MacG: 6 nothing much to do Matthews: 6 marginally better than Gunter Lavelle: 6.5 fairly solid and better distribution Pearce: 6 battled away nearly cost us late on pissing about Souaré: 5 at fault for 2nd goal legs had gone last 15 Gilbey: 6 selfish in good attacking areas little end product Arter: 5 didn’t notice him and only lasted 45 Watson: 6 extra half point for diagonal to CBT to set up our 2nd otherwise meh Leko: 6 couple of nice runs but no end product Stockley: 5 oh dear, he’s lost his mojo Davison should’ve started Lee: 6 not sure we can play him and Gilbey together faded and subbed off again Clare: 6 brought some energy,extra point for his goal minus half a point for being partly culpable fir their second Referee: 6 a few week decisions but all those booked deserved it
Davison: 8 poachers goal, more impact in10 mins than Stockley’s 80. Blackett-Taylor: 9 saved Adkins skin another who should’ve started
Blackett Taylor not fit your start … Adkins got it spot on today
Your start, you what??? I'll tell you what you're not fit to post! Mathews 9, Watson 8 & Stockley 7 🤣🤣🤣. Adkins is living on borrowed time, CBT and Davison saved his skin for the time being.
Adkins going nowhere .. CBT was ruled out by the medical team he was wrapped up in ice on Tuesday not trained till Friday .. NA took a massive gamble with him that’s why he only risked him for 10 mins ..
If he isn’t then neither are we, another season in L1 beckons 😏. If CBT was really that bad he shouldn’t have been on the bench at all.
Against my better judgement this is my last post on this thread as it makes Lancs job difficult when collating the marks. Try and refrain in future and take any issues you may have to the post match thread which you should be fully aware of in your former lives on this site.
MacG: 6 Matthews: 3 at fault for first goal and spends most of the time on the half way line Lavelle: 6 Pearce: 6 Souaré: 6 Gilbey: 6 Arter: 5 - did not see much of him Watson: 7 - won loads of tackles in midfield Leko: 5.5 Stockley: 5.5 Lee: 6.5 Clare: 7 Referee: 6
MacG: 7 Matthews: 5 Lavelle: 6 - solid. Pearce: 4 - got himself in a pickle a few times Souaré: 6 Gilbey: 7 did well - good for him to get 90 mins under his belt. Arter: 2 - send him back now. Watson: 6 - Leko: 6.5 - we don’t use him enough. Bit greedy in the shooting today. Stockley: 3 - offered nothing, just whinges all the time. Better team without him in it. Lee: 6.5 - average performance Clare: 7 - good energy and great finish Referee: 5
MacG: 6 nothing to say Matthews: 6 ok needs to get forward more, but not at expense of defending doesn’t get it so stays back Lavelle: 6.5 Solid Pearce: 6.5 Best and worse of him today, but a real Charlton man so love him for it Souaré: 6.5 I liked him, yes bit wild at times, but can’t fault work ethic from such an inexperienced player Gilbey:6.5 For second game back impressive one of the few with credit 1st half Arter: 1 saw him JOG off at HT honestly first time I noticed him. I hope he’s not fit. Because if is he can jog on Watson: 4 i have defended him so far this season, but thought he lived up to his reputation today Leko: 5 In and out, did nothing much Stockley: 3 Did nothing gets nothing does a lot of whining Lee: 6 started well faded late on think he is going to be a good signing Clare: 6.5 Nigels only credit today was his half time introduction. The later subs worked, but gets no crédit as they were at least 15 mins to late Referee: 4 Ok first half, totally pathetic second
MacG: 6 - I had the fella sitting next to me saying he should be POTM, but he hasn't kept a clean sheet all month (but has conceded 1 per game before today, so he is slipping up). Matthews:5 Lavelle: 5 Pearce: 5 Souaré: 5 The back line just kept hoofing the ball up, but it improved in the second half Gilbey: 6 Arter: 5 Watson: 7 Leko: 5 Stockley: 4- Didn't know he was on the pitch kept on falling over. Lee: 7 Clare: 7 Well taken goal. Davison: 7 Lets be real the goal was a tap in, but took it well. Blackett-Taylor: 7 - Set up the goal. SUPER BLACKETT TAYLOR
Atkins: 6 - Was lucky today - got the subs right (Davison looked knackered on Tuesday, so I understand why he was on the bench today)- needs three points for my faith on Tuesday though.
Referee: Was annoying me all game. Before they got their second goal we could of got a goal had the referee played advantage- he did it for Portsmouth and they got the second goal. (4 if I have to give a rating)
MacG: 6 Distribution needs to quicken but otherwise sound enough Matthews: 8 so much effort and so unprotected at times including the first goal where he was left in an absolutely unforgivable no win situation Lavelle: 7 Settling in very well and very quickly Pearce: 4 The youngsters need mentoring - please stick to that job, you will be great Souaré: 6 Equally exposed by lack of cover at times and better going forward than defending so far, but feel he will offer more and more as each week passes Gilbey: 7 Really good to see him settling back in and thought his first half run and shot was a great teaser trailer for more to come Arter: 4 Underwhelmed so far but a lot of the season to go Watson: 5 Just a bit meh at times, but in fairness he battled to the very end Leko: 6 A bag of tricks, pace and unpredictability - love watching him Stockley: 4 Would give him a few games break as much as it pains me to say it, as the Headmaster has led by example in the past, but is a shadow of himself in recent games Lee: 6 Wanted to see him on the ball more, a real talent who will get his fair share of MOMs this season, but not enough for today Clare: 8 MOM Has come back in and proven what he can do. Very good shot for the first equaliser, very athletic forward running and was in their faces when he needed to be. Welcome Sean! Referee: 3
MacG: 5 Matthews: 5 Lavelle: 5 Wide-open spaces in central defence Pearce: 5 Ditto Souaré: 5 Gilbey: 5.5 Gets forward Arter: 4 Utterly anonymous Watson: 5 Leko: 5 Faded quickly Stockley: 5 Suffers from inaccurate service Lee: 5 Needs to make an impression on the game Clare: 5 Referee: 6 Well played, ref
We were very, very lucky - those easy chances that Portsmouth missed...
MacG: 6 Matthews: 3 at fault for first goal and spends most of the time on the half way line Lavelle: 6 Pearce: 6 Souaré: 6 Gilbey: 6 Arter: 5 - did not see much of him Watson: 7 - won loads of tackles in midfield Leko: 5.5 Stockley: 5.5 Lee: 6.5 Clare: 7 Referee: 6
The goal was down to Leko who failed to track the number 3 which gave Matthews two men running at him ….
MacG: 6 Matthews: 6 Lavelle: 4 - often out of position (2nd goal in particular) and too flat footed, not convinced at this level. Pearce: 6 Always puts in a shift, but not sure he's the answer at this level playing out from the back! Souaré: 5.5 Gilbey: 7 Arter: 4 Didn't notice him for the 1st 15! Watson: 6 better from Watson Leko: 6.5 Stockley: 5 'Best striker in the division' - get a grip Adkins. Lee: 6.5 Clare: 6.5 good goal Referee: 6
MacG: 6 Matthews: 6. didn't see a poor game and I think harsh to blame him for the goal Lavelle: 6 he’s ordinary. Note we didn’t try to build through him at all. Not his game but I felt sorry for Jason that we seemed to want him to pass out from the back. Pearce: 5.5 Committed but woeful in possession Souaré: 6. He’ll get better Gilbey: 7 high energy. We’ve missed him Arter: 2. If Morgan allegedly hides. Woeful Watson: 5. Needs to come out permanently. Committed but detrimental to our play. Leko: 6 tries things. Found space between the lines Stockley: 3. I’m a fan but he needs to come out until Adkins goes Lee: 5.5 not bad, not great Clare: 6 . Plus one for the goal. Can’t pass but high energy.
CBT man of the match.
Adkins 0. Starting that dreadful formation and waiting too long to make the latter changes cost us the win, rather than winning us the point.
MacG: 6.5 so now Famewo's dropped he passes to Pearce, gets it back and hoofs it. Matthews: 6.5 Lavelle: 7 Pearce: 6.5 still worries me when we're doing passing out from back Souaré: 6.5 Gilbey: 6 Arter: 3 Watson: 6.5 some good work, needs someone who can run next to him Leko: 6 tried hard not everything came off but until 80 mins was our main threat Stockley: 4 yes you get no protection but stop whining. Lee: 7.5 our best player Clare: 7.5 good goal, good work, some poor passes Referee: 4 I must have said the same thing as @Covered End around the same time, when he turned into the sort of ref Pompey always seem to get.
Davison: n/a excellent cameo Blackett-Taylor: n/a sign him up
MacG: 6 Dealt with a few low weakish shots but his only other action was the goals. Matthews: 6 A couple of good bits but looked a bit slow to support the attack late on. Fitness? Lavelle: 6 Not bad. Looks to be settling in reasonably well. Pearce: 5.5 Is really going to struggle all the time we try not to whack it up to Stockley. Not his best game but never gave up and actually finished quite strongly. Souaré: 5.5 He's clearly been a good player but he faded badly 2nd half. Needed him the to read the play for the 2nd goal and squeeze in a lot more. He'll be rested for Bolton. Gilbey: 6.5 This was a good showing after such a long absence. Showed enough to suggest that he's going to be a first choice pick. Makes good timed runs into the box. Arter: 5 Good enough on the ball but nowhere near it off the ball. Started to get into it from about 30 mins. I think he'll be ok but he's got to bust a gut rather than try to cruise. Watson: 7.5 Held the midfield together for the 1st half because he didn't get much help from Arter. Passed the ball well and played a lovely surprise ball to CBT for the equaliser. Leko: 7 No goals but plenty of action and a couple of powerful shots from distance. Looks really quick and although he did tire late on, he looks like he's getting fitter. Stockley: 5.5 Not a lot came off for him but the effort was still there. Needs a trademark thumping header to get him going. Lee: 7 Very lively and a good player. Like Gilbey, he's going to be one of the first names on the teamsheet. Clare: 7 What a lovely crisp shot for the equaliser at 1-1. Showed plenty of drive going forward and came up with a brilliant last-ditch tackle to save a goal too. Referee: 6.5 I liked him but it was a shame about the whistle for the Gilbey chance.
Davison: n/a A well deserved goal, for his efforts on Tuesday. Blackett-Taylor: n/a We've seen him produce two good cameos on the left and one half of brilliance on the right. Good player and great to have someone so adaptable. He'll start v Bolton.
MacG: no chance with the two goals. 7 Matthews: 6 Lavelle: 6 Pearce: 4 Souaré: 6 Gilbey: 6 Arter: 6 Watson: would be 3 but for the pass to B-T for the second. 4 Leko: 7 Stockley: 2 Lee: 8 Clare: Shame he didn't keep up the 'touches to goals' ratio. 7 Referee: 4
MacG: 6 Matthews: 3 Can't stand him only plays because Gunter matches his inepitude Lavelle: 7 Good buy steady player Pearce: 5 Always gives 100% but stop trying to play out when you dont have the skill Souaré: 4 Poor Bambi on ice giving away the ball too often Gilbey: 7 Did wellfirst half.Need to perservere to get him fit Arter: 4 Legs gone Watson: 4 ditto Leko: 6.5 Gives us a threat running beyond Stockley: 4 Using Watson's concrete boots Lee: 6 Like him but felt he lacked fitness Clare: 6.5 Energy and great goal Referee: 4 an idiot did Gilbey out of 1 on 1 with GK Davison 7.5 Great work with his goal needs to start CBT 8 MoM Saved the game. Give him 3 year contract asap
The question is, why did the 'keeper pass out to him? It was never going to work the way they pressed and nearly cost us on more than one occasion.
Comments
Matthews: 6
Lavelle: 6
Pearce: 6
Souaré: 5
Gilbey: 6
Arter: 4
Watson: 6
Leko: 7
Stockley: 5
Lee: 7
Clare: 6
Referee: 6
Matthews: 6
Lavelle: 6
Pearce: 6
Souaré: 6
Gilbey: 7
Arter: 4
Watson: 5
Leko: 6
Stockley: 5.5
Lee: 6
Clare: 6.5
Referee: 5
Matthews: 6
Lavelle: 6
Pearce: 6
Souaré: 6
Gilbey: 6
Arter: 5
Watson: 6
Leko: 6
Stockley: 5
Lee: 6
Clare: 7
Referee: 4
Matthews: 3 at fault for first goal and spends most of the time on the half way line
Lavelle: 6
Pearce: 6
Souaré: 6
Gilbey: 6
Arter: 5 - did not see much of him
Watson: 7 - won loads of tackles in midfield
Leko: 5.5
Stockley: 5.5
Lee: 6.5
Clare: 7
Referee: 6
Matthews: 6
Lavelle: 6
Pearce: 4
Souaré: 6
Gilbey: 6
Arter: 3
Watson: 7
Leko: 6
Stockley: 5
Lee: 7.5
Clare: 7
Referee: 5
Matthews: 5
Lavelle: 6 - solid.
Pearce: 4 - got himself in a pickle a few times
Souaré: 6
Gilbey: 7 did well - good for him to get 90 mins under his belt.
Arter: 2 - send him back now.
Watson: 6 -
Leko: 6.5 - we don’t use him enough. Bit greedy in the shooting today.
Stockley: 3 - offered nothing, just whinges all the time. Better team without him in it.
Lee: 6.5 - average performance
Clare: 7 - good energy and great finish
Referee: 5
Matthews: 6 ok needs to get forward more, but not at expense of defending doesn’t get it so stays back
Lavelle: 6.5 Solid
Pearce: 6.5 Best and worse of him today, but a real Charlton man so love him for it
Souaré: 6.5 I liked him, yes bit wild at times, but can’t fault work ethic from such an inexperienced player
Gilbey:6.5 For second game back impressive one of the few with credit 1st half
Arter: 1 saw him JOG off at HT honestly first time I noticed him. I hope he’s not fit. Because if is he can jog on
Watson: 4 i have defended him so far this season, but thought he lived up to his reputation today
Leko: 5 In and out, did nothing much
Stockley: 3 Did nothing gets nothing does a lot of whining
Lee: 6 started well faded late on think he is going to be a good signing
Clare: 6.5 Nigels only credit today was his half time introduction. The later subs worked, but gets no crédit as they were at least 15 mins to late
Referee: 4 Ok first half, totally pathetic second
Matthews:5
Lavelle: 5
Pearce: 5
Souaré: 5
The back line just kept hoofing the ball up, but it improved in the second half
Gilbey: 6
Arter: 5
Watson: 7
Leko: 5
Stockley: 4- Didn't know he was on the pitch kept on falling over.
Lee: 7
Clare: 7 Well taken goal.
Davison: 7 Lets be real the goal was a tap in, but took it well.
Blackett-Taylor: 7 - Set up the goal. SUPER BLACKETT TAYLOR
Atkins: 6 - Was lucky today - got the subs right (Davison looked knackered on Tuesday, so I understand why he was on the bench today)- needs three points for my faith on Tuesday though.
Referee: Was annoying me all game. Before they got their second goal we could of got a goal had the referee played advantage- he did it for Portsmouth and they got the second goal. (4 if I have to give a rating)
Matthews: 8 so much effort and so unprotected at times including the first goal where he was left in an absolutely unforgivable no win situation
Lavelle: 7 Settling in very well and very quickly
Pearce: 4 The youngsters need mentoring - please stick to that job, you will be great
Souaré: 6 Equally exposed by lack of cover at times and better going forward than defending so far, but feel he will offer more and more as each week passes
Gilbey: 7 Really good to see him settling back in and thought his first half run and shot was a great teaser trailer for more to come
Arter: 4 Underwhelmed so far but a lot of the season to go
Watson: 5 Just a bit meh at times, but in fairness he battled to the very end
Leko: 6 A bag of tricks, pace and unpredictability - love watching him
Stockley: 4 Would give him a few games break as much as it pains me to say it, as the Headmaster has led by example in the past, but is a shadow of himself in recent games
Lee: 6 Wanted to see him on the ball more, a real talent who will get his fair share of MOMs this season, but not enough for today
Clare: 8 MOM Has come back in and proven what he can do. Very good shot for the first equaliser, very athletic forward running and was in their faces when he needed to be. Welcome Sean!
Referee: 3
Davison: n/a
Blackett-Taylor: n/a
Matthews: 6
Lavelle: 7
Pearce: 6
Souaré: 6
Gilbey: 6
Arter: 5
Watson: 6
Leko: 6
Stockley: 6
Lee: 6
Clare: 6
Matthews: 5
Lavelle: 5 Wide-open spaces in central defence
Pearce: 5 Ditto
Souaré: 5
Gilbey: 5.5 Gets forward
Arter: 4 Utterly anonymous
Watson: 5
Leko: 5 Faded quickly
Stockley: 5 Suffers from inaccurate service
Lee: 5 Needs to make an impression on the game
Clare: 5
Referee: 6 Well played, ref
We were very, very lucky - those easy chances that Portsmouth missed...
Matthews: 6
Lavelle: 6
Pearce: 7
Souaré: 5
Gilbey: 6
Arter: 4
Watson: 5
Leko: 6
Stockley: 5
Lee: 5
Clare: 6
Referee: 5
Matthews: 6
Lavelle: 4 - often out of position (2nd goal in particular) and too flat footed, not convinced at this level.
Pearce: 6 Always puts in a shift, but not sure he's the answer at this level playing out from the back!
Souaré: 5.5
Gilbey: 7
Arter: 4 Didn't notice him for the 1st 15!
Watson: 6 better from Watson
Leko: 6.5
Stockley: 5 'Best striker in the division' - get a grip Adkins.
Lee: 6.5
Clare: 6.5 good goal
Referee: 6
Matthews: 5
Lavelle: 6
Pearce: 5
Souaré: 5
Gilbey: 6.5
Arter: 4
Watson: 5
Leko: 5
Stockley: 4
Lee: 6
Clare: 6
Referee: 4
Matthews: 6
Lavelle: 6.5
Pearce: 6
Souaré: 6
Gilbey: 6.5
Arter: 4
Watson: 6.5
Leko: 6.5
Stockley: 5
Lee: 6
Clare: 6.5
Referee: 6
Matthews: 5
Lavelle: 7
Pearce: 5
Souaré: 5
Gilbey: 7
Arter: 3
Watson:4
Leko: 6
Stockley: 5
Lee: 6
Clare:7
Referee:5
Matthews: 6
Lavelle: 7
Pearce: 6
Souaré: 6
Gilbey: 7.5
Arter: 5.5
Watson: 7
Leko: 7
Stockley: 5.5
Lee: 7
Clare: 7.5
Referee: 8
Matthews: 4 Cost us again
Lavelle: 7
Pearce: 5 Nearly cost us twice
Souaré: 6
Gilbey: 6.5
Arter: 5
Watson: 5
Leko: 6
Stockley: 4
Lee: 6.5
Clare: 6.5
Referee: 5
Matthews: 7
Lavelle: 6.5
Pearce: 6
Souaré: 6.5
Gilbey: 6
Arter: 5
Watson: 6
Leko: 6.5
Stockley: 5
Lee: 6
Clare: 6.5
Referee: 5
Matthews: 6.5
Lavelle: 6.5
Pearce: 6
Arter: 4
Watson: 6
Leko: 6
Stockley: 5.5
Lee: 6.5
Clare: 7
Referee: 6
Matthews: 6. didn't see a poor game and I think harsh to blame him for the goal
Lavelle: 6 he’s ordinary. Note we didn’t try to build through him at all. Not his game but I felt sorry for Jason that we seemed to want him to pass out from the back.
Pearce: 5.5 Committed but woeful in possession
Souaré: 6. He’ll get better
Gilbey: 7 high energy. We’ve missed him
Arter: 2. If Morgan allegedly hides. Woeful
Watson: 5. Needs to come out permanently. Committed but detrimental to our play.
Leko: 6 tries things. Found space between the lines
Stockley: 3. I’m a fan but he needs to come out until Adkins goes
Lee: 5.5 not bad, not great
Clare: 6 . Plus one for the goal. Can’t pass but high energy.
CBT man of the match.
Matthews: 6.5
Lavelle: 7
Pearce: 6.5 still worries me when we're doing passing out from back
Souaré: 6.5
Gilbey: 6
Arter: 3
Watson: 6.5 some good work, needs someone who can run next to him
Leko: 6 tried hard not everything came off but until 80 mins was our main threat
Stockley: 4 yes you get no protection but stop whining.
Lee: 7.5 our best player
Clare: 7.5 good goal, good work, some poor passes
Referee: 4 I must have said the same thing as @Covered End around the same time, when he turned into the sort of ref Pompey always seem to get.
Davison: n/a excellent cameo
Blackett-Taylor: n/a sign him up
Matthews: 6 A couple of good bits but looked a bit slow to support the attack late on. Fitness?
Lavelle: 6 Not bad. Looks to be settling in reasonably well.
Pearce: 5.5 Is really going to struggle all the time we try not to whack it up to Stockley. Not his best game but never gave up and actually finished quite strongly.
Souaré: 5.5 He's clearly been a good player but he faded badly 2nd half. Needed him the to read the play for the 2nd goal and squeeze in a lot more. He'll be rested for Bolton.
Gilbey: 6.5 This was a good showing after such a long absence. Showed enough to suggest that he's going to be a first choice pick. Makes good timed runs into the box.
Arter: 5 Good enough on the ball but nowhere near it off the ball. Started to get into it from about 30 mins. I think he'll be ok but he's got to bust a gut rather than try to cruise.
Watson: 7.5 Held the midfield together for the 1st half because he didn't get much help from Arter. Passed the ball well and played a lovely surprise ball to CBT for the equaliser.
Leko: 7 No goals but plenty of action and a couple of powerful shots from distance. Looks really quick and although he did tire late on, he looks like he's getting fitter.
Stockley: 5.5 Not a lot came off for him but the effort was still there. Needs a trademark thumping header to get him going.
Lee: 7 Very lively and a good player. Like Gilbey, he's going to be one of the first names on the teamsheet.
Clare: 7 What a lovely crisp shot for the equaliser at 1-1. Showed plenty of drive going forward and came up with a brilliant last-ditch tackle to save a goal too.
Referee: 6.5 I liked him but it was a shame about the whistle for the Gilbey chance.
Davison: n/a A well deserved goal, for his efforts on Tuesday.
Blackett-Taylor: n/a We've seen him produce two good cameos on the left and one half of brilliance on the right. Good player and great to have someone so adaptable. He'll start v Bolton.
Matthews: 6
Lavelle: 6
Pearce: 4
Souaré: 6
Gilbey: 6
Arter: 6
Watson: would be 3 but for the pass to B-T for the second. 4
Leko: 7
Stockley: 2
Lee: 8
Clare: Shame he didn't keep up the 'touches to goals' ratio. 7
Referee: 4