Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Who would you keep/like to see move on at the end of the season?
cabbles
Posts: 15,261
I touched on this on my post match comments, but I’m curious to see who others would like to keep or move on at the end of the season? I think for me, keep Amos, Morgan, Jayesimi, Inniss, Schwarz and Aneke. Would like to get Millar and Stockley, but think both will have better options at the end of the season
0
Comments
-
Bowyer
finish top 6 you can stay
miss out on top 6 on your way
7 -
I would offer new contracts to Aneke and JFC and offer Stockley a deal. Everyone else out of contract or on loan, I would not be angry if they left. Would like to see us keep Famewo (unlikely).Don’t think we’ve got any chance of keeping Millar.0
-
Isn't Jaiyesimi on a three-and-a-half year deal?cabbles said:I touched on this on my post match comments, but I’m curious to see who others would like to keep or move on at the end of the season? I think for me, keep Amos, Morgan, Jayesimi, Inniss, Schwarz and Aneke. Would like to get Millar and Stockley, but think both will have better options at the end of the season
With Sandgaard's five-year plan to reach the Premier League, Jaiyesimi is part of our all-conquering Championship winning squad.
Oh, Jesus!
2 -
I think my list is the same as yours except take out Amos and add Famewo - although the latter probably goes in the Millar/Stockley category.cabbles said:I touched on this on my post match comments, but I’m curious to see who others would like to keep or move on at the end of the season? I think for me, keep Amos, Morgan, Jayesimi, Inniss, Schwarz and Aneke. Would like to get Millar and Stockley, but think both will have better options at the end of the season0 -
Assuming we are still League One which looks likely I would keep the below but clearly likes of Famewo and Millar are massively unlikely.
Likes of Matthews and Purrington as back up, and particularly because we need some stability, we can't bring 20 new players in and hope to be successful.
GK
AMB
Defence
MatthewsFamewoInnisPurrington
MidfieldMorganMillarShinnieGilbey?JayesimiJFC
StrikersStockleySchwartzAneke
Would then need a keeper, 4 defenders, 1 striker and 2-3 midfielders. Question mark on Gilbey as I simply have not seen enough of him to make a decision but he does have previous pedigree.
8-9 true quality additions to the above and we should be a very decent L1 outfit but they would need to be top class additions as most would be starters.0 -
Keep: Sandgaard, Gallen9
-
I totally agree.oohaahmortimer said:Bowyer
finish top 6 you can stay
miss out on top 6 on your way0 -
Keep
AMB
Matthews
FamewoInnissOshilajaPurrington
MorganJFC
JaiyesimiSchwartz
AnekeWashington
Try to buyShinnie
Stockley
No hope but try
Millar1 -
A lot of people not keeping Gunter, who has a contract for next season already?0
-
Are you really judging a player based on two substitute appearances?Dave Rudd said:
Isn't Jaiyesimi on a three-and-a-half year deal?cabbles said:I touched on this on my post match comments, but I’m curious to see who others would like to keep or move on at the end of the season? I think for me, keep Amos, Morgan, Jayesimi, Inniss, Schwarz and Aneke. Would like to get Millar and Stockley, but think both will have better options at the end of the season
With Sandgaard's five-year plan to reach the Premier League, Jaiyesimi is part of our all-conquering Championship winning squad.
Oh, Jesus!13 -
Sponsored links:
-
GK
Amos - look for better, would be happy to keep as 2nd choice
AMB - loan him out ideally to a League 2 side
RB
Gunter - under contract, let go if someone comes in for him otherwise keep as back up
Matthews - out of contract, replace with a first choice long term permanent signing. A quicker more attacking right back as an alternative to Gunter
CB
Inniss - keep as under contract, don’t extend unless he can stay largely injury free.
Famewo - try to loan back if he returns to the team and stays fit.
Oshilaja - release, mid table L1 at best
Pearce - release, as above
LB
Maatsen - ideally replace with a long term permanent signing
Purrington - keep as 2nd choice
DM
Watson - release and replace with a long term permanent signing, a mobile energetic DM with Championship+ potential
Pratley - keep as cover and for his character/experience
CM
Morgan - keep
Shinnie - like him but 32 in the summer, not convinced next season won’t be a year too far. Needs pace, energy and physicality around him
Gilbey - too early to write him off, under contract, will be interesting to see if we do move him on in the summer
JFC - never been fully convinced but yesterday perhaps showed he’s better defensively than Shinnie, probably keep assuming he’s not picked up another bad injury
Smith - impossible to judge
Wingers
Millar - keep but no chance of that unless we go up
Jaiyesimi - keep
New wingers - sign 3 including a Millar replacement, our strikers benefit from good service out wide
Strikers
Aneke - offer new contract
Schwartz - keep, will score goals with good reliable service
Stockley - sign
Washington - would replace with better if we could but probably not realistic11 -
I am really looking forward to having a new club captain. Perhaps a winner who makes others raise their game. Someone who will bang heads together, rather than nice guy Pearce.
We're also desperate for a top-class CM, despite all our options. A Whiteman or a Fraser, a player who can run games and who we can build for the future around. JFC, Gilbey, Pratley, Shinnie, they just aren't good enough or aren't that kind of player.
Other than that, I agree with all Scoham's choices, except Pratley who I would let go.3 -
Yup.Todds_right_hook said:
Are you really judging a player based on two substitute appearances?Dave Rudd said:
Isn't Jaiyesimi on a three-and-a-half year deal?cabbles said:I touched on this on my post match comments, but I’m curious to see who others would like to keep or move on at the end of the season? I think for me, keep Amos, Morgan, Jayesimi, Inniss, Schwarz and Aneke. Would like to get Millar and Stockley, but think both will have better options at the end of the season
With Sandgaard's five-year plan to reach the Premier League, Jaiyesimi is part of our all-conquering Championship winning squad.
Oh, Jesus!
Let's keep track of this, shall we?
I will be delighted to be wrong.0 -
I'd only keep Pratley now that the salary cap has gone and there's no other limited put in place. He'd be there as someone to have around the squad, not guaranteed to be in the match day squad every week. Good to have a few like that just as we had with players like Euell and Hughes in our title winning season.Chunes said:I am really looking forward to having a new club captain. Perhaps a winner who makes others raise their game. Someone who will bang heads together, rather than nice guy Pearce.
We're also desperate for a top-class CM, despite all our options. Someone like a Whiteman or a Fraser - a player who can run games and who we can build for the future around. JFC, Gilbey, Pratley, Shinnie, they just aren't good enough or aren't that kind of player.
Other than that, I agree with all Scoham's choices, except Pratley who I would let go.1 -
Keep
AMB
Amos (but not as first choice)Matthews
InnissOshilajaPurrington
MorganJFC
Jaiyesimi
Pratley
SchwartzAnekeTry to buyShinnie
Stockley
Try to extend Millar and Famewo loan
Unsure about Gilbey. I do think there is a player in there.0 -
I would get rid of
Purrington
Pearce
Oshilaja
Watson
Morgan
Pratley
Gilbey (Has been awful but part of me thinks there could be a decent player in there, but as it stands get rid)
From the loans I would try to bring back
Shinnie
Stockley
Millar (Think he will be playing Championship football at least next season with or without us.
Famewo (If his injury is going to clear up sometime this century.
Smith (Not sure yet as hardly played)
Maatsen (Lots of promise at start but been poor last few months, when he comes back into the team we can see. Not sure
Would also like a better Keeper then Amos, Amos can be no 2.
Keep the rest.
0 -
I certainly wouldn’t keep hold of Bowyer.3
-
You know the drill - write players off before the ink is dry on their contract.Todds_right_hook said:
Are you really judging a player based on two substitute appearances?Dave Rudd said:
Isn't Jaiyesimi on a three-and-a-half year deal?cabbles said:I touched on this on my post match comments, but I’m curious to see who others would like to keep or move on at the end of the season? I think for me, keep Amos, Morgan, Jayesimi, Inniss, Schwarz and Aneke. Would like to get Millar and Stockley, but think both will have better options at the end of the season
With Sandgaard's five-year plan to reach the Premier League, Jaiyesimi is part of our all-conquering Championship winning squad.
Oh, Jesus!2 -
As I said to the original comment, let's re-visit this as often as you like.ricky_otto said:
You know the drill - write players off before the ink is dry on their contract.Todds_right_hook said:
Are you really judging a player based on two substitute appearances?Dave Rudd said:
Isn't Jaiyesimi on a three-and-a-half year deal?cabbles said:I touched on this on my post match comments, but I’m curious to see who others would like to keep or move on at the end of the season? I think for me, keep Amos, Morgan, Jayesimi, Inniss, Schwarz and Aneke. Would like to get Millar and Stockley, but think both will have better options at the end of the season
With Sandgaard's five-year plan to reach the Premier League, Jaiyesimi is part of our all-conquering Championship winning squad.
Oh, Jesus!
Happy to be wrong ... but confident that I am not.0 -
Give him time Dave.Dave Rudd said:
As I said to the original comment, let's re-visit this as often as you like.ricky_otto said:
You know the drill - write players off before the ink is dry on their contract.Todds_right_hook said:
Are you really judging a player based on two substitute appearances?Dave Rudd said:
Isn't Jaiyesimi on a three-and-a-half year deal?cabbles said:I touched on this on my post match comments, but I’m curious to see who others would like to keep or move on at the end of the season? I think for me, keep Amos, Morgan, Jayesimi, Inniss, Schwarz and Aneke. Would like to get Millar and Stockley, but think both will have better options at the end of the season
With Sandgaard's five-year plan to reach the Premier League, Jaiyesimi is part of our all-conquering Championship winning squad.
Oh, Jesus!
Happy to be wrong ... but confident that I am not.1 -
Sponsored links:
-
Would be great if we could sign Stockley & Millar - but I know that’s not very realistic. Would like to sign Shinnie & give new contracts to Aneke, Amos, JFC & Pratley. Possibly a fit Famewo, on another season long loan. Don’t think Maddison or Oztumer have a future at the club.
I wouldn’t be upset if we got rid of Oshilaja & Gilbey.0 -
Aneke, Stockley and Millar.
Jaiyesimi looks promising so he can stay as well.
JFC is an odd one for me - He's done well for half of this season, but its taken about 3-4 years to see any proper form out of him.
The rest I really won't lose any sleep at all if they go. Can't remember many teams we've had like this where I've felt so little of a connection to the players on our books. Even when we had terrible seasons in the past there was still a Jackson or a Solly who you could hang your hat on as bit of a 'Mr Charlton'.1 -
Wtf ????cafctom said:
Jaiyesimi looks promising so he can stay as well.
We only signed him 2 weeks ago on a 3 and a half year deal.
Another one for #deluded2 -
We don't often keep loans for more than one season. Cullen and Da Silva are the only ones that come to mind in recent years.I hope we get Chuks on a long-term contract but I expect another big clearout, a whole load of new players and when we're mid-table an excuse from the man agersaying we're overachieving as the new players haven't had time to gel.3
-
Sorry, what?golfaddick said:
Wtf ????cafctom said:
Jaiyesimi looks promising so he can stay as well.
We only signed him 2 weeks ago on a 3 and a half year deal.
Another one for #deluded
How does that make me deluded?1 -
It's a weird one to have Washington as a replace for me, he is more than adequate at this level. His shots to goals ratio is actually quite impressive. He just needs to be a bit more greedy and show faith in his ability.Scoham said:GK
Amos - look for better, would be happy to keep as 2nd choice
AMB - loan him out ideally to a League 2 side
RB
Gunter - under contract, let go if someone comes in for him otherwise keep as back up
Matthews - out of contract, replace with a first choice long term permanent signing. A quicker more attacking right back as an alternative to Gunter
CB
Inniss - keep as under contract, don’t extend unless he can stay largely injury free.
Famewo - try to loan back if he returns to the team and stays fit.
Oshilaja - release, mid table L1 at best
Pearce - release, as above
LB
Maatsen - ideally replace with a long term permanent signing
Purrington - keep as 2nd choice
DM
Watson - release and replace with a long term permanent signing, a mobile energetic DM with Championship+ potential
Pratley - keep as cover and for his character/experience
CM
Morgan - keep
Shinnie - like him but 32 in the summer, not convinced next season won’t be a year too far. Needs pace, energy and physicality around him
Gilbey - too early to write him off, under contract, will be interesting to see if we do move him on in the summer
JFC - never been fully convinced but yesterday perhaps showed he’s better defensively than Shinnie, probably keep assuming he’s not picked up another bad injury
Smith - impossible to judge
Wingers
Millar - keep but no chance of that unless we go up
Jaiyesimi - keep
New wingers - sign 3 including a Millar replacement, our strikers benefit from good service out wide
Strikers
Aneke - offer new contract
Schwartz - keep, will score goals with good reliable service
Stockley - sign
Washington - would replace with better if we could but probably not realistic0 -
He also looked very good in his first appearance (albeit a short one) and showed some great touches in the second one, even though he clearly wasn't at his best - who was though?Todds_right_hook said:
Are you really judging a player based on two substitute appearances?Dave Rudd said:
Isn't Jaiyesimi on a three-and-a-half year deal?cabbles said:I touched on this on my post match comments, but I’m curious to see who others would like to keep or move on at the end of the season? I think for me, keep Amos, Morgan, Jayesimi, Inniss, Schwarz and Aneke. Would like to get Millar and Stockley, but think both will have better options at the end of the season
With Sandgaard's five-year plan to reach the Premier League, Jaiyesimi is part of our all-conquering Championship winning squad.
Oh, Jesus!0 -
I'd just get used to it. There's always been a portion of our support that has never got tricky wingers. Even Jerome Thomas used to get pelters for doing too many stepovers and 'no end product'. This will be a continuing theme with DJ.moutuakilla said:
He also looked very good in his first appearance (albeit a short one) and showed some great touches in the second one, even though he clearly wasn't at his best - who was though?Todds_right_hook said:
Are you really judging a player based on two substitute appearances?Dave Rudd said:
Isn't Jaiyesimi on a three-and-a-half year deal?cabbles said:I touched on this on my post match comments, but I’m curious to see who others would like to keep or move on at the end of the season? I think for me, keep Amos, Morgan, Jayesimi, Inniss, Schwarz and Aneke. Would like to get Millar and Stockley, but think both will have better options at the end of the season
With Sandgaard's five-year plan to reach the Premier League, Jaiyesimi is part of our all-conquering Championship winning squad.
Oh, Jesus!
1 -
At this stage I've no idea. For a start it depends on how we finish the season.
We could go up in triumph via the playoffs, in which case we'll need Championship players
We could miss out on promotion but finish strongly with positive momentum, in which case we'd want to keep as many of the squad as possible
We could dribble along to 10th or lower playing poorly, in which case we'd want to change things
0 -
Osilaja and Pearce to move on. Use the lions share of the transfer budget to get 2 strong proven centre backs in. Maybe also a left back to compete with Purrington and allow Maatsen to play left mid in a more attacking role.
Keep Akin Famewo, Millar and Stockley if possible and keep the remaining others.
I think with a solid reliable defence this squad gets promoted.1
