Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Players Marks: Charlton v MK Dons
lancashire lad
Posts: 15,629
Yes back to the proper stuff, your marks please:
Amos:
Solly:
Konsa:
Sarr:
Kashi:
DaSilva:
Marshall:
Forster-Caskey:
Reeves:
Holmes:
Magennis:
Fosu-Henry: n/a
Ahearne-Grant: n/a
Amos:
Solly:
Konsa:
Sarr:
Kashi:
DaSilva:
Marshall:
Forster-Caskey:
Reeves:
Holmes:
Magennis:
Fosu-Henry: n/a
Ahearne-Grant: n/a
0
Comments
-
Grrrr
Amos 6 didn't have much to do, maybe could have come for the cross for the first goal?
Solly 7 mostly very good
Konsa 6 did some very silly things, including gifting them the best chance of the game
Sarr 7.5 pretty imperious, a couple of errors but really was on course for a 9 for most of the game. Dreadful miss that shouldn't have mattered
Kashi 6 when he was good he ran the show, but started making all sorts of weird blunders, including the penalty
DaSilva 7.5 great as ever
Marshall 6 so quick yet so little end product (so far)
JFC 8 MOM basically taught MK Dons how to play football for 60 minutes. Wasn't his fault we weren't 3-0 up. Well I guess there was that headed miss
Reeves 7.5 looked very sharp
Holmes 7 effort, pace, bite and skill. And awful set-plays.
Magennis 7.5 on it today, nice goal
Fosu and KAG combined nicely for what should have been our winner. We were so much better than them. That bloody ref8 -
Golbourne set one up for them but then scored a blinding volley for us, so he can have a 7 as well8
-
Amos: 7 good
Solly: 6
Konsa : 5 . Imperious and then casual
Sarr : 6 ditto
Kashi 5 poor
DaSilva: 6
Marshall: 6 defensively good
Forster-Caskey 6.5
Reeves: 6
Holmes: 6 overplaying massively at the moment
Magennis 5 he tries quite hard but he doesn't contribute much. Extra mark for the goal
Fosu-Henry: n/a
Ahearne-Grant: n/a0 -
Amos - 6
Solly - 6
Konsa - 5.5
Sarr - 7
Kashi - 5.5
Da Silva - 6
Marshall - 5.5
Forster-Caskey - 6
Reeves - 5.5
Holmes - 6.5
Magennis - 6.50 -
Watched on the stream
Amos: 6.5 Didn't have much to do really but what he did have he did ok
Solly: 8 Best game I've seen from Solly for a while
Konsa: 7 Did ok
Sarr: 7 Did ok
Kashi: 6 He did ok but gave the ball away a few times in dangerous situations
DaSilva: 7 Did ok
Marshall: 6.5 Did ok. Not too much end product
Forster-Caskey: 6.5. Did ok. Nothing spectacular
Reeves: 6 I wasn't really impressed. he seems a bit lightweight
Holmes: 8 I thought Ricky played well. Never stopped running.
Magennis: 7 Nice goal. It's lonely up there for him and the service isn't great0 -
Amos 6.5 Solid
Solly 6.5 Solid
Konsa 6 Started well,but near the end got tired?.
Sarr 6.5 I like him, but near the end he did a roulette,then passed it across the box to a MK player.Also should have scored.
Da Silva 7 Always good.
Kashi 6
Marshall 6 I know he can do more.
Forster-Caskey 7 Played well.
Reeves 6 Prefer Clarke still.
Holmes 6.5 Ran down too many blind alleys.
Magennis 7 Not the best touch.But I like his attitude.
0 -
Amos - 6
Solly - 6.5
Konsa - 6
Sarr - 6
Kashi - 6
Da Silva - 6
Marshall - 5.5
Forster-Caskey - 5.5
Reeves - 5.5
Holmes - 6
Magennis - 6.51 -
Amos: 6 - Did well in wet conditions, stopped a few chances which would have made it 2-1 to them
Solly: 7 - Nice solid performance
Konsa: 6 - Did well in the absence of Bauer, dealt with his MK Attacker well
Sarr: 8 (MOTM) - Love how the fans are chanting his name, was immense would have gotten a 10 BUT mistimed his header which made it 1-1
Dasilva: 7 - Got forward well and recovered from the attempt to rip his face off... Showed maturity to not get into a fight with the twat
Kashi: 6 - Shouldnt have got involved at the end there, silly yet controlled the Midfield well
Forster-Caskey: 6 - Maybe should have scored in the first half but the ball needed to come down more for that to happen
Marshall: 6 - Has lightning pace yet drifts in and out of the game... A proper winger
Reeves: 6 - Hate to say but didnt notice him
Holmes: 7.5 - Faded in the second half to the point I didnt notice him; first half though he was everywhere and was brilliant
Magennis: 7 - Dealt with the Northern Ireland disappointment extremely well today; fantastic performance0 -
Amos: 6
Solly: 6
Konsa: 6
Sarr: 6
Kashi: 5
DaSilva: 6.5
Marshall: 6
Forster-Caskey: 6.5
Reeves: 6.5
Holmes: 6.5
Magennis: 70 -
lancashire lad said:
Yes back to the proper stuff, your marks please:
Amos: 6 ok
Solly: 7 fairly solid
Konsa: 7 ditto
Sarr: 7 should have scored though
Kashi: 5.5 gave ball away a few times in dangerous areas.
DaSilva: 7 love this guy
Marshall: 7 more to come from him
Forster-Caskey: MOM 8 great tenacity
Reeves: 3 just dont know what he contributes at all
Holmes: 6 great player but sometimes too greedy
Magennis: 7 well taken goal needs more service
Fosu-Henry: should have started instead of Reeves
Ahearne-Grant: 3 i just dont rate him at all
Referee and linesman -570 - Sponsored links:
-
Sorry Lancs. Dont know how i got your name on there.0
-
Amos - 6 - didn’t do anything obviously wrong other than the customary dodgy distribution. I just don’t fancy him.
Solly - 7 - good solid game
Konsa - 6 - good solid game with a few indiscretions in the second half.
Sarr - 5. A colossus in the first half. Heading for a nailed on 9. Bambi on ice in the second half. Completely different player.
Kashi - 5 very frustrating. Constant lackadaisical passing puts teammates in bother. Clearly talented but gives me the heebegeebees
Da Silva - 7. Good game.
Marshall - 5.5. If he’s fully fit he’s slower than I thought he was. Good first half. Anonymous second other than the chance he should have scored.
Forster-Caskey - 6.5. Unsung hero as always.
Reeves - 5 Passenger. I’m really not getting this guy. Hurry up and get fit Billy.
Holmes - 6. - never stopped trying but crossing was absolutely shite.
Magennis - 5.5. Ploughs a lone furrow but achieved little other than the goal.2 -
Amos: 6.5 nothing to do
Solly: 7.5 best game in ages
Konsa: 6 poor end to game
Sarr: 7. Last 15 minutes reduced the rating
Kashi: 6.5 faded and made mistakes
DaSilva: 7.5
Marshall: 6
Forster-Caskey: 7 worked hard but bad miss
Reeves: 6 didn’t get involved
Holmes: 6 not his day. Ran lots but didn’t beat his man or put good balls into the box
Magennis: 8 worked hard
Fosu-Henry: n/a
Ahearne-Grant: n/a0 -
Amos - 6.5 - Ok
Solly - 6.5 - Solid enough
Konsa - 6 - looked good at start, but looked more shaky as game proceeded.
Sarr - 7 - Great first half. Would have been excellent, if he had scored.
Da Silva - 7 good tidy player
Kashi - 6 - good in places but misplaced passes & gave chance for MKD dive for pen with unnecessary challenge.
Forster-Caskey - 6 - Ok
Marshall - 6 - looks quick, should have scored 1 on 1 chance. Faded as game went on.
Reeves - 6 - looked promising but faded
Holmes - 7 - Drove team forward, good energy
Magennis - 7 - strong, good player. Needs another decent striker partner.
Referee- lost control of the game & didn’t punish some dirty MK Dons play. Gave crap penalty.
Robinson - Fosu sub helped steady the ship but is hamstrung tactically by limited options on the bench.
0 -
Did you also miss him being outjumped for their first goal and missing a header that let to the mix up for the penalty?ForeverAddickted said:A
Sarr: 8 (MOTM) - Love how the fans are chanting his name, was immense would have gotten a 10 BUT mistimed his header which made it 1-1
ce
Excellent 1st half but poor 2nd half
2 -
Amos: 6
Solly: 6.5
Konsa: 6
Sarr: 6.5
Kashi: 6
DaSilva: 7
Marshall: 5.5
Forster-Caskey: 6.5
Reeves: 5
Holmes: 7
Magennis: 70 -
Amos: 6
Solly: 7.5
Konsa: 6
Sarr: 6.5
DaSilva: 7
Kashi: 5
Marshall: 6.5
Forster-Caskey: 7
Reeves: 4
Holmes: 7
Magennis: 70 -
Amos - 7 - hard to fault but nothing exceptional
Solly - 7
Konsa - 7 - good 1st half but couple of basic errors in 2nd
Sarr - 6 - excellent 1st half but poor second half
Kashi - 6.5 - so good at times but caught on the ball in dangerous positions again
Da Silva - 6.5
Marshall - 6.5 very good 1st half but faded
Forster-Caskey - 7.5
Reeves - 7
Holmes - 6 -
Magennis - 7.5 - hold up play good today particularly 1st half, but we do expect too much from him1 -
Amos - 6
Solly - 6
Konsa - 5 OK game but didn't look like a £5m sale in January to me
Sarr - 6
Da Silva - 6
Kashi - 7 Our most consistently good player
Marshall - 6
Forster-Caskey - 6
Reeves - 6
Holmes - 7 Kept the ball rather too much to himself at times
Magennis - 6
Fosu - 6
Ahearne-Grant - 6
Problem today was the wretched conditions: v cold, freezing drizzle, slippery ground. Difficult to judge how "good" or "bad" some of the performances were. Most of the players did ok, but, equally, most made errors.0 -
Amos: 6.5
Solly: 6.5
Konsa: 5
Sarr: 5
Kashi: 6
DaSilva: 6.5
Marshall: 6
Forster-Caskey: 6
Reeves: 5
Holmes: 5.5
Magennis: 6
Fosu-Henry: n/a
Ahearne-Grant: n/a1 - Sponsored links:
-
Did you actually read what I put...? - I've re-added it for you to read properlyredman said:
Did you also miss him being out jumped for their first goal and missing a header that let to the mix up for the penalty?ForeverAddickted said:A
Sarr: 8 (MOTM) - Love how the fans are chanting his name, was immense would have gotten a 10 BUT mistimed his header which made it 1-1
ce
Excellent 1st half but poor 2nd halfForeverAddickted said:Sarr: 8 (MOTM) - Love how the fans are chanting his name, was immense would have gotten a 10 BUT mistimed his header which made it 1-1
1 -
Amos: 6
Solly: 6
Konsa: 5.5
Sarr: 6.5
Kashi: 5.5
DaSilva: 5.5
Marshall: 6
Forster-Caskey: 5
Reeves: 6
Holmes: 5.5
Magennis: 61 -
Amos - 6
Solly - 6.5
Konsa - 6
Sarr - 6
Kashi - 6
Da Silva - 6
Marshall - 5
Forster-Caskey - 5.5
Reeves - 5
Holmes - 7
Magennis - 62 -
Amos: 6
Solly: 6
Konsa: 6
Sarr: 7
Kashi: 7
DaSilva: 6.5
Marshall: 6
Forster-Caskey: 6
Reeves: 5
Holmes: 6
Magennis: 7
0 -
Amos: 6
Solly: 7
Konsa: 7
Sarr: 7
Kashi: 6
DaSilva: 7
Marshall: 6
Forster-Caskey: 6
Reeves: 7
Holmes: 7
Magennis: 70 -
Amos: 6 not much to do but did it competently
Solly: 7 mom
Konsa: 6 looks imperious at times but always makes one terrible mistake that almost leads to a goal
Sarr: 6 good first half wobbly the second
Kashi: 6 too many mistakes today
DaSilva: 6 solid enough
Marshall: 6 lacked confidence; rarely took his man on
Forster-Caskey: 7 worked hard
Reeves: 5 barely noticed him
Holmes: 6 worked hard
Magennis: 7 worked hard, extra point for the goal
Fosu-Henry: n/a
Ahearne-Grant: n/a
0 -
Amos: 6
Solly: 7.5
Konsa: 6
Sarr: 6
DaSilva: 7
Kashi: 6
Marshall: 6
Forster-Caskey: 6.5
Reeves: 5.5
Holmes: 7
Magennis: 70 -
Amos: 6
Solly: 7.5
Konsa: 6
Sarr: 6.5
Kashi: 5.5
DaSilva: 7
Marshall: 5
Forster-Caskey: 7
Reeves: 6
Holmes: 6
Magennis: 80 -
Amos: 7
Solly: 7
Konsa: 6
Sarr: 6
Kashi: 6
DaSilva: 7
Marshall: 6
Forster-Caskey: 7
Reeves: 6
Holmes: 6
Magennis: 70 -
sorry, I did misread what you said. However to suggest he should get a 10 other than 1 mistake still irritates me. He is being turned into a cult a hero when we have far better and more consistent players who are not getting the plaudits,ForeverAddickted said:
Did you actually read what I put...? - I've re-added it for you to read properlyredman said:
Did you also miss him being out jumped for their first goal and missing a header that let to the mix up for the penalty?ForeverAddickted said:A
Sarr: 8 (MOTM) - Love how the fans are chanting his name, was immense would have gotten a 10 BUT mistimed his header which made it 1-1
ce
Excellent 1st half but poor 2nd halfForeverAddickted said:Sarr: 8 (MOTM) - Love how the fans are chanting his name, was immense would have gotten a 10 BUT mistimed his header which made it 1-1
1
