Players Marks: Charlton v Peterborough

lancashire lad · November 2017

Phew! Your marks please, and as a special dispensation the odd remark as well:)

Amos:
Konsa:
Bauer:
Sarr:
DaSilva:
Kashi:
Marshall:
Forster-Caskey:
Holmes:
Best:
Magennis:
Dijksteel:

Aribo: n/a
Ahearne-Grant: n/a

Bedsaddick · November 2017

Amos: 6
Konsa 5
Bauer: 5
Sarr: 6
DaSilva: 6.5
Kashi: 4
Marshall: 5
Forster-Caskey: 6
Holmes: 7 MOM
Best: 4
Meginiss: 5
Dijksteel: 6

Pico · November 2017

Amos: 7
Konsa: 5
Bauer: 6
Sarr: 7.5
DaSilva 8
Kashi: 4
Marshall: 4
Forster-Caskey: 6
Holmes: 8.5
Best: 4
Magennis: 5
Dijksteel: 7

I thought Ricky, DaSilva and Sarr were excellent but cancelled out by Marshall, Kashi and Best who were very poor. I didn't think Konsa was much better either. Dijksteel wasn't at all flustered defensively - looked very assured.

palarsehater · November 2017

Amos: 7
Konsa: 5
Bauer: 5
Sarr: 4
Dasilva: 6.5
Kashi: 4
Marshall: 4
Forster caskey: 6
Best: 3 ( not needed and a pointless signing, something we’re becoming used to )
Holmes: 8
Magennis: 5
Djiksteel: 6.5

Charlton_Stu · November 2017

Amos: 6
Konsa: 5
Bauer: 5
Sarr: 5
DaSilva: 7
Kashi: 4
Marshall: 4.5
Forster-Caskey: 6
Holmes: 7
Best: 5.5
Magennis: 5
Dijksteel: 6.5

john3 · November 2017

Amos:6
Konsa: 4
Bauer: 3
Sarr: 7
DaSilva 7
Kashi: 3
Marshall: 3
Forster-Caskey: 6
Holmes: 5
Best: 3
Magennis: 3
Dijksteel6

masicat · November 2017

Amos: 6
Konsa; 5
Bauer: 3 must have been the injury
Sarr; 4 bloody awful
DaSilva: 6
Kashi; 3 I have never seen him play well. I have been told he does sometimes.
Marshall: 4.5
Forster-Caskey; 6
Holmes: 7 MOM
Best: 4
Magennis; 4
Dijksteel; 5

Aribo: n/a
Ahearne-Grant: n/a

tgarrat1 · November 2017

They were all shocking. Magennis is pathetic, stood still all game, never came short for the ball. Our midfield gets no respite because the ball comes back every time

Dazzler21 · November 2017

stream

Amos: 6.5
Konsa: 5
Bauer: 5
Sarr: 7
DaSilva 7.5
Kashi: 4
Marshall: 4
Forster-Caskey: 6
Holmes: 8
Best: 4
Magennis: 5
Dijksteel: 7

We look totally demoralised. However we do still look a cut above most opponents when the players turn it on. Shame it's rare.

Nicholas · November 2017

Amos: 6.5
Konsa: 6
Bauer: 5
Sarr: 5.5
DaSilva: 5.5
Kashi: 5.5
Marshall: 4 really not rating this bloke at the min. Getting bored of saying wait till his fully fit.
Forster-Caskey: 6
Holmes: 6
Best: 6
Magennis: 6
dijksteel 6

Leuth · November 2017

Some right mad marking going on

Amos 7.5 made a great save early on and distributed ok
Konsa 5.5 muuuuuuch better in the centre, lost his man for the 2nd goal though
Bauer 4.5 ugh, a bit of a shocker
Sarr 7.5 We saw more of Bad Naby today, but a) he was IMMENSE during the last half-hour and b) he still got the vital assist
DaSilva 8 MOM a class apart, his delivery was the best of anyone's too
Kashi 5 did not play well and gave away the crucial foul...again
Marshall 5 rubbish but ran all day
JFC 6 basically did ok, excellent work on our own goalline too (he's done that a few times)
Holmes 6 really good at winning corners. absolutely useless at taking them. his delivery today was TERRIBLE. he would have gotten a 3 or 4 if a) his very last cross didn't end up in a goal and b) he didn't run at them effectively at times
Best 5 tried well, didn't come off for him, unsurprisingly
Magennis 5 really not his day either
Dijksteel 7.5 looked absolute class. keep him in the side

Green Valley · November 2017

Amos: 6
Konsa: 6
Bauer: 6
Sarr: 5
DaSilva 8
Kashi: 5
Marshall: 6
Forster-Caskey: 6
Holmes: 6
Best: 4
Magennis: 5
Dijksteel: 7

seth plum · November 2017

Amos: 7 the one on one boosts him
Konsa: 6
Bauer: 6
Sarr: 8
DaSilva: 7.5
Kashi: 5.5
Marshall: 5
Forster-Caskey: 6
Holmes: 6.5
Best: 4
Magennis: 5
Dijksteel: 7

seth plum · November 2017

The marks some people give to Sarr today confirms how differently a lot of us see the game.

Leuth · November 2017

If JDS' shot in the 95th minute had flown in, I think I'd have given my first ever mark of 11

feesh_cafc · November 2017

Amos: 6
Konsa: 5
Bauer: 4
Sarr: 6.5
DaSilva: 7.5
Kashi: 4
Marshall: 3
Forster-Caskey: 6.5
Holmes: 8
Best: 4
Magennis: 4
Dijksteel: 7

Sillybilly · November 2017

Amos; 7 - one on one save first half was crucial. Better distribution than recently.

Bauer - 4 Vorsprung Durch Shocker!!!!

Sarr: 6.5 - reasonably good

Konsa: 5 - lazy

DaSilva: 7.5. Never stopped trying.

Kashi 4 - overrated. Getting on my tits.

Marshall: 4 - there’s something in there. Wish to hell it would come out!

Forster-Caskey : 5 - not up to recent standard.

Best. 3. Statuesque would be overstating his mobility.

Holmes: 8 - boundless energy and ultimately won us a point but please please pretty please Rickster, you are allowed to pass the bloody ball!!!!!

Magennis: 6.5. Thought he did well tonight.

Dijksteel -7 very promising. Allergic to going forward but that may have been under instruction.

KAG - pleased for him. Looked like Pele. Mind you he usually does for about five minutes then he looks like Pele’s little sister.

Aribo - like to see him given a full game instead of Wilkins, sorry Kashi.

1StevieG · November 2017

Amos: 6 No chance with either goals but made some decent saves to keep us in it.
Konsa: 6 Poor game by his standard.
Bauer: 6 Some shabby defending at times and more useless punts to their keeper.
Sarr: 7 Cute header putting KAG in for equaliser.
DaSilva: 6.5 Got some crosses in and almost got a winner at the end.
Kashi: 4 Worst game so far. Gave away needless free kick for their first.
Marshall: 6.5 Unlucky not to score.
Forster-Caskey: 7 Steady in the middle and won the foul to get the penalty.
Holmes: 7.5 Even after having a poor game still managed to put away the penalty and put the ball in for the equaliser.
Best: 5 Ineffective but did’t have much service.
Magennis: 6 Not great playing out wide or behind Best.
Dijksteel: 7 Bauers replacement did very well showed his strength holding off the opposition and quick on the ball.

Mckforester · November 2017

Amos: 6
Konsa: 6
Bauer: 6
Sarr: 6.5
DaSilva: 6.5
Kashi: 5
Marshall: 6
Forster-Caskey: 6
Holmes: 6
Best: 6
Magennis: 6
Dijksteel: 7

Aribo: n/a
Ahearne-Grant: n/a

redman · November 2017

Amos: 7 - kept us in the game
Konsa: 5 - better when he went CH
Bauer: 5
Sarr: 4
DaSilva: 7
Kashi: 5
Marshall: 5
Forster-Caskey: 5
Holmes: 6
Best: 4
Magennis: 5
Dijksteel: 6.5 - must start in future if Solly is injured

Clem_Snide · November 2017

Amos - 6
Konsa - 5.5
Bauer - 4
Sarr - 6
Da Silva - 6.5
Kashi - 5
Marshall - 5.5
Forster-Caskey - 5
Holmes - 6
Best - 4
Magennis - 5
Dijksteel - 6

Pretty crap all round tbh.

JamesSeed · November 2017

Amos: 7
Konsa: 5
Bauer: 6
Sarr: 7.5
DaSilva 7.5
Kashi: 5
Marshall: 5
Forster-Caskey: 6
Holmes: 7
Best: 5.5
Magennis: 5
Dijksteel: 7

rananegra · November 2017

Amos: 6.5 some good saves
Konsa: 5.5 not a RB
Bauer: 4.5 poor today, we got better when he went off
Sarr: 6.5 some lovely touches and some liabilities, but I'm enjoying some of his moves. He's really good at shepherding the ball out - did it a couple of times and they couldn't get past him
DaSilva: 7 our best defender
Kashi: 4 poor today
Marshall: 4.5 not a lot came off
Forster-Caskey: 7 good link up, kept going at both ends of the pitch
Holmes: 7.5 our main threat again just like last year, we all remember how well that went
Best: 3.5 anonymous
Magennis: 5 tried, no service.
Dijksteel: 7 promisinh

Aribo: n/a
Ahearne-Grant: n/a pleased he scored. He's been good at stretching tired defences and not a lot else. Hope he kicks on

clive · November 2017

Amos: 7
Konsa: 6
Bauer: 6
Sarr: 6
DaSilva: 7.5
Kashi: 5
Marshall: 5.5
Forster-Caskey: 6
Holmes: 7
Best: 5
Magennis: 5.5
Dijksteel: 6.5

shirty5 · November 2017

Amos: 6.5
Konsa: 5.5
Bauer: 5.5
Sarr: 5.5
DaSilva: 7
Kashi: 5
Marshall: 5.5
Forster-Caskey: 6
Holmes: 7
Best: 5
Magennis: 5.5
Dijksteel: 7

killerandflash · November 2017

Amos: 7
Konsa: 5
Bauer: 4
Sarr: 6.5
DaSilva: 7.5 MOM
Kashi: 5
Marshall: 5
Forster-Caskey: 6
Holmes: 6.5 dominated the match, but so many poor crosses
Best: 5
Magennis: 5
Dijksteel: 6.5

Buglehorn · November 2017

Amos 6
Konsa 5.5
Bauer 5.5
Sarr 6
Dasilva 6
Kashi 5.5
Marshall 5.5
Forster caskey 6
Holmes 7
Best 5
Magennis 6

Dijksteel 6.5

SexyDave · November 2017

Amos: 6.5 - didn't do anything wrong, couple of good saves and stood up well for the one on one
Konsa: 5.5 - poor at RB, better at centre back.
Bauer: 5 - some poor moments, balls over the top showed his weakness, some good tackles.
Sarr: 7 - few poor moments, but was the one to bring it out of defence and play it out. Great assist.
DaSilva: 6.5 - ran and ran, everything went down the left for us, caught out of position a couple of times.
Kashi: 4.5 - poor by his standards, but still some very neat tidying up and passing, but does slow the game down a lot.
Marshall: 6 - a lot did not come off for him, but I loved his defensive work and his sprinting back to help the team was great. Wish he'd get more involved.
Forster-Caskey: 6 - some good some bad, won the penalty.
Holmes: 7.5 - our only real outlet, everything went through him. Shot headed off the line was superb.
Best: 4.5 - more to come I think, some neat touches and link play, but just not involved at all.
Magennis: 5.5 - not involved, couple of good moments holding up the ball.
Dijksteel: 6.5 - did what he had to well, some good defending, pace and strength.

Aribo: n/a - thought he did ok if not a lot
Ahearne-Grant: n/a - some movement up top at last, pleased he scored, did well.

All that seemed to happen was passing from right to left, to Ricky to try and cross. Big hole behind the front two, missed Clarke.