Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks:EFL Cup R4: Manchester United v Charlton Athletic (closes Thursday elevenses)

2

Comments

  • Bedsaddick
    Bedsaddick Posts: 24,741
    M-B: 9
    Clare: 7
    Inniss: 8
    Ness: 8
    Sessegnon: 7.5
    Morgan: 6
    Dobson: 8.5
    Fraser: 8
    R-S: 8
    Leaburn: 6.5
    B-T: 6.5
    O'Connell: 7
    Payne: 6
  • DubaiCAFC
    DubaiCAFC Posts: 2,461
    M-B: 8.5 few saves you expect keeper to make, then one outstanding save, the one that went through all the bodies, low down and close to him, which are tough!
    Clare: 7.5 first 20 minutes was woeful, and I thought we was going to be in for a long night, but got better as the game went on.. Was good going forward, but defensively awful!
    Inniss: 8.5 very good game, got stuck in, put his body on the line.
    Ness: 8.5 another impressive game, was shattered at the end. We have a good defender on our hands here!
    Sessegnon: 9 I thought he was outstanding defensively and going forward, he looked like the only Charlton player that would be comfortable in the premier league on a regular basis.
    Morgan: 6 worked hard, never really got on the ball and when he did, he gave it away
    Dobson: 8.5 worked so hard, broke up play very well, important tackles and blocks. Not as good on the ball tonight, but never less had a good game
    Fraser: 7.5 worked hard again, looking to make things happen, it didn't really come off for him. He was at fault for the 2nd goal that killed us. If he had carried that ball then, we had men forward, and you never know!
    R-S: 8 didn't realize he was playing first 35 minutes and then come into the game, and I thought he did really well, some smart play drawing fouls in. And looked to create stuff.
    Leaburn: 6 got to be honest, I thought he was really poor.. Didn't work the CB at all in the game, was all a little bit too easy. Given he didn't have the service. 
    B-T: 8.5 shame he come off, he was our most dangerous player, could have been a little bit more direct, but looked like something might happen everytime he got the ball. But changing the formation allowed us to get higher up the pitch so fair play Holden. 
    O'Connell: 7.5 thought he was very good coming on, was calm on the ball, and stepped out with it well. Actually like him in the middle of the back 3.
    Payne: 6 Didn't do that much, couple of blocks and got up and down.
    Referee: 8 thought he was good. Maybe missed handball with AMB..

    Henry: n/a
    Stockley: n/a actually thought he looked good when he come on, and caused them trouble, would have like to have seen him come on earlier, might have made a bigger difference!
  • Buglehorn
    Buglehorn Posts: 1,003
    MB 8
    Clare 6.5
    Inniss 7
    Ness 7.5
    Sessegnon 7.5
    Morgan 7
    Dobson 7.5
    Fraser 7.5
    Rs 7
    Leaburn 7
    Bt 6.5
    Oconnell 6
    Payne 6
    Ref 5
  • mattwils
    mattwils Posts: 212
    M-B: 7
    Clare: 6.5
    Inniss: 7
    Ness: 8
    Sessegnon: 8.5
    Morgan: 7
    Dobson: 8
    Fraser: 8
    R-S: 7
    Leaburn: 6
    B-T: 6.5
    O'Connell: 8
    Payne: 6.5
    Referee: 6
  • foxjam
    foxjam Posts: 208
    M-B: 8
    Clare: 7
    Inniss: 7
    Ness: 8
    Sessegnon: 9
    Morgan: 7
    Dobson: 8
    Fraser: 8
    R-S: 7.5
    Leaburn: 7.5
    B-T: 7
    O'Connell: 8
    Payne: 7
    Referee: 5

    Henry: n/a
    Stockley: n/a
  • leaving this open a little longer to allow our lot to get home

    M-B: 8
    Clare: 7
    Inniss: 6.5
    Ness: 8
    Sessegnon: 7
    Morgan: 7
    Dobson: 7.5
    Fraser: 7
    R-S: 8.5
    Leaburn: 6.5
    B-T: 7
    O'Connell: 6
    Payne: 5
    Referee: 3

    Henry: n/a
    Stockley: n/a


  • clive
    clive Posts: 19,456
    M-B: 7
    Clare: 7
    Inniss: 7
    Ness: 8
    Sessegnon: 7.5
    Morgan: 7
    Dobson: 7.5
    Fraser: 7.5
    R-S: 7
    Leaburn: 7
    B-T: 7
    O'Connell: 6
    Payne: 6
    Referee: 5
  • CAFCDAZ
    CAFCDAZ Posts: 1,199
    M-B: 8
    Clare: first half he was shocking, being skinned, kept slipping over and diving in, a 4. 2nd half.. Well that is the Clare we need to see week in week out, he was superb 8. Overall a 7.5
    Inniss: 7
    Ness: 7
    Sessegnon: 8
    Morgan: 7 
    Dobson: 9 just a leader, absolutely brilliant 
    Fraser: 7.5
    R-S: 6.5 
    Leaburn: 7
    B-T: 6.5
    O'Connell: 6
    Payne: 6
    Referee: 5
  • cafc4life
    cafc4life Posts: 4,632
    M-B: 9
    Clare: 7
    Inniss: 7.5
    Ness: 8
    Sessegnon: 7.5
    Morgan: 7
    Dobson: 8.5
    Fraser: 8
    R-S: 8
    Leaburn: 8
    B-T: 7.5
    O'Connell: 7
    Payne: 7
    Referee: 2
    Henry: n/a
    Stockley: n/a

    dont normally give scores but can’t really fault anyone last night. A couple were a bit off the pace but as an overall team performance, can’t fault any of them
  • M-B: 8
    Clare: 7
    Inniss: 7.5
    Ness: 8
    Sessegnon: 8
    Morgan: 6.5 Busy, but not much came off
    Dobson: 8.5 Everywhere
    Fraser: 7.5
    R-S: 7
    Leaburn: 7
    B-T: 7.5
    O'Connell: 7.5
    Payne: 6.5
    Referee: 5 Didn't give much our way
  • Sponsored links:



  • M-B: 7.5
    Clare: 7.5
    Inniss: 7
    Ness: 8
    Sessegnon: 8
    Morgan: 6.5
    Dobson: 8
    Fraser: 7.5
    R-S: 7
    Leaburn: 6.5
    B-T: 6
    O'Connell: 7
    Payne: 5
    Referee: 4
  • king addick
    king addick Posts: 3,701
    M-B: 8.5 some fantastic saves...hope Wollacott doesn't expect to walk back in the team

    Clare: 7 poor first half but better second. Needs more positional awareness training

    Inniss: 8 solid. Beast of a defender!
    Ness: 9 MOM for me. Look so assured and not once out of place.

    Sessegnon: 7.5 good game against a tricky opponent in Antony.

    Morgan: 6.5 extra 0.5 for effort but he isn't that good is he.

    Dobson: 8 some crunching tackles and lead by example.

    Fraser: 8 some great runs and unlucky not to have been played in by Dobson.

    R-S: 7.5 bag of tricks and grew into the game

    Leaburn: 8.5 extra 0.5 for shoving Maguire to the ground. Those 2 cbs struggled with him.

    B-T: 8 looked dangerous as always. Dalot didn't fancy it with him at all!

    O'Connell: 7 good to see him back. Played a blinding ball.to Sess to get in behind.

    Payne: 6 effort but not enough time to make proper go of it.

    Referee: 5 same shit different competition.
  • Gribbo
    Gribbo Posts: 8,485
    M-B: 8
    Clare: 7
    Inniss: 7
    Ness: 8
    Sessegnon: 8
    Morgan: 6
    Dobson: 8
    Fraser: 8
    R-S: 8
    Leaburn: 8
    B-T: 7
    O'Connell: 7
    Payne: 7
  • Pedro45
    Pedro45 Posts: 5,823
    M-B: 7.5 - Did all he could and no real chance with any of the goals
    Clare: 5.5 - Got embarrassed early but improved when he realised he could tackle the bloke!
    Inniss: 7 - Did well until tired at end against Rashford
    Ness: 8 (MoM) - A fantastic monster performance throughout
    Sessegnon: 7 - Got forward well
    Morgan: 5.5 - Typical Albie, all overhit!
    Dobson: 7.5 - Captain magnificent but some wayward passes...extra half point for the Maguire nutmeg!
    Fraser: 6.5 - Tried very hard to create but ditto
    R-S:  6.5 - Worked hard (for a change)
    Leaburn: 5-5 - Fed on scraps but never gave up
    B-T: 7 - Caused some issues with his pace but never quite got the final delivery right
    O'Connell: 6 - Slotted in to plug some of the tired gaps
    Payne: 5 - No chance to shine
    Referee: 5.5 - It was all about him, which upset both teams...
  • Pico
    Pico Posts: 1,029
    M-B:        8
    Clare:      7
    Inniss:     7
    Ness:      7.5
    Sessegnon:  8
    Morgan:   6
    Dobson:  7
    Fraser:    7
    R-S:        7
    Leaburn   6: 
    B-T:         6
    O'Connell:  7
    Payne:       6
    Referee:   5
  • ValleyGary
    ValleyGary Posts: 37,982
    M-B:  8
    Clare:  8
    Inniss: 8
    Ness:  8
    Sessegnon:  8.5
    Morgan:  7
    Dobson:  9
    Fraser:  8
    R-S:  7
    Leaburn: 5
    B-T:  7
    O'Connell:  7
    Payne:  6.5
    Referee:  2 
  • rananegra
    rananegra Posts: 3,689



    M-B: 9
    Clare: 7.5 improved 2nd half 
    Inniss: 7.5
    Ness: 8
    Sessegnon: 8.5
    Morgan: 7.5 
    Dobson: 8.5 
    Fraser: 8
    R-S: 8
    Leaburn: 7.5
    B-T: 7
    O'Connell: 7.5
    Payne: 7
    Referee: 2 gave us nothing. 

    Henry: n/a
    Stockley: n/a


  • Redmidland
    Redmidland Posts: 44,700
    Maynard-Brewer: 8
    Clare: 7.5
    Inniss: 8
    Ness: 9
    Sessegnon: 8
    Morgan: 7
    Dobson: 8.5
    Fraser: 8
    Rak-Sakyi: 7.5
    Leaburn: 7
    Blackett-Taylor: 7.5
    O'Connell: 8
    Payne: 6

    Referee: 4

  • JohnnyH2
    JohnnyH2 Posts: 5,342
    M-B: 8
    Clare: 7
    Inniss: 7
    Ness: 8
    Sessegnon: 7
    Morgan: 7
    Dobson: 7
    Fraser: 7
    R-S: 7
    Leaburn: 6
    B-T: 6
    O'Connell: 6
    Payne: 5
    Referee: 2
  • AddickRam
    AddickRam Posts: 471
    M-B: 7.5 (Decent distribution, commanding and few excellent saves)
    Clare: 7.5 (Started out of sorts but grew into game got forward and made some crunching tackles)
    Inniss: 7.5 (2 Big blocks, and was vital at organizing the line)
    Ness: 7.5 (Classy quick to intercept)
    Sessegnon: 7.5 (Good outlet, 
    Morgan: 6.5 (Put in effort, but too hasty wasteful in possession)
    Dobson: 8.5 (Beast, covered everywhere won possession constantly, nutmeg on Maguire had us laughing)
    Fraser: 7 (Moved the ball well, some neat touches)
    R-S: 7 (Some mazy runs, and got into good positions, won freekicks, tracked back)
    Leaburn: 7 (occupied both centre backs won flick ons, hard job)
    B-T: 7 (Lots of energy, tracked back took his man on)

    O'Connell: 6
    Payne: 6

    Referee: 6 (Okay, but frustrated on couple of clear fouls, he waved away)

  • Sponsored links:



  • cafc4ever
    cafc4ever Posts: 565
    M-B: 7.5
    Clare: 6
    Inniss: 7
    Ness: 8
    Sessegnon: 8
    Morgan: 5
    Dobson: 7.5
    Fraser: 7.5
    R-S: 7
    Leaburn: 5.5
    B-T: 6
    O'Connell: 7
    Payne: 5
    Referee: 7
  • ricky_otto
    ricky_otto Posts: 22,600
    M-B:  8
    Clare:  7
    Inniss: 7.5
    Ness:  7.5
    Sessegnon:  7.5
    Morgan:  6.5
    Dobson:  8.5
    Fraser:  8
    R-S:  7
    Leaburn: 6
    B-T:  7
    O'Connell:  7
    Payne:  6
    Referee:  2 
  • Karim_myBagheri
    Karim_myBagheri Posts: 12,722
    edited January 2023
    M-B: 7
    Clare: 7
    Inniss: 7
    Ness: 7
    Sessegnon: 8
    Morgan: 6
    Dobson: 7.5
    Fraser: 6.5
    R-S: 6
    Leaburn: 6
    B-T: 5.5
    O'Connell: 6
    Payne: 5.5
    Referee: 
  • BertieB
    BertieB Posts: 846
    M-B: 8
    Clare: 7
    Inniss: 8
    Ness: 8
    Sessegnon: 7
    Morgan: 5
    Dobson: 8
    Fraser: 7
    R-S: 7
    Leaburn: 6
    B-T: 6
    O'Connell: 7
    Payne: 6
    Referee: 3
  • RedChaser
    RedChaser Posts: 19,885
    M-B: 8
    Clare: 7
    Inniss: 7.5
    Ness: 8
    Sessegnon: 7.5
    Morgan: 7
    Dobson: 8
    Fraser:7.5 
    R-S: 7
    Leaburn: 7
    B-T: 7
    O'Connell: 7
    Payne: 6
    Referee: 4
  • 93Addick
    93Addick Posts: 134
    edited January 2023
    M-B: 8 Wonder save second half
    Clare: 7.5 Done well against a future star 
    Inniss: 8 Great Block in the first half
    Ness: 8 Solid display of defending
    Sessegnon: 9 thought he was exceptional forwards and backwards. Lost our threat when him, JRS and CBT went off 
    Morgan: 5.5 Anonymous. Felt like Dobson and Fraser were doing all the work in the centre 
    Dobson: 8 classy 
    Fraser: 7.5 After some poor passing first half made some good drives forward. Bit weak for one of their goals
    R-S: 8.5 A real outlet and won some fouls in great positions for us
    Leaburn: 6 Bit of a donkey last night tbh. Stockley would get pelters for that performance
    B-T: 7 Some good work out on the wing 
    O'Connell: 6.5 
    Payne: 6
    Referee: 3 Nob 

    Henry: n/a
    Stockley: n/a
  • 801912601
    801912601 Posts: 620
    At the game and so proud of the team and the fans. It’s the nights like this that keep you a Charlton Fan

    M-B: 9 Many saves, loved the slide out the box with the ball.
    Clare: 8 Terrible first 20 mins but quality in defence and attack after that
    Inniss: 9 Solid defending, crunching tackles and brave shot block with his head.
    Ness: 9 So composed and looked comfortable against premier league players.
    Sessegnon: 9 - same as Ness
    Morgan: 6.5 - Great first 20 mins making tackles all over the pitch. Shame his passing wasn’t accurate lat night but never stopped trying.
    Dobson: 8 Great tackling and effort (loved the nutmeg on Maguire), got into great breakaway positions but the final passes were awful.
    Fraser: 7 Poor first 20 mins with his passes being intercepted but great second half although his attempts on goal were poor.
    R-S: 7.5 - Thought he worked really hard and got back to defend well. Was dangerous in the ball and was fouled constantly but not according to the Pratt of a ref
    Leaburn: 6 Saw his rareness last night as he struggled to make an impact but keep trying.
    B-T: 6 Our best outlet all game but constantly took the wrong option and doesn’t like to track back - could have done better to stop the first goal.
    O'Connell: 8 what a composed cameo and so good in the ball
    Payne: 7 Typical Payne performance, works hard, made one good defensive clearance but doesn’t create anything.
    Referee: 2 Total homer - gave Manure every decision 
  • Once again all the Morgan detractors come out to say negative comments. Overhit passes yep one especially at a free kick notwithstanding no detractors to the fact that 3 times fraser in the 1st half passed to CBT that fell short which immediatelyput us on the back foot. Dobson breaking gave the wrong option as did Raki. Do we forget the little incisive lay off to Fraser in the 2nd half which was our best opportunity that he shot well over oh yes that was Morgan or the delayed pass to Clare when he put a dangerous cross in.

    Absolutely blinkered opinions picking out negative comments on individuals in a team that performed well as a team. Yes there was individual mistakes and we could pick up on Clare getting invidually roasted in the first 15 but he had a good game. Sessegnon letting their winger coming back on his left for the 1st goal but was excellent. Who was marking Rasford at the end ? And so on.

    All these players played against top class players and to a man contributed.

    I would give 7.5 to all but extra .5 to AMB, Sessegnon and Ness.

  • M-B: 9
    Clare: 8.5
    Inniss: 8
    Ness: 8 
    Sessegnon: 8.5
    Morgan: 7
    Dobson: 8.5
    Fraser: 7
    R-S: 8
    Leaburn: 7
    B-T: 7.5
    O'Connell:  7
    Payne: 6
    Referee: 4
  • MuttleyCAFC
    MuttleyCAFC Posts: 47,729
    M-B:  7.5
    Clare:  7
    Inniss: 7
    Ness:  7
    Sessegnon:  8.5
    Morgan:  6.5
    Dobson:  7.5
    Fraser:  7
    R-S:  6.5
    Leaburn:  7
    B-T:  6.5
    O'Connell:  7
    Payne:  6.5