Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Charlton v Reading match thread 11/07/2020
Comments
-
Officials are not there to "guess" decisions.Callumcafc said:
Understand that. What I was saying is that the limo probably guessed on a call that could’ve gone either way because Aneke found himself in so much space. It *looked* offside.Oggy Red said:
Then the officials are inept ..... because the Offside Law clearly states "at the moment the ball is played".Callumcafc said:
In this frame, Aneke’s chest may be offside. However the shot is taken after the ball already left McGeady’s foot.It’s a very very marginal call and I believe it only went against us because he was standing in an offside position when the ball fell at his feet.
3 -
Yes we areForeverAddickted said:
We're not at that stage yetpeterreeves said:
It's called desperation!ForeverAddickted said:
Sarr has done shit up front this season!!peterreeves said:Put sarr up front he'll scare the defence... God we need something... And Lyle if youre watching.... This is on you you basterd!1 -
Posted at54'
Michael Morrison (Reading) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
0 -
54' The Reading players aren't best pleased as Pratley clatters into Morrison - not so much for the challenge, but because the ball had broken for a counter, but the ref blew for a foul.0
-
Posted at55'
Jason Pearce (Charlton Athletic) wins a free kick in the defensive half.
Posted at55'Foul by George Puscas (Reading).
0 -
How? - Weve three games left and any win can left us a number of placesfloydroadfaithfull said:
Yes we areForeverAddickted said:
We're not at that stage yetpeterreeves said:
It's called desperation!ForeverAddickted said:
Sarr has done shit up front this season!!peterreeves said:Put sarr up front he'll scare the defence... God we need something... And Lyle if youre watching.... This is on you you basterd!
Thats not desperation!!0 -
Not good enough or it would have been a goalForeverAddickted said:Good effort from Bonne1 -
56' Reading sub: Puscas off, Baldock on.
0 -
That's what the opposition Goalkeeper is there for you know... To stop the other team from scoring!!floydroadfaithfull said:
Not good enough or it would have been a goalForeverAddickted said:Good effort from Bonne0 -
Because the bottom sides keep winning?ForeverAddickted said:
How? - Weve three games left and any win can left us a number of placesfloydroadfaithfull said:
Yes we areForeverAddickted said:
We're not at that stage yetpeterreeves said:
It's called desperation!ForeverAddickted said:
Sarr has done shit up front this season!!peterreeves said:Put sarr up front he'll scare the defence... God we need something... And Lyle if youre watching.... This is on you you basterd!
Thats not desperation!!0 - Sponsored links:
-
Come on Lads...keep going0
-
My question for Bowter though is why does he feel we need two holding mids when Reading are sitting back inviting pressure? It’s not like Albie is utterly incapable of defending and he can always bring Field on later, but he can’t bring Albie back out now.ForeverAddickted said:At the moment we're still threatening and still dangerous so would say Bowyer has made the right call so far0 -
No but he has to make a decision either way. Flag up or flag down, it would be a guess. Are you advocating for VAR here? :-)Oggy Red said:
Officials are not there to "guess" decisions.Callumcafc said:
Understand that. What I was saying is that the limo probably guessed on a call that could’ve gone either way because Aneke found himself in so much space. It *looked* offside.Oggy Red said:
Then the officials are inept ..... because the Offside Law clearly states "at the moment the ball is played".Callumcafc said:In this frame, Aneke’s chest may be offside. However the shot is taken after the ball already left McGeady’s foot.It’s a very very marginal call and I believe it only went against us because he was standing in an offside position when the ball fell at his feet.It looked 50/50 on a freeze frame replay. When he sees Aneke pick the ball up in a position that’s a couple of feet offside, I reckon that’s swayed him.0 -
But its still not a desperate situationChunes said:
Because the bottom sides keep winning?ForeverAddickted said:
How? - Weve three games left and any win can left us a number of placesfloydroadfaithfull said:
Yes we areForeverAddickted said:
We're not at that stage yetpeterreeves said:
It's called desperation!ForeverAddickted said:
Sarr has done shit up front this season!!peterreeves said:Put sarr up front he'll scare the defence... God we need something... And Lyle if youre watching.... This is on you you basterd!
Thats not desperation!!
2 -
It’s the hope that kills you0
-
To be fair, I wish I felt like you doForeverAddickted said:
But its still not a desperate situationChunes said:
Because the bottom sides keep winning?ForeverAddickted said:
How? - Weve three games left and any win can left us a number of placesfloydroadfaithfull said:
Yes we areForeverAddickted said:
We're not at that stage yetpeterreeves said:
It's called desperation!ForeverAddickted said:
Sarr has done shit up front this season!!peterreeves said:Put sarr up front he'll scare the defence... God we need something... And Lyle if youre watching.... This is on you you basterd!
Thats not desperation!!1 -
I reckon the lino's thought that as our strikers don't really move when they're in the box if Chuks has received the ball in an offside position he therefore must have been offside when the ball was played.Callumcafc said:
No but he has to make a decision either way. Flag up or flag down, it would be a guess. Are you advocating for VAR here? :-)Oggy Red said:
Officials are not there to "guess" decisions.Callumcafc said:
Understand that. What I was saying is that the limo probably guessed on a call that could’ve gone either way because Aneke found himself in so much space. It *looked* offside.Oggy Red said:
Then the officials are inept ..... because the Offside Law clearly states "at the moment the ball is played".Callumcafc said:In this frame, Aneke’s chest may be offside. However the shot is taken after the ball already left McGeady’s foot.It’s a very very marginal call and I believe it only went against us because he was standing in an offside position when the ball fell at his feet.It looked 50/50 on a freeze frame replay. When he sees Aneke pick the ball up in a position that’s a couple of feet offside, I reckon that’s swayed him.1 -
Posted at58'
Tom Lockyer (Charlton Athletic) wins a free kick on the right wing.
Posted at58'Foul by Sam Baldock (Reading).
0 -
Because we can lose today and still get three resultsChunes said:
To be fair, I wish I felt like you didForeverAddickted said:
But its still not a desperate situationChunes said:
Because the bottom sides keep winning?ForeverAddickted said:
How? - Weve three games left and any win can left us a number of placesfloydroadfaithfull said:
Yes we areForeverAddickted said:
We're not at that stage yetpeterreeves said:
It's called desperation!ForeverAddickted said:
Sarr has done shit up front this season!!peterreeves said:Put sarr up front he'll scare the defence... God we need something... And Lyle if youre watching.... This is on you you basterd!
Thats not desperation!!
Its all IFs whatever way you look at it but desperate for me is a result where relegation is confirmed if we dont win!!0 -
Not a bad shout lolBriston_Addick said:
I reckon the lino's thought that as our strikers don't really move when they're in the box if Chuks has received the ball in an offside position he therefore must have been offside when the ball was played.Callumcafc said:
No but he has to make a decision either way. Flag up or flag down, it would be a guess. Are you advocating for VAR here? :-)Oggy Red said:
Officials are not there to "guess" decisions.Callumcafc said:
Understand that. What I was saying is that the limo probably guessed on a call that could’ve gone either way because Aneke found himself in so much space. It *looked* offside.Oggy Red said:
Then the officials are inept ..... because the Offside Law clearly states "at the moment the ball is played".Callumcafc said:In this frame, Aneke’s chest may be offside. However the shot is taken after the ball already left McGeady’s foot.It’s a very very marginal call and I believe it only went against us because he was standing in an offside position when the ball fell at his feet.It looked 50/50 on a freeze frame replay. When he sees Aneke pick the ball up in a position that’s a couple of feet offside, I reckon that’s swayed him.0 - Sponsored links:
-
Posted at59'
Jonathan Williams (Charlton Athletic) wins a free kick on the left wing.
Posted at59'Foul by Andy Rinomhota (Reading).
0 -
Isn’t there a rule that the benefit of the doubt always goes to the attacker?Callumcafc said:
No but he has to make a decision either way. Flag up or flag down, it would be a guess. Are you advocating for VAR here? :-)Oggy Red said:
Officials are not there to "guess" decisions.Callumcafc said:
Understand that. What I was saying is that the limo probably guessed on a call that could’ve gone either way because Aneke found himself in so much space. It *looked* offside.Oggy Red said:
Then the officials are inept ..... because the Offside Law clearly states "at the moment the ball is played".Callumcafc said:In this frame, Aneke’s chest may be offside. However the shot is taken after the ball already left McGeady’s foot.It’s a very very marginal call and I believe it only went against us because he was standing in an offside position when the ball fell at his feet.It looked 50/50 on a freeze frame replay. When he sees Aneke pick the ball up in a position that’s a couple of feet offside, I reckon that’s swayed him.0 -
Still cant see how this lot beat Luton 5-01
-
I would rather win today and then worry about the other three games laterForeverAddickted said:
Because we can lose today and still get three resultsChunes said:
To be fair, I wish I felt like you didForeverAddickted said:
But its still not a desperate situationChunes said:
Because the bottom sides keep winning?ForeverAddickted said:
How? - Weve three games left and any win can left us a number of placesfloydroadfaithfull said:
Yes we areForeverAddickted said:
We're not at that stage yetpeterreeves said:
It's called desperation!ForeverAddickted said:
Sarr has done shit up front this season!!peterreeves said:Put sarr up front he'll scare the defence... God we need something... And Lyle if youre watching.... This is on you you basterd!
Thats not desperation!!
Its all IFs whatever way you look at it but desperate for me is a result where relegation is confirmed if we dont win!!4 -
Glad Olise is off, reminded me of Aribo in his play (and his look tbh)0
-
Posted at60'
Jonathan Williams (Charlton Athletic) wins a free kick in the attacking half.
Posted at60'Foul by John Swift (Reading).
0 -
61' Reading sub: Richards on for Olise.
0 -
30 mins to save our season. Get Hemed on, hes more of a threat bringing others into play than Bonne.1
-
This isn’t good enough
1 -
Need to make this pressure count for something0
This discussion has been closed.
