MacG: 8 clean sheet and good saves. Not bad for a dud Matthews: 8, he pushed forward today Inniss: 6, not clicked yet this season Famewo: 7 solid Gunter: 7 not bad seeing he was out of position DJ: 8 good game Morgan: 8, so much better when playing deeper Watson: 7, so tidy and always in the right spot Kirk: 6, not great today but he will be Stockley: 8, anyone else disappointed that he didn’t get on his knees and head the ball on Washington: 7.5 great movement but finishing was poor Elerewe: 7 next one sold to the prem Referee:
MacG: 8.5 some top saves Matthews: 7 done well Inniss: 7 hope hes not badly hurt Famewo: 8.5 quality Gunter: 7 best this season DJ: 8 surprised he was subbed Morgan: 7 best this season Watson: 7 as above Kirk: 7 more to come Stockley: 8.5 non stop graft Washington: 7 should have had 2 goals Elerewe:7 lots of potential Referee: 8 very good
MacGillivray: 8 - Made some more top saves this afternoon, really starting to settle Matthews: 7 - Much better going forward, linked up well with DJ Inniss: 7 - Both Centre-Backs were a lot more assured today Famewo: 7.5 - Best game since returning to the club Gunter: 8 - Outstanding, lovely cross for the first goal Jaiyesimi: 8 - Took his goal really well, gave their Left-Back nightmares Morgan: 8 - MUCH better today, worked so hard for the team today Watson: 8 (MOTM) - Ran the Midfield, best game since he's joined Kirk: 7 - Still settling in, loads more for him to show Stockley: 8 - Really composed with his goal, links up really well with everyone Washington: 7.5 - Deserved a goal, puts in a proper shift for the team every week
Elerewe: 7 - Are we sure he's only seventeen?
Referee: 7 - Maybe a bit too lenient at times with Stockley being dragged about but good job today
MacG: 8 solid clean sheet with two decent stops Matthews: 8 decent performance and few great crosses Inniss: 7.5 solid as ever but again fitness worrying Famewo: 8 oozes class Gunter: 7.5 decent performance for a RB DJ: 8 plus 0.5 for excellent desire for goal and some nice tricks Morgan: 8 excellent performance from albie happy nige stuck with him and he is so much more comfortable is CM that’s his position sitting deeper spraying pin point passes one stunning pass just before half time to DJ and he never hides ever Watson: 8 thought he was excellent with AM in midfield today breaking play up and experience showed Kirk: 7 flashes of decent play but wasn’t a big threat Stockley: 9 motm brilliant no.9 had both the centre backs and scored a goal n worked socks off Washington: 8.5 excellent running would of been motm if had finished one of his chances Elerewe: 7 real prospect I feel Referee: 7 missed quite a few shirt pulls etc but tried to let game flow and one of better ones had
Lee: n/a (for interest be happy to see a mark for him but won't count): intelligent player v good addition I feel Clare: n/a Bags of energy looked sharp in short cameo
This is pretty accurate. Only difference is that I would give Dobson 10 for not playing and giving us a chance 😆
Matthews: 7.5 MOM really good Inniss: 6.5 Looking leaner/fitter Famewo: 7 Looking leaner/fitter Gunter: 7 One of his best for us DJ: 7 Extra 1 for the goal Morgan: 6.5 Best this season Watson: 6 Ok for the tortoise Kirk: 6 Quiet game, nice touches Stockley: 7.5 Usual Stockley Washington: 7 VG apart from shots Elerewe: 7 So composed. Referee: 8 Excellent Mr Invisible
MacG: 7.5 Matthews: 7.5 Inniss: 7 Famewo: 7 slightly surprised at some of the scores elsewhere, as he had a couple of iffy moment early in the game, e.g. when he lost the ball after trying to carry it out Gunter: 8 DJ: 8 Morgan: 7.5 Watson: 7.5 Kirk: 6.5 Stockley: 7 Washington: 7 would have been higher but for his finishing, as he was excellent otherwise Elerewe: 7 Referee: 6
MacG: 7.5 growing more comfortable every game I see him in, fast distribution as well Matthews: 7.5 solid today Inniss: 7 Famewo7.5 : Gunter: 7.5 DJ: 8 not everything came off but did very well Morgan: 7.5 he's so much better further back Watson: 7.5 better from him and think and he and Albie complemented each other Kirk: 6 but anonymous, went backwards a lot Stockley: 7.5 Washington: 7.5 fantastic work rate, hope he scores from open play soon Elerewe: 7.5 Referee: 7.5 a bit niggly at times but tried to keep the game flowing and largely succeeded
Lee: n/a (for interest be happy to see a mark for him but won't count): 7 Clare: n/a
MacG: 8 Decent saves - looks composed Matthews: 8.5 Defended & attacked well. Needs to improve his crossing. Inniss: 7 Defended well & won his headers Famewo: 7.5 Solid throughout but needs to improve his passing Gunter: 8 Defended well & great cross for the first goal DJ: 7 Good first half but tired in the second Morgan: 7.5, so much better today & worked his socks off. Needs to improve his crossing Watson: 7.5, so tidy and always in the right spot Kirk: 6, Struggled to get into the game Stockley: 8, Strong centre forward play & took goal well. Had his shirt pulled all game. Washington: 7.5 great movement but finishing was poor Elerewe: 8 Oozes quality Referee: 7
MacG: 7.5 - a couple of good saves and an authoritative display Matthews: 8 - a very classy performance Inniss: 6.5 - dominant in the air but fatigue and injury are a concern Famewo: 7.5 - gave the ball away once in a dangerous position but played very well otherwise. Good pace and use of his body strength Gunter: 7 - the best I've seen him play DJ: 8.5:MoTM - a box of tricks and ran their defence ragged until he tired late on Morgan: 8 - a fine performance in his preferred deeper position. So much more comfortable than being shoehorned into an advanced 'number 10' position for which he's ill-equipped Watson: 7 - played well and helped us control the game Kirk: 6 - some nice touches but a generally quiet game Stockley: 8 - took his chance really well and denied a second by an outstanding save Washington: 6.5 - a good assist but passed up two good chances Elerewe: 7 - a very composed and impressive half hour Referee: 7 - missed one or two things but I liked the way he let the game flow
Inniss: 7.5 - hopefully he's OK and was taken off as a precaution.
Famewo: 7.5 - played well
Gunter: 8 - great assist, great shot from range. Defended well
DJ: 8 - can't believe someone on another thread thought he was over rated... Man oozes creative brilliance constantly, such a threat
Morgan: 7.5 - much better deeper in midfield today, didn't stop running.
Watson: 7.5 - another solid display, under rated by many but very slow.
Kirk: 7 - wasn't involved enough, decent shot from the cross
Stockley: 8.5 - hussled and harried till the end, scored and nearly scored. Captains performance.
Washington: 8 - ran and ran and ran, great assist, should have scored, and hit the target with another.
Elerewe: 7 - classy player.
Referee: 6 - did OK, missed a lot of shirt pulling. Got more right than wrong though.
Lee: n/a (for interest be happy to see a mark for him but won't count): did on, got on the ball, was a threat in and around the box
Clare: n/a - played really well whilst he was on too. Some great link up play and tidying up
Well ... that would be me. So, let me help you.
I will concede that he had his best game in a Charlton shirt today.
Nice ... if unexpected ... headed goal. Some tricks, some good attempts at decent through-balls.
But ... woeful crossing. I really think that he doesn't know how to kick a ball. And check how many times on various threads that we hear ''good first half, but then faded."
So, if your definition of a good player is someone who does a few tricks and gets lucky from time to time ... then, yes, we have a winner.
Me? I think he's woeful.
And I really don't care if I am in the minority. Come back to this thread in 12 months and we'll have a humble pie festival.
MacG: 7 Couple of good saves, looks so much more assertive now. Matthews: 7 Very solid performance Inniss: 6 has his off moments, worried about him lasting a season though Famewo: 7.5 Commanded the back line, love seeing him do the odd forward run...catches teams off guard Gunter: 7 Very good game, best Ive personally seen of him DJ: 7 Curbs summed him up well, looks a bit tired until he's on the ball....great header. Learned from last week to actually get in the box more. Morgan:7.5 Much more suited to this roll in 442, he had a great game and didnt hide. Watson: 7.5 Classy today, didn't put much of a foot wrong, made the simple stuff look elegant. Kirk: 6 Touches of class but not involved enough Stockley:7.5 Works his arse off and love the passion Washington: 6 Worked very hard, good in a two up front Elerewe:7 great future n front of him. Referee: 6......shame he didn't pull up the constant shirt pulls though. otherwise pretty good.
Lee: n/a (for interest be happy to see a mark for him but won't count): 6 not bad for a first game off the bench. Clare: n/a
MacG: 8 solid. Distribution could be more imaginative Matthews: 7 Easy afternoon for him. Crewe used to have a good left winger, but he wasn't playing for them yesterday Inniss: 6.5 concern from me. Not quite the player he was last season Famewo: 7 solid but got caught in possession once or twice. Cruising Gunter: 8.5 Best game for a while DJ: 8. Includes his bonus point for wearing black boots. Better in the air than people might think Morgan: 8.5 Phheew! Watson: 7.5. He's a calming influence Kirk: 7 Had a couple of shots. Stockley: 8.5. Bossed it again Washington: 9. Everything but a goal Elerewe: 7 bit of a baby giraffe. Would like to see him tested against some big nasty f**ckers Referee: 9 missed a bit of shirt pulling, but excellent really
As for Lee, 5. Looked rusty and slow-footed. If his name was Hasselbaink, I doubt he'd be getting the plaudits so early on. I'm sure he'll get better and will be a regular though.
MacG: 7.5 Good saves and quick throws. Matthews: 8 Defended very well and got forward with a lot of purpose in 2nd half. Looked a class player. Inniss: 7 Very steady, stood up well one on one in the box and won a lot of 1st balls from our own set-pieces. Famewo: 7.5 I like the way he tries to stay on his feet and use body strength rather than be reckless. Gunter: 8 Looked every inch a top player at this level. Ok, he's not going to produce great passes at left-back but his cross was perfect and his rocket shot would have been goal of the decade. Got in first to nick the ball and started attacks. DJ: 7 - Saw a lot of the ball in the first 10 mins and his header was superb. But he does struggle a bit defensively and one of the reasons the game was so open (joy!) was that he was a tad lazy tracking back. However...this did mean he was available for the counter. Has a good touch, is strong and turns very tightly. He'll get better too. Morgan: 7.5 Covered a lot of ground and played as a more all-round, old fashioned midfielder. Made quite a few vital blocks and clearances. Watson: 7.5 So comfortable on the ball and benefited from the 4-4-2, which allowed him to play more of his game higher up. Kirk: 6 He looks a good player but struggled to get enough ball because we play out to the right (avoiding putting Gunter onto his weaker foot). That's why he tucked inside quite a bit. I did like his positional play when we were out of possession and he looks an intelligent player. Ghosted in well for his shot at goal and you can see him getting quite a few. Stockley: 8 - Their centre-back pulled him about a bit early on but he didn't let that rattle him. He stayed true to his game and gradually got the upper hand. Took his goal well and only a fantastic save stopped him from getting another. Really good centre-forward. Wish we'd had him in The Championship. Washington: 8 - The off the ball runs were magnificent and completely threw the Crewe defence out of line. His touches were good, especially for the Stockley goal and he's a really important player for the team. He'll get some goals further down the line but his runs from deep are key. Elerewe: 8 - Wow! Never seen the lad before but he looks good. Bigger clubs will already be looking at him based on what I saw yesterday. The blend of composure and good defending were very eye-catching. Referee: 7 - Let the game flow but did seem to miss the early shirt-pulling from Crewe. Overall though, I prefer to see things kept moving, so well done.
Lee: n/a (for interest be happy to see a mark for him but won't count): 6.5 - Maybe a tad unfit (that'll come) but seemed quite bright in his movement and touch. Looks a decent player. Clare: n/a Showed some excellent touches and looked very sharp. Exactly what you need from a sub late in a game.
Comments
Matthews: 8
Inniss: 7
Famewo: 7
Gunter: 7
DJ: 7
Morgan: 6
Watson: 6.5
Kirk: 6.5
Stockley: 7.5
Washington: 7
Elerewe:7
Matthews: 8, he pushed forward today
Inniss: 6, not clicked yet this season
Famewo: 7 solid
Gunter: 7 not bad seeing he was out of position
DJ: 8 good game
Morgan: 8, so much better when playing deeper
Watson: 7, so tidy and always in the right spot
Kirk: 6, not great today but he will be
Stockley: 8, anyone else disappointed that he didn’t get on his knees and head the ball on
Washington: 7.5 great movement but finishing was poor
Elerewe: 7 next one sold to the prem
Referee:
Matthews: 7 done well
Inniss: 7 hope hes not badly hurt
Famewo: 8.5 quality
Gunter: 7 best this season
DJ: 8 surprised he was subbed
Morgan: 7 best this season
Watson: 7 as above
Kirk: 7 more to come
Stockley: 8.5 non stop graft
Washington: 7 should have had 2 goals
Elerewe:7 lots of potential
Referee: 8 very good
Matthews: 6.5
Inniss: 6.5
Famewo: 6.5
Gunter: 7
DJ: 8
Morgan: 7.5
Watson: 7
Kirk: 7
Stockley: 8
Washington: 8.5
Elerewe: 6.5
Referee: 7
Matthews: 7 - Much better going forward, linked up well with DJ
Inniss: 7 - Both Centre-Backs were a lot more assured today
Famewo: 7.5 - Best game since returning to the club
Gunter: 8 - Outstanding, lovely cross for the first goal
Jaiyesimi: 8 - Took his goal really well, gave their Left-Back nightmares
Morgan: 8 - MUCH better today, worked so hard for the team today
Watson: 8 (MOTM) - Ran the Midfield, best game since he's joined
Kirk: 7 - Still settling in, loads more for him to show
Stockley: 8 - Really composed with his goal, links up really well with everyone
Washington: 7.5 - Deserved a goal, puts in a proper shift for the team every week
Elerewe: 7 - Are we sure he's only seventeen?
Referee: 7 - Maybe a bit too lenient at times with Stockley being dragged about but good job today
Matthews: 7
Inniss: 7
Famewo: 8.5
Gunter: 7
DJ: 7.5
Morgan: 7
Watson: 7
Kirk: 6
Stockley: 8
Washington: 7
Elerewe: 7
Referee: 6.5
Matthews: 7
Inniss: 7
Famewo: 7
Gunter: 8
DJ: 7
Morgan: 7
Watson: 7
Kirk: 7
Stockley: 8
Washington: 8
Elerewe: 7
Referee: 7
Matthews: 7.5
Inniss: 7
Famewo: 7 slightly surprised at some of the scores elsewhere, as he had a couple of iffy moment early in the game, e.g. when he lost the ball after trying to carry it out
Gunter: 8
DJ: 8
Morgan: 7.5
Watson: 7.5
Kirk: 6.5
Stockley: 7
Washington: 7 would have been higher but for his finishing, as he was excellent otherwise
Elerewe: 7
Referee: 6
Matthews: 8
Inniss: 7
Famewo: 8
Gunter: 7
DJ: 7
Morgan: 7
Watson: 7
Kirk: 6
Stockley: 7
Washington: 6
Elerewe: 6
Matthews: 7.5
Inniss: 7
Famewo: 7
Gunter: 7.5
DJ: 7.5
Morgan: 7.5
Watson: 7.5
Kirk: 5
Stockley: 8
Washington: 8
Elerewe: 7
Referee: 6
Matthews: 8
Inniss: 7
Famewo: 7
Gunter: 7.5
DJ: 7.5
Morgan: 8
Watson: 7.5
Kirk: 6.5
Stockley: 8
Washington: 8
Elerewe: 7.5
Referee: 7
Matthews: 7
Inniss: 7
Famewo: 7
Gunter: 7
DJ: 7
Morgan:7
Watson: 8
Kirk: 7
Stockley: 8
Washington: 7
Elerewe:7
Referee: 6
Matthews: 7
Inniss: 7
Famewo: 8
Gunter: 8.5
DJ: 8
Morgan: 7
Watson: 7
Kirk: 6
Stockley: 8
Washington: 7
Elerewe: 7
Referee: 7
Lee: n/a (for interest be happy to see a mark for him but won't count): 7
Clare: n/a
Matthews: 7
Inniss: 7
Famewo: 7
Gunter: 7.5
DJ: 7.5
Morgan: 7
Watson: 7
Kirk: 7
Stockley: 8
Washington: 7.5
Elerewe: 7
Referee: 6
Matthews: 7.5 solid today
Inniss: 7
Famewo7.5 :
Gunter: 7.5
DJ: 8 not everything came off but did very well
Morgan: 7.5 he's so much better further back
Watson: 7.5 better from him and think and he and Albie complemented each other
Kirk: 6 but anonymous, went backwards a lot
Stockley: 7.5
Washington: 7.5 fantastic work rate, hope he scores from open play soon
Elerewe: 7.5
Referee: 7.5 a bit niggly at times but tried to keep the game flowing and largely succeeded
Lee: n/a (for interest be happy to see a mark for him but won't count): 7
Clare: n/a
Matthews: 8.5 Defended & attacked well. Needs to improve his crossing.
Inniss: 7 Defended well & won his headers
Famewo: 7.5 Solid throughout but needs to improve his passing
Gunter: 8 Defended well & great cross for the first goal
DJ: 7 Good first half but tired in the second
Morgan: 7.5, so much better today & worked his socks off. Needs to improve his crossing
Watson: 7.5, so tidy and always in the right spot
Kirk: 6, Struggled to get into the game
Stockley: 8, Strong centre forward play & took goal well. Had his shirt pulled all game.
Washington: 7.5 great movement but finishing was poor
Elerewe: 8 Oozes quality
Referee: 7
Matthews:7 very good defensively, indecisive going forwards
Inniss: 7
Famewo:7.5
Gunter: 7
DJ: 7
Morgan: 8
Watson: 7
Kirk: 5
Stockley 7.5:
Washington: 7
Elerewe:7
Referee: 6
Lee: n/a (for interest be happy to see a mark for him but won't count): 5
Clare: n/a 7
Matthews: 8 - a very classy performance
Inniss: 6.5 - dominant in the air but fatigue and injury are a concern
Famewo: 7.5 - gave the ball away once in a dangerous position but played very well otherwise. Good pace and use of his body strength
Gunter: 7 - the best I've seen him play
DJ: 8.5:MoTM - a box of tricks and ran their defence ragged until he tired late on
Morgan: 8 - a fine performance in his preferred deeper position. So much more comfortable than being shoehorned into an advanced 'number 10' position for which he's ill-equipped
Watson: 7 - played well and helped us control the game
Kirk: 6 - some nice touches but a generally quiet game
Stockley: 8 - took his chance really well and denied a second by an outstanding save
Washington: 6.5 - a good assist but passed up two good chances
Elerewe: 7 - a very composed and impressive half hour
Referee: 7 - missed one or two things but I liked the way he let the game flow
Matthews: 7.5
Inniss: 7
Famewo: 7
Gunter: 8
DJ: 8
Morgan: 8
Watson: 7.5
Kirk: 7
Stockley: 7.5
Washington: 8
Elerewe: 7
Referee: 7
I will concede that he had his best game in a Charlton shirt today.
Nice ... if unexpected ... headed goal. Some tricks, some good attempts at decent through-balls.
But ... woeful crossing. I really think that he doesn't know how to kick a ball. And check how many times on various threads that we hear ''good first half, but then faded."
So, if your definition of a good player is someone who does a few tricks and gets lucky from time to time ... then, yes, we have a winner.
Me? I think he's woeful.
And I really don't care if I am in the minority. Come back to this thread in 12 months and we'll have a humble pie festival.
Matthews: 7
Inniss: 6
Famewo: 7
Gunter: 6
DJ: 7
Morgan: 7
Watson: 8
Kirk: 6
Stockley: 7
Washington: 6
Elerewe:7
Referee: 6
Matthews: 7 Very solid performance
Inniss: 6 has his off moments, worried about him lasting a season though
Famewo: 7.5 Commanded the back line, love seeing him do the odd forward run...catches teams off guard
Gunter: 7 Very good game, best Ive personally seen of him
DJ: 7 Curbs summed him up well, looks a bit tired until he's on the ball....great header. Learned from last week to actually get in the box more.
Morgan:7.5 Much more suited to this roll in 442, he had a great game and didnt hide.
Watson: 7.5 Classy today, didn't put much of a foot wrong, made the simple stuff look elegant.
Kirk: 6 Touches of class but not involved enough
Stockley:7.5 Works his arse off and love the passion
Washington: 6 Worked very hard, good in a two up front
Elerewe:7 great future n front of him.
Referee: 6......shame he didn't pull up the constant shirt pulls though. otherwise pretty good.
Lee: n/a (for interest be happy to see a mark for him but won't count): 6 not bad for a first game off the bench.
Clare: n/a
Matthews: 7 Easy afternoon for him. Crewe used to have a good left winger, but he wasn't playing for them yesterday
Inniss: 6.5 concern from me. Not quite the player he was last season
Famewo: 7 solid but got caught in possession once or twice. Cruising
Gunter: 8.5 Best game for a while
DJ: 8. Includes his bonus point for wearing black boots. Better in the air than people might think
Morgan: 8.5 Phheew!
Watson: 7.5. He's a calming influence
Kirk: 7 Had a couple of shots.
Stockley: 8.5. Bossed it again
Washington: 9. Everything but a goal
Elerewe: 7 bit of a baby giraffe. Would like to see him tested against some big nasty f**ckers
Referee: 9 missed a bit of shirt pulling, but excellent really
As for Lee, 5. Looked rusty and slow-footed. If his name was Hasselbaink, I doubt he'd be getting the plaudits so early on. I'm sure he'll get better and will be a regular though.
Matthews: 8 Defended very well and got forward with a lot of purpose in 2nd half. Looked a class player.
Inniss: 7 Very steady, stood up well one on one in the box and won a lot of 1st balls from our own set-pieces.
Famewo: 7.5 I like the way he tries to stay on his feet and use body strength rather than be reckless.
Gunter: 8 Looked every inch a top player at this level. Ok, he's not going to produce great passes at left-back but his cross was perfect and his rocket shot would have been goal of the decade. Got in first to nick the ball and started attacks.
DJ: 7 - Saw a lot of the ball in the first 10 mins and his header was superb. But he does struggle a bit defensively and one of the reasons the game was so open (joy!) was that he was a tad lazy tracking back. However...this did mean he was available for the counter. Has a good touch, is strong and turns very tightly. He'll get better too.
Morgan: 7.5 Covered a lot of ground and played as a more all-round, old fashioned midfielder. Made quite a few vital blocks and clearances.
Watson: 7.5 So comfortable on the ball and benefited from the 4-4-2, which allowed him to play more of his game higher up.
Kirk: 6 He looks a good player but struggled to get enough ball because we play out to the right (avoiding putting Gunter onto his weaker foot). That's why he tucked inside quite a bit. I did like his positional play when we were out of possession and he looks an intelligent player. Ghosted in well for his shot at goal and you can see him getting quite a few.
Stockley: 8 - Their centre-back pulled him about a bit early on but he didn't let that rattle him. He stayed true to his game and gradually got the upper hand. Took his goal well and only a fantastic save stopped him from getting another. Really good centre-forward. Wish we'd had him in The Championship.
Washington: 8 - The off the ball runs were magnificent and completely threw the Crewe defence out of line. His touches were good, especially for the Stockley goal and he's a really important player for the team. He'll get some goals further down the line but his runs from deep are key.
Elerewe: 8 - Wow! Never seen the lad before but he looks good. Bigger clubs will already be looking at him based on what I saw yesterday. The blend of composure and good defending were very eye-catching.
Referee: 7 - Let the game flow but did seem to miss the early shirt-pulling from Crewe. Overall though, I prefer to see things kept moving, so well done.
Lee: n/a (for interest be happy to see a mark for him but won't count): 6.5 - Maybe a tad unfit (that'll come) but seemed quite bright in his movement and touch. Looks a decent player.
Clare: n/a Showed some excellent touches and looked very sharp. Exactly what you need from a sub late in a game.