Players Marks: West Bromwich Albion v Charlton Athletic (closes Monday evening)

lancashire lad

At the Hawthorns or from a live stream, your marks please

Phillips: 
Lockyer: 
Pearce: 
Sarr: 
Solly: 
Pratley: 
Cullen: 
Gallagher: 
Purrington: 
Oztuma: 
Bonne: 
Referee: 

Aneke: n/a
Kayal: n/a
Davison: n/a

Leuth

Phillips: 8.5 some enormous saves
Lockyer: 7 his side was successfully attacked a few times but he did okay
Pearce: 7.5 the usual excellence
Sarr: 7.5 one awful error but the rest of the game he was very good, +0.5 for the desire to get into the position where he won the penalty
Solly: 6 decent role in the goal but basically let HR-K walk in their second goal and wasn't totally able to handle his men
Pratley: 8 PRATLEY! What's happened
Cullen: 8.5 CULLEN! And what a penalty!
Gallagher: 7.5 ran the game for us at times
Purrington: 6 a step down from JFC but wasn't awful
Oztumer: 7.5 some really excellent stuff until he tired
Bonne: 8 becoming a really formidable striker
Referee: 2 utterly bonkers refereeing performance

Aneke: n/a defended well at the end
Kayal: n/a tried to let them score a third
Davison: n/a welcome to Charlton

wmcf123

Leuth said:

Phillips: 8.5 some enormous saves
Lockyer: 7 his side was successfully attacked a few times but he did okay
Pearce: 7.5 the usual excellence
Sarr: 7.5 one awful error but the rest of the game he was very good, +0.5 for the desire to get into the position where he won the penalty
Solly: 6 decent role in the goal but basically let HR-K walk in their second goal and wasn't totally able to handle his men
Pratley: 8 PRATLEY! What's happened
Cullen: 8.5 CULLEN! And what a penalty!
Gallagher: 7.5 ran the game for us at times
Purrington: 6 a step down from JFC but wasn't awful
Oztumer: 7.5 some really excellent stuff until he tired
Bonne: 8 becoming a really formidable striker
Referee: 2 utterly bonkers refereeing performance

Aneke: n/a defended well at the end
Kayal: n/a tried to let them score a third
Davison: n/a welcome to Charlton

Is that the lowest score you’ve ever given Sarr ? Glad I’m sitting down.

sorry LL.

jbcafc

Phillips: 8.5
Lockyer: 7
Pearce: 7.5
Sarr: 6.5
Solly: 6.5
Pratley: 7.5
Cullen: 8.5
Gallagher: 7.5
Purrington: 6.5
Oztuma: 7.5
Bonne: 8.5
Referee: 3

ForeverAddickted

Phillips: 9 - Made some outstanding saves!!
Lockyer: 7 - Him and Solly came under a lot of pressure today, probably at error for the first goal
Pearce: 7.5 - Love how he winds up the opposition; Perreira was an embarrassment
Sarr: 7.5 - Slight mistake at the start of the 2nd Half; did really well getting forward
Solly: 7 - Got forward well, exposed a bit at Wing-Back
Pratley: 8 - Thank god he survived another week without a booking
Cullen: 9 (MOTM) - Class act, was hiding when he took the penalty, apologies for not having faith Josh!!
Gallagher: 8 - Back to his best today
Purrington: 6 - Gave balance back to the team, put in a good effort as bet he's been rushed back
Oztumer: 7 - Second best performance, faded in the second half
Bonne: 8 - Had absolutely no service today yet still scored, mark of a good Striker!!

Referee: 1 - Send off the wrong bloke? - One of the biggest crimes when your an official

Aneke: 7 (N/A) - Felt he had some good touches, was better compared to Wednesday
Kayal: 5 (N/A) - Wasnt up to speed but almost gifted them the winner
Davison: 6 (N/A) - Bet your in dream land lad!!... Hope its the first appearance of many

Southbank

Phillips: 8 Great saves and distribution better
Lockyer: 8 Some great interceptions
Pearce: 8
Sarr: 6 Gave ball away too often
Solly: 6 Struggled to contain their winger
Pratley: 8 Has become a great player for us 
Cullen: 8 Always comfortable in possession and a cool penalty
Gallagher: 7 Good, but could do with a break
Purrington: 7 Solid
Oztumer: 7.5 Best performance since Forest 
Bonne: 8 Looks a proper striker
Referee: 5 Never a penalty

Aneke: n/a Should have been Kayal
Kayal: n/a Should have been Davison
Davison: n/a Should have been Aneke

SheedyCAFC

Phillips: 9 - If it wasn’t for Dillon we’d have been 4-0 down in the first 20 minutes of that second half
Lockyer: 7.5 - Solid
Pearce: 7.5 - Solid
Sarr: 6.5 - The occasional sloppy pass
Solly: 6 - Questionable positioning at times
Pratley: 8 - I love the old man
Cullen: 8.5 - Gutsy and a proper midfielder, really composed penalty
Gallagher: 8 - Lovely performance as always
Purrington: 7 - Solid if not slightly slow / rusty after just coming back from injury
Oztumer: 7.5 - Almost unstoppable in the first half
Bonne: 8.5 - A proper striker
Referee: 1 - Bottled sending Livermore off in the first half, sent the wrong player off, missed a handball before West Brom scored their second, gave us a penalty that wasn’t a pen

Rob

Phillips:  7
Lockyer:  7
Pearce:  7
Sarr:  6
Solly:  7
Pratley:  7
Cullen:  8
Gallagher:  7.5
Purrington:  7
Oztumer:  5.5
Bonne:  7
Referee:  4 

KettsJohn

Phillips:  8
Lockyer:  8
Pearce:  8
Sarr:  7
Solly:  7
Pratley:  8
Cullen:  9 MOM 
Gallagher:  8
Purrington:  6.5
Oztumer:  7
Bonne:  8
Referee:  4 

QatarNapsy

Phillips:  9
Lockyer:  7.5
Pearce:  7.5
Sarr:  7
Solly:  7
Pratley:  8.5
Cullen:  9 MOM 
Gallagher:  8.5
Purrington:  6.5
Oztumer:  8
Bonne:  8
Referee:  2 

RedRyan

SheedyCAFC said:

Phillips: 9 - If it wasn’t for Dillon we’d have been 4-0 down in the first 20 minutes of that second half
Lockyer: 7.5 - Solid
Pearce: 7.5 - Solid
Sarr: 6.5 - The occasional sloppy pass
Solly: 6 - Questionable positioning at times
Pratley: 8 - I love the old man
Cullen: 8.5 - Gutsy and a proper midfielder, really composed penalty
Gallagher: 8 - Lovely performance as always
Purrington: 7 - Solid if not slightly slow / rusty after just coming back from injury
Oztumer: 7.5 - Almost unstoppable in the first half
Bonne: 8.5 - A proper striker
Referee: 1 - Bottled sending Livermore off in the first half, sent the wrong player off, missed a handball before West Brom scored their second, gave us a penalty that wasn’t a pen

Exactly the same as this for me

matt88

Phillips: 8
Lockyer: 7
Pearce: 7
Sarr: 5 (can’t believe the high marks above, thought his distribution was dreadful today!)
Solly: 7.5
Pratley: 7.5
Cullen: 7.5
Gallagher: 8
Purrington: 6
Oztumer: 6.5
Bonne: 8

carly burn

LOL. Mistaken identity

RedChaser

At the match;

Phillips: 8 a couple of brilliant saves to keep us in it
Lockyer: 7.5 some great interceptions but misread Robson Kanu's move inside for their 2nd goal
Pearce: 7.5 solid defending
Sarr: 7 mixed bag but played the 40 yard diagonal for Solly's up and under leading to the 1st goal and won the penalty 
Solly: 6.5 slow start but settled down and had a hand in 1st equaliser
Pratley: 7 His fine form breaking up play continues
Cullen: 8.5 Great effort and tenacity all game held his nerve to convert the extra time penalty with aplomb
Gallagher: 7.5 Given a reducer 1st minute by Livermore but was undeterred and gave his usual fine performance 
Purrington: 6.5 looked rusty as expected and struggled to take a player on but set up Cullen for the rebound to Bonne for 1st equaliser
Oztuma: 7 Provided the probing needed in Williams absence did well buzzing around their box
Bonne: 8 worked hard and was Jonny on the spot for the 1st equaliser should have scored first half but delayed the shot
Referee: 4 Poor as others have highlighted made at least three shocking decisions,

Nicholas

Phillips: 8
Lockyer: 8
Pearce: 7
Sarr: 6
Solly: 6
Pratley: 8
Cullen: 8
Gallagher: 8
Purrington: 6
Oztuma: 7
Bonne: 7.5

Covered End

Phillips: 8

Lockyer: 8
Pearce: 9 MOM
Sarr: 7 decent but 4 awful passes
Solly: 7.5
Pratley: 8
Cullen: 8.5
Gallagher: 8
Purrington: 7
Oztuma: 7
Bonne: 8
Referee: 7 extra mark for our pen

Dazzler21

Phillips: 8
Lockyer: 7
Pearce: 7.5
Sarr: 7.
Solly: 6.5
Pratley: 7.5
Cullen: 8 
Gallagher: 7
Purrington: 6.5
Oztumer: 7
Bonne: 8
Referee: 3 but got the red right.

Aneke: n/a 
Kayal: n/a 
Davison: n/a 

FULLERpromise

from a live stream, 

Phillips: 8 - Solid
Lockyer: 8 excellent as per
Pearce: 8 warrior love him 
Sarr: 6.5 too many misplaced passes 
Solly: 6.5 was ok 
Pratley: 7.5 good performance 
Cullen: 9 MOTM pure class 
Gallagher: 8 classic Gallagher 
Purrington: 7 was good to have a left back again 
Oztumer: 8.5 thought he was excellent today and could of got a winner had he stayed on as again chuks was far to slow for me
Bonne: 8.5 fast becoming a cult hero 
Referee: 6 done ok for us but bit of a shambles 

Aneke: n/a
Kayal: n/a
Davison: n/a

Buglehorn

Phillips 8
Lockyer 7.5
Pearce 7.5
Sarr 7
Solly 7
Pratley 7.5
Cullen 8.5
Gallagher 8
Purrington 7
Oztumer 7.5
Bonne 8
Ref 5

killerandflash

At the game

Phillips: 7.5 excellent saves
Lockyer: 6.5 decent but one or two errors and I was worried he might get a second yellow
Pearce: 7.5 the best defender today
Sarr: 6 a mixed bag today, dithered on the ball too much
Solly: 6.5 both wing backs struggled today a bit
Pratley: 7
Cullen: 8.5 MOTM Great penalty and was everywhere on the pitch
Gallagher: 7.5
Purrington: 6.5 as above
Oztumer: 6 slightly surprised by some of the other comments, as I and many people around me thought he struggled. Yes he tried, but he passed up many opportunities to shoot and didn't create that much
Bonne: 7 struggled up top by himself BUT showed that he is a true poacher which is priceless
Referee: 5

ateamofcorygibbs

At the game 

Phillips: 7.5
Lockyer: 7.5
Pearce: 7.5
Sarr: 4.5 was dire, and best thing was winning a penalty that shouldn't have been given!
Solly: 4.5 looked exhausted from half an hour in, kept waiting for oshilaja to come on, amazed he finished the game 
Pratley: 6
Cullen: 7
Gallagher: 8
Purrington: 6
Oztuma: 6.5
Bonne: 7
Referee: 3

clive

At the game
Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 7.5
Pearce: 7.5
Sarr: 6
Solly: 7
Pratley: 7
Cullen: 8.5
Gallagher: 8
Purrington: 7
Oztuma: 7
Bonne: 7.5
Referee: 4

grumpyaddick

Phillips:  7
Lockyer:  7
Pearce:  7
Sarr:  6
Solly:  7.5
Pratley: 6.5
Cullen:  9     An extremely fine all round performance. Tackled, passed, scored and assisted. Buy him. 
Gallagher:  7.5
Purrington: 6.5
Oztuma: 6.5
Bonne:  8
Referee:embarrassing but largely in our favour 3

Aneke: n/a
Kayal: n/a
Davison: n/a

kenhem

Phillips: 8.5
Lockyer: 7
Pearce: 7.5
Sarr: 7
Solly: 6.5
Pratley: 8
Cullen: 9
Gallagher: 8
Purrington: 7
Oztuma: 7
Bonne: 7.5
Referee: 5

Charlton_Stu

Phillips: 8
Lockyer: 7
Pearce: 7
Sarr: 6.5
Solly: 7
Pratley: 7
Cullen: 7
Gallagher: 8.5 
Purrington: 7
Oztuma: 7
Bonne: 8
Referee: 4

Arry Addick

Phillips 8

Lockyer 7.5
Pearce 7.5
Sarr 7
Solly 6.5
Pratley 7.5
Cullen 8.5
Gallagher 8
Purrington 7
Oztumer 7.5
Bonne 7.5
Ref 4

Talal

Phillips: 8.5
Lockyer: 7
Pearce: 7.5
Sarr: 5.5
Solly: 6
Pratley: 8
Cullen: 8.5
Gallagher: 8
Purrington: 6
Oztumer: 7.5
Bonne: 8
Referee: 2

superdulvertonred

Phillips 8

Lockyer 7
Pearce 7.5
Sarr 7
Solly 6.5 (looked tired would have benefited from a rest but injuries wouldn’t allow. Has been good this season)
Pratley 7.5
Cullen 8.5
Gallagher 8
Purrington 7
Oztumer 7.5
Bonne 7.5

Essex_Al

Phillips:  8
Lockyer:  8
Pearce:  8
Sarr:  6
Solly:  7.5
Pratley:  8
Cullen:  8.5
Gallagher:  7.5
Purrington:  7
Oztuma:  8
Bonne:  8
Referee:  4

BexhillAddick

Phillips: 8.5 Some excellent saves. Kept us in the game.
Lockyer: 7.5 seemed to win everything in the air and contained their striking threat down the middle
Pearce: 7.5 Same as Lockyer
Sarr: 7 Always looking to make things happen. I love this guy but he is prone to mistakes in dangerous positions.
Solly: 7 Looked vulnerable against West Brom's winger. Otherwise typical Solly performance.
Pratley: 7.5 Not as good as his performance last week but still very effective in breaking up play.
Cullen: 8.5 Chased and harried as usual all game plus he got into some good positions going forward. Don't know where he gets his energy from.Extra 0.5 for the penalty... Never in doubt!
Gallagher: 7.5 Class
Purrington: 7 Looked like a player who has just recovered from injury. Would have liked to see him overlap more often.. but then this was an away game against the top team!
Oztuma: 7 I like his movement and quality on the ball. Played it simple when needed but also tried to get things moving up front. More game time and I reckon he will be important for us this year.
Bonne: 7 Difficult for him against two class central defenders. Seems to love playing at this level.
Referee: 5 Some awful decisions but to be fair seemed to keep the game flowing.

Aneke: n/a There's a good player in there waiting to shine. 
Kayal: n/a
Davison: n/a

CatAddick

Hawthorns (then Marylebone ;-)  )

Phillips: 8
Lockyer: 7
Pearce: 7.5
Sarr: 7
Solly: 7
Pratley: 7
Cullen: 7.5
Gallagher: 7.5
Purrington: 7
Oztuma: 7
Bonne: 7.5
Referee: 6.5