Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Hall of Fame vote

2»

Comments

  • Hans Jeppson
  • Smith; Summers; Walsh
  • A magnificent 4 page spread in yesterday's programme. (Thank you Olly). But no photo of the legend that is Norman Smith. Do not forget him when you cast your vote. 450 matches for Charlton in a 14 year spell with the club, 1922-36 and the only player ever to play in 3 promotion teams.
  • Smith,
    Powell
    Walsh

  • A magnificent 4 page spread in yesterday's programme. (Thank you Olly). But no photo of the legend that is Norman Smith. Do not forget him when you cast your vote. 450 matches for Charlton in a 14 year spell with the club, 1922-36 and the only player ever to play in 3 promotion teams.

    He should have used my profile picture, although it did take me a long time to find one of the great Norman Smith
  • Smith
    Powell
    Walsh

    The first I don't know, bu then don't know any of them so will give my vote to Norman Smith. The two Colins I know and they both deserve it in my opinion.
  • Keep the votes rolling in
  • Still plenty of time to vote and to get tickets for the Dinner on 1st May where the three winners will be announced.
  • Last chance to vote this weekend. Results will be announced at the POTY Dinner next Sunday.
  • We announced the winners of the Hall of Fame vote last night. Harold Phipps, centre half in the 1947 FA Cup winning team won the pre 1950 category, Colin Powell triumphed in the 1951-80 vote and in an incredibly tight post 1980 tussle, Colin Walsh defeated Bob Bolder by just 8 votes. The 3 winners will have their names added to the Hall of Fame honours board in the Museum.

    Bolder and the other runners up, Jimmy Oakes and John Hewie will have their names carried forward to the 2017 vote where they will be joined by 4 new nominations. Suggestions please for the 2017 contest ?
  • Sponsored links:


  • Shocked that Norman Smith didn't win or even come second.

    Jimmy Seed, Matt Tees, Kish
  • We announced the winners of the Hall of Fame vote last night. Harold Phipps, centre half in the 1947 FA Cup winning team won the pre 1950 category, Colin Powell triumphed in the 1951-80 vote and in an incredibly tight post 1980 tussle, Colin Walsh defeated Bob Bolder by just 8 votes. The 3 winners will have their names added to the Hall of Fame honours board in the Museum.

    Bolder and the other runners up, Jimmy Oakes and John Hewie will have their names carried forward to the 2017 vote where they will be joined by 4 new nominations. Suggestions please for the 2017 contest ?

    Matt Holland
  • edited May 2016

    We announced the winners of the Hall of Fame vote last night. Harold Phipps, centre half in the 1947 FA Cup winning team won the pre 1950 category, Colin Powell triumphed in the 1951-80 vote and in an incredibly tight post 1980 tussle, Colin Walsh defeated Bob Bolder by just 8 votes. The 3 winners will have their names added to the Hall of Fame honours board in the Museum.

    Bolder and the other runners up, Jimmy Oakes and John Hewie will have their names carried forward to the 2017 vote where they will be joined by 4 new nominations. Suggestions please for the 2017 contest ?

    Jack Horton
    Brian Kinsey
    John Robinson
  • edited May 2016
    Smith (never saw him play but over 400 games and three promotions ? .. very few other Addicks have achieved this level of consistency)

    Hewie (Just a legend and one of my heroes from the first days when I was impressionable boy in the early 60s)

    Walsh (didn't see him that often as I was abroad during much of his stay .. a Clough 'graduate' .. immensely skilful and brave .. oh for a few like him in the team for 2016/17)

    EDIT .. missed the deadline .. would my uncounted vote have made any difference ((:>)
  • What about Nicky Johns? Played more matches for us than any other keeper apart from Sam Bartram, and three times player of the year. We've been blessed with many good keepers over the years, and he is one of the very best.
  • Who are the previous nominations that have come 3rd and therefore can't be voted for again?

    Just so we don't nominate anyone who isaid ineligible.
  • Scott Parker?
  • got to have Eddie Firmani on the board at some time
  • bellz2002 said:

    Who are the previous nominations that have come 3rd and therefore can't be voted for again?

    Just so we don't nominate anyone who isaid ineligible.

    I was wondering about that, I presume people like Steve Gritt have been nominated before
  • Sponsored links:


  • got to have Eddie Firmani on the board at some time

    and I would go for another legendary figure in Lord Llewellyn (a k a Alan) Curbishley .. Firmani a sublime player and half decent manager .. Curbs a sublime manager and half decent player
  • Seed
    Lawrence
    Curbishley
  • Prehistoric: Scotty Kingsley, Seth Plum, Bert Johnson

    Historic: John Hewie, John Hewie, John Hewie ( Eddie Firmani, Cyril Hammond)

    Modern: Radostin Kishishev, Dean Kiely, Peter Shirtliff)
  • John Robinson
    Alan Curbishley
    Theo Foley
    Steve Brown
  • Special cases to be made for

    Fred Chick
    Jim McKenzie
    Nobby Nightingale
  • Steve Brown is a great shout for the Modern nomination...

    Spent 12-years at the club he was there before we came back to the Valley and left us in the Premier League, went in Goal when required and the moment he pulled off that save against Villa almost saved us from Relegation!!
  • Hans Jeppson
  • Davide Petrucci?
  • edited May 2016

    We announced the winners of the Hall of Fame vote last night. Harold Phipps, centre half in the 1947 FA Cup winning team won the pre 1950 category, Colin Powell triumphed in the 1951-80 vote and in an incredibly tight post 1980 tussle, Colin Walsh defeated Bob Bolder by just 8 votes. The 3 winners will have their names added to the Hall of Fame honours board in the Museum.

    Bolder and the other runners up, Jimmy Oakes and John Hewie will have their names carried forward to the 2017 vote where they will be joined by 4 new nominations. Suggestions please for the 2017 contest ?

    @killerjerrylee (or anyone) did Colin Walsh win to be added to the Hall of Fame board? I see him at work and was telling him that and it was news to him. I will let him know it's the case and he can claim his free half a shandy in Bartrams if someone would please confirm?

    Cheers
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!