Players Marks: Derby County v Charlton Athletic (closes New Year's Day after breakfast)

lancashire lad

at Pride Park, on Sky or a live stream your marks, let's keep it to marks and no negative remarks please:

Phillips: 
Lockyer: 
Pratley:
Sarr: 
Solly:  
Oshilaja:
Morgan: 
Gallagher: 
Purrington:
Doughty: 
Bonne: 
Taylor: 
Davison:
Referee:

Dempsey: n/a

Danny Addick

Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 6.5
Pratley: 5
Sarr: 6
Solly:  5
Oshilaja: 5.5
Morgan: 5
Gallagher: 7
Purrington: 5.5
Doughty: 5.5
Bonne: 5
Taylor: 5
Davison: 4

Rob7Lee

On Sky

Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 7
Pratley: 6.5
Sarr: 6
Solly:  5
Oshilaja: 5
Morgan: 6
Gallagher: 6
Purrington: 5
Doughty: 5
Bonne: 5
Taylor: 5
Davison: 4
Referee: 7

addick_for_life

Phillips: 5
Lockyer: 5
Pratley:5
Sarr: 5
Solly:  4
Oshilaja:3
Morgan: 4
Gallagher:6
Purrington:5
Doughty: 4
Bonne: 4
Taylor: 3
Davison:2
overall absolute rubbish - one penalty and one shot against 10 men and how many unnecessary fouls did we give away

Bedsaddick

Phillips: 6
Lockyer: 7
Pratley: 6
Sarr: 6
Solly:  6
Oshilaja: 5
Morgan: 6
Gallagher: 6
Purrington: 6
Doughty: 5
Bonne: 5
Taylor: 6
Davison: 6
Referee: 8 MOM 

Nicholas

Phillips: 6 nothing to do besides pick the ball out the net
Lockyer:  5 passing was rubbish 
Pratley: 7 tried hard, only playing centre back cos his knackered
Sarr:  5 Would have stayed on if he didn't get that booking
Solly:  2 Awful, just awful
Oshilaja: 3 Dreadful in midfield
Morgan: 4 Slow to everything
Gallagher: 5 Got the shit kicked out of him and ran out of puff in the second half.
Purrington: 5 
Doughty: 5 looked better crossing in from the right.
Bonne:  5 another injury zzzzz
Taylor: 6.5 only player with a bit of class at his feet
Davison: 4 looked out of his depth, not his fault.
Referee: 4

Leuth

Phillips: 7.5 good as usual, maybe deserves more, too annoyed to give him more though
Lockyer: 6 could have done better for the first goal? made a few defensive errors later on. also is not much of a winger
Pratley: 5 when we needed a lockpick, we got a boxing glove
Sarr: 6.5 yeah yeah he gave the ball away before the first goal, trying to pass to a striker. responsible for the majority of our actual defending thereafter; we looked much better with him on. absurd to remove him 
Solly: 4.5 this was looking like a 3, especially defensively, but played a couple of decent passes. looks shot
Oshilaja: 6.5 also should never have come off, was battling well
Morgan: 5 not his day
Gallagher: 7 not not his day, won a pen and got kicked to high heaven
Purrington: 5 unclear what he actually does
Doughty: 6 not his day, but not really his fault either
Bonne: 5 if you're injured, come off immediately
Taylor: 6.5 not a great display but a cool pen
Davison: 4 looked lost
Referee: 7 didn't bottle the big call and seemed fair thereafter. must have missed wisdom's stamp completely; have taken off 0.5 for that

Dempsey: n/a almost the glory boy; didn't do anything else at all

2121

Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 5
Pratley:6
Sarr: 6
Solly:  5
Oshilaja: 6
Morgan: 4
Gallagher: 7
Purrington: 6
Doughty: 6
Bonne: 5
Taylor: 7
Davison: 6
Referee:

kenhem

On Sky

Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 7
Pratley: 6
Sarr: 5
Solly:  5
Oshilaja: 5
Morgan: 6
Gallagher: 6
Purrington: 5.5
Doughty: 5
Bonne: 5
Taylor: 6
Davison: 4
Referee: 8

lancashire lad

Phillips: 6
Lockyer: 6
Pratley:5
Sarr: 5
Solly:  5
Oshilaja:6
Morgan: 5
Gallagher: 6
Purrington:4
Doughty: 5.5
Bonne: 6
Taylor: 6
Davison:5
Referee:5

Mckforester

Phillips: 6
Lockyer: 5.5
Pratley: 6.5
Sarr: 6.5
Solly:  5.5
Oshilaja:5.5
Morgan: 5.5
Gallagher: 5.5
Purrington: 5.5
Doughty: 5
Bonne: 6
Taylor: 5.5
Davison: 5
Referee:6

Charlton_Stu

Watched on Sky
Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 6.5
Pratley: 6.5
Sarr: 6.5
Solly:  5
Oshilaja: 6
Morgan: 5
Gallagher: 6.5
Purrington: 4.5
Doughty: 5
Bonne: 5.5
Taylor: 6.5
Davison: 4.5
Referee: 5

MuttleyCAFC

Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 7
Pratley: 6.5
Sarr: 6.5
Solly:  3
Oshilaja: 5
Morgan: 5
Gallagher: 7
Purrington: 6
Doughty: 5
Bonne: 5
Taylor: 6
Davison: 3

ricky_otto

Phillips: 7 - great save at the very start
Lockyer: 7
Pratley: 6.5
Sarr: 6.5
Solly:  4
Oshilaja: 5
Morgan: 5
Gallagher: 7
Purrington: 5
Doughty: 5
Bonne: 5
Taylor: 6
Davison: 4

mid_life_crisis

Phillips: 6
Lockyer: 5
Pratley: 6
Sarr: 6
Solly: 3 (a Charlton legend, but unfortunately his time is now up)
Oshilaja: 5
Morgan: 6
Gallagher: 6
Purrington: 3 (ball watching and out of position for both goals)
Doughty: 5
Bonne: 5
Taylor: 6
Davison: 4
Referee: 4 ( -2 for missing the 2nd potentially career ending tackle on Gallagher)

newyorkaddick

Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 6
Pratley: 6
Sarr: 6
Solly: 4
Oshilaja: 6
Morgan: 6
Gallagher: 6
Purrington: 4
Doughty: 4
Bonne: 4
Taylor: 5
Davison: 4
Referee: 7

blackpool72

Phillips  8
Gallagher  7
Everyone else 4

RedChaser

Phillips: 7 made some good stops with little protection

Lockyer: 6.5 best defender

Pratley: 6 should have been in midfield from the off see Deji below

Sarr: 5.5 minus 1 for giving ball away for their 1st

Solly: 4.5 started the move for their opener first thought these days is sideways backwards passing extra 0.5 for goal saving interception

Oshilaja: 5 not a midfielder horses for courses should have been in back line which lacks pace

Morgan: 5 boy lost first half not a natural tackler better second period

Gallagher: 6.5 was targeted again, extra half point for the pen

Purrington: 5 see Solly plus both goals came from the left side of the box

Doughty: 6 only decent crosser of a ball 

Bonne: 4 some lower league stuff on show tonight should have been subbed as soon as hammy went

Taylor: 6.5 held it up well cool pen again

Davison: 4 no impact

Referee: 6

jbcafc

Phillips: 6.5
Lockyer: 5.5
Pratley: 6
Sarr: 5
Solly:  4
Oshilaja: 4
Morgan: 4
Gallagher: 5
Purrington: 5
Doughty: 5
Bonne: 4
Taylor: 5.5
Davison: 4
Referee: 8

seth plum

Phillips: 6.5
Lockyer: 8
Pratley: 7
Sarr: 6.5
Solly:  7
Oshilaja: 6
Morgan: 6
Gallagher: 6.5
Purrington: 5
Doughty: 5
Bonne: 6.5
Taylor: 6.5
Davison: 5.5
Referee: 8

Essex_Al

Phillips:  6.5
Lockyer:  6.5
Pratley:  6.5
Sarr:  6
Solly:   5
Oshilaja:  6
Morgan:  6.5
Gallagher:  6
Purrington:  4
Doughty:  4
Bonne:  5
Taylor:  6
Davison:  4
Referee:  6

Davo55

Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 7
Pratley: 6
Sarr: 5
Solly:  5
Oshilaja: 5.5
Morgan: 5
Gallagher: 6.5
Purrington: 5.5
Doughty: 4.5
Bonne: 5
Taylor: 5.5
Davison: 4

Vincenzo

Phillips:  7
Lockyer: 5
Pratley: 6
Sarr: 6
Solly: 5
Oshilaja: 6
Morgan: 5
Gallagher: 6
Purrington: 5
Doughty: 5
Bonne: 5
Taylor: 6
Davison: 5
Referee: 7

Dempsey: n/a 

ForeverAddickted

Why does Dempsey not get a mark? - He came on at the same time as Davison?

ForeverAddickted

Phillips: 7 - Comes out of the game with credit, stopped it being 4-1, hope he's truly ended any doubt about his "level"
Lockyer: 6 - Pretty solid at the back, almost got caught out, managed to recover though
Pratley: 6 - His experience is so important, we'd be truly fucked if he were injured... Proper dark horse
Sarr: 6 - One of a few players at fault for the goal, one of our main passing outlets though
Solly: 5 - Struggled to deal with Derby today, isnt a Wing-Back
Oshilaja: 6 - Didnt really do anything that merited complaint to be honest
Morgan: 4 - Invisible today, should have taken the game by the scruff of the neck
Gallagher: 7 - Our best player... Was invisible though second half, got no protection whatsoever!!
Purrington: 5 - Like Solly he isnt a Wing-Back so is being punished by opponents
Doughty: 5 - Really poor with his crossing tonight until the last 10mins
Bonne: 6 - Had scraps but wasted two good opportunities

Taylor: 6 - Looked a yard off the pace at times
Davison: 4 - Nothing I've seen says he'll make it at this level sadly
Dempsey: 5 - Could have scored, out of his depth

Referee: 5 - Pandered to the home crowd after the sending off, should have given another red though

JamesSeed

Phillips: 7 Couple of very good stops.
Lockyer: 6 
Pratley: 6
Sarr: 6 He didn't gift Derby the first goal. Should have stayed on.
Solly:  4
Oshilaja: 6 Not a midfielder
Morgan: 5 
Gallagher: 7 Extra point for the bloody socks
Purrington: 5
Doughty: 5
Bonne: 5.5
Taylor: 6
Davison: 4.5 
Referee: 7

lancashire lad

ForeverAddickted said:

Why does Dempsey not get a mark? - He came on at the same time as Davison?

according to the Press Association Davison came on in the 69th minute and Dempsey came on 2nd in the 70th minute with the game finishing in the 99th minute so Dempsey completed 29 minutes. - bit like VAR really!!!

ForeverAddickted

lancashire lad said:

ForeverAddickted said:

Why does Dempsey not get a mark? - He came on at the same time as Davison?

according to the Press Association Davison came on in the 69th minute and Dempsey came on 2nd in the 70th minute with the game finishing in the 99th minute so Dempsey completed 29 minutes. - bit like VAR really!!!

Cheers Lancs, robbed by the armpit again!!

cafc4ever

Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 6
Pratley: 5.5
Sarr: 5.5
Solly: 5
Oshilaja: 4.5
Morgan: 5
Gallagher: 7
Purrington: 4
Doughty: 4
Bonne: 6
Taylor: 6.5
Davison: 3
Referee: 5

ross1

lancashire lad said:

 on Sky 

Phillips: 6.5 not to blame for goals, saved another 
Lockyer: 6.5 best defender
Pratley: MOM 6.5 loses .5 because of stupid yellow card
Sarr: 6 cost us the first goal, but only player to move the ball forward
Solly:  5.5 looks slow
Oshilaja: 5.5 glimpses of skill but not enough
Morgan: 5.5 ditto
Gallagher: 6.5 worked hard, badly fouled twice, but does act like a headless chicken sometimes
Purrington: 5.5 OK
Doughty: 5.5 OK
Bonne: 6.5 Did OK and we will miss him now for a time
Taylor: 6 No service, tried hard
Davison: 5 Never noticed him

Referee:5. Missed Gallagher being stamped on for another red card against him

Dempsey: n/a

killerandflash

Phillips 7
Lockyer 6
Pratley 6
Sarr 5.5
Solly 5
Oshilaja 5.5
Morgan 5.5
Gallagher 6.5
Purrington 4.5
Doughty 4.5 
Bonne 5
Taylor 6
Davison 4
Referee 5 seemed to give all the 50/50s to Derby, through gave the big decisions to us