MacG: 6 Didn't have much to do Matthews: 5 poor defending for there first Lavelle: 5 second is down to him being pulled out of shape Pearce: 6 apart from suicide forward passes defended really well Souaré: 5 not fit and gets caught with the ball a lot Gilbey: 7 Outstanding considering how long he has been out Arter: 3 erm why? Watson: 6 played well again Leko: 5 poor first half but slightly better second Stockley: 3 better without him. Bringing nothing apart from whining Lee: 5 fades in and out. Clare: 5 good goal but gives the ball away in dangerous positions Referee: 5
MacG: 6.5 not much to say tbh Matthews: 6 can't decide about him. Some bad, some decent, and saved us a couple of times Lavelle: 7.5 I really rate him tbh Pearce: 6.5 yes he courted disaster, but it never actually happened. Now if Famewo promises not to biff it out of play all the time he can have another go maybe Souaré: 6 a few great tackles but some rusty passing. One lovely cross Gilbey: 6 a sort of random outcome generator but gamely ran about at least Arter: 2 a genuine fucking disgrace. End his loan now, he's shot Watson: 6 not his best game but has somehow become a...shudder...key cog. Unsustainable but it is what it is Leko: 6.5 Endeavour, effort, skill and some wild finishing Stockley: 3 offered nothing, came off way too late Lee: 7.5 at times our only footballer and instrumental to everything good we did while he was on Clare: 7 great finish, great engine, hilarious booking. HE'S BACK Referee: 4 one of the worst non-advantages in living memory
MacG: 6 nothing much to do Matthews: 6 marginally better than Gunter Lavelle: 6.5 fairly solid and better distribution Pearce: 6 battled away nearly cost us late on pissing about Souaré: 5 at fault for 2nd goal legs had gone last 15 Gilbey: 6 selfish in good attacking areas little end product Arter: 5 didn’t notice him and only lasted 45 Watson: 6 extra half point for diagonal to CBT to set up our 2nd otherwise meh Leko: 6 couple of nice runs but no end product Stockley: 5 oh dear, he’s lost his mojo Davison should’ve started Lee: 6 not sure we can play him and Gilbey together faded and subbed off again Clare: 6 brought some energy,extra point for his goal minus half a point as partly culpable for their 2nd Referee: 6 a few weak decisions but all those booked deserved it
Davison: 8 poachers goal, more impact in10 mins than Stockley’s 80. Blackett-Taylor: 9 saved Adkins skin another who should’ve started
at the Valley or from a live screen your marks please:
MacG: 6 showed too much of the goal for the first Matthews: 5 crossing was worse than ever Lavelle: 6 a limited player Pearce: 7.5 strong defending Souaré: 5 prefer Purrington Gilbey: 7.5 kept going , but shooting a bit Church like Arter: 2 should have come off sooner Watson: 4 some decent passes , but woefully slow Leko: 5 got into good positions , but looked clueless when he had the ball Stockley: 2.5 should have come off at half time Lee: 6 good at times , but looked frustrated as his teammates refused to pass to him Clare: 7 got stuck in , but looks a bit cumbersome Referee: 2 didn't play advantage , and didn't give clear foul on Soure resulting in their 2nd
Davison: 7 should have been on at half time Blackett-Taylor: 8 scared the shit out of them . Should have been on at half time
Lavelle: 7 Pearce: 8 Souaré: 6 Gilbey: 7 Arter: 6 Watson: 8 Leko: 7 at fault for first goal not tracking his man and leaving Matthews with the impossible task of marking two Stockley: 7 Lee: 7 Clare 7
MacG: 6 nothing much to do Matthews: 6 marginally better than Gunter Lavelle: 6.5 fairly solid and better distribution Pearce: 6 battled away nearly cost us late on pissing about Souaré: 5 at fault for 2nd goal legs had gone last 15 Gilbey: 6 selfish in good attacking areas little end product Arter: 5 didn’t notice him and only lasted 45 Watson: 6 extra half point for diagonal to CBT to set up our 2nd otherwise meh Leko: 6 couple of nice runs but no end product Stockley: 5 oh dear, he’s lost his mojo Davison should’ve started Lee: 6 not sure we can play him and Gilbey together faded and subbed off again Clare: 6 brought some energy,extra point for his goal minus half a point for being partly culpable fir their second Referee: 6 a few week decisions but all those booked deserved it
Davison: 8 poachers goal, more impact in10 mins than Stockley’s 80. Blackett-Taylor: 9 saved Adkins skin another who should’ve started
Blackett Taylor not fit your start … Adkins got it spot on today
MacG: 6 Not much chance with either goal. Matthews: 6 Was he at fault for the first? Not so sure. Lavelle: 6 Like him. Shame about the second goal Pearce: 6 Very mixed game, to say the least! Souaré: 5.5 Last 20 minutes knackered Gilbey: 7 Our best player today. Amazing considering his covid. Arter: 3 Surely he's better than we saw today? Watson: 6 Wonderful pass setting up the cross for the second. Leko: 6 Tired towards the end. Stockley: 4 Poor season so far. Lee: 6.5 Did fine. Clare: 6.5 Good sub, well taken goal. Referee: 5 Played several advantages today but not the most obvious one.
MacG: 6 nothing much to do Matthews: 6 marginally better than Gunter Lavelle: 6.5 fairly solid and better distribution Pearce: 6 battled away nearly cost us late on pissing about Souaré: 5 at fault for 2nd goal legs had gone last 15 Gilbey: 6 selfish in good attacking areas little end product Arter: 5 didn’t notice him and only lasted 45 Watson: 6 extra half point for diagonal to CBT to set up our 2nd otherwise meh Leko: 6 couple of nice runs but no end product Stockley: 5 oh dear, he’s lost his mojo Davison should’ve started Lee: 6 not sure we can play him and Gilbey together faded and subbed off again Clare: 6 brought some energy,extra point for his goal minus half a point for being partly culpable fir their second Referee: 6 a few week decisions but all those booked deserved it
Davison: 8 poachers goal, more impact in10 mins than Stockley’s 80. Blackett-Taylor: 9 saved Adkins skin another who should’ve started
Blackett Taylor not fit your start … Adkins got it spot on today
Your start, you what??? I'll tell you what you're not fit to post! Mathews 9, Watson 8 & Stockley 7 🤣🤣🤣. Adkins is living on borrowed time, CBT and Davison saved his skin for the time being.
MacG: 6 No chance with either goal, not sure he did anything standout either though
Matthews: 5 At fault for the first, didn't commit to a decision either way.
Lavelle: 7.5 Pretty solid and showed some decent reading of the yame.
Pearce: 6 okay - that horrific Cruyff aside.
Souaré: 6.5 First 90 in how long? Did well enough imo. Certainly better than Gunter.
Gilbey: 7.5 Kept at it all game. He's our no.10 for me.
Arter: 3 not sure I've ever seen someone do so little of use. Somehow he had a 90% pass success rate how he missed 10% of two foot passes is beyond me. He legitimately made it feel like we had 10 men, then those two corners.
Watson: 6 If he could time his tackles he'd be a 7.5
Leko: 6.5 Looked shattered by the end.
Stockley: 4 Can't play well in a 4-3-3 this season... Missing Millar?
Lee: 7 constant threat.
Clare: 7.5 came on scored. Worked hard, won tackles, took the tactical booking.
Referee: 4. Should be booked for blowing too early on a clear advantage situation.
Lavelle: 7 Pearce: 8 Souaré: 6 Gilbey: 7 Arter: 6 Watson: 8 Leko: 7 at fault for first goal not tracking his man and leaving Matthews with the impossible task of marking two Stockley: 7 Lee: 7 Clare 7
MacG: 6 nothing much to do Matthews: 6 marginally better than Gunter Lavelle: 6.5 fairly solid and better distribution Pearce: 6 battled away nearly cost us late on pissing about Souaré: 5 at fault for 2nd goal legs had gone last 15 Gilbey: 6 selfish in good attacking areas little end product Arter: 5 didn’t notice him and only lasted 45 Watson: 6 extra half point for diagonal to CBT to set up our 2nd otherwise meh Leko: 6 couple of nice runs but no end product Stockley: 5 oh dear, he’s lost his mojo Davison should’ve started Lee: 6 not sure we can play him and Gilbey together faded and subbed off again Clare: 6 brought some energy,extra point for his goal minus half a point for being partly culpable fir their second Referee: 6 a few week decisions but all those booked deserved it
Davison: 8 poachers goal, more impact in10 mins than Stockley’s 80. Blackett-Taylor: 9 saved Adkins skin another who should’ve started
Blackett Taylor not fit your start … Adkins got it spot on today
Your start, you what??? I'll tell you what you're not fit to post! Mathews 9, Watson 8 & Stockley 7 🤣🤣🤣. Adkins is living on borrowed time, CBT and Davison saved his skin for the time being.
Adkins going nowhere .. CBT was ruled out by the medical team he was wrapped up in ice on Tuesday not trained till Friday .. NA took a massive gamble with him that’s why he only risked him for 10 mins ..
Mac G 7 Matthews 6 Lavelle 7 Pearce 6 Souare 6 There's a good player in there once he is match fit Gilbey 7 Good performance for a man coming back from Covid Arter 5 Clearly not match fit and shouldn't be allowed to take corners Watson 7 The oil in the machine Leko 7 Glimpses of how good he will be when he has further game time Stockley 5 Predictable and one dimensional Lee 7 Good value for money Clare 6 Took his goal well but his passing is a little wayward at times Referee 6
Davison 6 Should be starting Blackett-Taylor 8 A real handful
MacG: 6 Matthews: 6 Lavelle: 6 Pearce: 6 Souaré: 6.5 Looked a cut above the rest Gilbey: 6.5 Very promising, hope he's properly fit soon Arter: 2 He first touched the ball on 20 mins and had another 10 mins later, when he kicked the ball 30 foot straight up in the air. I've never seen a worse performance. Watson: 7 I hate Watson but he was the best of a bad bunch & his best game for Charlton. Leko: 6 Generally runs with the ball & loses it & doesn't track back. Had one good shot. Stockley: 5 Poor although lots of effort. Lee: 6 Ok Clare: 7 Scored a good goal & plenty of running which we desperately need. But a lot of his passes were poor. Referee: 5 He was bloody excellent until about 60 mins, when I said as such. After that he was dreadful, giving them nearly everything and us nothing.
MacG: 6 Matthews: 7 Left isolated by poor tactics and fought hard Lavelle: 6.5 like him Pearce: 4 what can you say? Too decent a bloke to be humiliated in public by Nigel like this Souaré: 7 same as Matthews. Gilbey: 6 faded Arter: 4 never saw him Watson: 4 wish I hadn't Leko: 6 Stockley: 4 even his aimless running about looked awkward. Is he ill? Lee: 6 looked very frustrated about something Clare: 7 Looked goo and great goal Referee: 4 an idiot.
MacG: 5 - should have stopped their 2nd Matthews: 5 - should have stopped their 1st Lavelle: 6 pretty solid Pearce: 5 great in a scrap but a liability with the ball Souaré: 6 some good defending but caught in possession too often Gilbey: 6 did ok but not enough impact on the game Arter: 4 off the pace Watson: 7 played well Leko: 5 some poor decisions and execution Stockley: 5 never threatened Lee: 6.5 did well till he tired Clare: 7 good energy & great finish Referee: 5
MacG: 6 Matthews: 3 Can't stand him only plays because Gunter matches his inepitude Lavelle: 7 Good buy steady player Pearce: 5 Always gives 100% but stop trying to play out when you dont have the skill Souaré: 4 Poor Bambi on ice giving away the ball too often Gilbey: 7 Did wellfirst half.Need to perservere to get him fit Arter: 4 Legs gone Watson: 4 ditto Leko: 6.5 Gives us a threat running beyond Stockley: 4 Using Watson's concrete boots Lee: 6 Like him but felt he lacked fitness Clare: 6.5 Energy and great goal Referee: 4 an idiot did Gilbey out of 1 on 1 with GK Davison 7.5 Great work with his goal needs to start CBT 8 MoM Saved the game. Give him 3 year contract asap
Comments
Matthews: 5
Lavelle: 6
Pearce: 6
Souaré: 6
Gilbey: 6
Arter: 4
Watson: 5
Leko: 6
Stockley: 4
Lee: 7
Clare: 7
Referee: 4
Matthews: 5 poor defending for there first
Lavelle: 5 second is down to him being pulled out of shape
Pearce: 6 apart from suicide forward passes defended really well
Souaré: 5 not fit and gets caught with the ball a lot
Gilbey: 7 Outstanding considering how long he has been out
Arter: 3 erm why?
Watson: 6 played well again
Leko: 5 poor first half but slightly better second
Stockley: 3 better without him. Bringing nothing apart from whining
Lee: 5 fades in and out.
Clare: 5 good goal but gives the ball away in dangerous positions
Referee: 5
Really pleased for Josh and Corey.
Matthews: 6 can't decide about him. Some bad, some decent, and saved us a couple of times
Lavelle: 7.5 I really rate him tbh
Pearce: 6.5 yes he courted disaster, but it never actually happened. Now if Famewo promises not to biff it out of play all the time he can have another go maybe
Souaré: 6 a few great tackles but some rusty passing. One lovely cross
Gilbey: 6 a sort of random outcome generator but gamely ran about at least
Arter: 2 a genuine fucking disgrace. End his loan now, he's shot
Watson: 6 not his best game but has somehow become a...shudder...key cog. Unsustainable but it is what it is
Leko: 6.5 Endeavour, effort, skill and some wild finishing
Stockley: 3 offered nothing, came off way too late
Lee: 7.5 at times our only footballer and instrumental to everything good we did while he was on
Clare: 7 great finish, great engine, hilarious booking. HE'S BACK
Referee: 4 one of the worst non-advantages in living memory
Davison: n/a yes lad
Blackett-Taylor: n/a YES LAD
MacG: 8
Matthews: 7
Lavelle: 6.5
Pearce: 6
Souaré: 6.5
Gilbey: 6
Arter: 5
Watson: 6
Leko: 6.5
Stockley: 5
Lee: 6
Clare: 6.5
Referee: 5
Matthews: 6 marginally better than Gunter
Lavelle: 6.5 fairly solid and better distribution
Pearce: 6 battled away nearly cost us late on pissing about
Souaré: 5 at fault for 2nd goal legs had gone last 15
Gilbey: 6 selfish in good attacking areas little end product
Arter: 5 didn’t notice him and only lasted 45
Watson: 6 extra half point for diagonal to CBT to set up our 2nd otherwise meh
Leko: 6 couple of nice runs but no end product
Stockley: 5 oh dear, he’s lost his mojo Davison should’ve started
Lee: 6 not sure we can play him and Gilbey together faded and subbed off again
Clare: 6 brought some energy,extra point for his goal minus half a point as partly culpable for their 2nd
Referee: 6 a few weak decisions but all those booked deserved it
Davison: 8 poachers goal, more impact in10 mins than Stockley’s 80.
Blackett-Taylor: 9 saved Adkins skin another who should’ve started
Matthews: 7
Lavelle: 6.5
Pearce: 6
Souaré: 5
Gilbey: 6.5
Arter: 3
Watson: 4
Leko: 6
Stockley: 4
Lee: 7
Clare: 6.5
Referee: 4
Matthews: 5.5
Lavelle: 6
Pearce: 6
Souaré: 6
Gilbey: 6.5
Arter: 5
Watson: 6
Leko: 6.5
Stockley: 5
Lee: 7
Clare: 7
Referee: 3
Lavelle: 5
Pearce: 5
Souaré: 4
Gilbey: 6
Arter: 2
Watson: 4.5
Leko: 6.5
Stockley: 3.5
Lee: 6.5
Clare: 6.5
Referee: 3
Matthews: 9 MOM
Lavelle: 7
Pearce: 8
Souaré: 6
Gilbey: 7
Arter: 6
Watson: 8
Leko: 7 at fault for first goal not tracking his man and leaving Matthews with the impossible task of marking two
Stockley: 7
Lee: 7
Clare 7
Referee: 2 shocking second half
Matthews: 6 Was he at fault for the first? Not so sure.
Lavelle: 6 Like him. Shame about the second goal
Pearce: 6 Very mixed game, to say the least!
Souaré: 5.5 Last 20 minutes knackered
Gilbey: 7 Our best player today. Amazing considering his covid.
Arter: 3 Surely he's better than we saw today?
Watson: 6 Wonderful pass setting up the cross for the second.
Leko: 6 Tired towards the end.
Stockley: 4 Poor season so far.
Lee: 6.5 Did fine.
Clare: 6.5 Good sub, well taken goal.
Referee: 5 Played several advantages today but not the most obvious one.
Matthews: 4.5
Lavelle: 6
Pearce: 4
Souaré: 5
Gilbey: 7
Arter: 5
Watson: 6
Leko: 6.5
Stockley: 4.5
Lee: 6
Clare: 6.5
Referee: 5
Matthews: 5
Lavelle: 6
Pearce: 5
Souaré: 6
Gilbey: 6.5
Arter: 3
Watson: 6
Leko: 5
Stockley: 4
Lee: 7
Clare: 7
Referee: 4
Matthews 6
Lavelle 6
Pearce 6
Souare 6
Gilbey 6
Arter 5.5
Watson 6.5
Leko 6
Stockley 5.5
Lee 6.5
Clare 6.5
Ref 5.5
Matthews: 6
Lavelle: 7
Pearce: 6
Souaré: 6
Gilbey: 6
Arter: 4
Watson: 4
Leko: 6
Stockley: 5
Lee: 6
Clare: 7
Referee: 4
Davison: n/a
Blackett-Taylor: n/a
MacG: 6 No chance with either goal, not sure he did anything standout either though
Matthews 6
Lavelle 7
Pearce 6
Souare 6 There's a good player in there once he is match fit
Gilbey 7 Good performance for a man coming back from Covid
Arter 5 Clearly not match fit and shouldn't be allowed to take corners
Watson 7 The oil in the machine
Leko 7 Glimpses of how good he will be when he has further game time
Stockley 5 Predictable and one dimensional
Lee 7 Good value for money
Clare 6 Took his goal well but his passing is a little wayward at times
Referee 6
Davison 6 Should be starting
Blackett-Taylor 8 A real handful
MacG: 6
Matthews: 5
Lavelle: 6
Pearce: 5
Souaré: 5.5
Gilbey: 4
Arter: 4
Watson: 6
Leko: 5
Stockley: 5
Lee: 5
Clare: 6.5
Matthews: 6
Lavelle: 6
Pearce: 6
Souaré: 6.5 Looked a cut above the rest
Gilbey: 6.5 Very promising, hope he's properly fit soon
Arter: 2 He first touched the ball on 20 mins and had another 10 mins later, when he kicked the ball 30 foot straight up in the air. I've never seen a worse performance.
Watson: 7 I hate Watson but he was the best of a bad bunch & his best game for Charlton.
Leko: 6 Generally runs with the ball & loses it & doesn't track back. Had one good shot.
Stockley: 5 Poor although lots of effort.
Lee: 6 Ok
Clare: 7 Scored a good goal & plenty of running which we desperately need. But a lot of his passes were poor.
Referee: 5 He was bloody excellent until about 60 mins, when I said as such. After that he was dreadful, giving them nearly everything and us nothing.
Matthews: 7 Left isolated by poor tactics and fought hard
Lavelle: 6.5 like him
Pearce: 4 what can you say? Too decent a bloke to be humiliated in public by Nigel like this
Souaré: 7 same as Matthews.
Gilbey: 6 faded
Arter: 4 never saw him
Watson: 4 wish I hadn't
Leko: 6
Stockley: 4 even his aimless running about looked awkward. Is he ill?
Lee: 6 looked very frustrated about something
Clare: 7 Looked goo and great goal
Referee: 4 an idiot.
Matthews: 5 - should have stopped their 1st
Lavelle: 6 pretty solid
Pearce: 5 great in a scrap but a liability with the ball
Souaré: 6 some good defending but caught in possession too often
Gilbey: 6 did ok but not enough impact on the game
Arter: 4 off the pace
Watson: 7 played well
Leko: 5 some poor decisions and execution
Stockley: 5 never threatened
Lee: 6.5 did well till he tired
Clare: 7 good energy & great finish
Referee: 5
Davison: n/a 7
Blackett-Taylor: n/a 7
Matthews: 3 Can't stand him only plays because Gunter matches his inepitude
Lavelle: 7 Good buy steady player
Pearce: 5 Always gives 100% but stop trying to play out when you dont have the skill
Souaré: 4 Poor Bambi on ice giving away the ball too often
Gilbey: 7 Did wellfirst half.Need to perservere to get him fit
Arter: 4 Legs gone
Watson: 4 ditto
Leko: 6.5 Gives us a threat running beyond
Stockley: 4 Using Watson's concrete boots
Lee: 6 Like him but felt he lacked fitness
Clare: 6.5 Energy and great goal
Referee: 4 an idiot did Gilbey out of 1 on 1 with GK
Davison 7.5 Great work with his goal needs to start
CBT 8 MoM Saved the game. Give him 3 year contract asap
Matthews: 6
Lavelle: 6
Pearce: 5.5
Souaré: 6.5
Gilbey: 7
Arter: 3
Watson: 6.5
Leko: 6
Stockley: 5
Lee: 6.5
Clare: 6.5
Referee: 5
Matthews: 6
Lavelle: 7
Pearce: 5
Souaré: 6
Gilbey: 7
Arter: 5
Watson: 7
Leko: 6
Stockley: 5
Lee: 6
Clare: 7
Referee: 6
Matthews: 6.5
Lavelle: 6.5
Pearce: 5
Souaré: 6
Gilbey: 7
Arter: 3
Watson: 6.5
Leko: 6
Stockley: 4
Lee: 7
Clare: 6.5
Referee: 6