Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

BBQ's- Gas or Coals?

124»

Comments

  • I brought a kamado egg oven use lumpwood charcoal, best thing ever.
    I was looking at getting a big green egg, which is very similar. Can you smoke on it too?

    Also where do you get your lumpwood from? Mine always comes from Amazon, but would be great to have a local supplier.
  • edited August 2020
    PopIcon said:
    It seems odd that people in the UK would buy a gas bbq. Why not just use the oven indoors? 

    I've had both and would never return to using a gas bbq.
    Trouble is when you are burning human remains it starts to smell indoors. Best to parboil the body parts and finish them off on a gas BBQ outdoors. 
  • PopIcon said:
    It seems odd that people in the UK would buy a gas bbq. Why not just use the oven indoors? 

    I've had both and would never return to using a gas bbq.
    Trouble is when you are burning human remains it starts to smell indoors. Best to parboil the body parts and finish them off on a gas BBQ outdoors. 
    Any particular cut?
  • PopIcon said:
    PopIcon said:
    It seems odd that people in the UK would buy a gas bbq. Why not just use the oven indoors? 

    I've had both and would never return to using a gas bbq.
    Trouble is when you are burning human remains it starts to smell indoors. Best to parboil the body parts and finish them off on a gas BBQ outdoors. 
    Any particular cut?
    Not really, I tend to use a jigsaw and go wherever the cut takes me.
  • James86 said:
    @carly burn have you not tried buying a second hand of Facebook/Marketplace for a couple of quid then getting round it that way?
     It's a god shout. Had a quick look on gumtree. Not much about so maybe others having the Sam idea.

    Might ask a few pals. They may have one laying about.
    I’ve got a spare gas bottle (empty) you can have - depends where you live though and if it’s worth your while picking up. 
    I'd send a private PM mate.
    A certain poster will be along in a minute if he thinks something's going for free
  • PopIcon said:
    I brought a kamado egg oven use lumpwood charcoal, best thing ever.
    I was looking at getting a big green egg, which is very similar. Can you smoke on it too?

    Also where do you get your lumpwood from? Mine always comes from Amazon, but would be great to have a local supplier.
    Get it from Amazon also, yeah have done quite a bit of smoking on it, using cherry, apple, oak and whiskey barrel wood.
  • PopIcon said:
    I brought a kamado egg oven use lumpwood charcoal, best thing ever.
    I was looking at getting a big green egg, which is very similar. Can you smoke on it too?

    Also where do you get your lumpwood from? Mine always comes from Amazon, but would be great to have a local supplier.
    Expo International Supermarket on Plumstead High Street usually does restaurant quality lump wood.  A cut above anything from a garage forecourt. 
  • Ordered us a gas Barby as I can't be asked with charcoal anymore.

    Bit of a problem though. You can't get a new gas bottle anywhere for love nor money! 
    Calor are insisting only new bottles can be sold if an old one is returned first. 


    Anyone else been caught out?

    @carly burn
       Yes I was caught out exactly the same. Spent money and couldn't get Calor gas. 
    However you can buy Flogas. I got a medium sized bottle from Ruxley garden centre. They didn't have big bottle at time. Ironically the saleslady recomended I went elsewhere and got Calor as they were likely to change over for next year and have to be careful not to lose the £20 bottle deposit. 
    Anyway got one and fired up nicely.
  • they all bloody stink when you live next door to barbecue fanatics, why not use the equipment designed to cook food properly in the kitchen, and let me open the sodding back doors without passing out from fumes just once in a while!!!!!!
  • I don’t suppose your neighbours are too impressed with the fumes when you open your back doors.
  • Sponsored links:


  • edited August 2020
    ROTW said:
    I don’t suppose your neighbours are too impressed with the fumes when you open your back doors.
    Actually I may try avoiding using the proper indoor facilities and try a little outdoor plumbing and see how they like them apples.
  • Hal1x said:
    ROTW said:
    I don’t suppose your neighbours are too impressed with the fumes when you open your back doors.
    Actually I may try avoiding using the proper indoor facilities and try a little outdoor plumbing and see how they like them apples.
    Christ some people are really miserable sods
  • edited August 2020
    It is a good debate. Gas is absolutely more convenient. Charcoal doesn't impart much flavour into the meat, but a layer of soaked wood chips on top can do that very well. Ultimately, done properly, you can get a better effect from charcoal, but it is more hassle and I would assume a little less environmentally friendly. I am a charcoal man though.

    What is strange is how us men are drawn to a BBQ whether it be charcoal or gas. Not so much the cooker in the kitchen. 
  • cafcfan said:
    You can use as much science as you like but the taste buds don't lie.
    Actually, yes they do. That's exactly what they do. Your sense of taste can be fooled in all sorts of ways. The colour of a drink, for example, can heavily alter one's perception of its taste. Here's an article that covers the subject. To quote: "The findings of a German study seem to back this up. Its subjects rated wine as tasting 50% sweeter if drunk under red light, rather than under blue or white" Or maybe you could try National Geographic. The same thing happens with crisps. Try out some crisp flavours without seeing the bags, or better still, get someone to swap some Walkers around and see if you can get the flavours first time. So if you can't trust your tastebuds, that just leaves... science!
    That's right about the crisps. I've done a couple of pub quiz rounds where the questions were blind tasting various flavours. The only ones I ever got right were prawn cocktail and basic potato flavour.
    Basic potato flavour? Never seen that one.
  • I ended up with 3 BBQs at one point, a European Outdoor Chef gas BBQ, a Weber charcoal Kettle BBQ and a Weber Smokey Mountain Smoker.

    I got rid of the Kettle as I just couldn’t get on with it!
    The smoker was fantastic for cooking ribs. 4 hours in the smoker and they were juicy, fell off the bone and were absolutely delicious. Had to get rid of it because we moved to a flat and didn’t want to smoke out the neighbours!
    So I’m now left with the gas grill. I’m happy with it, although I do have to admit that we use it for fish and vegetables only as we have given up meat.
  • Fish are meat... Just saying. 

    BBQ'd fish however in a smoker - That's damn fine eating. 
  • In Italy there used to be a restaurant named Kamikase. It was owned by an AC Milan keeper of the 60s who had that nickname. It specialised in BBQ fish and the flavour was incredible. A platter of different BBQ fish and you were as close to heaven as it was possible to be. 
  • Probably in the minority but I can’t stand a bbq
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!