Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Would you sign any of our loanees this season permanently..?
Pavoren007
Posts: 2,525
Just wondered what your thoughts are on this question?
It may be an obvious one which equates to none, or some may see potential for one or more to be sticking around.
The only one player of this season’s loanees I would offer a deal to is Norwich’s Famewo. He can do better and be more consistent no doubt, but he is still young and I just have this inkling may turn into a very good player over the coming few years.
The only one player of this season’s loanees I would offer a deal to is Norwich’s Famewo. He can do better and be more consistent no doubt, but he is still young and I just have this inkling may turn into a very good player over the coming few years.
A pass for me on Lee, Leko (regrettably and more the system we are playing than him, as I really like the lad), Burstow, Castillo and John (latter two neither of which I have seen).
Our loanee strategy has clearly not worked out this season, so let’s hope for better next season…
Our loanee strategy has clearly not worked out this season, so let’s hope for better next season…
0
Comments
-
Pass on all of them. The evidence is on the pitch - they haven’t been good enough to achieve the goal of promotion6
-
Pay day loans this year. Send them back.0
-
The only one I would sign is John for the u23s. Of course that won't happen so it's a no from me.0
-
Definitely sign Nile John. He hasn't put a foot wrong.
I'd keep Famewo but none of the others.5 -
Nope1
-
Torn on Famewo, rated him last season, but he's been a lot worse this season.
But then I wonder if he could turn that around, and whether we'd get any better. We need to sign 3 or 4 CBs if Pearce and Inniss go and we're going to play 3 at the back, he's a left footer etc....
The others, nope.3 -
Nope not at all0
-
Possibly Famewo, Burstow (but only if Chelski pay us), not Arter, Lee or Leko, can’t comment on the other two.0
-
I think Burstow will still turn out to be a good player and playup at least league one level but the whole situation worked out badly for him and us in the short-term.
He was scoring regularly at U18 and U23 level and got a few in the first team remember but injuries meant he was thrown in before he was really ready.
Don't think another season here would help us or him.6 -
I wouldn’t keep any of them.
I would rather see encouragement for our younger players than the types of loan we have had for the past couple of seasons.
Hard to think about much that loan players have added recently rather than make up the numbers.
0 - Sponsored links:
-
None of them.0
-
That's been true this season, due to an obvious change in policy, but I wouldn't say Millar, Maatsen, Stockley even Famewo and Shinnie just made up the numbers last season.seth plum said:I wouldn’t keep any of them.
I would rather see encouragement for our younger players than the types of loan we have had for the past couple of seasons.
Hard to think about much that loan players have added recently rather than make up the numbers.5 -
Prior to that the likes of Cullen and Bielik prove we can get useful players in. This season it has just not worked out.2
-
Akin for me . Certainly not Leko or Lee1
-
None except maybe Famewo if a free / small transfer fee. Too inclined to pass it long and often misses the target.0
-
No.0
-
Agreed. Famewo could be a good addition to the squad if he doesn’t take up too much of our budget.HardyAddick said:None except maybe Famewo if a free / small transfer fee. Too inclined to pass it long and often misses the target.1 -
My hope is we'll build a strong squad of our own contracted players plus our U23s.
Then a few loans can be the cherry on the already baked cake.5 -
Famewo but only if it doesn't take too much out of our budget.1
-
No.
Not good enough for the money them or their club would demand.0 - Sponsored links:
-
No0
-
Was there an option to buy written into the loan deal?se9addick said:
Agreed. Famewo could be a good addition to the squad if he doesn’t take up too much of our budget.HardyAddick said:None except maybe Famewo if a free / small transfer fee. Too inclined to pass it long and often misses the target.0 -
Definitely Famewo. Possibly Lee because I'm not convinced by Fraser.0
-
Yeah we do have an option to buy him - Whether that is conditional on us getting promoted to the Championship though, as others suggested when it was announced, remains to be seen.HardyAddick said:
Was there an option to buy written into the loan deal?se9addick said:
Agreed. Famewo could be a good addition to the squad if he doesn’t take up too much of our budget.HardyAddick said:None except maybe Famewo if a free / small transfer fee. Too inclined to pass it long and often misses the target.
After two years with us though, I wouldnt be surprised if Akin wants to go on loan with a Championship club now - Or even attempt to force his way into the Norwich team, now they're back at that level.1 -
There was, I’m not sure how much it was. I wouldn’t spend much though as I would hope he’s just a squad player.HardyAddick said:
Was there an option to buy written into the loan deal?se9addick said:
Agreed. Famewo could be a good addition to the squad if he doesn’t take up too much of our budget.HardyAddick said:None except maybe Famewo if a free / small transfer fee. Too inclined to pass it long and often misses the target.1 -
Decent loan signings are out there and we've had a few very good ones - the likes of Cullen, Bielik, Gallagher and Dasilva to name four. We should have a decent handle on the ones at PL London clubs and those four all came from there but the ones we've been sent recently seem to have been part of some sort of bizarre agreement just to get them off their host club's books - Castillo and John have made two appearances between them - presumably because they have too many of that ilk and ability.
1 -
Famewo at a pinch.
At his best he can shine in this league and he is still young enough to develop consistency and improve his game.
None of the others.
Whatever loans we bring in this summer I hope will be of sufficient quality to improve the squad, not just make up the numbers4 -
No0
-
Castillo is the one that made most sense, on the face of it, when we first signed him. We didn't really have a natural left wing back. Out of contract in the summer, good age, pedigree etc etc.Addick Addict said:Decent loan signings are out there and we've had a few very good ones - the likes of Cullen, Bielik, Gallagher and Dasilva to name four. We should have a decent handle on the ones at PL London clubs and those four all came from there but the ones we've been sent recently seem to have been part of some sort of bizarre agreement just to get them off their host club's books - Castillo and John have made two appearances between them - presumably because they have too many of that ilk and ability.
Then the real reason we signed him came up.......2 -
Nope none of them for me0
