Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Penalty Shoot Outs

Love them or hate them?

I must confess I thought I was going to have a heart attack at Wembley as it was so stressful in 1998, and I was only in my 20’s!

Hope we’ve been practicing lots!

Comments

  • Love them 
    the sickness of it all 
    loved playing in them and love watching them , people shit themselves , the mind games and fortune favours the brave/mad/gamblers 
  • Love them or hate them?

    I must confess I thought I was going to have a heart attack at Wembley as it was so stressful in 1998, and I was only in my 20’s!

    Hope we’ve been practicing lots!
    Maybe Ahadme has and that’s when he resurfaces? 
  • Love them or hate them?

    I must confess I thought I was going to have a heart attack at Wembley as it was so stressful in 1998, and I was only in my 20’s!

    Hope we’ve been practicing lots!
    Maybe Ahadme has and that’s when he resurfaces? 
    Bring him on in the last minute of play off time for the pens , there’s a corner he rises majestically glances the ball in to the roof of the net for a 120th minute winner 




















    for Orient with an og 
  • It always seems to me that we only have them because the neutrals outweigh the number of supporters. So many casual football fans love the tension and excitement but if it’s your team involved then they’re a nightmare.

    They should be scrapped because I think that there are far better solutions.

    My personal choice would be a match count of goalkeeper touches. The team whose goalkeeper has touched the ball the least wins the game. This would encourage attacking play and discourage boring passing it around the back.
    In the event of a draw, the team who’d been going for a win more would win. Both teams in extra time would really be attacking. Imagine the excitement as your team shoots, the goalkeeper saves and the other team records a ’goalkeeper  touch.’ This would be shown on the scoreboard so all players and fans can see the situation. Teams would be desperate to get the ball away from their goal and force the other goalkeeper to touch it. Isn’t that what football should be all about?
    So you just spend 30 mins hoofing the ball out for goal kicks for the opposition so the keeper has to touch it? No thanks
  • If we end up in a penalty shoot-out this season I'd be delighted if our keeper, whether it be Will or Ash, actually dive the right chuffing way let alone save one.
    Maynard-Brewer was the last Goalkeeper to save a penalty, against Brighton... In a penalty shootout...
  • Our keepers do need to really practice their penalty saving technique, and indeed body language. Neither has the sort of presence that says to the penalty taker "I'm going to save it".
  • If we end up in a penalty shoot-out this season I'd be delighted if our keeper, whether it be Will or Ash, actually dive the right chuffing way let alone save one.
    Maynard-Brewer was the last Goalkeeper to save a penalty, against Brighton... In a penalty shootout...
    In our lifetime?! Or an alternative universe?

    Blimey, that's going back a fair bit, isn't it?
  • edited May 4
    If we end up in a penalty shoot-out this season I'd be delighted if our keeper, whether it be Will or Ash, actually dive the right chuffing way let alone save one.
    Maynard-Brewer was the last Goalkeeper to save a penalty, against Brighton... In a penalty shootout...
    In our lifetime?! Or an alternative universe?

    Blimey, that's going back a fair bit, isn't it?
    To be fair its been a bit difficult, as we've not been involved in a shootout since ;)

    Was only two seasons ago though, we've faced 15-penalties in matches since that game

    Maynard-Brewer (9-penalties, all but one in the League)
    Mannion (3-penalties)
    Isted (3-penalties)
  • Sponsored links:


  • edited May 4
    For context

    Stockport:
     - Addai has saved one penalty, he's conceded three this season

    Wycombe:
     - Norris has actually saved SEVEN in his career (cant have used his wrists!!)
     - None of which happened this season, of which he's conceded seven for Wycombe and Portsmouth

    Leyton Orient
     - Keeley: Has never saved a penalty, three conceded this season
  • I prefer a more footballing method of settling a match. Golden goal was brought in for just that scenario.....but then the football authorities tacked penalties onto it so ruined the whole concept.

    A golden  goal should be just that. Keep playing until one team scores. Without the "safety net" of penalty kicks teams would have to try to score, otherwise if you concede you're out. 
  • It all depends if you win, then its a fantastic way to finish a season.
  • I prefer a more footballing method of settling a match. Golden goal was brought in for just that scenario.....but then the football authorities tacked penalties onto it so ruined the whole concept.

    A golden  goal should be just that. Keep playing until one team scores. Without the "safety net" of penalty kicks teams would have to try to score, otherwise if you concede you're out. 
    I think at the end of extra time rather than penalties the team that's kept the most clean sheets over the season should win 😉
  • Hate them, even when watching as a neutral. But short of replays I think on balance it's probably the best way to decide a drawn game.
  • edited May 4
    Love watching them as a neutral. Hate them when it's Charlton or England but if you win them it's a different story.
  • Hate them, even when watching as a neutral. But short of replays I think on balance it's probably the best way to decide a drawn game.
    I'd almost forgotten about replays, odd when one was our greatest game ever, but yes, it's a draw, 8 o clock at Maine Road in 4 days time. 
  • sam3110 said:
    It always seems to me that we only have them because the neutrals outweigh the number of supporters. So many casual football fans love the tension and excitement but if it’s your team involved then they’re a nightmare.

    They should be scrapped because I think that there are far better solutions.

    My personal choice would be a match count of goalkeeper touches. The team whose goalkeeper has touched the ball the least wins the game. This would encourage attacking play and discourage boring passing it around the back.
    In the event of a draw, the team who’d been going for a win more would win. Both teams in extra time would really be attacking. Imagine the excitement as your team shoots, the goalkeeper saves and the other team records a ’goalkeeper  touch.’ This would be shown on the scoreboard so all players and fans can see the situation. Teams would be desperate to get the ball away from their goal and force the other goalkeeper to touch it. Isn’t that what football should be all about?
    So you just spend 30 mins hoofing the ball out for goal kicks for the opposition so the keeper has to touch it? No thanks
    Don’t count goalkicks then. Simple.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!