Amos: 7 completely let down for the goals, nothing else to do really, certainly no wonder saves this week.
Gunter: 5 Not exactly bad, but nothing to be proud of either. Handed Matthews the start for next week. Oshilaja: 6 dived in for the second but was more solid than his partner. Should have made himself an option for... Pearce: 4 proper awful mistake, nearly cost us a penalty and generally breaks any chance of us getting forward by constantly calling for it to be played back and forth along the defence. Morgan: 4 Not good today, but was more of a team player than Gilbey, who barring two shots was anonymous. Forster-Caskey: 6 best of a bad bunch. We don't win with him in the side though. Gilbey: 3 Good position for his 2 shots, useless otherwise. Maatsen: 5 cost us the second with his awful attempt to bring the ball down and take on the team to break out of defence. Was constantly put under undue pressure by our tactics. Millar: 5 Good prospect, maybe a bit too direct. Don't fucking dive, would have been a 7 without two dives. -1pt for each dive. Smyth: 6 Good today, didn't quite come off for him, but works hard. Washington: 6 no idea why he was sacrificed. We looked worse with... Aneke: 5 the impact man made no impact. Williams: 5 toothless. Referee: 4 should have sent Millar off for two obvious dives.
Amos: 6 Not much to do, had no chance with the goals, same as most games of late. Gunter: 6 Didn't see much of him tbh. Oshilaja: 7 Our best player & unlucky with the 2nd as he was exposed by JFC & then Maatsen's failure to clear. Pearce: 5 Gave away the first & didn't look comfortable. Morgan: 5 Quiet game very disappointing not good enough again. Forster-Caskey: 6 One of his better games, but not good enough again. Gilbey: 6 2nd best game for us, but was still average at best. Maatsen: 5 Passing was poor, slipping over again, most at fault for 2nd goal. Millar: 6 Started off looking really good & then disappeared. Smyth: 5.5 Average at best. Washington: 6 Ok, but had to be subbed to bring on Aneke. Aneke: 6 Average. Williams: 4 Poor offered next to nothing. Referee: 9 He must have been excellent because I never noticed him.
Amos: 5 felt he could have made himself bigger for the first goal Gunter: 4 poor game, which got worse the longer it went on Oshilaja: 5 a few decent blocks but, again, his game fell away Pearce: 4 a liability. Can’t defend without having his hands all over the opponent & the header back was dreadful Morgan: 3 might as well have sat in the stand Forster-Caskey: 7 some decent play. Only he and Millar had decent games. Gilbey: 3 as anonymous as Morgan Maatsen: 6 linked well with Millar in the first half. Like the rest, game dropped in the 2nd Millar: 7.5 impressive first game. Can’t believe he was subbed and Gilbey & Morgan were left on. Smyth: 6 Tried, but little end product. Washington: 6 held the ball up well. Would have left him on with Chuks & pulled Gilbey Aneke: 5.5 nothing really worked for him Williams: 4.5 ran around Referee:
Amos: 7 tried to play it out Quickly. not his fault tge team is awful. Gunter: 6 Not terrible. Oshilaja: 6 looked rusty. Maybe trying to prove a point a bit too much. Decent. Pearce: 3 Carthorse. Morgan: 4 Anonymous. Forster-Caskey: 6 Battled but by himself. Gilbey: 4 one shot is all i remember. Maatsen: 4 clearly terrified of the ball getting to Pearce and for good reason. Millar: 6 does he have a left foot? If not he's going to get found out really quickly. Smyth: 7 battled hard. If only he had a little more weight to throw around. Washington: 6 a 5'10 lone striker up against those giants? Aneke: 6 should have started. I understand him being super sub but that role becomes impossible when the game is already lost. Williams: 4 Too lightweight for this league. Referee: 6.
Amos: 5 - No saves and nearly dropped the ball at the forward's feet. Hope he's not going downhill like the others. Gunter: 5 - Didn't see him getting forward. Oshilaja: 6.5 - Given that he hasn't played for quite a while, he did ok. It was a great bit of skill for their 2nd goal and he needed to make a lunge to make up the distance. Probably shouldn't have gone for the initial header though. He'd be fine alongside Inniss and at least he gives you everything (no sulking). Pearce: 5 - Clumsy all night. Morgan: 4 - Was he playing? Forster-Caskey: 6 - At least tried to cover some ground was badly let down by Gilbey and Morgan 1st half. Very decent effort saved. Gilbey: 5.5 - Anonymous in the 1st half apart from the odd shot. Improved 2nd half and I hope that he might just be turning the corner. Maatsen: 5 - Tried so hard and had the odd forward moment but looks in need a of a rest. His balls forward weren't good. Millar: 6 - Started very brightly but disappeared after 25 mins. A couple of decent forays in the 2nd half. Does look a decent player. Smyth: 5.5 - Mainly for effort. Had to laugh when he went past the bloke 2nd half and plunged off the pitch and into the hoardings....sort of summed us up. Washington: 5.5 - Actually showed some good control early on when the ball was going into his feet. But once the service stopped, he was out of it. Aneke: 7 - Showed excellent control, often when surrounded by 2 or 3 white shirts. Williams: 5 - Like Maddison, he needs a solid midfield structure to operate from. We didn't have that last night and he looked lost. Referee: 7 - He was ok.
Maddison n/a - Looked a nasty injury. Schwartz: n/a - Was it him who nearly found someone at the back post with a lovely looking chip? Good to get him started. Purrington n/a - Actually looked strong and surely deserves another crack?
Amos: 5 mauve could’ve done better for the first. Looked slow on the night Gunter: 5 our best defender Oshilaja: 4.5 clearly rusty. Partially at fault for 2nd Pearce: 3 amateur mistake for the 1st. Arguably his worst game in a Charlton shirt Morgan: 4 anonymous Forster-Caskey: 6 tried hard but difficult to do much when you’re holding up the midfield on your own Gilbey: 3 he bottles every single challenge and hides when we need him defensively. Would rather start one of the kids Maatsen: 4 worst game for us. Needs a rest. Partially to blame for 2nd Millar: 6.5 first half was very good. Second half the whole team were shit Smyth: 5.5 tried hard Washington: 5 didn’t do a lot wrong. Didn’t do a lot right... didn’t really do a lot Aneke: 5 see Washington Williams: 5 he was never ever going to influence this game from the bench. Referee: 6 done okay
Maddison n/a bottled a tackle and got injured. Fab Schwartz: n/a glad he got minutes into the legs Purrington n/a needs to start next game
Amos: 5 could he of done better for the goals maybe Gunter: 6 ok Oshilaja: 6 took 15 to grow into game then was ok Pearce: 4 -1 for the costly error Morgan: 4 so happy he got start but sadly he seemed lost Forster-Caskey: 6 not huge fan of his but our only midfielder who wasn’t hiding Gilbey: 3 don’t understand how he is getting 90 mins one shot aside was so so so rubbish get lapslie back in the team (never thought would say that) Maatsen: 4 huge fan of his but poor game today Millar: 6 greedy at times but I don’t mind that looked our main threat Smyth: 5 good couple of runs but far to quiet for me overall Washington: 5 tried as always wasn’t disappointed he was subbed half time Aneke: 6 although no real chances he won headers held ball up nice turns hopefully him and Schwartz can get a partnership going Williams: 4 apart from looking tidy doesn’t do it enough higher up pitch Referee: 7
Amos: 6 Gunter: 5 - cant defend. Oshilaja: 5.5 - thought he did ok if a bit shaky at times. Pearce: 4 - that header was dreadful. he struggled afterwards cos of confidence. Morgan: 3 - played too far forward. barely had the ball. Forster-Caskey: 6 - passed it around ok but went missing for large spells of the game. Gilbey: 2 - Lapslie is better than Gilbey. Maatsen: 5 some good defending but not always successful. tries though. Millar: 6 - some poor crosses but he was our only attacking threat. so in Bowyers opinion take him off. Smyth: 4 - didn't really see him do anything creative or threatening. Washington: 5 - he does what he usually does which is run around, wouldn't of taken him off though. Aneke: 5 - held the ball up a few times but needed support and in the second half we looked accepting of a defeat. Williams: 3 - again in the wrong position. poor when he did get the ball. Referee: 5
Probably the lowest scores and most derogatory comments I’ve ever given for some players.
Amos: 5 - Not at fault with either goal. Gunter: 5.5 - Gone backwards Oshilaja: 4 - dreadful player. Pearce: 4 - Absolute carthorse. All he does is hold people in the box. His defending for the first goal was embarrassing. Maybe a nervous 17 year old kid on his debut would get away with being slaughtered if he did that , but we are talking about a 32 year old with 500 odd games under his belt. Morgan: 3 - gone back to how he was before. Didn’t get much right last night. Forster-Caskey: 5 -better than Morgan and Gilbey. Gilbey: 3 - what a surprise,another shit performance from Alex Gilbey. He is quite simply a pile of shit. Offers absolutely nothing. Just get rid. Maatsen: 4 -Bowyer has turned him from a good player to an average Joe.Chelsea should recall him and send him to play under a better manager. His petulance needs sorting. Millar: 6.5 - looked lively and direct. Bowyer will soon knock that out of him. Smyth: - 5.-Too lightweight Washington: 5 - huffs and puffs, but ultimately I don’t think he good enough. Aneke: 5 - No threat whatsoever Williams: 3 - His Charlton career is never going to materialise, not under Bowyer and not whilst he is in and out the team / subbed on/ off.
Amos: 3 Just as much to blame for first goal as Pearce Gunter: 4 Keeps working Oshilaja: 6 I would rather have him in the team than Pearce Pearce: 2 Dreadful for a man of his experience, never let the ball bounce Morgan: 2 Hardly noticed him Forster-Caskey: 5 He did what he could with the lazy players around him, good shot on goal Gilbey: 2 WHO? Maatsen: 4 Kept trying but made a mistake for the second goal Millar: 5 I liked him, will get better but at least pushed forward Smyth: 5 Some nice runs and crosses Washington: 4 Worked hard, not a natural goalscorer Aneke: 7 He knows how to hold the ball up but cannot do it all on his own Williams:2 Very disappointing Referee: 5
Amos: 6 Gunter: 6 Oshilaja: 6 Pearce: 4.5 sadly looking a bit over the hill now Morgan: 4.5 anonymous Forster-Caskey: 6.5 tried hard Gilbey: 5 Maatsen: 5 Millar: 6.5 decent debut Smyth: 6.5 one of his best matches for us, looked much better in the 433 than when he played more centrally Washington: 5.5 Aneke: 5.5 Williams: 3 invisible Referee: 7
Comments
Gunter: 5
Oshilaja: 6
Pearce: 4
Morgan: 4
Forster-Caskey: 6
Gilbey: 5
Maatsen: 4 (looks shell shocked)
Millar: 6.5
Smyth: 5
Washington: 5
Aneke: 5
Williams: 4
Referee: 6
Gunter: 5
Oshilaja: 6
Pearce: 4
Morgan: 4.5
Forster-Caskey: 5.5
Gilbey: 5
Maatsen: 5
Millar: 6.5
Smyth: 6
Washington: 7
Aneke: 6.5
Williams: 5
Referee: 6
Gunter: 6 Didn't see much of him tbh.
Oshilaja: 7 Our best player & unlucky with the 2nd as he was exposed by JFC & then Maatsen's failure to clear.
Pearce: 5 Gave away the first & didn't look comfortable.
Morgan: 5 Quiet game very disappointing not good enough again.
Forster-Caskey: 6 One of his better games, but not good enough again.
Gilbey: 6 2nd best game for us, but was still average at best.
Maatsen: 5 Passing was poor, slipping over again, most at fault for 2nd goal.
Millar: 6 Started off looking really good & then disappeared.
Smyth: 5.5 Average at best.
Washington: 6 Ok, but had to be subbed to bring on Aneke.
Aneke: 6 Average.
Williams: 4 Poor offered next to nothing.
Referee: 9 He must have been excellent because I never noticed him.
Gunter: 4 poor game, which got worse the longer it went on
Oshilaja: 5 a few decent blocks but, again, his game fell away
Pearce: 4 a liability. Can’t defend without having his hands all over the opponent & the header back was dreadful
Morgan: 3 might as well have sat in the stand
Forster-Caskey: 7 some decent play. Only he and Millar had decent games.
Gilbey: 3 as anonymous as Morgan
Maatsen: 6 linked well with Millar in the first half. Like the rest, game dropped in the 2nd
Millar: 7.5 impressive first game. Can’t believe he was subbed and Gilbey & Morgan were left on.
Smyth: 6 Tried, but little end product.
Washington: 6 held the ball up well. Would have left him on with Chuks & pulled Gilbey
Aneke: 5.5 nothing really worked for him
Williams: 4.5 ran around
Referee:
Gunter: 6
Oshilaja: 6
Pearce: 4
Morgan: 4
Forster-Caskey: 6
Gilbey: 4
Maatsen: 4
Millar: 6
Smyth: 5
Washington: 5
Aneke: 5
Williams: 4
Referee: 9
Why only 6 then??
Gunter: 5.5
Oshilaja: 6
Pearce: 4
Morgan: 4.5
Forster-Caskey: 4.5
Gilbey: 4
Maatsen: 4
Millar: 6
Smyth: 5.5
Washington: 5.5
Aneke: 6
Williams: 5
Referee:
Gunter: 4
Oshilaja: 5
Pearce: 3
Morgan: 5
Forster-Caskey: 5
Gilbey: 3
Maatsen: 5
Millar: 6.5
Smyth: 4
Washington: 4.5
Aneke: 6
Williams:4.5
Gunter: 5.5
Oshilaja: 6
Pearce: 4.5
Morgan: 4
Forster-Caskey: 6.5
Gilbey: 6
Maatsen: 5
Millar: 6
Smyth: 6
Washington: 5
Aneke: 6.5
Williams:6
Gunter: 8
Oshilaja: 4
Pearce: 4
Morgan: 6
Forster-Caskey: 7
Gilbey: 3
Maatsen: 7
Millar: 8
Smyth: 6
Washington:7
Aneke: 5
Referee: 4
Quickly. not his fault tge team is awful.
Gunter: 6 Not terrible.
Oshilaja: 6 looked rusty. Maybe trying to prove a point a bit too much. Decent.
Pearce: 3 Carthorse.
Morgan: 4 Anonymous.
Forster-Caskey: 6 Battled but by himself.
Gilbey: 4 one shot is all i remember.
Maatsen: 4 clearly terrified of the ball getting to Pearce and for good reason.
Millar: 6 does he have a left foot? If not he's going to get found out really quickly.
Smyth: 7 battled hard. If only he had a little more weight to throw around.
Washington: 6 a 5'10 lone striker up against those giants?
Aneke: 6 should have started. I understand him being super sub but that role becomes impossible when the game is already lost.
Williams: 4 Too lightweight for this league.
Referee: 6.
Maddison n/a
Schwartz: n/a
Purrington n/a
Gunter: 5 - Didn't see him getting forward.
Oshilaja: 6.5 - Given that he hasn't played for quite a while, he did ok. It was a great bit of skill for their 2nd goal and he needed to make a lunge to make up the distance. Probably shouldn't have gone for the initial header though. He'd be fine alongside Inniss and at least he gives you everything (no sulking).
Pearce: 5 - Clumsy all night.
Morgan: 4 - Was he playing?
Forster-Caskey: 6 - At least tried to cover some ground was badly let down by Gilbey and Morgan 1st half. Very decent effort saved.
Gilbey: 5.5 - Anonymous in the 1st half apart from the odd shot. Improved 2nd half and I hope that he might just be turning the corner.
Maatsen: 5 - Tried so hard and had the odd forward moment but looks in need a of a rest. His balls forward weren't good.
Millar: 6 - Started very brightly but disappeared after 25 mins. A couple of decent forays in the 2nd half. Does look a decent player.
Smyth: 5.5 - Mainly for effort. Had to laugh when he went past the bloke 2nd half and plunged off the pitch and into the hoardings....sort of summed us up.
Washington: 5.5 - Actually showed some good control early on when the ball was going into his feet. But once the service stopped, he was out of it.
Aneke: 7 - Showed excellent control, often when surrounded by 2 or 3 white shirts.
Williams: 5 - Like Maddison, he needs a solid midfield structure to operate from. We didn't have that last night and he looked lost.
Referee: 7 - He was ok.
Maddison n/a - Looked a nasty injury.
Schwartz: n/a - Was it him who nearly found someone at the back post with a lovely looking chip? Good to get him started.
Purrington n/a - Actually looked strong and surely deserves another crack?
Gunter: 5 our best defender
Oshilaja: 4.5 clearly rusty. Partially at fault for 2nd
Pearce: 3 amateur mistake for the 1st. Arguably his worst game in a Charlton shirt
Morgan: 4 anonymous
Forster-Caskey: 6 tried hard but difficult to do much when you’re holding up the midfield on your own
Gilbey: 3 he bottles every single challenge and hides when we need him defensively. Would rather start one of the kids
Maatsen: 4 worst game for us. Needs a rest. Partially to blame for 2nd
Millar: 6.5 first half was very good. Second half the whole team were shit
Smyth: 5.5 tried hard
Washington: 5 didn’t do a lot wrong. Didn’t do a lot right... didn’t really do a lot
Aneke: 5 see Washington
Williams: 5 he was never ever going to influence this game from the bench.
Referee: 6 done okay
Maddison n/a bottled a tackle and got injured. Fab
Schwartz: n/a glad he got minutes into the legs
Purrington n/a needs to start next game
Gunter: 6
Oshilaja: 6
Pearce: 4
Morgan: 5
Forster-Caskey: 5
Gilbey: 4
Maatsen: 5
Millar: 6
Smyth: 5
Washington: 5
Aneke: 6
Williams: 4
Referee: 7
Gunter: 6 ok
Oshilaja: 6 took 15 to grow into game then was ok
Pearce: 4 -1 for the costly error
Morgan: 4 so happy he got start but sadly he seemed lost
Forster-Caskey: 6 not huge fan of his but our only midfielder who wasn’t hiding
Gilbey: 3 don’t understand how he is getting 90 mins one shot aside was so so so rubbish get lapslie back in the team (never thought would say that)
Maatsen: 4 huge fan of his but poor game today
Millar: 6 greedy at times but I don’t mind that looked our main threat
Smyth: 5 good couple of runs but far to quiet for me overall
Washington: 5 tried as always wasn’t disappointed he was subbed half time
Aneke: 6 although no real chances he won headers held ball up nice turns hopefully him and Schwartz can get a partnership going
Williams: 4 apart from looking tidy doesn’t do it enough higher up pitch
Referee: 7
Gunter 6
Oshilaja 6
Pearce 4
Morgan 4
JFK 6.5
Gilby 5
Maatsen 4
Millar 6.5
Smyth 6
Washington 5.5
Aneke 5
Williams 5
Gunter: 5.5
Oshilaja: 6
Pearce: 5
Morgan: 5
Forster-Caskey: 6.5
Gilbey:5
Maatsen: 5.5
Millar: 6.5
Smyth: 6
Washington: 5
Aneke: 6
Williams:5
Referee: 6
Gunter: 5 - cant defend.
Oshilaja: 5.5 - thought he did ok if a bit shaky at times.
Pearce: 4 - that header was dreadful. he struggled afterwards cos of confidence.
Morgan: 3 - played too far forward. barely had the ball.
Forster-Caskey: 6 - passed it around ok but went missing for large spells of the game.
Gilbey: 2 - Lapslie is better than Gilbey.
Maatsen: 5 some good defending but not always successful. tries though.
Millar: 6 - some poor crosses but he was our only attacking threat. so in Bowyers opinion take him off.
Smyth: 4 - didn't really see him do anything creative or threatening.
Washington: 5 - he does what he usually does which is run around, wouldn't of taken him off though.
Aneke: 5 - held the ball up a few times but needed support and in the second half we looked accepting of a defeat.
Williams: 3 - again in the wrong position. poor when he did get the ball.
Referee: 5
Gunter: 5
Oshilaja: 6
Pearce: 5.5
Morgan: 5
Forster-Caskey: 6
Gilbey: 5
Maatsen: 4.5
Millar: 5.5
Smyth: 6
Washington: 5
Aneke: 5
Williams: 5
Referee:7.5
So poor, the referee was the best performer along with Deji and JFC
Gunter: 5.5 - Gone backwards
Oshilaja: 4 - dreadful player.
Pearce: 4 - Absolute carthorse. All he does is hold people in the box. His defending for the first goal was embarrassing. Maybe a nervous 17 year old kid on his debut would get away with being slaughtered if he did that , but we are talking about a 32 year old with 500 odd games under his belt.
Morgan: 3 - gone back to how he was before. Didn’t get much right last night.
Forster-Caskey: 5 -better than Morgan and Gilbey.
Gilbey: 3 - what a surprise,another shit performance from Alex Gilbey. He is quite simply a pile of shit. Offers absolutely nothing. Just get rid.
Maatsen: 4 -Bowyer has turned him from a good player to an average Joe.Chelsea should recall him and send him to play under a better manager. His petulance needs sorting.
Millar: 6.5 - looked lively and direct. Bowyer will soon knock that out of him.
Smyth: - 5.-Too lightweight
Washington: 5 - huffs and puffs, but ultimately I don’t think he good enough.
Aneke: 5 - No threat whatsoever
Williams: 3 - His Charlton career is never going to materialise, not under Bowyer and not whilst he is in and out the team / subbed on/ off.
Gunter: 6
Oshilaja: 5
Pearce: 4
Morgan: 4
Forster-Caskey: 7
Gilbey: 4
Maatsen: 5
Millar: 7
Smyth: 6
Washington: 5
Aneke: 7
Williams: 5
Referee: 7
Gunter: 5.5
Oshilaja: 6
Pearce: 3
Morgan: 5
Forster-Caskey: 6
Gilbey: 4
Maatsen: 5
Millar: 6
Smyth: 6
Washington: 6
Aneke: 6
Williams: 5
Referee: 7
Gunter: 4 Keeps working
Oshilaja: 6 I would rather have him in the team than Pearce
Pearce: 2 Dreadful for a man of his experience, never let the ball bounce
Morgan: 2 Hardly noticed him
Forster-Caskey: 5 He did what he could with the lazy players around him, good shot on goal
Gilbey: 2 WHO?
Maatsen: 4 Kept trying but made a mistake for the second goal
Millar: 5 I liked him, will get better but at least pushed forward
Smyth: 5 Some nice runs and crosses
Washington: 4 Worked hard, not a natural goalscorer
Aneke: 7 He knows how to hold the ball up but cannot do it all on his own
Williams:2 Very disappointing
Referee: 5
Maddison n/a
Schwartz: n/a
Purrington n/a
Gunter: 6
Oshilaja: 6
Pearce: 4.5 sadly looking a bit over the hill now
Morgan: 4.5 anonymous
Forster-Caskey: 6.5 tried hard
Gilbey: 5
Maatsen: 5
Millar: 6.5 decent debut
Smyth: 6.5 one of his best matches for us, looked much better in the 433 than when he played more centrally
Washington: 5.5
Aneke: 5.5
Williams: 3 invisible
Referee: 7
Gunter: 6 :
Oshilaja:6
Pearce:4
Morgan: 3
Forster-Caskey:5
Gilbey: 2
Maatsen: 6
Millar:7
Smyth: 7
Washington:5
Aneke: 8
Williams:5
Referee:
Maddison n/a
Schwartz: n/a
Purrington n/a
Gunter: 5
Oshilaja: 6.5
Pearce: 4
Morgan: 4
Forster-Caskey: 6
Gilbey: 5
Maatsen: 4
Millar: 6
Smyth: 6
Washington: 5
Aneke: 6
Williams: 3
Referee: 7