Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

The Takeover Thread v3.0 - DONE! - Methven interview in the Telegraph (p55)

1242527293060

Comments

  • I wrote a balanced, long, piece last week about the potential benefits and the potential pitfalls of the new regime.

    It got 80 likes and a promote.

    Only AFKA then removed the promote and closed down the old thread to stop people reading it.

    That has caused this bickering and the blinkered views.

    For that reason I'm out.

    PS I also said last week that the takeover would be finally announced today, Thursday.
    Wouldnt have minded reading that. But too odious the preceding 13k posts.
  • imagine if it all fell apart now
    If it does, we know who to blame.
  • JamesSeed said:
    Can’t think of anybody has been more right about Charlton related matters than Airman. I don’t always agree with his views, but that’s when I’m wrong. 
    That’s a decent standpoint to be fair but you think these New owners are a bunch of no hopers also ? 
  • I wrote a balanced, long, piece last week about the potential benefits and the potential pitfalls of the new regime.

    It got 80 likes and a promote.

    Only AFKA then removed the promote and closed down the old thread to stop people reading it.

    That has caused this bickering and the blinkered views.

    For that reason I'm out.

    PS I also said last week that the takeover would be finally announced today, Thursday.
    https://forum.charltonlife.com/discussion/comment/5025336#Comment_5025336

    :smile:
  • Just see 3 magpies
  • clive said:
    TEL said:
    I wrote a balanced, long, piece last week about the potential benefits and the potential pitfalls of the new regime.

    It got 80 likes and a promote.

    Only AFKA then removed the promote and closed down the old thread to stop people reading it.

    That has caused this bickering and the blinkered views.

    For that reason I'm out.

    PS I also said last week that the takeover would be finally announced today, Thursday.
    Wouldnt have minded reading that. But too odious the preceding 13k posts.
    In the interest of saving the planet I was going to write the China Syndrome part 3 and recycle most if not all of what I said when Duchatelet took over and when it looked like it was Spiegal's group coming in the door.

    Firstly, I come to bury Sandgaard, not to praise him.  

    He pulled us out the ESI mess, for which he deserves credit.

    After that he deserves very little other than scorn.

    Built some nice and much needed buildings at the training ground but failed to get Cat 1 status for the academy, which was the purpose of them.  Note that Reading just got Cat 1 restored to them despite being league 1.

    Sandgaard hasn't built a squad, largely because we've not had a manager start and finish the same season under him.  He's decimated the non-playing staff, lost a lot skilled, experienced staff while encouraging a culture of bullying, vindictive hire and fire and nepotism.

    He failed to appoint a proper CEO until Storrie was forced on him and PS only had to be competent to show just how much we've missed proper leadership for a decade.

    And he played that God awful song.

    So we have to move on from Sandgaard but are the people he's selling to any better?

    Right now we can't know either way but even this optimist has doubts.

    Hopefully the convoluted ownership will be explained when the takeover is finalised.  The rumours are that there are nine groups, all with multiple members.

    Three, Friedman, Breber and Rosenfeld will, if the rumours are true (which is always a big risk to assume) hold 23.3% each.   The remaining 30% will be split between the Singapore soccer school, Marc Boyan's marketing and bartering business and a number of other smaller investors which will probably include Charlie Methvan and perhaps someone from Lanaghan family late of Oxford Utd and Wigan Warriors.

    Maybe not having one big ego owner (see RD and TS) will temper the map cap ideas.

    But it could also mean that decision making becomes over complicated.  But in our premier years we had a very large board and had success so it can work.  But then the board were all fans and we had another supporter as CEO.  And Varney's job managing all those directors wasn't easy.

    The other way of looking at it is that with no one big owner the decision making is left to the Chairman and CEO which sounds like a good thing IF IF IF we have a good Chairman and CEO but we're likely to get Charlie Methvan.  Maybe he's realised, after his time at Sunderland, that he's not a people manager and will take a back seat.   But he will be involved.

    I fully expect some money to be spent.  The new owners will want to make a splash.  May's deal was being delayed until the takeover but Leaburn's injury made it a priority.  Other good players will come in and fans, me included, will be more optimistic about what could happen on the pitch.  A few signings cheers everyone up, even Golfie for a few minutes.

    And if we didn't have some small piece of hope somewhere in our hearts that this year, this ownership, would be the one to turn things around we couldn't be football fans.  Even the most vocally negative fans (you know who you are) hope for better.

    And some will say "All I care about is what happens on the pitch" which is understandable but what happens in the board room impacts directly onto playing performance so we can't separate the two.   We need stable and forward looking management at Sparrows Lane and at the Valley for the club to progress.  Can this new consortium offer that for not just one year but for seasons and seasons, some of which will not bring glory but will mean the owners putting another £8m plus into the club every 12 months?

    Slater and Jimenez achieved a lot with Varney, Kavanagh and Powell and we were all set for a bright future.

    Only they had sold a lie to the money man, Kevin Cash, and when they went back to him asking for more cash (pun intended) he said "no" and Powell's plan's for the 2012/13 season collapsed.  We still nearly made the play-offs but it couldn't last.

    I fear that Methvan, like the PR man he is, has oversold the club and just how difficult and expensive it is to get sustained success in English football.

    The new owners are all experienced business people you say, they wouldn't fall for that. 

    Well, Kevin Cash did and both Duchatelet and Sandgaard thought that football was easy and that their business genius would be enough.  And they are all three successful business men. 

    I might very well be wrong, maybe everything is open and clear and the new guys realise that it won't be easy or cheap to run Charlton, I really hope that is the case.

    I bought my season ticket months ago, I'll be there regardless and I really think in Holden we have a good manager who just needs backing.  And I believe that the support is there.  Give us a team to cheer and gates will increase.  Not enough to fill the Valley as Thomas thought but enough for league 1 football.

    But please give us a long term plan and long term hope not more fantasies about break even or finding a new way to run a club that no one else has tried.  

    And please under promise and over deliver for a change.
    Thank you Clive and Ben. Level headed approach. Makes sense and lets hope things go in the football club and fans favour for the first time since the Prem days.
  • I'm being cautiously optimistic. 

    No good reason, just fancy a change of scene.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Charlie Methven started his career as a journalist on the Racing Post, so he is fully aware that many wealthy people like a punt and nearly all racing owners lose lots of money pursuing their hobby in search of that elusive top class horse. I suggest that these new owners know that is going to happen at Charlton. The issue will be how long they are prepared to sustain those losses and whether they feel they are getting enough of a buzz or emotional satisfaction from being an owner. Results on the pitch will be important for all of us and them - and not just from a financial perspective. 
  • The glass should always be seen as half full until it is proven to be half empty.
  • Typical CL, barely a mention of football.

    Spot on.
    The only opinion that really matters
    Is Shay Given !
  • edited July 2023
    TEL said:
    clive said:
    TEL said:
    I wrote a balanced, long, piece last week about the potential benefits and the potential pitfalls of the new regime.

    It got 80 likes and a promote.

    Only AFKA then removed the promote and closed down the old thread to stop people reading it.

    That has caused this bickering and the blinkered views.

    For that reason I'm out.

    PS I also said last week that the takeover would be finally announced today, Thursday.
    Wouldnt have minded reading that. But too odious the preceding 13k posts.
    In the interest of saving the planet I was going to write the China Syndrome part 3 and recycle most if not all of what I said when Duchatelet took over and when it looked like it was Spiegal's group coming in the door.

    Firstly, I come to bury Sandgaard, not to praise him.  

    He pulled us out the ESI mess, for which he deserves credit.

    After that he deserves very little other than scorn.

    Built some nice and much needed buildings at the training ground but failed to get Cat 1 status for the academy, which was the purpose of them.  Note that Reading just got Cat 1 restored to them despite being league 1.

    Sandgaard hasn't built a squad, largely because we've not had a manager start and finish the same season under him.  He's decimated the non-playing staff, lost a lot skilled, experienced staff while encouraging a culture of bullying, vindictive hire and fire and nepotism.

    He failed to appoint a proper CEO until Storrie was forced on him and PS only had to be competent to show just how much we've missed proper leadership for a decade.

    And he played that God awful song.

    So we have to move on from Sandgaard but are the people he's selling to any better?

    Right now we can't know either way but even this optimist has doubts.

    Hopefully the convoluted ownership will be explained when the takeover is finalised.  The rumours are that there are nine groups, all with multiple members.

    Three, Friedman, Breber and Rosenfeld will, if the rumours are true (which is always a big risk to assume) hold 23.3% each.   The remaining 30% will be split between the Singapore soccer school, Marc Boyan's marketing and bartering business and a number of other smaller investors which will probably include Charlie Methvan and perhaps someone from Lanaghan family late of Oxford Utd and Wigan Warriors.

    Maybe not having one big ego owner (see RD and TS) will temper the map cap ideas.

    But it could also mean that decision making becomes over complicated.  But in our premier years we had a very large board and had success so it can work.  But then the board were all fans and we had another supporter as CEO.  And Varney's job managing all those directors wasn't easy.

    The other way of looking at it is that with no one big owner the decision making is left to the Chairman and CEO which sounds like a good thing IF IF IF we have a good Chairman and CEO but we're likely to get Charlie Methvan.  Maybe he's realised, after his time at Sunderland, that he's not a people manager and will take a back seat.   But he will be involved.

    I fully expect some money to be spent.  The new owners will want to make a splash.  May's deal was being delayed until the takeover but Leaburn's injury made it a priority.  Other good players will come in and fans, me included, will be more optimistic about what could happen on the pitch.  A few signings cheers everyone up, even Golfie for a few minutes.

    And if we didn't have some small piece of hope somewhere in our hearts that this year, this ownership, would be the one to turn things around we couldn't be football fans.  Even the most vocally negative fans (you know who you are) hope for better.

    And some will say "All I care about is what happens on the pitch" which is understandable but what happens in the board room impacts directly onto playing performance so we can't separate the two.   We need stable and forward looking management at Sparrows Lane and at the Valley for the club to progress.  Can this new consortium offer that for not just one year but for seasons and seasons, some of which will not bring glory but will mean the owners putting another £8m plus into the club every 12 months?

    Slater and Jimenez achieved a lot with Varney, Kavanagh and Powell and we were all set for a bright future.

    Only they had sold a lie to the money man, Kevin Cash, and when they went back to him asking for more cash (pun intended) he said "no" and Powell's plan's for the 2012/13 season collapsed.  We still nearly made the play-offs but it couldn't last.

    I fear that Methvan, like the PR man he is, has oversold the club and just how difficult and expensive it is to get sustained success in English football.

    The new owners are all experienced business people you say, they wouldn't fall for that. 

    Well, Kevin Cash did and both Duchatelet and Sandgaard thought that football was easy and that their business genius would be enough.  And they are all three successful business men. 

    I might very well be wrong, maybe everything is open and clear and the new guys realise that it won't be easy or cheap to run Charlton, I really hope that is the case.

    I bought my season ticket months ago, I'll be there regardless and I really think in Holden we have a good manager who just needs backing.  And I believe that the support is there.  Give us a team to cheer and gates will increase.  Not enough to fill the Valley as Thomas thought but enough for league 1 football.

    But please give us a long term plan and long term hope not more fantasies about break even or finding a new way to run a club that no one else has tried.  

    And please under promise and over deliver for a change.
    Thank you Clive and Ben. Level headed approach. Makes sense and lets hope things go in the football club and fans favour for the first time since the Prem days.
     Funny enough I never read it when  Henners first posted it.

    (Joke!)

    I think it pretty much sums up where your run of the mill majority Charlton fan sits.
    With this new lot, I suppose it all depends on what you're hankering for..
    Charlton of the past. Things done exactly as they was during the successful years and running as close to that. I think the game has changed a lot since then so might not be as smooth.

    Or are you looking at a Brentford or Burnley with a different but sensible model and thinking I want a bit of that?

  • As for our new overlords, the post by the member for M&S cardigans is pretty good, and I'll await for further facts to emerge 
  • Sponsored links:


  • Hal1x said:
    DDOUBLEE said:
     Sorry but the halfway line should be in line with the stairs in the AC stand.
    Built the stand too far along.
    And given some of the rubbish we have had to watch this last 15 years the wrong way round as well  :)
  • Saw two this morning whilst having tea in my backyard. I was having the tea not them, they were flying and perching.
  • Chizz said:
    DDOUBLEE said:
    Interesting to couple this announcement with a photograph of South London's most enormous line of coke
    Chrissy Powell's having a party - bring the vodka and the charley!!
  • Chizz said:
    DDOUBLEE said:
    Interesting to couple this announcement with a photograph of South London's most enormous line of coke
    On the Charlie 
  • Just gotta love the double standards 
  • Just for the record I'm with @Airman Brown.

    I might be slightly more optimistic if I knew who the owners were or even which offshore tax haven they were hiding in. 

    And if I was a ruthless PR professional purchasing a football club, I would ensure that my chosen messaging and narrative was aggressively pushed via fan forums, even if that meant discrediting trusted stalwarts of the club.  
    We know who the owners are 
    Friedman , Berber are the two main men 

    Friedman family 33.5%
    Berber 33.5%
    Global Football Holdings 33%

    Global holdings include ACA  appox 10% and rest split between 5 individuals including CM 


Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!