Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Summer Window 2026 - Rumours and Discussion

1414243444547»

Comments

  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 18,390
    Carter said:
    I hope we have put an offer to Oxford for Cameron Brannagan, always looked a class above whenever I've seen him. Good dead ball delivery, always involved and positive

    Can't say I know much about the foreign players 

    The kid from Palace who was playing for Wednesday looked ok but thats it, no better than Chambers an no worse 

    Cantwell at Blackburn is one of the best midfielders in this division but I think is above our pay scale but I'd love us to sign him 

    I might be guilty of bias on how good he looked when we played against him but Sorenson from Lincoln and now Huddersfield at right wing back or the kid who plays for Burton, always fit gets forward and hits a decent delivery 

    Mumba at Plymouth or wherever he is now has always impressed me but I imagine would be expensive cover for Edwards. He is fun to watch though and properly pins opposing players back 

    Charlie Savage is a class player but that may be that he is one of the players who is at the perfect level for his ability, decent player stays fit and affects games. 

    I'd be happy with any of the above but most are league 1 players and come with the usual question marks about stepping up apart from Cantwell who is really a premier league player 

    If Tottenham manage to stay up I'd be interested in Lankshear and Donley probably on loan as they have futures in the game at a high level 




    Don’t want to demolish your list specifically but always find them interesting and think they show how hard recruitment is. It’s hard for fans to keep on track of every player!

    Brannagan - Effectively a one club man, hard to tempt away and a risk (as seen with JRC)

    Adaramola - Decent player, Cawley said we’re interested but would he want to be back up?

    Cantwell - Stinking attitude, fell out with every manager he’s ever had. No way NJ goes near 

    Sorensen - Cracking player, probably has the attributes to step up

    Mumba - Moved to Huddersfield for 7 figures in Jan, 5 assists all season and poor defensive numbers 

    Savage - Coming off statistically the worst season of his career in a mid table L1 side

    Donley & Lankshear - Decent pick ups


    All of this is opinion of course but it all comes from things in the public record, Chapple and his recruitment team will have better stats, time to watch clips and in person as well as character references 
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 18,390
    Carter said:
    Bailey said:
    I think dipping back into division one for players comes with risk, possibly only Kelman and Carey could be given plus marks so far. That's not to say the any signings are risk free, they all are, but Charlton need quality that doesn't exist in that division, plenty of potential there, but the leap into Championship football hinders their progression. It's also become very difficult to blood youngsters, as it was in our premiership days, the league, as Nathan Jones stated is a 'monster' and we need players who are equipped to handle that. 
    Absolutely it does, its also in reality the pond we are fishing in. Besides that I don't know enough about fringe players in this division or the depth of premier league academies to make comment on them 


    NJ has said L1 isn’t the pond we’re fishing in, if that’s true or not is a different question!
  • The Red Robin
    The Red Robin Posts: 27,588
    fenaddick said:
    Carter said:
    Bailey said:
    I think dipping back into division one for players comes with risk, possibly only Kelman and Carey could be given plus marks so far. That's not to say the any signings are risk free, they all are, but Charlton need quality that doesn't exist in that division, plenty of potential there, but the leap into Championship football hinders their progression. It's also become very difficult to blood youngsters, as it was in our premiership days, the league, as Nathan Jones stated is a 'monster' and we need players who are equipped to handle that. 
    Absolutely it does, its also in reality the pond we are fishing in. Besides that I don't know enough about fringe players in this division or the depth of premier league academies to make comment on them 


    NJ has said L1 isn’t the pond we’re fishing in, if that’s true or not is a different question!
    I knew Jones liked a fish pun. 
  • Henry Irving
    Henry Irving Posts: 86,107
    fenaddick said:
    Carter said:
    Bailey said:
    I think dipping back into division one for players comes with risk, possibly only Kelman and Carey could be given plus marks so far. That's not to say the any signings are risk free, they all are, but Charlton need quality that doesn't exist in that division, plenty of potential there, but the leap into Championship football hinders their progression. It's also become very difficult to blood youngsters, as it was in our premiership days, the league, as Nathan Jones stated is a 'monster' and we need players who are equipped to handle that. 
    Absolutely it does, its also in reality the pond we are fishing in. Besides that I don't know enough about fringe players in this division or the depth of premier league academies to make comment on them 


    NJ has said L1 isn’t the pond we’re fishing in, if that’s true or not is a different question!
    I took it not to mean that we won't ever sign anyone from league 1, rather that it won't be our main source, as it was last year.
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 18,390
    fenaddick said:
    Carter said:
    Bailey said:
    I think dipping back into division one for players comes with risk, possibly only Kelman and Carey could be given plus marks so far. That's not to say the any signings are risk free, they all are, but Charlton need quality that doesn't exist in that division, plenty of potential there, but the leap into Championship football hinders their progression. It's also become very difficult to blood youngsters, as it was in our premiership days, the league, as Nathan Jones stated is a 'monster' and we need players who are equipped to handle that. 
    Absolutely it does, its also in reality the pond we are fishing in. Besides that I don't know enough about fringe players in this division or the depth of premier league academies to make comment on them 


    NJ has said L1 isn’t the pond we’re fishing in, if that’s true or not is a different question!
    I took it not to mean that we won't ever sign anyone from league 1, rather that it won't be our main source, as it was last year.
    Sure but that makes L1 signings the exception rather than the pond we’re fishing in as OP said 
  • thenewbie
    thenewbie Posts: 11,459
    If we do end up looking in league one I suspect it will be players who have fallen from the Championship or at the very least featured for teams at the top end rather than "prospects."
  • Bailey
    Bailey Posts: 3,835
    Carter said:
    Bailey said:
    I think dipping back into division one for players comes with risk, possibly only Kelman and Carey could be given plus marks so far. That's not to say the any signings are risk free, they all are, but Charlton need quality that doesn't exist in that division, plenty of potential there, but the leap into Championship football hinders their progression. It's also become very difficult to blood youngsters, as it was in our premiership days, the league, as Nathan Jones stated is a 'monster' and we need players who are equipped to handle that. 
    Absolutely it does, its also in reality the pond we are fishing in. Besides that I don't know enough about fringe players in this division or the depth of premier league academies to make comment on them 


    I think the signing of Collins Sichenje may offer some clues, Carter. If we were to look at Premiership fringe or youngsters, then in the first case, the wages would we be beyond us and in the second case players such as Chambers, probably do not improve us, not in the short term anyway. I refer to Sichenje because he was little known in this country and showed that, in the few games he appeared in, that he was an upgrade on Burke and allowed us to rotate Ramsay in that right side position. I think our net will be wider than people think and there may be some surprises in players arriving. For now lets see who is retained and the rumours can begin. 
  • ShootersHillGuru
    ShootersHillGuru Posts: 51,040
    Bailey said:
    Carter said:
    Bailey said:
    I think dipping back into division one for players comes with risk, possibly only Kelman and Carey could be given plus marks so far. That's not to say the any signings are risk free, they all are, but Charlton need quality that doesn't exist in that division, plenty of potential there, but the leap into Championship football hinders their progression. It's also become very difficult to blood youngsters, as it was in our premiership days, the league, as Nathan Jones stated is a 'monster' and we need players who are equipped to handle that. 
    Absolutely it does, its also in reality the pond we are fishing in. Besides that I don't know enough about fringe players in this division or the depth of premier league academies to make comment on them 


    I think the signing of Collins Sichenje may offer some clues, Carter. If we were to look at Premiership fringe or youngsters, then in the first case, the wages would we be beyond us and in the second case players such as Chambers, probably do not improve us, not in the short term anyway. I refer to Sichenje because he was little known in this country and showed that, in the few games he appeared in, that he was an upgrade on Burke and allowed us to rotate Ramsay in that right side position. I think our net will be wider than people think and there may be some surprises in players arriving. For now let’s see who is retained and the rumours can begin. 
    I’ve heard a Belgian and a Moroccan.
  • The Red Robin
    The Red Robin Posts: 27,588
    Bailey said:
    Carter said:
    Bailey said:
    I think dipping back into division one for players comes with risk, possibly only Kelman and Carey could be given plus marks so far. That's not to say the any signings are risk free, they all are, but Charlton need quality that doesn't exist in that division, plenty of potential there, but the leap into Championship football hinders their progression. It's also become very difficult to blood youngsters, as it was in our premiership days, the league, as Nathan Jones stated is a 'monster' and we need players who are equipped to handle that. 
    Absolutely it does, its also in reality the pond we are fishing in. Besides that I don't know enough about fringe players in this division or the depth of premier league academies to make comment on them 


    I think the signing of Collins Sichenje may offer some clues, Carter. If we were to look at Premiership fringe or youngsters, then in the first case, the wages would we be beyond us and in the second case players such as Chambers, probably do not improve us, not in the short term anyway. I refer to Sichenje because he was little known in this country and showed that, in the few games he appeared in, that he was an upgrade on Burke and allowed us to rotate Ramsay in that right side position. I think our net will be wider than people think and there may be some surprises in players arriving. For now let’s see who is retained and the rumours can begin. 
    I’ve heard a Belgian and a Moroccan.
    Masicat, never wrong. 
  • jose
    jose Posts: 1,239
    I have always liked that Bruno bloke at Manchester United.
    We have a team of billionaire owners, so they could make an offer.

  • Sponsored links:



  • guinnessaddick
    guinnessaddick Posts: 30,043
    edited 10:49AM
    CafcWest said:
    I really hope Ramsey goes and we keep Ramsay...
    I know which one was playing against the spanners this season.
  • NabySarr
    NabySarr Posts: 5,521

    We should be all over this. Believe he’s a Charlton fan? RWB is a key position we need strengthening and we should be able to compete with West Brom given their financial situation 
  • sam3110
    sam3110 Posts: 23,032
    Imray would be good, I'd look at Neufville again too, I mentioned him last summer as a stand out player for AFCW, he moved to Bradford and again has looked good, might be too much of a step but I reckon he'd be at least as impactful as Fevrier was in the end. 

    I'd be trying to raid Sheffield Wednesday and Oxford as much as possible, taking the best of them, poach a couple of free agents from sides higher up the championship, maybe a couple of premier league loanees and 3 or 4 foreign imports
  • thenewbie
    thenewbie Posts: 11,459
    sam3110 said:
    Imray would be good, I'd look at Neufville again too, I mentioned him last summer as a stand out player for AFCW, he moved to Bradford and again has looked good, might be too much of a step but I reckon he'd be at least as impactful as Fevrier was in the end. 

    I'd be trying to raid Sheffield Wednesday and Oxford as much as possible, taking the best of them, poach a couple of free agents from sides higher up the championship, maybe a couple of premier league loanees and 3 or 4 foreign imports
    I certainly wouldn't say "as much as possible", they have maybe one or two worth a look but these teams went down for a reason. Even given the broader circumstances, surely they'd be mostly "Championship survival" level rather than pushing on as we want to.
    There probably are the Oxford/Wednesday equivalents to L Jones who actually are Championship standard but for the most part they have failed at this level.


  • sam3110
    sam3110 Posts: 23,032
    thenewbie said:
    sam3110 said:
    Imray would be good, I'd look at Neufville again too, I mentioned him last summer as a stand out player for AFCW, he moved to Bradford and again has looked good, might be too much of a step but I reckon he'd be at least as impactful as Fevrier was in the end. 

    I'd be trying to raid Sheffield Wednesday and Oxford as much as possible, taking the best of them, poach a couple of free agents from sides higher up the championship, maybe a couple of premier league loanees and 3 or 4 foreign imports
    I certainly wouldn't say "as much as possible", they have maybe one or two worth a look but these teams went down for a reason. Even given the broader circumstances, surely they'd be mostly "Championship survival" level rather than pushing on as we want to.
    There probably are the Oxford/Wednesday equivalents to L Jones who actually are Championship standard but for the most part they have failed at this level.


    Sheffield Wednesday went down because half their squad were kids and they had no rotation available, in addition to the points deduction. They'll still have 3 or 4 players that will improve us, likewise Oxford. 

    I'm not saying sign 7 players from each, but I wouldn't be averse to signing a couple from both, especially if we're targeting 10+ signings
  • ShootersHillGuru
    ShootersHillGuru Posts: 51,040
    I’d prefer to steer clear of signings from both Sheffield Wednesday and Oxford if I’m honest. I’m hoping we can aim higher and do better.
  • FishCostaFortune
    FishCostaFortune Posts: 11,164
    Bailey said:
    Carter said:
    Bailey said:
    I think dipping back into division one for players comes with risk, possibly only Kelman and Carey could be given plus marks so far. That's not to say the any signings are risk free, they all are, but Charlton need quality that doesn't exist in that division, plenty of potential there, but the leap into Championship football hinders their progression. It's also become very difficult to blood youngsters, as it was in our premiership days, the league, as Nathan Jones stated is a 'monster' and we need players who are equipped to handle that. 
    Absolutely it does, its also in reality the pond we are fishing in. Besides that I don't know enough about fringe players in this division or the depth of premier league academies to make comment on them 


    I think the signing of Collins Sichenje may offer some clues, Carter. If we were to look at Premiership fringe or youngsters, then in the first case, the wages would we be beyond us and in the second case players such as Chambers, probably do not improve us, not in the short term anyway. I refer to Sichenje because he was little known in this country and showed that, in the few games he appeared in, that he was an upgrade on Burke and allowed us to rotate Ramsay in that right side position. I think our net will be wider than people think and there may be some surprises in players arriving. For now lets see who is retained and the rumours can begin. 
    Although he didn’t really pull up any trees I think Chambers did improve us in the short term - and was the exact sort of signing we needed at the time.

    Hes not the sort of signing we need moving forwards though. 
  • NabySarr
    NabySarr Posts: 5,521
    Bailey said:
    Carter said:
    Bailey said:
    I think dipping back into division one for players comes with risk, possibly only Kelman and Carey could be given plus marks so far. That's not to say the any signings are risk free, they all are, but Charlton need quality that doesn't exist in that division, plenty of potential there, but the leap into Championship football hinders their progression. It's also become very difficult to blood youngsters, as it was in our premiership days, the league, as Nathan Jones stated is a 'monster' and we need players who are equipped to handle that. 
    Absolutely it does, its also in reality the pond we are fishing in. Besides that I don't know enough about fringe players in this division or the depth of premier league academies to make comment on them 


    I think the signing of Collins Sichenje may offer some clues, Carter. If we were to look at Premiership fringe or youngsters, then in the first case, the wages would we be beyond us and in the second case players such as Chambers, probably do not improve us, not in the short term anyway. I refer to Sichenje because he was little known in this country and showed that, in the few games he appeared in, that he was an upgrade on Burke and allowed us to rotate Ramsay in that right side position. I think our net will be wider than people think and there may be some surprises in players arriving. For now lets see who is retained and the rumours can begin. 
    Although he didn’t really pull up any trees I think Chambers did improve us in the short term - and was the exact sort of signing we needed at the time.

    Hes not the sort of signing we need moving forwards though. 
    It was a loan that worked very well for both parties. We had no left wing back, Chambers filled the gap and improved us in the short term. Chambers needed to play games to prove he can stay fit and play at championship level, he proved that 

    He’s not a Nathan Jones wing back though, so it’s not one for the long term for us. I think he will do well for a championship team that plays more football than we do and plays a back 4 
  • Holdkneebomb
    Holdkneebomb Posts: 1,298
    Assuming all those with contracts running down, re-sign, I believe we have a better chance of improving the squad if we go 4-1-3-2 or 4-1-2-3

    Mannion
    Ramsay/Sichenze/Asiimwe
    Jones
    Graham/Bell
    Edwards
    Apter/Fev
    De Keersmaeke
    JRC/New
    Campbell
    Kelman
    Leaburn/Jatta/New/Kanu

    Perhaps four signings, one on a free, one cheap.

    As our current set-up:-

    Mannion
    Ramsay/Sichenze/ Asiimwe
    Jones
    Graham/Bell/Edwards
    New/Fukuda
    New
    New
    New
    New
    Kelman
    Leaburn/Jatta/New/Kanu

    To replace the five with decent quality will be expensive.  I hope Anderson will play a part. Tangerines love him.

    Any money spent must be starters. Obviously Graham,  De Keersmaeker and Jatta are suggestions. Id also add Iorpenda as a squad addition.

    Perhaps go with a four until we are established, then go back to Nathans five.


    We definitely won't be going for players at L2 last year in Iorpenda (L1 huddersfield didnt want him) or Jatta
    I'm not sure how you watched Anderson earlier this year and think he's suddenly the solution
    Jones is never going to suddenly switch formation as a Plan A considering all his success is with a 352.
    Really don’t get the negativity around Anderson. Home grown, still only 21 and improving, has had an excellent loan at Blackpool helping turn them from relegation candidates to one of the most in form sides in the division, really hope Jones finds a place in the squad for him
  • Chunes
    Chunes Posts: 18,329
    Assuming all those with contracts running down, re-sign, I believe we have a better chance of improving the squad if we go 4-1-3-2 or 4-1-2-3

    Mannion
    Ramsay/Sichenze/Asiimwe
    Jones
    Graham/Bell
    Edwards
    Apter/Fev
    De Keersmaeke
    JRC/New
    Campbell
    Kelman
    Leaburn/Jatta/New/Kanu

    Perhaps four signings, one on a free, one cheap.

    As our current set-up:-

    Mannion
    Ramsay/Sichenze/ Asiimwe
    Jones
    Graham/Bell/Edwards
    New/Fukuda
    New
    New
    New
    New
    Kelman
    Leaburn/Jatta/New/Kanu

    To replace the five with decent quality will be expensive.  I hope Anderson will play a part. Tangerines love him.

    Any money spent must be starters. Obviously Graham,  De Keersmaeker and Jatta are suggestions. Id also add Iorpenda as a squad addition.

    Perhaps go with a four until we are established, then go back to Nathans five.


    We definitely won't be going for players at L2 last year in Iorpenda (L1 huddersfield didnt want him) or Jatta
    I'm not sure how you watched Anderson earlier this year and think he's suddenly the solution
    Jones is never going to suddenly switch formation as a Plan A considering all his success is with a 352.
    Really don’t get the negativity around Anderson. Home grown, still only 21 and improving, has had an excellent loan at Blackpool helping turn them from relegation candidates to one of the most in form sides in the division, really hope Jones finds a place in the squad for him

    I think it's because he's another battling midfielder who isn't going to help us progress the ball. 

  • Sponsored links:



  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 18,390
    edited 12:23PM
    Chunes said:
    Assuming all those with contracts running down, re-sign, I believe we have a better chance of improving the squad if we go 4-1-3-2 or 4-1-2-3

    Mannion
    Ramsay/Sichenze/Asiimwe
    Jones
    Graham/Bell
    Edwards
    Apter/Fev
    De Keersmaeke
    JRC/New
    Campbell
    Kelman
    Leaburn/Jatta/New/Kanu

    Perhaps four signings, one on a free, one cheap.

    As our current set-up:-

    Mannion
    Ramsay/Sichenze/ Asiimwe
    Jones
    Graham/Bell/Edwards
    New/Fukuda
    New
    New
    New
    New
    Kelman
    Leaburn/Jatta/New/Kanu

    To replace the five with decent quality will be expensive.  I hope Anderson will play a part. Tangerines love him.

    Any money spent must be starters. Obviously Graham,  De Keersmaeker and Jatta are suggestions. Id also add Iorpenda as a squad addition.

    Perhaps go with a four until we are established, then go back to Nathans five.


    We definitely won't be going for players at L2 last year in Iorpenda (L1 huddersfield didnt want him) or Jatta
    I'm not sure how you watched Anderson earlier this year and think he's suddenly the solution
    Jones is never going to suddenly switch formation as a Plan A considering all his success is with a 352.
    Really don’t get the negativity around Anderson. Home grown, still only 21 and improving, has had an excellent loan at Blackpool helping turn them from relegation candidates to one of the most in form sides in the division, really hope Jones finds a place in the squad for him

    I think it's because he's another battling midfielder who isn't going to help us progress the ball. 
    Which is true but we've seen in the last few weeks how useful they can be. He also would be great at the top of a box midfield if he had players around him once he won the ball. He was great up there with Allan Campbell against Birmingham in L1 because he pressed the back line like a machine 
  • NabySarr
    NabySarr Posts: 5,521
    edited 12:39PM
    I think there’s a clear succession plan for Anderson. Games like Saturday show that sometimes you need someone to win the ball back and we missed Docherty there on Saturday. 

    Docherty has 1 year left on his contract and can play that role as a squad player next season. Anderson does a full year in league 1 playing every week, hopefully developing on the ball. Then next summer we say thank you and goodbye to Docherty with Anderson becoming our new battling midfielder. He’s never played a full season as a first team footballer so a full year in league 1 will bring him on loads 
  • wolfgang
    wolfgang Posts: 734
    Scoham said:


    Leicester paid around £1m for Vardy from the same league and that was in 2012.
    And where did it get them? : League One
  • Steven81
    Steven81 Posts: 1,336
    wolfgang said:
    Scoham said:


    Leicester paid around £1m for Vardy from the same league and that was in 2012.
    And where did it get them? : League One
    Vardy helped them win the premiership what has he got to do with them being relegated when he never played for them this season.
  • Henry Irving
    Henry Irving Posts: 86,107
    Steven81 said:
    wolfgang said:
    Scoham said:


    Leicester paid around £1m for Vardy from the same league and that was in 2012.
    And where did it get them? : League One
    Vardy helped them win the premiership what has he got to do with them being relegated when he never played for them this season.
    If you look up you'll see the joke going over your head
  • Steven81
    Steven81 Posts: 1,336
    Steven81 said:
    wolfgang said:
    Scoham said:


    Leicester paid around £1m for Vardy from the same league and that was in 2012.
    And where did it get them? : League One
    Vardy helped them win the premiership what has he got to do with them being relegated when he never played for them this season.
    If you look up you'll see the joke going over your head
    So it seems fair enough.
  • Sword65pf
    Sword65pf Posts: 1,735
    MarcusH26 said:
    Coventry are prepared to break their transfer record to sign Sorba Thomas from Stoke City … sort of winger we need.
    Sorba Thomas who we could have signed from Boreham Wood if we'd managed to agree a fee. 

    We've got to go and find the next Sorba Thomas from Non League because we sure as hell haven't got the budget for ready-made championship wingers with his kind of production. 
    They wanted 500,000 for him no way was we going to pay that for a non league player 

    How the hell do you know what we are prepared or can spend on any player, like all of us if you were honest you don’t have a fucking clue, pure guesswork at best. The club will spend what they can and what they see fit.
  • Brownie12
    Brownie12 Posts: 1,639
    Sword65pf said:
    MarcusH26 said:
    Coventry are prepared to break their transfer record to sign Sorba Thomas from Stoke City … sort of winger we need.
    Sorba Thomas who we could have signed from Boreham Wood if we'd managed to agree a fee. 

    We've got to go and find the next Sorba Thomas from Non League because we sure as hell haven't got the budget for ready-made championship wingers with his kind of production. 
    They wanted 500,000 for him no way was we going to pay that for a non league player 

    How the hell do you know what we are prepared or can spend on any player, like all of us if you were honest you don’t have a fucking clue, pure guesswork at best. The club will spend what they can and what they see fit.
    I believe he read it in the Plymouth Herald.
  • CafcSteve
    CafcSteve Posts: 1,067
    Sword65pf said:
    MarcusH26 said:
    Coventry are prepared to break their transfer record to sign Sorba Thomas from Stoke City … sort of winger we need.
    Sorba Thomas who we could have signed from Boreham Wood if we'd managed to agree a fee. 

    We've got to go and find the next Sorba Thomas from Non League because we sure as hell haven't got the budget for ready-made championship wingers with his kind of production. 
    They wanted 500,000 for him no way was we going to pay that for a non league player 

    How the hell do you know what we are prepared or can spend on any player, like all of us if you were honest you don’t have a fucking clue, pure guesswork at best. The club will spend what they can and what they see fit.
    I believe that his solicitor relative told him when helping with the takeover by The Aussies.