Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Which player has surprised you most

2

Comments

  • Bexley Dan
    Bexley Dan Posts: 3,658
    Pritchard for me as well - i liked him last year but now see him as a key player in our side which he wasn't last year - I'd also wrote Stephens off as well but there is no doubt he has added bite to his game this year and is much improved.
  • SuperYann
    SuperYann Posts: 130
    Matt Taylor in the past 2 games. Stephens has really stepped up. But Jackson seems to have improved, leading the team and scoring like he used tooooo.
  • Dave2l
    Dave2l Posts: 8,880
    Negative:

    Green, Frimpong, BWP, Hollands, Cook (hasn't featured as much as I would have thought)

    Positive:

    Main candidate - Pritchard, Solly, Hamer, Jackson. If only Haynes could remain injury free his number of performances have been impressive.
  • EastTerrace
    EastTerrace Posts: 3,964

    Hollands.
    Thought he would be capable at this level.

    Likewise
  • Bexley Dan
    Bexley Dan Posts: 3,658
    Maybe Hollands will come again - didn't he have a bit of an injury early season and i think the defeat by palace saw a bit of a panic and need to act and hollands was one of those who was probably pinpointed. If he was right on top of his game i reckon he could do a job for us now we've got our act together although wouldn't really be a starter. I think that defeat by palace worried a few but i don't think anybody realised at the time just how good a couple of their players were.
  • Kap10
    Kap10 Posts: 15,615

    For this season I'd say Ceddy. I thought he'd be a L1 player by the end of his development. I never thought he'd be keeping Wiggins on the bench in the Championship as I am sure he will continue to do for a few more weeks. He's always been good going forward but it seems like the defensive side of his game has improved as well. Need to get him tied down to a new deal as his contract is up in the summer I think. Really pleased with him

    My thoughts exactly, really like Cedric.



  • Absurdistan
    Absurdistan Posts: 8,024
    Solly, thought he might be a tad short for this level. ;-)
  • RedChaser
    RedChaser Posts: 19,891

    Maybe Hollands will come again - didn't he have a bit of an injury early season and i think the defeat by palace saw a bit of a panic and need to act and hollands was one of those who was probably pinpointed. If he was right on top of his game i reckon he could do a job for us now we've got our act together although wouldn't really be a starter. I think that defeat by palace worried a few but i don't think anybody realised at the time just how good a couple of their players were.

    Think he had to have one of his toes fused BD. Enjoyed his performances last season and was looking forward to seeing him at this level. On the plus side Pritchard who has grabbed his late opportunity with both hands.
  • daveaddick
    daveaddick Posts: 1,926
    For me it's Wilson gives great energy and has skill. Makes a big difference
  • Lots of positives: Hamer, Pritch, Wilson, Haynes have all stepped up very well. The only downsides really would be Hollands and BWP, both of whom I'm sure can make it, but seemed to lose a bit.

  • Sponsored links:



  • Redhenry
    Redhenry Posts: 5,363
    Danny Green not playing
  • Henry Irving
    Henry Irving Posts: 85,366
    Redhenry said:

    Danny Green not playing

    But he has played. 13 times in fact.

    Agree with Hamer. Has cut out the handling mistakes and really looks the part at a higher level.

    Could be that eye op or just regular games and good coaching.
  • Redhenry
    Redhenry Posts: 5,363
    Only 7 starts in the league.
  • Henry Irving
    Henry Irving Posts: 85,366
    Redhenry said:

    Only 7 starts in the league.

    13 games, one goal, two assists, awful in last outing v Ipswich since which we've not lost a league game, offered to Notts Co as part of a two for one offer for Judge.

    Was a part of our Championship season for which he should always be remembered positively but time for him to move on. Hasn't stepped up at this level despite being given 13 chances.

  • BR7_addick
    BR7_addick Posts: 10,221
    Bradley Pritchard for me as well.

    The man covers the most ground in the team by a long way, although he is mainly a defence minded midfielder, he's often seen attacking and crossing. Work rate is unbelievable, refreshing as well as so much emphasis is put on whether you're a holding midfielder or an attacking midfielder these days, he does the lot!

    P.O.T.Y for me so far.
  • Mr. Happy
    Mr. Happy Posts: 655
    Been pleasantly surprised with a fair few this season, especially those who weren't even starting at the end of last season in league 1.

    But it has to be Pritchard for me. I used to be slightly disappointed if I saw his name on the team sheet, now I'd be utterly shocked if it wasn't. If he keeps his form up I reckon he's well on course to win player of the year.
  • Bill_Stumps
    Bill_Stumps Posts: 887
    edited January 2013
    I'd like to come up with a different name but can't. Definitely Pritchard for me. I thought he looked a bit out of his depth in League 1 at times. Never thought he'd play such a major role in the Championship. I do feel sorry for BWP. He hasn't really been given a chance this season and probably won't now that 4-5-1 seems the way to go.
  • Scoham
    Scoham Posts: 37,562
    BWP hasn't had a chance? He's had 11 starts, 7 sub apps and scored 1 goal. He's struggled to cause problems at this level and lost his place.
  • SheffieldRed
    SheffieldRed Posts: 3,772

    Hasn't stepped up at this level despite being given 13 chances.

    Danny Green's performance at Derby County showed he had stepped up a level and is more than capable in the Championship. It would of course be fair to argue he has failed to maintain this level on a consistent basis. This can be partly attributed to himself and partly to the midfield in general (a midfield consistently playing well and to his strengths would have brought out the best in him on a more consistent basis).
  • cafctom
    cafctom Posts: 11,377

    Redhenry said:

    Only 7 starts in the league.

    13 games, one goal, two assists, awful in last outing v Ipswich since which we've not lost a league game, offered to Notts Co as part of a two for one offer for Judge.

    Was a part of our Championship season for which he should always be remembered positively but time for him to move on. Hasn't stepped up at this level despite being given 13 chances.

    I disagree that he hasn't shown the promise in 13 chances. His most recent form certainly hasn't been his best, but I do remember a number of people commenting (including myself) that he looked decent at the beginning of the season - particularly at home against Blackburn and away to Ipswich. Looked like the only major threat to Palace when he came off the bench too.

    The sort of player who may only produce one or two great moments a game. May not be enough but he is talented. I can imagine him being an Ambrose like player who we would let go and then become a revelation somewhere else.

  • Sponsored links:



  • Bexley Dan
    Bexley Dan Posts: 3,658
    I'd definitely agree that league 1 is as far as it goes for bwp and danny green - not enough strength, desire or b*ll*x for the championship.
  • Scoham said:

    BWP hasn't had a chance? He's had 11 starts, 7 sub apps and scored 1 goal. He's struggled to cause problems at this level and lost his place.

    You're quite right. I just feel a tad disappointed that his game isn't suited to the style which the team has successfully developed this season, especially after he did so well in League 1. Nine of his eleven starts this season were in the opening nine games, before the team had got into its stride, and the 10th was against Middlesbrough - again, before we really got going in this league. In fact we hovered just above the relegation places for most of the time before November. Since then, leaving aside cup games, he's started just once. Still, if rumour is to be believed, he'll be off to MKD soon and perhaps that will be more his level.
  • Bexley Dan
    Bexley Dan Posts: 3,658
    Ben hamer surprised my son and nephew yesterday - walked straight past them outside my brothers house in chislehurst. Told them they should have tested him with a quick snow ball before he was set.
  • Bexley Dan
    Bexley Dan Posts: 3,658

    Scoham said:

    BWP hasn't had a chance? He's had 11 starts, 7 sub apps and scored 1 goal. He's struggled to cause problems at this level and lost his place.

    You're quite right. I just feel a tad disappointed that his game isn't suited to the style which the team has successfully developed this season, especially after he did so well in League 1. Nine of his eleven starts this season were in the opening nine games, before the team had got into its stride, and the 10th was against Middlesbrough - again, before we really got going in this league. In fact we hovered just above the relegation places for most of the time before November. Since then, leaving aside cup games, he's started just once. Still, if rumour is to be believed, he'll be off to MKD soon and perhaps that will be more his level.
    a lot of rose tinted glasses with regards to bwp if you ask me - from november onwards he was a liability last year
  • addick16
    addick16 Posts: 1,017
    most suprising player this campaign = lawrie wilson
  • stoneroses19
    stoneroses19 Posts: 7,326
    Definitely Wilson. I was very worried we'd overpaid for what I believed to be league 1 player at best. But he has shone in this league and is one of my favourite players to watch now (on the ball and for his character off the ball).

    As of late 2012/ early 2013, Stephens has greatly impressed me.
  • Scott Wagstaff.......two games,two wins and 1 goal.........from someone that gets murdered at times on this site,,,,Everyone stepped up a gear when he came back.......
  • MuttleyCAFC
    MuttleyCAFC Posts: 47,804
    I think Sir Chris has realised that having a winger - who may have a good game or may be anonymous from one week to the next is not the way to go in this league. When you see Solly and Wilson link up - you get defensive stability, workrate and good width.
  • Good, Cort - Man mountain who gets in the way of everything (well most)
    Bad, Hollands - thought he would step up but so far looks like a league 1 player
  • Anna_Kissed
    Anna_Kissed Posts: 3,302
    Bradley Pritchard. Many of our good moves and goals come from his work. Also noteworthy is his work off the ball; he closes down, gets in the way, breaks up a move before it gets going. He reminds me of Keith Jones, who I rated highly. But whilst Jones had played at the top level with Chelsea, Pritchard has come from non-league Hayes and Yeading. Well done to whoever scouted him. What a find!