Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
+++ Omonia Nicosia complete Thomas Kaminski loan signing (p34) +++
Comments
-
Very likely to be announced early next week, most likely be going out on loan2
-
“My understanding is.. “Radostanradical said:
Which phrase ?wmcf123 said:
That phrase . You’ve either heard it or you’ve made it up, but it doesn’t need a lot of understanding .Radostanradical said:
My understanding is that TK hasnt thrown his toys out of the pram and is prepared to play if called uponBedsaddick said:
I take it Doc hasn’t thrown his toys out the pram like TK ? . He doesn’t seem the type.Radostanradical said:So I cant give full details but NJ and Kaminski had a falling out last season which im sure everyone remembers and he was dropped for Mannion then WM had a bit of a mare and Jones was forced to recall TK. Its a case of forgiven but not forgotten, NJ does not want TK at the club and TK is happy to leave as long as he doesnt lose money.
Edit -
I wouldnt be suprised if we see something similar with Doc0 -
A serious question to all of Kaminski's fans.
Who wishes he was still our 1st choice?2 -
Covered End said:A serious question to all of Kaminski's fans.
Who wishes he was still our 1st choice?
Could just as easily say:
A serious question to all of Mannion's fans.
Who wishes he was still our 1st choice?
I for one am glad it's Okonkwo and not either of them.14 -
People can still be a fan of Kaminski while agreeing Okonkwo makes us a better team.Covered End said:A serious question to all of Kaminski's fans.
Who wishes he was still our 1st choice?9 -
If it was him or Mannion I'd pick Kaminski still, no question. Luckily, that's not the choice we have to make.Covered End said:A serious question to all of Kaminski's fans.
Who wishes he was still our 1st choice?5 -
stoneroses19 said:
People can still be a fan of Kaminski while agreeing Okonkwo makes us a better team.Covered End said:A serious question to all of Kaminski's fans.
Who wishes he was still our 1st choice?
He's only played one game, hopefully he'll be what we are after. Only time will tell.
2 -
Yeah it's exactly this for me. I don't know that I'm a Kaminski fan as much as I think some of the stick he got was over the top. I think he's a better option than Mannion. But I think/hope Okonkwo will be a better option than either of them. And even though he's only a loan and out of contract in the summer, at 24 Okonkwo has a lot of years to improve before he hits his peak as a keeper, whereas I think Mannion and TK are what they are.thenewbie said:
If it was him or Mannion I'd pick Kaminski still, no question. Luckily, that's not the choice we have to make.Covered End said:A serious question to all of Kaminski's fans.
Who wishes he was still our 1st choice?4 -
Terrible keeper, up there with MacGillivray. Be pleased to never have to see him in a Charlton shirt again.12
-
superclive98 said:Terrible keeper, up there with MacGillivray. Be pleased to never have to see him in a Charlton shirt again.
The memories, thanks for that... 🤣5 -
Sponsored links:
-
Just shows how far we've come recently.fenlandaddick said:superclive98 said:Terrible keeper, up there with MacGillivray. Be pleased to never have to see him in a Charlton shirt again.
The memories, thanks for that... 🤣
God I've missed the Championship, it's a great league.3 -
CaptainRobbo said:
Just shows how far we've come recently.fenlandaddick said:superclive98 said:Terrible keeper, up there with MacGillivray. Be pleased to never have to see him in a Charlton shirt again.
The memories, thanks for that... 🤣
God I've missed the Championship, it's a great league.
And long may it continue. Feels great. I'm sure we will have a dip at some point this season, but NJ knows his apples.3 -
Please don't mention Apples.fenlandaddick said:CaptainRobbo said:
Just shows how far we've come recently.fenlandaddick said:superclive98 said:Terrible keeper, up there with MacGillivray. Be pleased to never have to see him in a Charlton shirt again.
The memories, thanks for that... 🤣
God I've missed the Championship, it's a great league.
And long may it continue. Feels great. I'm sure we will have a dip at some point this season, but NJ knows his apples.11 -
I’m more than happy to see him walk this season but Macgillvray was another level of horror. Kaminski has been bang average personally think his reputation and wages have made him seem worse than he actually is.superclive98 said:Terrible keeper, up there with MacGillivray. Be pleased to never have to see him in a Charlton shirt again.Isted and Macgillvray were lucky to even make it professionally4 -
CaptainRobbo said:
Please don't mention Apples.fenlandaddick said:CaptainRobbo said:
Just shows how far we've come recently.fenlandaddick said:superclive98 said:Terrible keeper, up there with MacGillivray. Be pleased to never have to see him in a Charlton shirt again.
The memories, thanks for that... 🤣
God I've missed the Championship, it's a great league.
And long may it continue. Feels great. I'm sure we will have a dip at some point this season, but NJ knows his apples.
How far have we come. I honestly cannot believe it... we must stay behind our club and our team. There is something special going on...4 -
Crispywood said:
I’m more than happy to see him walk this season but Macgillvray was another level of horror. Kaminski has been bang average personally think his reputation and wages have made him seem worse than he actually is.superclive98 said:Terrible keeper, up there with MacGillivray. Be pleased to never have to see him in a Charlton shirt again.Isted and Macgillvray were lucky to even make it professionally
If I'm not mistaken MacGillvray was POTY for Portsmouth the previous season to us signing him. On paper it looked a reasonable signing.
9 -
MacGilvray was a decent shot stopper.ElfsborgAddick said:Crispywood said:
I’m more than happy to see him walk this season but Macgillvray was another level of horror. Kaminski has been bang average personally think his reputation and wages have made him seem worse than he actually is.superclive98 said:Terrible keeper, up there with MacGillivray. Be pleased to never have to see him in a Charlton shirt again.Isted and Macgillvray were lucky to even make it professionally
If I'm not mistaken MacGillvray was POTY for Portsmouth the previous season to us signing him. On paper it looked a reasonable signing.
But flapped at crosses, indecisive and never seemed to command his area.
However, POTY at Pompey ....what was the difference?
Perhaps the Pompey defence were disciplined to cover his deficiencies?
Mind you, Pompey still allowed him to leave despite being their POTY.
0 -
Christian Daily was our POTY.......ElfsborgAddick said:Crispywood said:
I’m more than happy to see him walk this season but Macgillvray was another level of horror. Kaminski has been bang average personally think his reputation and wages have made him seem worse than he actually is.superclive98 said:Terrible keeper, up there with MacGillivray. Be pleased to never have to see him in a Charlton shirt again.Isted and Macgillvray were lucky to even make it professionally
If I'm not mistaken MacGillvray was POTY for Portsmouth the previous season to us signing him. On paper it looked a reasonable signing.0 -
Clean shorts Holland won it for being a good guy. I don’t think he passed it forwards once all season and he was way past his best .Radostanradical said:
Christian Daily was our POTY.......ElfsborgAddick said:Crispywood said:
I’m more than happy to see him walk this season but Macgillvray was another level of horror. Kaminski has been bang average personally think his reputation and wages have made him seem worse than he actually is.superclive98 said:Terrible keeper, up there with MacGillivray. Be pleased to never have to see him in a Charlton shirt again.Isted and Macgillvray were lucky to even make it professionally
If I'm not mistaken MacGillvray was POTY for Portsmouth the previous season to us signing him. On paper it looked a reasonable signing.5 -
This could be TK you're describingOggy Red said:
MacGilvray was a decent shot stopper.ElfsborgAddick said:Crispywood said:
I’m more than happy to see him walk this season but Macgillvray was another level of horror. Kaminski has been bang average personally think his reputation and wages have made him seem worse than he actually is.superclive98 said:Terrible keeper, up there with MacGillivray. Be pleased to never have to see him in a Charlton shirt again.Isted and Macgillvray were lucky to even make it professionally
If I'm not mistaken MacGillvray was POTY for Portsmouth the previous season to us signing him. On paper it looked a reasonable signing.
But flapped at crosses, indecisive and never seemed to command his area.
However, POTY at Pompey ....what was the difference?
Perhaps the Pompey defence were disciplined to cover his deficiencies?
Mind you, Pompey still allowed him to leave despite being their POTY.0 -
Sponsored links:
-
You sound like you really didn't understand Holland's role in the team - or why all his managers picked him for every game?wmcf123 said:
Clean shorts Holland won it for being a good guy. I don’t think he passed it forwards once all season and he was way past his best .Radostanradical said:
Christian Daily was our POTY.......ElfsborgAddick said:Crispywood said:
I’m more than happy to see him walk this season but Macgillvray was another level of horror. Kaminski has been bang average personally think his reputation and wages have made him seem worse than he actually is.superclive98 said:Terrible keeper, up there with MacGillivray. Be pleased to never have to see him in a Charlton shirt again.Isted and Macgillvray were lucky to even make it professionally
If I'm not mistaken MacGillvray was POTY for Portsmouth the previous season to us signing him. On paper it looked a reasonable signing.
12 -
Holland couldn't tackle, couldn't pick a pass, didn't have a captain's mentality. He was fine alongside someone like Parker, but he definitely contributed to our relegation. Holland and Hughes as a central midfield were toothless/simply not good enough (although Hughes did chip in with the odd goal).Oggy Red said:
You sound like you really didn't understand Holland's role in the team - or why all his managers picked him for every game?wmcf123 said:
Clean shorts Holland won it for being a good guy. I don’t think he passed it forwards once all season and he was way past his best .Radostanradical said:
Christian Daily was our POTY.......ElfsborgAddick said:Crispywood said:
I’m more than happy to see him walk this season but Macgillvray was another level of horror. Kaminski has been bang average personally think his reputation and wages have made him seem worse than he actually is.superclive98 said:Terrible keeper, up there with MacGillivray. Be pleased to never have to see him in a Charlton shirt again.Isted and Macgillvray were lucky to even make it professionally
If I'm not mistaken MacGillvray was POTY for Portsmouth the previous season to us signing him. On paper it looked a reasonable signing.
Fault of the board though for not replacing Parker.2 -
I understood it when Curbs picked him narrow on the right .Oggy Red said:
You sound like you really didn't understand Holland's role in the team - or why all his managers picked him for every game?wmcf123 said:
Clean shorts Holland won it for being a good guy. I don’t think he passed it forwards once all season and he was way past his best .Radostanradical said:
Christian Daily was our POTY.......ElfsborgAddick said:Crispywood said:
I’m more than happy to see him walk this season but Macgillvray was another level of horror. Kaminski has been bang average personally think his reputation and wages have made him seem worse than he actually is.superclive98 said:Terrible keeper, up there with MacGillivray. Be pleased to never have to see him in a Charlton shirt again.Isted and Macgillvray were lucky to even make it professionally
If I'm not mistaken MacGillvray was POTY for Portsmouth the previous season to us signing him. On paper it looked a reasonable signing.0 -
I see Ramsdale is training with Soton U-21's now
mad to think less than 3 years ago was Arsenal's number 1 and in England squads0 -
Had to look back, he won player of the year in 07/08 but in his last season in 08/09 that was a fair assessment. He was part of the reason our midfield was so poor and we got relegated. He was so far past his best he retired that summer. He went from being a solid PL player to a weak link in the Championship, that wouldn’t have been the case if he was still up to it.Oggy Red said:
You sound like you really didn't understand Holland's role in the team - or why all his managers picked him for every game?wmcf123 said:
Clean shorts Holland won it for being a good guy. I don’t think he passed it forwards once all season and he was way past his best .Radostanradical said:
Christian Daily was our POTY.......ElfsborgAddick said:Crispywood said:
I’m more than happy to see him walk this season but Macgillvray was another level of horror. Kaminski has been bang average personally think his reputation and wages have made him seem worse than he actually is.superclive98 said:Terrible keeper, up there with MacGillivray. Be pleased to never have to see him in a Charlton shirt again.Isted and Macgillvray were lucky to even make it professionally
If I'm not mistaken MacGillvray was POTY for Portsmouth the previous season to us signing him. On paper it looked a reasonable signing.3 -
Yeah plus he's in our esteemed hall of fame, unlike Humphrey. What a jokeScoham said:
Had to look back, he won player of the year in 07/08 but in his last season in 08/09 that was a fair assessment. He was part of the reason our midfield was so poor and we got relegated. He was so far past his best he retired that summer. He went from being a solid PL player to a weak link in the Championship, that wouldn’t have been the case if he was still up to it.Oggy Red said:
You sound like you really didn't understand Holland's role in the team - or why all his managers picked him for every game?wmcf123 said:
Clean shorts Holland won it for being a good guy. I don’t think he passed it forwards once all season and he was way past his best .Radostanradical said:
Christian Daily was our POTY.......ElfsborgAddick said:Crispywood said:
I’m more than happy to see him walk this season but Macgillvray was another level of horror. Kaminski has been bang average personally think his reputation and wages have made him seem worse than he actually is.superclive98 said:Terrible keeper, up there with MacGillivray. Be pleased to never have to see him in a Charlton shirt again.Isted and Macgillvray were lucky to even make it professionally
If I'm not mistaken MacGillvray was POTY for Portsmouth the previous season to us signing him. On paper it looked a reasonable signing.3 -
He was the flasker's dream: a nice chap with clean shorts who claps the fans every week. Marvellous.Scoham said:
Had to look back, he won player of the year in 07/08 but in his last season in 08/09 that was a fair assessment. He was part of the reason our midfield was so poor and we got relegated. He was so far past his best he retired that summer. He went from being a solid PL player to a weak link in the Championship, that wouldn’t have been the case if he was still up to it.Oggy Red said:
You sound like you really didn't understand Holland's role in the team - or why all his managers picked him for every game?wmcf123 said:
Clean shorts Holland won it for being a good guy. I don’t think he passed it forwards once all season and he was way past his best .Radostanradical said:
Christian Daily was our POTY.......ElfsborgAddick said:Crispywood said:
I’m more than happy to see him walk this season but Macgillvray was another level of horror. Kaminski has been bang average personally think his reputation and wages have made him seem worse than he actually is.superclive98 said:Terrible keeper, up there with MacGillivray. Be pleased to never have to see him in a Charlton shirt again.Isted and Macgillvray were lucky to even make it professionally
If I'm not mistaken MacGillvray was POTY for Portsmouth the previous season to us signing him. On paper it looked a reasonable signing.
Not to say he was rubbish. He ran a lot, but he didn't offer much of anything. I really don't think Matty would be enjoying a Prem career in this day and age.4 -
Strange and inflammatory question which I will take the bait on. :-)Covered End said:A serious question to all of Kaminski's fans.
Who wishes he was still our 1st choice?
I think you’ll be hard pressed to find anyone who describes themselves as a “Kaminski fan”.
Put this way, I personally had hoped we upgraded from a League One 8/10 or Championship 6/10 in Mannion, to a Championship 8 or 9/10 in Kaminski.He turned out to a 6.5/10 and not worth what he was getting paid, but in a vacuum I’d still rather play the 6.5 than the 6.3 -
Signing for a Cypriot team according to Cawley0
-
Good riddancese9addick said:Signing for a Cypriot team according to Cawley5
