Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

PLayers Marks FA Cup Halifax FC 0-4 Charlton

lancashire lad
lancashire lad Posts: 15,709
edited November 2011 in General Charlton
Sorry this is a bit late but just got home from The Shay
For those at The Shay and watching the broadcast your marks up to 10, just copy and paste the list:

Sullivan
Solly
Morrison
Taylor
Evina
Wagstaff
Hollands
Hughes
Jackson
Hayes
Euell

Wright Phillips n/a
Smith n/a
Pritchard n/a

I'll leave this thread opens until Tuesday morning

«13

Comments

  • C_A_F_C
    C_A_F_C Posts: 3,878
    edited November 2011


    Sullivan - 6.0
    Solly - 7.5
    Morrison - 6.5
    Taylor - 7.0
    Evina - 6.0
    Wagstaff - 6.0
    Hollands - 7.0
    Hughes - 6.5
    Jackson - 7.5
    Hayes - 6.5
    Euell - 6.0
  • Lincsaddick
    Lincsaddick Posts: 32,498
    Sullivan 6
    Solly 6
    Morrison 7
    Taylor 8
    Evina 7 
    Wagstaff 6
    Hollands 7
    Hughes 6
    Jackson 7
    Hayes 6
    Euell 5

    Wright Phillips n/a
    Smith n/a
    Pritchard n/a


  • Nozza2310
    Nozza2310 Posts: 210
    Sullivan - 6
    Solly - 7.5
    Morrison -6.5
    Taylor - 8
    Evina - 7.5
    Wagstaff - 6.5
    Hollands -7
    Hughes - 6.5
    Jackson - 8
    Hayes - 6.5
    Euell - 5
  • Addickted4life
    Addickted4life Posts: 7,479
    edited November 2011
    Sullivan - 7.5- Looks better than Hamer and pulled off a good save plus he throws the ball quick

    Solly - 8 - Another class performance and he copped with that speedy sub extremely well MOTM

    Morrison - 6.5 - Him and Taylor looked a bit dodgy at times but did well enough

    Taylor - 7 - an extra 0.5 for the goal

    Evina - 7 - linked up with Jackson well but looked like he had more in him

    Wagstaff - 6 - non existent at times and didn't do much 

    Hollands - 7.5 all over the pitch again

    Hughes - 6 - Not really involved

    Jackson - 8 - linked up well with Evina and his goal was class

    Hayes - 6 - again not really involved but his cross to set up Taylor was good

    Euell - 5 - way past it and shouldn't be on the bench fro our next game
  • BIG_ROB
    BIG_ROB Posts: 5,274
    Sullivan - 6
    Solly -7

    Morrison -6
    Taylor -7
    Evina -8
    Wagstaff -7

    Hollands -6
    Hughes -6

    Jackson -7
    Hayes -6
    Euell -4
  • Oriental_Addick
    Oriental_Addick Posts: 1,003
    edited November 2011
    Sullivan - 6 (Not much to do)
    Solly - 7.5 (Did the most defending out of the entire back-line including an outstanding last-ditch tackle in the second half)
    Morrison - 6 (Quiet but efficient)
    Taylor - 8 (Fantastic header & a goal threat all game)
    Evina - 8 (Made some surging runs down the left channel and showed he is capable of delivering a good cross and cutting inside)
    Wagstaff - 6 (Quiet game for Waggy)
    Hollands - 7 (Solid if unspectacular first half but bossed the midfield in the second)
    Hughes - 6 (Quiet but broke up play well at times)
    Jackson - 7.5 (Excellent strike to kill the game off, good set pieces and linked up well with Evina)
    Hayes - 6 (Subdued game overall, decent cross for Taylor's goal)
    Euell - 5 (Anonymous)


  • stonemuse
    stonemuse Posts: 34,245


    Sullivan 6

    Solly 8

    Morrison 7

    Taylor 7

    Evina 7.5

    Wagstaff 6.5

    Hollands 6.5

    Hughes 6

    Jackson 7.5

    Hayes 6

    Euell 5
  • Will
    Will Posts: 36
    edited November 2011
    Sullivan - 6.5
    Solly - 8
    Morrison - 7.5
    Taylor - 8
    Evina - 7.5
    Wagstaff - 6.5
    Hollands - 6.5
    Hughes - 6
    Jackson - 7.5
    Hayes- 7
    Euell - 4

    Wright Phillips n/a
    Smith n/a
    Pritchard n/a
  • Rob
    Rob Posts: 12,040
    edited November 2011
    Sullivan - 5   Wasn't impressed
    Solly - 6.5  A couple of crucial tackles in the 2nd half    
    Morrison - 7  Solid
    Taylor - 7.5  Solid and an extra half for the goal. Probably my MOM
    Evina  - 6.5  Did ok coming forward a couple of times.
    Wagstaff - 6  Didn't do much
    Hollands - 7  I like Danny. Glad he got the goal
    Hughes - 6.5  Did ok
    Jackson - 7  A captains performance again
    Hayes  - 7  It was difficult with Euell. All in all did ok 
    Euell - 4  Awful

  • Clem_Snide
    Clem_Snide Posts: 11,810
    Sullivan - 6
    Solly - 7.5
    Morrison - 7
    Taylor - 7.5
    Evina - 7
    Wagstaff - 5
    Hollands - 6.5
    Hughes - 6.5
    Jackson - 7
    Hayes - 6 (extra mark for the assists)
    Euell - 4.5

  • Sponsored links:



  • Bedsaddick
    Bedsaddick Posts: 24,978
    edited November 2011
    Watched on the box.

    Sullivan - 5
    Solly - 8.5 MOM
    Morrison - 7
    Taylor - 7
    Evina - 7.5
    Wagstaff - 4.5
    Hollands - 7
    Hughes - 7.5
    Jackson -7
    Hayes - 5.5
    Euell - 4
  • Richard J
    Richard J Posts: 8,040

    Watched on the box

    Sullivan 6 I thought he looked shaky at times
    Solly 7 Dealt with the speedy sub well
    Morrison 6 Didn't look as secure as normal 
    Taylor 7 Extra mark for well taken goal and constant threat from set plays
    Evina 8 It's a real shame he has to compete with Wiggins for a spot . Could he be the impact left footer that I and others want to cover Jacko ?
    Wagstaff 6 An honest shift
    Hollands 7 Showed he has the necessary physical presence
    Hughes 7 Ideal player for this game , knew what was coming
    Jackson 9 Looked a class above today
    Hayes 7 Good link up play
    Euell 6 Played his part but not the player he was ten years ago

    Wright Phillips n/a What a sub to bring on if it had gone badly .
    Smith n/a Good to see him get a taste ,good assist
    Pritchard n/a Great goal

  • Paddy Powell
    Paddy Powell Posts: 2,860
    edited November 2011
    Watched it twice.

    Sullivan - 6.5 - Flapped at a couple of crosses, but made a key save at 1-0.
    Solly - 7.5 - Mr Dependable. Excellent workrate, good on the ball and does his defending with little fuss.
    Morrison - 7 - Taylor got the plaudits for the goal, but Morrison was the better of the two defensively.
    Taylor - 7 - Cracking header, but caught the wrong side a couple of times at the back.
    Evina - 7.5 - Really impressed me. In no trouble defensively and linked well with Jackson in attack.
    Wagstaff - 6 - Willing enough, but didn't really get into the game.
    Hollands - 7 - His usual box-to-box game. Made some well timed runs into their box and delivered a couple of decent crosses. Deserved his goal.
    Hughes - 6.5 - Does all his good work off the ball. Won a crucial defensive header just after that speedy left winger came on.
    Jackson - 7.5 MOM - Best player on the pitch. Used the ball well and picked some lovely passes that BWP and Kermit would have thrived on. Scored the killer 2nd after a nice turn.
    Hayes - 6.5 - Looked frustrated, but was involved in a couple of goals.
    Euell - 5 - Off the pace. Didn't win a header all game. Frustrating.

    Wright Phillips - n/a - Didn't see the point of bringing him on.
    Smith - n/a - Excellent work to set up Pritchard, but shanked a good chance when well placed.
    Pritchard - n/a - Looked lively against tired opposition. Well taken goal.

    Overall - 7/10 - There wasn't a lot to be gained from today, but they got the job done professionally enough.
  • Garrymanilow
    Garrymanilow Posts: 13,438
    Sullivan - 6.5. Flapped at crosses but one outstanding save
    Solly - 7.5. Near-flawless as ever
    Morrison - 7. Nothing beat him
    Taylor - 7.5. Strong and got his first goal
    Evina - 7. Good going forward, not quiet so good at the back
    Wagstaff - 5. Nowhere to be seen, didn't look for the ball
    Hollands - 8. Outstanding on and off the ball.
    Hughes - 7. Did his job harrying players well
    Jackson - 7. Good link-up with Evina, great goal.
    Hayes - 6. Poor overall performance, terrible first touch, but two assists.
    Euell - 4. Awful. Miles off the pace and had an incredibly poor first touch when put through.

    Wright Phillips n/a
    Smith n/a
    Pritchard n/a
  • Redmidland
    Redmidland Posts: 44,700
    edited November 2011
    Watched on the telly


    Sullivan - 6
    Solly - 7.5
    Morrison - 7
    Taylor- 7
    Evina - 7
    Wagstaff - 5.5
    Hollands - 7
    Hughes - 6
    Jackson - 8
    Hayes - 7
    Euell - 5

    Wright Phillips n/a
    Smith n/a
    Pritchard n/a
  • Buglehorn
    Buglehorn Posts: 1,020
    Sullivan 6.5
    Solly 7
    Morrison 7
    Taylor 7
    Evina 7.5
    Wagstaff 6.5
    Hollands 7
    Hughes 6.5
    Jackson 8 MOM
    Hayes 6.5
    Euell 6

    Wright Phillips n/a
    Smith n/a
    Pritchard n/a
  • Brighton Addick
    Brighton Addick Posts: 208
    Sullivan - 6. Not convinced by him - Hamer is definitely the number 1
    Solly - 7.5.  Usual quality performance
    Morrison - 7.  Steady as always
    Taylor - 7. Good goal but was caught our twice in the first half, but otherwise very good
    Evina - 7.5. Impressive performance - we must have the 2 best left backs in the league.
    Wagstaff - 6.5.  Could not really get involved. 
    Hollands - 7. Mr Reliable
    Hughes - 7.  This midfield holding role suits him and he's becoming an important player.
    Jackson - 8. Excellent overall performance and great goal (MoM)
    Hayes - 5.5.  Poor.  We need another striker as cover for Yann and BWP 
    Euell - 5. Love him, but his time is up.

    Wright Phillips n/a
    Smith n/a
    Pritchard n/a
  • Dazzler21
    Dazzler21 Posts: 51,570

    Sullivan 6
    Solly 8
    Morrison 7
    Taylor 7
    Evina 7
    Wagstaff 6.5
    Hollands 7
    Hughes 6.5
    Jackson 7
    Hayes 7
    Euell 5

    Wright Phillips n/a 6
    Smith n/a 6.5
    Pritchard n/a 7
  • Scoham
    Scoham Posts: 37,775
    edited November 2011
    Watched on TV

    Sullivan 6
    Solly 7
    Morrison 7
    Taylor 7
    Evina 7 good competition for Wiggins
    Wagstaff 6
    Hollands 7
    Hughes 7
    Jackson 7
    Hayes 6
    Euell 5
  • vff
    vff Posts: 6,915
    edited November 2011
    Sullivan 6 - not much to do in reality, steady enough.
    Solly -7.5  - His fitness and speed was really good in keeping their nippy left winger in check. Some terrific interceptions.
    Morrison 7 - steady. Did not notice him too much, steady at the heart of the defence.
    Taylor 7.5 - Solid performance. Extra 0.5 for aeriel threat and goal.
    Evina 7 - Good performance. Some really nice interpassing with Jackson down the left wing and did his defensive duties well enough. Good enough for the first team.
    Wagstaff - 6 OK, didn't notice him beating his man too often.
    Hollands 7 - Steady in the centre of midfield. Worked hard and combatative. It was what was required and that kind of battling that we have missed for some years at Charlton.
    Hughes 7 - Didn't notice him that much. Played well at base of the midfield.
    Jackson 7.5 - Great quality for the decisive second goal.
    Hayes 6 - Pretty anonymous + 0.5 for the assists.
    Euell 5 - Didn't really get close to the ball. Poor game but not as bad as some of the responses on the other threads state. Place in the squad as a steadying influence late on, not an impact player at the moment.

    Wright Phillips n/a - Great to hear the 'He's better than Shaun' song, He seemed to enjoy that.
    Smith n/a - Looks a promising prospect.
    Pritchard n/a - Great to see him back and score. I think he is going to be a very good player for us. Has got great energy and a good attitude. For the subs bench to back up midfield.

  • Sponsored links:



  • feesh_cafc
    feesh_cafc Posts: 135
    Sullivan - 6.5
    Solly - 8
    Taylor - 8
    Morrison - 7
    Evina - 7
    Wagstaff - 5.5
    Hughes - 6.5
    Hollands - 7
    Jackson - 8
    Euell - 4.5
    Hayes - 6

  • Mortimerician
    Mortimerician Posts: 5,222
    Sullivan - 6.5 Fumbled at a couple, but a good save and a clean sheet. 
    Solly - 7.5 Great challenge and got up well
    Morrison - 7 Powell's most important decision was not resting the defence.  Like a rock
    Taylor - 7.5 As with Morro, but with added goals
    Evina - 7.5 Picked up from the Bs game.
    Wagstaff -6 A few good crosses, but a lot of moaning.  Not what I'd hoped for.
    Hollands - 8.5 MOM critical to everything.  Smart footwork for the finish and bossed the midfield throughout.
    Hughes - 8 Very solid, well worth his start.
    Jackson - 7.5 linked well on the left.  Finished well.  One of his best games
    Hayes - 5.5 Fluffed an early chance and never recovered really.
    Euell - 5 If he was as bad as some have suggested he'd have stunk the place out.  Still, not a good showing, but no need for some of the disrespect.  As fans we demand loyalty in players then some of us show none.  Quite a shame.
  • Oggy Red
    Oggy Red Posts: 44,990
    edited November 2011
    .

    Sullivan 7 - After an uncertain start grew into the game and commanded his box well. Crucial save at 1-0.
    Solly 7 -  Always comfortable, then raised his game to shackle their whippet sub. Vital tackles.
    Morrison 6 - Generally solid enough at the back. Should have scored though with that free header.
    Taylor 7 - As part of the CB pairing, did his job. Great header scoring from that wonderful Hayes cross.
     Evina
    7 - So quick and anticipates well. Love his 1st touch and link up play with Jacko.
    Wagstaff 6 - Grafts and grafts and creates space for team mates. Tidy on the ball but no real penetration.
    Hollands - 7 Seems to thrive playing the attacking midfield role, which Hughes' contribution allows him.
    Hughes 7 - Mends all the punctures in our play - right from that brilliant 1st minute tracking back and tackle in our box. Could have been so easy to mis-time and concede a penalty.
    Jackson 8 - MOM Cool, calm, composed. Dictates the tempo of our play
    Hayes 7 - Started a little off the pace but provided 2 assists today. Reads play so well.
    Euell 6 - Not really sharp enough these days to be played as a striker, but drops off well and drags defenders out of position. Even so, you only have to see his contribution off the ball to understand why Powell has kept him in his regular matchday squad.
  • cholland
    cholland Posts: 169
    edited November 2011
    please ignore

  • thewolfboy
    thewolfboy Posts: 2,950

    From the telly
    Sullivan 6
    Solly 8
    Taylor 8
    Morrison - 7
    Evina - 8
    Wagstaff - 6.5
    Hughes - 6
    Hollands - 7.5
    Jackson - 8
    Euell - 5
    Hayes - 6
  • Mckforester
    Mckforester Posts: 854
    Sullivan 6

    Solly 7.5

    Morrison 7.5

    Taylor 8

    Evina 7

    Wagstaff 6.5

    Hollands 7.5

    Hughes 7

    Jackson 8

    Hayes 7

    Euell 6

    Wright Phillips n/a

    Smith n/a

    Pritchard 7.5 His goal desrves recognition
  • Salad
    Salad Posts: 10,189
    Sullivan 7
    Solly 7
    Morrison 7
    Taylor 7
    Evina 7
    Wagstaff  5
    Hollands 7
    Hughes 6.5
    Jackson 8
    Hayes 6
    Euell 5
  • Essex_Al
    Essex_Al Posts: 3,592
    Sullivan  6
    Solly  7.5
    Morrison  7
    Taylor  7
    Evina  7
    Wagstaff  5
    Hollands  7
    Hughes  6
    Jackson  7.5
    Hayes  4
    Euell  3

  • HarryHutchens
    HarryHutchens Posts: 541
    Sullivan 6
    Solly 8
    Morrison 7
    Taylor 7.5
    Evina 7
    Wagstaff 7
    Hollands 7
    Hughes 7
    Jackson 7.5
    Hayes 6
    Euell 5.5

  • Holdkneebomb
    Holdkneebomb Posts: 1,271
    Sullivan 7
    Solly 7
    Morrison 7
    Taylor 7
    Evina 7
    Wagstaff 7
    Hollands 7
    Hughes 6
    Jackson 7 mom
    Hayes 6
    Euell 5

    watched on tv. well done travelling addicks, great to hear valley floyd rd and better than shaun today

Categories

“Marketplace”