Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Charlton v Doncaster semi-final leg 2 post-match views

1679111214

Comments

  • Kap10
    Kap10 Posts: 15,577
    rikofold said:
    SDAddick said:
    Don't care if he was rubbish, he wasn't alone, Naby is part of what got us here and I love him for it. He looked so nervous before the pens. But I'd put money right now on him being MOTM at Wembley. Class persists. 
    Worth a mention that Naby is Muslim and as it's Ramadan he'd not eaten or drunk anything all day.  On that basis his performance was heroic. He wasn't terrible anyway. 
    He may have been given dispensation, Salah was last year prior to Chanpions League final.
  • Posted without reading 9 pages:

    Donny were f**king good, pressed us for 100 minutes, they deserve credit for that performance!

    How many of our players had ever seen 25,000 fans at a match?

    Great prep for Wembley 

    COYR’s
  • Maybe there is a God.  Maybe love does conquer all.  This morning I believe. Phew. 

     
  • Redmidland
    Redmidland Posts: 44,700
    Couldn't post last night as I was stuck somewhere between euphoria and exhaustion!! Donny were the better team on the night and we seemed to have lost our game plan. I'm so pleased we got through and Wembley is now a reality, but can we just put the Mackems to the sword in 90 minutes, please!! Well played boys and what a fantastic atmosphere, it came over great on the TV, 8 days until we play again, 8 days to sort out a game plan, 8 days until promotion? 
  • Davo55
    Davo55 Posts: 7,838
    edited May 2019
    Resilience
    guts
    courage
    passion
    fight
    energy
    emotion
    pride
    fear
    despair
    hope
    bravery
    love
    elation

    Mix em all up, and it’s the Charlton fan cocktail. Drink it all in, because it’ll all me needed again next Sunday. 

    Still shaky and emotional this morning. 

    Sort out Bowyer’s contract you senile old Belgian prick, and then do one. If you watched it last night you might just have got the slightest idea what it’s like to be Charlton. But you’ll never, ever be part of it. 

    Bowyer gets it. Jacko gets it. Chrissie Powell gets it. The ex players in the stands with the crowd last night get it. You don’t have to have been a lifelong fan to get it. But you do have to respect and treasure this wonderful club. 
  • blackpool72
    blackpool72 Posts: 23,683
    Hangover from hell 
    But as happy as can possibly be. 

  • olster
    olster Posts: 1,399
    Hated every minute of it
  • orpingtonRED
    orpingtonRED Posts: 3,474
    What happened with the penalty shootout. Did Donnie win the toss but were not allowed to chose the Jimmy Seed end? Im sure the police were on the pitch and decided it had to be at the covered end? I didn't imagine that did i
  • Uboat
    Uboat Posts: 12,199
    What happened with the penalty shootout. Did Donnie win the toss but were not allowed to chose the Jimmy Seed end? Im sure the police were on the pitch and decided it had to be at the covered end? I didn't imagine that did i
    I don't know, but their goalie was very pissed off, so that could be it. 
  • Chris_from_Sidcup
    Chris_from_Sidcup Posts: 36,034
    Fucking class seeing a full Valley for the first time in years and great seeing so many celebrating on the pitch at the end.

  • Sponsored links:



  • Fumbluff
    Fumbluff Posts: 10,129
    It looked to me as if the popo decided and told the ref it had to me the cupboard end on some safety grounds as when the players came up to toss you could see the Donny player getting a bit narked and pointing at all our supporters there...
  • Uboat
    Uboat Posts: 12,199
    edited May 2019

    Great comments from everyone. Still can't believe we came through that. 
    Just like 1998 I think Sunderland will go into the final (over)full of confidence, which is fine by me. 
    Bit sad singing 'Wemberlee!' knowing full well I'll be on holiday when they kick off next Sunday, but also a bit relieved, cos I don't think I could take it again. 
  • Cardinal Sin
    Cardinal Sin Posts: 5,233
    And, in fairness to Parker, he'd run himself into the ground - so there wasn't much left to give before being subbed. 
    I'd like to see him run himself out of the ground.
  • And, in fairness to Parker, he'd run himself into the ground - so there wasn't much left to give before being subbed. 
    I'd like to see him run himself out of the ground.
    Certainly works hard but can't finish.
  • SoundAsa£
    SoundAsa£ Posts: 22,483
    edited May 2019
    rikofold said:
    SDAddick said:
    Don't care if he was rubbish, he wasn't alone, Naby is part of what got us here and I love him for it. He looked so nervous before the pens. But I'd put money right now on him being MOTM at Wembley. Class persists. 
    Worth a mention that Naby is Muslim and as it's Ramadan he'd not eaten or drunk anything all day.  On that basis his performance was heroic. He wasn't terrible anyway. 
    It’s entirely up to the individual....and anyway, many Muslims don’t stick to the somewhat lax rules and under certain circumstances, even for devout Muslims, they can be allowed to break the fast.....such a circumstance would certainly be an athlete or sportsman needing correct sustenance for an important event.
    Not saying Nabby did one thing or the other but I very much doubt he would have gone out there under any duress due to lack of food or water if that’s what you’re thinking.
  • BR7_addick
    BR7_addick Posts: 10,212
    Pretty disgusting how in 2019 the cameras are still picking out the sorts for viewers to perv over..
  • rikofold
    rikofold Posts: 4,051
    rikofold said:
    SDAddick said:
    Don't care if he was rubbish, he wasn't alone, Naby is part of what got us here and I love him for it. He looked so nervous before the pens. But I'd put money right now on him being MOTM at Wembley. Class persists. 
    Worth a mention that Naby is Muslim and as it's Ramadan he'd not eaten or drunk anything all day.  On that basis his performance was heroic. He wasn't terrible anyway. 
    It’s entirely up to the individual....and anyway, many Muslims don’t stick to the somewhat lax rules and under certain circumstances, even for devout Muslims, they can be allowed to break the fast.....such a circumstance would certainly be an athlete or sportsman needing correct sustenance for an important event.
    Not saying Nabby did one thing or the other but I very much doubt he would have gone out there under any duress due to lack of food or water if that’s what you’re thinking.
    Not what I'm thinking, it's a fact. 
  • Southendaddick
    Southendaddick Posts: 5,314
    Managed to pull a quad muscle jumping on the pitch (further than it looks) 😂

    Doncaster really did a number on us and deserved the win on the night and I thought we were done for at 3-1 but a brave performance in the end

    Not sure whether it was a combination of Ramadan, new babies, over confidence, tiredness, nerves, tactics or what but we need to raise our game next week and I’m sure we will

    Best Valley atmosphere and scenes I’ve ever seen, never thought I would see blocks of people standing in the East 😂

    Roll on Wembley so glad I booked our half term holiday for the Monday now 
  • Algarveaddick
    Algarveaddick Posts: 21,156
    Only read a couple of pages. My take is this.

    Absolutely dreadful performance, other than the first five minutes, seven minutes of the first half of extra time and the first three penalties. it was like ten strangers were on the pitch.

    That game was so "big occasion" Charlton it should be the definition in the dictionary. Passes going nowhere, when they did go somewhere it was inevitably to a player who was tightly marked (yes I know Donny did a good job, but on many occasions there was clearly a better option, and it was rarely taken). Needless fouls given away, passing when shots were on, fannying about on the ball just outside our area... the list goes on.

    I hated every effing minute after they scored their first. 

    Then I get home to find that my poor missus (who tried to watch at home on a stream, with little success) was gutted as we had "lost" 4-3 on penalties according to the BBC. It's not often I make her smile when I get in from the pub. 

    Couldn't even celebrate properly as we are working today. 

    And we wont be able to make it to Wembley either.

    Still - can't wait to watch it on tele next Sunday, I hope the customers don't expect to be served quickly... :D 

    COYA!   

           

  • Sponsored links:



  • Algarveaddick
    Algarveaddick Posts: 21,156
    Oh - one upside was the pub I was watching in. I was the only Charlton fan in there, although several mates were in there rooting for us. By the time he missed that penalty, the whole darn place erupted on my behalf - bless 'em. All I could manage was an arm in the air...     
  • Nug
    Nug Posts: 4,623
    Amazing night. Scoring that early really took the pressure off Donny and they had to go for it and they certainly did that. It was so crucial to equalise quickly when their 3rd went in, they would have cheated and time wasted their way to the final whistle and we’d have struggled to get the ball. The hostile atmosphere for the penalties was a huge factor too. 13 year old son was on the pitch, saw his school mates on there, that’s what it’s all about, can’t wait to take him to Wembley I missed the last time while living abroad.
  • EveshamAddick
    EveshamAddick Posts: 7,019
    What happened with the penalty shootout. Did Donnie win the toss but were not allowed to chose the Jimmy Seed end? Im sure the police were on the pitch and decided it had to be at the covered end? I didn't imagine that did i
    Bauer won the toss and chose to go first. Before the toss the ref explained it would be happening in front of the covered end. Their captain was pissed off.
  • Viewfinder
    Viewfinder Posts: 4,912
    edited May 2019
    Ecstasy and delirium at the very end should not mask a performance full of mistakes.  After a bright first 10 minutes we tried to play possession football, tip-taps sideways and backwards - yet we know our players lack the necessary skills and are bound to come a-cropper.  Slow, ponderous moves bring self-inflicted errors and invite opponents to advance.  We are strongest and most effective going straight for the jugular.

    In the 93rd minute of normal time, Marquis rushing in at the back post was a whisker from making it 3-1 and ending our season.  Half of our squad would have been released next week.  Instead, we anticipate Wembley with high excitement.

    But, but - we must play at a higher tempo, with more power and aggression, making smarter moves approaching the box.  Where is Ben Reeves?  He has the ability to unlock defences - and score goals - and is miles more effective than Morgan and Lapslie.  Sunderland were the finest team at The Valley this season, a class above us in the first half.  If we bumble around like last night, we'll get mullered.   We must raise our game for one final victory.       
  • MartinCAFC
    MartinCAFC Posts: 3,224
    PWR

    Just on the penalties I thought we'd blown it until I saw the camera zoom in on Bowyer looking so helpless a bit like Curbs during pens at Wembley in 98. I felt so sorry for Bowyer looking so helpless but at that point I did think we would go on to win on pens just for Bowyer if anything anf thankfully that was the case.
  • TEL
    TEL Posts: 10,100
    TEL said:
    Poor performance but what a win! Sat behind Bowyer and he wasn’t a happy bunny about the refereeing. He and Jacko had a few choice words with the fourth official. Great atmosphere, got a brilliant video of the crowd on the pitch. Unreal night but hey, we got there in the end.
    Who was it in the dugout that got booked?
    Jacko for his comments on the offside goal
  • AddicksAddict
    AddicksAddict Posts: 15,801
    Leuth said:
    The pitch invasion was spectacular and there was a LOT of pent-up frustration and emotion that went into it, but I do object to it, on the grounds that we're not up yet - enjoy the moment I suppose! But I'm already worrying about the final...
    I'd be worried if you weren't worrying.
  • AddicksAddict
    AddicksAddict Posts: 15,801
    SE7toSG3 said:
    Great scenes after, and at London Bridge, Donny played well but inaging that journey home for them now, brilliant night and one I will remember for years to come...get in! 
    I'm in that picture.  Fame at last.
  • TEL
    TEL Posts: 10,100
    What happened with the penalty shootout. Did Donnie win the toss but were not allowed to chose the Jimmy Seed end? Im sure the police were on the pitch and decided it had to be at the covered end? I didn't imagine that did i
    Yeah the old bill called it.
  • charltonkeston
    charltonkeston Posts: 7,369
    TEL said:
    What happened with the penalty shootout. Did Donnie win the toss but were not allowed to chose the Jimmy Seed end? Im sure the police were on the pitch and decided it had to be at the covered end? I didn't imagine that did i
    Yeah the old bill called it.
    For safety reasons, apparently. But I like to think it was done for us.