Players Marks:EFL Cup R4: Manchester United v Charlton Athletic (closes Thursday elevenses)

lancashire lad

leaving this open a little longer to allow our lot to get home

M-B: 
Clare: 
Inniss: 
Ness: 
Sessegnon: 
Morgan: 
Dobson: 
Fraser: 
R-S: 
Leaburn: 
B-T: 
O'Connell: 
Payne: 
Referee: 

Henry: n/a
Stockley: n/a

Fumbluff

M-B: 9
Clare: 7
Inniss: 7.5
Ness: 8
Sessegnon: 7.5
Morgan: 6.5
Dobson: 7.5
Fraser: 7
R-S: 7
Leaburn: 7
B-T: 7
O'Connell: 7
Payne: 4
Referee: 2

Essex_Al

M-B:  8
Clare:  7
Inniss: 7
Ness:  8
Sessegnon:  8.5
Morgan:  6.5
Dobson:  7
Fraser:  7
R-S:  6.5
Leaburn:  6
B-T:  6.5
O'Connell:  6.5
Payne:  6
Referee:  5

Sydneyaddick

M-B: 8

Clare: 8
Inniss: 8
Ness: 8.5
Sessegnon: 8
Morgan: 7
Dobson: 8.5 MOM
Fraser: 8
R-S: 8
Leaburn: 8
B-T: 7
O'Connell: 8
Payne: 7
Referee: 4

Henry: n/a
Stockley: n/a

Chunes

M-B: 9 Worldie saves. Didn't deserve to concede three. 
Clare: 5
Inniss: 7
Ness: 8.5
Sessegnon: 7.5
Morgan: 5 Ran around like a hyperactive 8-year-old at a birthday party but his decision-making is poor.
Dobson: 7.5
Fraser: 7
R-S: 7
Leaburn: 6 Very isolated so not his fault
B-T: 7
O'Connell: 7.5
Payne: 5
Referee: 4 Proper Old Trafford ref

Dazzler21

M-B: 8.5 could he have done better with Rashford's goals but he was fantastic overall

Clare: 7, grew into the game.

Inniss: 8 solid,

Ness: 9 Lucas Ness Monster.

Sessegnon: 8.5 very good, wouldn't have subbed him.

Morgan: 6.5, sadly not his best game, couple of good passes, taking him off for Payne doesn't seem to help.

Dobson: 8 good, worked hard broke up play, passing could have been better.

Fraser: 8 first half mostly invisible, second half fantastic until he stopped running whilst on the ball to request a foul. Still best attacking midfielder tonight.

R-S: 7 standard Rak-Sakyi game. He's good, but sometimes makes the wrong decisions.

Leaburn: 7 he's young and battled all game with one of England's best defenders.

B-T: 7 ran at em, scared em, subbed too early imo. 

O'Connell: 7 so class on the ball, so glad he's back.

Payne: 6.5 standard Payne, Jack Russell.

Referee: 4 gave as much as he could their way.

Henry: n/a

Stockley: n/a

All in all I really enjoyed watching our side who battled well all game, Rashford and fitness were really the only difference between the sides second half.

Congratulations to everyone that managed to be there in person. Proper jealous.

CafcWest

M-B:  8
Clare:  7
Inniss: 7
Ness:  8
Sessegnon:  8.5
Morgan:  7.5
Dobson:  8.5
Fraser:  8
R-S:  7
Leaburn:  6.5
B-T:  7
O'Connell:  7
Payne:  6.5
Referee:  5

newyorkaddick

M-B: 8
Clare: 6
Inniss: 6
Ness: 7
Sessegnon: 6
Morgan: 6
Dobson: 7
Fraser: 7
R-S: 6
Leaburn: 5
B-T: 5
O'Connell: 6
Payne: 6
Referee: 6

Valley11

M-B: 8.5
Clare: 8
Inniss: 8
Ness: 9
Sessegnon: 8
Morgan: 7
Dobson: 8
Fraser: 8.5
R-S: 7.5
Leaburn: 8.5
B-T: 7
O'Connell: 8
Payne: 7
Referee: 5 - bottled it

ForeverAddickted

Maynard-Brewer: 9
Clare: 7
Inniss: 8
Ness: 9
Sessegnon: 8
Morgan: 7
Dobson: 8
Fraser: 8
Rak-Sakyi: 7
Leaburn: 7
Blackett-Taylor: 7

O'Connell: 8
Payne: 6

Referee: 4
Fans: 10

ParkinsonOut

M-B: 8 - fantastic save & no chance with the goals 
Clare: 7.5
Inniss: 7.5
Ness: 8.5 - great effort from the youngster
Sessegnon: 7.5
Morgan: 6
Dobson: 8 - Duracell bunny in first half, didn’t notice him as much in 2nd
Fraser: 7
R-S: 7
Leaburn: 7
B-T: 6.5
O'Connell: 6.5
Payne: 5 - did he do anything?

thewolfboy

M-B:  8
Clare:  7 improved 2nd half
Inniss: 7
Ness:  8
Sessegnon:  8
Morgan:  6.5
Dobson:  7.5
Fraser:  7.5
R-S:  7 Kept running
Leaburn:  7 worked hard
B-T:  7.5 Always a threat
O'Connell:  6
Payne:  5
Referee:  5

Our fans 10!
On dodgy ESPN stream

TEL

M-B: 8.5 two great saves
Clare: 7 mainly for the second half
Inniss: 7 playing it simple...can tell Holden has had a chat with him
Ness: 9 simply superb....to think he was at Torquay back in November. Incredible
Sessegnon: 8 no idea why he came off
Morgan: 7 huffed and puffed
Dobson: Did a Dobbo 8
Fraser: 7.5 would have been an 8 but poor first half.
R-S: 7 didnt really feature greatly. Compared to the Utd youngsters you can see why he's in League 1
Leaburn: 7 not much service but he gave the Utd defence something to think about
B-T: 6.5....didnt really get into it...shame really.
O'Connell: 7 some good touches but rusty understandably
Payne: 6...hate to mark him down but really, what does he offer?
Referee: 4 pretty shit and a bit of a homer...missed a lot. The Clare incident wasnt a Penalty but definitely a free kick.

Support 11.....were we playing at the Valley

RonnieMoore

M-B: 9
Clare: 9
Inniss: 9
Ness: 9
Sessegnon: 9
Morgan: 9
Dobson: 9
Fraser: 9
R-S: 9
Leaburn: 7
B-T: 9
O'Connell: 7
Payne: 6
Referee 3 homer on the pay roll 

AllHailTheHen

I'd love to give them all 10s but a head over heart assessment...

M-B: 8 brilliant save
Clare: 7 recovered well from a torrid start. Far more effective going forward
Inniss: 8 solid
Ness: 8.5 really impressive. Could struggle to keep hold of him at this rate
Sessegnon: 8 thought he had a very good game and a shame he went off
Morgan: 6.5 can't say he did too much of note
Dobson: 8 great at snapping in and breaking up play
Fraser: 8.5 really drove us forward 2nd half
R-S: 7.5 did some good work first half but faded
Leaburn: 7.5 tough night up top on his own but stuck at it. Maguire will know he has been in a game
B-T: 6.5 not great for their 1st and wish he'd gone at Dalot and Wann-Bissaka more
O'Connell: 8 looked good when he came on. Great to have him back
Payne: 6.5 not much of an impact
Referee: 5 seemed to miss a few fouls for us. Couldn't see if AMB handled or not

Henry: n/a
Stockley: n/a

Utd fans - 0
Charlton Fans - 10

jbcafc

M-B: 8
Clare: 8
Inniss: 8
Ness: 8
Sessegnon: 8
Morgan: 7
Dobson: 8.5
Fraser: 7
R-S: 7
Leaburn: 6
B-T: 7
O'Connell: 7
Payne: 6
Referee: 5

swords_alive

M-B: 7 -not much to do
Clare:  7.5 i just like the way he plays, errors apart
Inniss: 7.5
Ness:  8
Sessegnon: 8
Morgan: 7.5
Dobson: 8
Fraser: 9
R-S: 8
Leaburn: 7.5
B-T: 7
O'Connell: 7 - looked assured on couple of times he took control
Payne: 7 
Referee: 7

No.1 in South London

M-B: 7
Clare: 6.5
Inniss: 7
Ness: 8.5
Sessegnon: 8
Morgan: 6.5
Dobson: 9
Fraser: 8.5
R-S: 7.5
Leaburn: 6.5
B-T: 7.5
O'Connell: 7
Payne: 6

seth plum

M-B: 7.5
Clare: 6.5
Inniss: 7
Ness: 8
Sessegnon: 7
Morgan: 6
Dobson: 7
Fraser: 6
R-S: 7
Leaburn: 7.5
B-T: 6
O'Connell: 7
Payne: 6

Referee: 4 

The Red Robin

M-B: 8
Clare: 8
Inniss: 7
Ness: 8
Sessegnon: 9
Morgan: 6.5
Dobson: 7
Fraser: 8
R-S: 7.5
Leaburn: 6.5
B-T: 7.5
O'Connell: 6
Payne: 6.5
Referee: 2

FULLERpromise

M-B: 8.5 didn’t deserve to pick ball out net 3 times, some excellent saves , would love to say he will be our no.1 for years to come but see him at a championship club minimum and wouldn’t even be surprised of a bid this window
Clare: 7.5 after 15 mins could see me scoring a 3 but kept at it and grew into game against one of their best players on the night done well 
Inniss: 7.5 decent overall couple good blocks 
Ness: 8 excellent for someone crazy how he has come on and got himself in as one of our main CBs
Sessegnon: 8 a class act level didn’t look above him 
Morgan: 7.5 loved his energy and desire even if end product wasn’t always there 
Dobson: 8.5 our captain extra .5 for the mega  
Fraser: 7.5 non existent 1st half excellent 2nd  
R-S: 7.5 excellent first half faded 2nd bar one food run 
Leaburn: 7 felt for him was a tough night but kept at it and will learn a lot from tonight 
B-T: 7 threatening when attacking but didn’t close down quick enough for their 1st 
O'Connell: 7 looked ok one class pass 
Payne: 6 worked hard 
Referee: 3 such a homey it was laughable 

sam3110

Ooooh I don't wanna mark it I want to give them all 10 for not shirking and all turning up and making us proud....

M-B: 9 what a save, brave lad too and didn't deserve to concede 3

Clare: 8 thought first half he really struggled against Garnacho (what a player he'll end up being I'm sure) but he really grew into it and was one of our attacking outlets second half. Got hauled down 3 separate occasions and the ref gave nothing

Inniss: 7.5 a couple of weird shaky clearances aside, he's been doing well recently

Ness: 8.5 this lad is the next one we need to tie to a long deal, he's popped out of nowhere and suddenly he's possibly our best defender at the moment? Silky and unfussy

Sessegnon: 8.5 worked his arse off tonight, Fulham watching that will offer him another deal and send him on loan to a Championship club minimum next season

Morgan: 7 thought some of his passing was off, but he battled and hustled and harried and kept plugging away

Dobson: 8 roaming around the pitch like the ghosts that chase pacman, he's always there just when you think they're getting away. I fucking love him as much as he loves parsnips

Fraser: 8.5 skipped past players like they're non league hackers, not world cup appearing superstars tonight, I feel he's finally showing us what he's about

R-S: 7 got tired end of the first half and midway through the second, but his running and trickery had them on the back foot everytime we went forwards

Leaburn: 7.5 was isolated at times, but went toe to toe with a World Cup winner and Harry "Blockhead" Maguire and didn't look too out of place. Loved that he stuck one on Harry near the end, mugged the overhyped donkey right off

B-T: 6 quieter than normal (difficult against AWB and Dalot before that) but I felt he was a little off the pace tonight, getting back and forwards later than everyone else

O'Connell: 7.5 came on and did a job, he loves a forward pass and it's something out defence has lacked recently

Payne: 6.5 came on and ran about like a little terrier, snapping at ankles. Decent ball in near the end

Referee: 3 gave us nothing and reluctant to show cards, also fell for their playacting and didn't get on top of them time wasting too (imagine having to resort to time wasting at home in a cup when winning to little old Charlton!)

JamesSeed

M-B:  8
Clare:  7
Inniss: 7
Ness:  8.5
Sessegnon:  8.5
Morgan:  7
Dobson:  8
Fraser:  8
R-S:  7
Leaburn:  6.5
B-T:  7
O'Connell:  7
Payne:  6.5
Referee:  4 Massive homer. Should be ashamed. 

Rob

M-B: 8
Clare:  5.5
Inniss:  7
Ness:  8
Sessegnon:  8
Morgan:  6
Dobson:  7
Fraser: 6
R-S: 5
Leaburn: 6
B-T: 5
O'Connell: 7
Payne: 7
Referee: 6

Nicholas

M-B: 8
Clare: 7.5
Inniss: 7
Ness: 7.5
Sessegnon: 7
Morgan: 4
Dobson: 7.5
Fraser: 7
R-S: 7
Leaburn: 6
B-T: 5
O'Connell: 7
Payne: 5
Referee: 2

superdulvertonred

On the way home

M-B: 8
Clare: 7.5
Inniss: 7
Ness: 8
Sessegnon: 7
Morgan: 6
Dobson: 7.5
Fraser: 8
R-S: 7
Leaburn: 7
B-T: 6
O'Connell: 7
Payne: 5
Referee: 4

charente addick

lancashire lad said:

leaving this open a little longer to allow our lot to get home

M-B: 8
Clare: 6.5
Inniss: 7 
Ness: 8
Sessegnon: 7.5
Morgan: 6
Dobson: 8
Fraser: 8
R-S: 7
Leaburn: 6
B-T: 6
O'Connell: 6
Payne: 6
Referee: 4

Henry: n/a
Stockley: n/a

golfaddick

lancashire lad said:

leaving this open a little longer to allow our lot to get home

M-B: 8
Clare: 6.5
Inniss: 7
Ness: 7.5
Sessegnon:  7.5
Morgan: 7
Dobson: 7.5
Fraser: 7.5
R-S: 7
Leaburn: 6.5
B-T:  7
O'Connell: 7.5
Payne: 7
Referee: 

Henry: n/a
Stockley: n/a

ateamofcorygibbs

M-B: 8
Clare: 7.5
Inniss: 7
Ness: 7.5
Sessegnon: 8
Morgan: 7
Dobson: 8
Fraser: 7
R-S: 7
Leaburn: 7
B-T: 7.5
O'Connell: 7
Payne: 7
Referee: 3

Weegie Addick

Just give all of them an 8 from me. Great to be there! 

Addictedoldgit

M-B:             7.5
Clare:           7.5
Inniss:           7
Ness:             8
Sessegnon:   7.5
Morgan:         7
Dobson:          8.5  mom
Fraser:             7.5
R-S:                   7
Leaburn:           7
B-T:                    7
O'Connell:          6.5
Payne:                6
Referee:              4

Henry: n/a
Stockley: n/a