyed the day outs immensly and had a bet but do have guilt over the deaths of horses esp during the national and wish it could be prevented.
2 -
For 177 years this race has been ran and there has been 80 deaths.so that means that a lot lot lot more have have come through unscathed.The owners know the risks of their horses when they put them in the national.i for one will continue to have a little flutter on the national and will as long as its ran.long live one of the greatest sporting highlights of the year the Grand National.4
-
Do horses still die on a course without jumps due to exhaustion or whatever or is that the primary cause?0
-
Maybe the horses like dying2
-
Yes. Less dangeorus than jumps but you still get injuries and fatalitieshudson-son-son said:Do horses still die on a course without jumps due to exhaustion or whatever or is that the primary cause?
0 -
0
