Players Marks: Oxford United v Charlton Athletic (closes Sunday teatime)

lancashire lad

sorry to close it a bit early but I'm working all day Monday. I'm using the same player list order as shown on Charlton TV

MacG: 
Matthews: 
Inniss: 
Famewo: 
Gunter: 
Dobson:
Clare: 
DJ:
Morgan: 
Washington:  
Stockley: 
Davison: 
Referee: 

Watson: n/a
Clayden n/a

Nicholas

MacG: 5 should have done better for the 1st
Matthews: 6
Inniss: 6
Famewo: 6
Gunter: 5
Dobson:7
Clare: 5
DJ:4
Morgan: 5 his fault for their first. He is simply not good enough 
Washington:  6
Stockley: 6.5
Davison: 5
Referee: 1 prick

MuttleyCAFC

MacG: 5 should have parried it right for the first 
Matthews: 5 Was fouled for the first but wasn't great
Inniss: 6.5 No up to speed but still decent
Famewo: 6.5 Did ok 
Gunter: 5
Dobson: 6.5
Clare: 5 ran about. No quality
DJ: 4 
Morgan: 5  
Washington: 6.5  
Stockley:6 
Davison: 5

RedChaser

MacG: 5 Good save to keep it 2-1 late on but teed up their first stopping a shot going wide
Matthews: 5.5 Average 
Inniss: 5.5 Worst performance to date, teed up their second and wasteful in their box from set pieces 
Famewo: 6.5 Solid performance best defender 
Gunter: 5.5 Not as comfortable today lots of loose balls
Dobson: 6 Steady
Clare: 5 Not sure what he’s bringing to the party atm
DJ: 3 Totally ineffective today
Morgan: 5.5 Had his pocket picked near their box for the break for their first still not showing enough for me to claim a regular starting place
Washington: 7 worked hard our only attacking threat today good pen
Stockley: 6 won the pen went quiet after the booking ok in our box
Davison: 5 made little impact 
Referee: 3 Poor have been refereed better on Blackheath

ricky_otto

MacG: 5
Matthews: 5.5
Inniss: 6
Famewo: 6
Gunter: 5
Dobson: 6
Clare: 5.5
DJ: 3 - was he even playing?
Morgan: 5
Washington: 6.5 
Stockley: 6
Davison: 4.5
Referee: 5

jamescafc

MacG: 6
Matthews: 6
Inniss: 6
Famewo: 6
Gunter: 5.5
Dobson: 6.5
Clare: 5
DJ: 4
Morgan: 6.5
Washington: 6
Stockley: 6.5
Davison: 5
Referee: 6

Bangkokaddick

MacG: 5.5

Matthews: 5.5

Inniss: 6

Famewo: 6
Gunter: 6
Dobson: 5
Clare: 4.5
DJ: 3.5
Morgan: 6

Washington: 6.5

Stockley: 6
Davison: 5
Referee: 5

RedChaser

No score for Innis @Bangkokaddick ?

MattTeesHeader

MacG: 6
Matthews: 5
Inniss: 5
Famewo: 6
Gunter: 6
Dobson: 6
Clare:5 
DJ: 5
Morgan: 5
Washington: 6 
Stockley: 6
Davison: 6
Referee: 5

JohnnyH2

MacG:  5
Matthews: 5
Inniss: 5
Famewo: 6
Gunter: 5
Dobson:6
Clare: 4
DJ: 4
Morgan: 5
Washington:  7
Stockley: 5
Davison: 5
Referee: 4

Watson: n/a
Clayden n/a

ParkinsonOut

MacG: 5
Matthews: 5
Inniss: 5
Famewo: 5
Gunter: 5
Dobson: 4
Clare: 4
DJ: 3
Morgan: 5
Washington: 5
Stockley: 6
Davison: 5
Referee: 3

RonnieMoore

MacG: 7 
Matthews: 6
Inniss: 7
Famewo: 7
Gunter: 6
Dobson: 7
Clare: 6
DJ:6
Morgan: 5
Washington:  8 MOM
Stockley: 6 
Davison: 5
Referee: 4

Rob

MacG: 5
Matthews: 6
Inniss: 5.5
Famewo: 6.5
Gunter: 5
Dobson: 5
Clare: 5
DJ: 4
Morgan: 5
Washington:  7
Stockley: 6
Davison: 5
Referee: 4

Paddy7

MacG: 5 Really disappointed by that gift for their first.
Matthews: 6 Adequate but offered little offensively.
Inniss: 5.5 Looked uncomfortable with their movement. 
Famewo: 7 Thought he was the pick of them.  
Gunter: 5.5 Out of position of course but they got in too often down that side. 
Dobson: 5.5 Eager start but didn't offer enough protection.
Clare: 4 All I really saw was energy.
DJ: 3 One of our only two creative players but completely anonymous.
Morgan: 5.5 With no other invention he's carrying far too big a burden. 
Washington: 6 Beavered away as always.  
Stockley: 5.5 Won most of his early headers, then suffered from the ref's reaction to Oxford's whining.
Davison: Not the answer for now.

Essex_Al

MacG:   5.5
Matthews:  5
Inniss:  5
Famewo:  5
Gunter:  5
Dobson:  5.5
Clare:  5
DJ:  4
Morgan:  5
Washington:  5
Stockley:  5
Davison:  4
Referee:  4

Bedsaddick

MacG: 6
Matthews: 6
Inniss: 7.5 MOM
Famewo: 5
Gunter: 6
Dobson: 6
Clare: 5
DJ: 4
Morgan: 6
Washington:  7
Stockley: 6
Davison: 5
Referee: 0

FULLERpromise

MacG: 5 made a couple of decent saves but defo should of done better for first goal 
Matthews: 5 didn’t get forward at all today really 
Inniss: 6 done ok 
Famewo: 6.5 just best of the defenders 
Gunter: 5 struggled compared to last week 
Dobson: 5 good first half didn’t seem to get involved second half 
Clare: 4.5 very quiet 
DJ: 3.5 had no more than a dozen touches all game I would of offered more today 
Morgan: 6.5 at least tried to make things happen and always wanted the ball but needs others around him too and the mainly route 1 what we playing at the moment isn’t helping  
Washington: 6.5 some nice touches and tried hard as always .5 for sticking penalty away to try and get us back in it 
Stockley: 5.5 not his game today not helping that all balls in air he is getting are not from decent crosses In the box which we need  
Davison: 4 DJ correctly subbed but Wud of rather Clayden 
Referee: 4 apart from pen which I think assistant gave in his ear was a proper homey 

Watson: n/a
Clayden n/a

objectivecafc

lancashire lad said:

sorry to close it a bit early but I'm working all day Monday. I'm using the same player list order as shown on Charlton TV

MacG: 6 sweeper keeper, doesn't seem to come for crosses ever. Couple of good saves though.
Matthews: 6 not his best today, probably gets 6 just because of the extra work as a result of so many poor performances
Inniss: 6 decent"big centre half" moments. needs to communicate with Matthews better, between the two got overlapped with ease
Famewo: 7.5 sensed and snuffed out danger all say. It could have easily been mistaken for being quiet, but actually kept us in it many times
Gunter: 6 they got in far too often, however has a passable ledt foot and deserves credit for a truly thankless task.
Dobson: 5.5 had moments, but got bypassed easily.
Clare: 4.5 find it really hard to score an invisible Man.
DJ: 4.5 see Clare
Morgan: 5.5 ish maybe 6 probably 5.5. set pieces were not good enough until too late in the second half. Obviously pick pocketed for the goal and some passes weren't easily controlled by others inviting pressure. The lad was everywhere and everything does go through him. More of that needs to connect sideways or go forward even if it doesn't come off, not fluffing it sideways.
Washington: 7.5 worked hard, looked the most likely in open play. MOM
Stockley: 5.5 offered little. Ref didn't like him, so we thought lump it to him some more. People have said he has feet, we possibly need to witness that.we didn't attack the channels and he was part of the problem
Davison: 5 really did little but did force their defenders away from stockley. I wonder if he has any feet fir us to see.
Referee: 3 he and his assistant nearest us need investigation. Abysmal. The joke of a lino by us never flagged either way because I'm not sure he was watching the game.

Watson: n/a I questioned it but made a difference with some decent passing
Clayden n/a didn't see him, so can't judge

cafcsinger

MacG: 4 - Poor keeping for the first goal. Not impressed so far.
Matthews: 5.5 - Average if we’re being kind, doesn’t get forward enough 
Inniss: 6 - Ok game, monster in the air. 
Famewo: 6 - Used his body well, decent game
Gunter:  5 - Out of position so i have some sympathy but he’s poor. 
Dobson: 6.5 - One of our better performers 
Clare: 4.5 - Really poor, gave away countless silly fouls
DJ: 3.5 - Forgot he was playing
Morgan: 6 - Not everything came off but one of our better players.
Washington:  7.5 - MOM, good player for league 1
Stockley: 5 - Isolated 
Davison: 5 - Not gonna be good enough
Referee: 4 

Longtimeaddicted

MacG: 4 worries me don’t push the ball back into play
Matthews: 6 got turned over
Inniss: 8 quality
Famewo: 8 as above 
Gunter: 3 not a left back also got turned over
Dobson: 4 lacked influence 
Clare: 3 worse than above
DJ:2 was he playing?
Morgan: 4 poor pondered on the ball again and again
Washington: 5 wish he had a left foot every time he gets the ball has to turn inside, should have score in 1st half
Stockley: 4 our only game plan Hoof it to Stockers, also he must have shagged the refs sister🥴
Davison: 4 tried
Referee: 2 awful I sure he did not give that pen he was on his way to the half way line

mart77

MacG: 5
Matthews: 5
Inniss: 6
Famewo: 6
Gunter: 5.5
Dobson: 6
Clare: 6
DJ: 3
Morgan: 6
Washington:  6.5
Stockley: 6
Davison: 5
Referee: 5

Watson: n/a
Clayden n/a

RichyB2

MacG: 5
Matthews: 5
Inniss: 5
Famewo: 5.5
Gunter: 5
Dobson: 5.5
Clare: 4
DJ: 3.5
Morgan: 3.5
Washington: 5
Stockley: 5
Davison: 4.5
Referee: 3

DubaiCAFC

MacG: 5 poor mistake for the 1st goal, shit myself every time the ball goes back to him him.
Matthews: 5.5 didn’t do anything wrong or anything good either 
Inniss: 5.5 fairly solid, nearly caught a few times in possession 
Famewo: 6 as above, giving an extra .5 because he dug himself out of difficult position 
Gunter: 6 did okay, couple of half decent crosses on weaker foot
Dobson: 5.5 was okay, did his job, but didn’t effect the game 
Clare: 4.5 very poor, ran around looking busy, didn’t get close to his man, ran away from the ball, and when he got the ball, it got stuck under his feet. Unimpressed so far
DJ: 4 was he event on the pitch, not sure if it was our tactics or he was so poor that he never got the ball 
Morgan: 6 he tried, but poor quality, he needs a big season, 2 games down, has made no impact as of yet.
Washington:  6 tried hard, but poor decision making, looks busy, gets in to good position but then lacks to deceive
Stockley: 5.5 needless fouls, lack of ball, lacked service too
Davison: 3 did he come on??
Referee: 6 I thought he got most right.. 

Watson: n/a
Clayden n/a
Clayden n/a

Taxi_Lad

MacG:  4  not impressed so far
Matthews:  4  not at it today 
Inniss: 6.5  solid
Famewo:  6.5 mom
Gunter:  4  oh dear!!
Dobson: 6  battled
Clare:  4  meh
DJ: 3 did DJs non footballing twin play
Morgan: 4  tried but not sure he has the talent so many think he has
Washington:  6  faded 2nd half
Stockley: 5  won a few headers
Davison: 4  

Pavoren007

MacG: 6 Pulled off a good save or two but could have done better with their first, albeit the damage was already done upfield 
Matthews: 5 A quiet game and was done on the overlap a couple of times a bit too easily
Inniss: 6 Thought his and Famewo’s passing to one another was bordering a bit arrogant and chancer like at times - otherwise his usual towering menace self
Famewo: 7 Took a chance or two at times at the back today but otherwise thought he threw his all in
Gunter: 5 Tried to fill in the best he could but he is not a left back, Welsh international or not
Dobson: 6 Tidy game extra half a point for the giggles he gave me watching him move around like a 70 year old when the ball was out of play - really odd body language for one so young, but liked it
Clare: 5 Needs more than energy
DJ: 5 Was starved of the ball
Morgan: 6 Sprightly enough - don’t shoot, don’t shoot…
Washington: 6 Industrious enough and cooly taken pen
Stockley: 6 Nice flicks but constrained by the referee’s pettiness at times 
Davison: 5 Was quieter than I had hoped, but how far did that ball bounce away from his Superman chest frame when he tried to chest it back to Matthews? A shame you don’t earn anything for that capability other than award the opposition a throw in. 
Referee: 4

Watson: n/a
Clayden n/a 

Scott

MacG: 6
Matthews: 5
Inniss: 6
Famewo: 7
Gunter: 6
Dobson: 4
Clare: 5
DJ: 4
Morgan: 4
Washington: 5
Stockley: 6
Davison: 5
Referee: 3

WhenIwasLittleBoy

MacG: 7
Matthews: 6
Inniss: 7
Famewo: 7
Gunter: 5
Dobson:6
Clare: 6
DJ:5
Morgan: 5
Washington:  7
Stockley: 6
Davison: 5
Referee 2

roseandcrown

MacG:  5.5
Matthews: 6
Inniss: 6.5
Famewo:  6
Gunter:  5.5
Dobson: 6
Clare: 6
DJ:  5
Morgan: 6
Washington:  7
Stockley: 6
Davison: 5.5
Referee:  5

seth plum

MacG: 5.5
Matthews: 6
Inniss: 5
Famewo: 7
Gunter: 6
Dobson: 6
Clare: 5
DJ: 5
Morgan: 7.5
Washington:  7
Stockley: 6.5

Davison: 6

Referee: 5

JamesSeed

MacG: 5
Matthews: 5
Inniss: 5 Not at his best. Will help his fitness playing 96 mins.
Famewo: 6
Gunter: 6
Dobson: 6
Clare: 5.5
DJ: 5 Wasn’t involved. His fault? Not sure. 
Morgan: 6 Had some good moments. Tenses up near their pen area. 
Washington: 6 Workmanlike
Stockley: 6 Too many long balls to his head. 
Davison: 6 Actually did quite well
Referee: 4

TEL

MacG 4.5 not convinced
Matthews: 5 blah
Inniss: 4.5 worst I've seen him play
Famewo: 5
Gunter: 4.5 not the answer is he.
Dobson:5 Juries out 
Clare: 3 was he playing?
DJ:3 was he playing too?
Morgan: 5 tidy but not the answer yet
Washington: 5 system not suiting his play
Stockley: 5 he is better than hoof ball, poor system
Davison: 4.5 not the answer 
Referee: 3 mega inconsistent.