Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Stoke 4-0 Charlton (closes Sunday high tea time)

2»

Comments

  • newyorkaddick
    newyorkaddick Posts: 3,085

    ONONKWO: 5

    BELL: 5

    BINDON: 4

    JONES: 5

    MESIK: 6

    SKIPP: 3

    OUMA: 1

    CAMPBELL: 5

    J.R-C: 5

    GRANT: 5

    LEABURN: 4

    McNAMARA: 3

    COVENTRY: 4

    ALLI: 3

    MBICK: 4

    APTER: 3

    Referee: 4

  • RugbyAddick
    RugbyAddick Posts: 2,154

    ONONKWO: 6 not at fault for any of the goals

    BELL: 5 part of a defence that conceded 4

    BINDON: 5 as above 

    JONES: 5 as above 

    MESIK: 6 as above but a threat going forward and tried to create things 

    SKIPP: 5 not a great debut but it’s probably the first time he’s kicked a ball with this group 

    OUMA: 3.5 pen wasn’t a pen and the second came from a handball in the build up. However he gave the pen away and was at fault for the second. Passing not great. I still think he will improve 

    CAMPBELL: 6 dangerous first 15 mins

    J.R-C: 6 not awful. Not a ten

    GRANT: 6 out of the game 

    LEABURN: 7 battled hard. No protection from the ref. 

    McNAMARA: 5 should never have been in a position to get a yellow in the first place as we should have had a corner… but don’t give this fraud of a ref the chance to show you a second yellow 

    COVENTRY: 6 looked better when he came on 

    ALLI: 6 game lost by the time he came on

    MBICK: 6 as above

    APTER: 6 as above 

    Referee: 0.5 only because I can’t give a zero. Disgraceful. Needs his Bet365 account checking. 

  • ButtleJR
    ButtleJR Posts: 1,827
    ONONKWO: 6

    BELL:4 not a left back 

    BINDON: 5 

    JONES: 4 embarrassing example set by him today, should've been worried about us not the stoke fans and players. 

    MESIK: 6.5 Like him

    SKIPP: 6 hard to judge when next to Ouma but looked steady on the ball 

    OUMA: 2 not prepared to write him off just yet but awful today

    CAMPBELL: 5 

    J.R-C: 4 shit stamina

    GRANT: 5 frustrating 

    LEABURN:6 isolated but not his fault

    McNAMARA: 5 weird sending off 

    COVENTRY: 6 should've started, showed the gaps Ouma left

    ALLI: 5

    MBICK: 4 still not convinced by him

    APTER: 4
  • Covered End
    Covered End Posts: 53,256
    ONONKWO: 6

    BELL: 6

    BINDON: 5 1 mark off for being at fault for the 3rd goal.

    JONES: 6.5

    MESIK: 6.5

    SKIPP: 5.5

    OUMA: 2

    CAMPBELL: 6.5

    J.R-C: 5

    GRANT: 5

    LEABURN: 7

    McNAMARA: 4 Ref may have been harsh, but Mac's big mouth got him sent off & now he's out for Wednesday, the idiot.

    COVENTRY: 7

    ALLI: 6

    MBICK: 5

    APTER: 5

    Referee: 3


  • DennisBooth
    DennisBooth Posts: 337
    edited September 5
    Poor all round, let’s write it off as a bad day at the office. I have watched Mbick through most of the age groups and I don’t know what all the fuss is about. I have watched the youth teams for a very long time. I have seen Parker, Shelvey, Bowyer, Gomez, Lookman, Konsa and loads more. You could see their star quality straight away. I have seen nothing like that with Mbick. He has the physical attributes but I am not convinced. Yes he is young, yes he did well on loan. I know I will get pelters for this but if we get another bid of 5million rising to 7 I think we should take it.

  • redman
    redman Posts: 5,495

    ONONKWO: 6

    BELL: 6

    BINDON: 5.5

    JONES: 5.5

    MESIK: 6

    SKIPP: 5.5

    OUMA: 3

    CAMPBELL: 6

    J.R-C: 5.5

    GRANT: 5.5

    LEABURN: 6

    McNAMARA:

    COVENTRY: 6

    ALLI: 5.5

    MBICK:5.5

    APTER: 3

    Referee: 2

  • Crispywood
    Crispywood Posts: 2,891

    ONONKWO: 5

    BELL: 4

    BINDON: 4

    JONES: 6

    MESIK:  6

    SKIPP: 5

    OUMA: 2

    CAMPBELL: 6

    J.R-C: 4

    GRANT: 5

    LEABURN: 7

    McNAMARA: 4

    COVENTRY: 6

    ALLI: 6

    MBICK: 6

    APTER: 5

    Referee: 0.5

  • Yorkshire_Addick
    Yorkshire_Addick Posts: 5

    ONONKWO: 5

    BELL: 4.5

    BINDON: 4

    JONES: 5

    MESIK: 4.5

    SKIPP: 5

    OUMA: 3

    CAMPBELL: 4.5

    J.R-C: 4

    GRANT: 4

    LEABURN: 5

    McNAMARA: 3.5

    COVENTRY: 5

    ALLI: 4

    MBICK: 4

    APTER: 4

    Referee: 1

  • clive
    clive Posts: 20,791

    At the game

    ONONKWO: 6

    BELL: 6

    BINDON: 6

    JONES: 6

    MESIK: 6

    SKIPP: 5

    OUMA: 3

    CAMPBELL: 6

    J.R-C: 5

    GRANT: 6

    LEABURN: 6.5

    McNAMARA: 4.5

    COVENTRY: 6

    ALLI: 6

    MBICK: 6

    APTER: 6

    Referee: 4

  • Nicholas
    Nicholas Posts: 7,857

    ONONKWO: 5

    BELL: 5

    BINDON: 5

    JONES: 5

    MESIK: 6

    SKIPP: 6

    OUMA: 2

    CAMPBELL:4

    J.R-C: 5

    GRANT: 5

    LEABURN: 6

    McNAMARA: 4

    COVENTRY:5

    ALLI: 3

    MBICK: 5

    APTER: 4



  • Sponsored links:



  • Bangkokaddick
    Bangkokaddick Posts: 4,429
    edited September 5

    ONONKWO: 5.5

    BELL: 5

    BINDON: 4.5

    JONES: 5

    MESIK: 6

    SKIPP: 5.5

    OUMA: 3

    CAMPBELL:4

    J.R-C: 4.5

    GRANT: 5.5

    LEABURN: 6.5

    McNAMARA: 4

    COVENTRY: 5.5

    ALLI: 4

    MBICK: 4

    APTER: 3.5

    Referee: 2

  • Southbank
    Southbank Posts: 5,939
    DennisBooth said:
    Poor all round, let’s write it off as a bad day at the office. I have watched Mbick through most of the age groups and I don’t know what all the fuss is about. I have watched the youth teams for a very long time. I have seen Parker, Shelvey, Bowyer, Gomez, Lookman, Konsa and loads more. You could see their star quality straight away. I have seen nothing like that with Mbick. He has the physical attributes but I am not convinced. Yes he is young, yes he did well on loan. I know I will get pelters for this but if we get another bid of 5million rising to 7 I think we should take it.

    I am fairly sure you will eat these words in 6 months
  • Franky
    Franky Posts: 1
    lancashire lad said:

    0.5 to 10 if you please:

    ONONKWO: 6

    BELL 5:

    BINDON: 4

    JONES: 6

    MESIK: 7

    SKIPP 4:

    OUMA: 1

    CAMPBELL 5

    J.R-C 6

    GRANT 7

    LEABURN 7:

    McNAMARA 2

    COVENTRY 6

    ALLI 4

    MBICK:5

    APTER: 5

    Referee 1

    lancashire lad said:

    0.5 to 10 if you please:

    ONONKWO:

    BELL:

    BINDON:

    JONES:

    MESIK:

    SKIPP:

    OUMA:

    CAMPBELL:

    J.R-C:

    GRANT:

    LEABURN:

    McNAMARA:

    COVENTRY:

    ALLI:

    MBICK:

    APTER:

    Referee:


  • Eric_Dales
    Eric_Dales Posts: 444

    0.5 to 10 if you please:

    ONONKWO: 5

    BELL: 6

    BINDON: 5

    JONES: 6

    MESIK:7

    SKIPP: 6

    OUMA: 4

    CAMPBELL: 6

    J.R-C: 6

    GRANT: 6

    LEABURN: 7

    McNAMARA: 4

    COVENTRY: 6

    ALLI: 5

    MBICK: 5

    APTER: 5

    Referee: 1



  • CostaFortune
    CostaFortune Posts: 443
    RonnieMoore said:

     NJ should have pulled the players off 



  • No.1 in South London
    No.1 in South London Posts: 4,038

    ONONKWO: 6

    BELL: 5

    BINDON: 4

    JONES: 6

    MESIK: 6

    SKIPP: 5

    OUMA: 4

    CAMPBELL: 5

    J.R-C: 4

    GRANT: 6

    LEABURN: 6

    McNAMARA: 4

    COVENTRY: 7

    ALLI: 5

    MBICK: 6

    APTER: 4

  • Pavoren007
    Pavoren007 Posts: 2,684

    ONONKWO: 6

    BELL: 5

    BINDON: 5

    JONES: 6

    MESIK: 7

    SKIPP: 5

    OUMA: 3

    CAMPBELL: 5

    J.R-C: 5

    GRANT: 5

    LEABURN: 6

    McNAMARA: 4

    COVENTRY:6

    ALLI: 6

    MBICK: 5

    APTER: 4

    Referee: 2

  • Fumbluff
    Fumbluff Posts: 10,614

    ONONKWO: 3

    BELL: 2.5

    BINDON: 2.5

    JONES: 3

    MESIK: 3

    SKIPP: 3

    OUMA: 0.5

    CAMPBELL: 2

    J.R-C: 2.5

    GRANT: 2.5

    LEABURN: 3.5

    McNAMARA: 1

    COVENTRY: 3

    ALLI: 1.5

    MBICK: 2

    APTER: 1.5

    Referee: 0.5

  • fat man on a moped
    fat man on a moped Posts: 1,020

    ONONKWO: 6 some kicking poor

    BELL: 6

    BINDON: 5.5

    JONES: 6

    MESIK: 7 good signing

    SKIPP: 6 looks OK some good committed tackles 

    OUMA: 4 looked poor

    CAMPBELL: 6 looked a threat while he was on

    J.R-C: 5 not a starter but good as a sub

    GRANT: 6

    LEABURN: 7 never gave up

    McNAMARA: 4 game was already lost, didn't need to get involved

    COVENTRY: 6.5

    ALLI: 5.5

    MBICK: 5.5

    APTER: 5 seems to have no confidence

    Referee: 2 turned up and brought his whistle, hence score of 2. 

    Would like to end the wrestling at corners but this can't just be applied randomly

  • killerandflash
    killerandflash Posts: 73,264
    ONONKWO: 6
    BELL: 6
    BINDON: 5
    JONES: 6
    MESIK: 6
    SKIPP: 6
    OUMA: 4
    CAMPBELL: 6
    J.R-C: 5
    GRANT: 6
    LEABURN: 6.5
    McNAMARA: 4
    COVENTRY: 6
    ALLI: 5
    MBICK: 5.5
    APTER: 5
    Referee: 3

  • Sponsored links:



  • Properdartford
    Properdartford Posts: 13
    ONONKWO: 5
    BELL: 4 - got bullied
    BINDON: 5
    JONES: 5
    MESIK: 5
    SKIPP: 4 - looked a bit like Barry Bannon from where I was sitting, unfortunately that's where the comparison ends.
    OUMA: 2 needs time with the U21's
    CAMPBELL: 4
    J.R-C: 4 - good off the bench, but not a starter 
    GRANT: 4 - needs a rest or a different position 
    LEABURN: 4
    McNAMARA: 5 -Made a difference shame it was short lived
    COVENTRY: 6 - Much better when he came on
    ALLI: 4
    MBICK: 4
    APTER: 4
    Referee: 1
    Fans 10 
  • Blucher
    Blucher Posts: 4,416
    edited September 6

    ONONKWO: 6 - nothing he could do about the goals, although he looked hesitant to come for crosses

    BELL: 5 - looked a bit weary. Unfortunately, McNamara’s sending off means he’ll have to play the next 2 games, which puts him at risk of injury

    BINDON: 5 - generally ok but very poor defending for Stoke’s third goal

    JONES: 6 - ok. Survived a blatant assault from the Stoke centre-forward which the referee saw fit not to punish

    MESIK: 6 - did ok, although might have done better in preventing the cross for the third goal

    SKIPP: 5 - a few decent interceptions and passes but largely anonymous. In mitigation, he’s only just arrived at the club and was thrown into a chaotic midfield 

    OUMA: 3 - he needs more time to get up to speed. Naive for the penalty and really poor for the second goal. Unable to cope with the intensity and quality of Galbraith and Soumare

    CAMPBELL: 6 - a couple of promising early runs but withdrawn early as a precaution 

    J.R-C: 5 - unable to influence the game

    GRANT: 5 - no real impact

    LEABURN: 6.5 - isolated throughout but battled gamely with zero protection from the ref (much like the officials in all the previous games)

    McNAMARA: 4 - very silly to get involved after the foul on Leaburn, not least because the referee had already shown his willingness to brandish cards to our players

    COVENTRY: 6 - brought some order to the chaos, although Stoke throttled back in the second half (save for occasionally putting the boot or elbow into our players)

    ALLI: 6 - quite a strong player and did his best in what was a hopeless situation

    MBICK: 6 - would have liked to seen him on a bit earlier, given the licence the ref had given Stoke’s defenders to kick Leaburn

    APTER: 4 - he looks like a boy in a men’s game 

    Referee: 2 - a hugely irritating blend of arrogance , megalomania and sheer ineptitude. I have not the slightest doubt that he got into his car after the game, entirely satisfied that he had an excellent game.

  • Zulu
    Zulu Posts: 498
    ONONKWO: 5
    BELL: 4
    BINDON: 6
    JONES: 5
    MESIK: 6
    SKIPP: 5 
    OUMA: 2 
    CAMPBELL: 4
    J.R-C: 4 
    GRANT: 4  
    LEABURN: 5
    McNAMARA 5
    COVENTRY: 6 
    ALLI: 4
    MBICK: 4
    APTER: 3
  • rowandc123
    rowandc123 Posts: 30

    OKONKWO: 5

    BELL: 4.5

    BINDON: 4.5

    JONES: 4

    MESIK: 4

    SKIPP: 5

    OUMA: 3

    CAMPBELL: 6

    J.R-C: 4.5

    GRANT: 5

    LEABURN: 6

    McNAMARA: 4

    COVENTRY: 6

    ALLI: 6

    MBICK: 5.5

    APTER: 4.5

    Referee: 1

  • SaySomething
    SaySomething Posts: 2,650

    ONONKWO:6

    BELL: 6

    BINDON: 5

    JONES: 6

    MESIK: 7.5

    SKIPP: 5.5

    OUMA: 4 hopefully this guy adjusts to Championship football and is not George Weah’s cousin 2.0

    CAMPBELL6

    J.R-C: 4.5

    GRANT: 6

    LEABURN: 7

    McNAMARA: 5

    COVENTRY:6.5

    ALLI: 6

    MBICK: 6

    APTER: 5.5 not sure if he is a 1v1 type if he doesn’t try to go past players- probably lacking confidence 

    Referee:1 abysmal

Categories