Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

POST-MATCH THREAD: Charlton Athletic v Norwich City: Saturday 21st March 2026: KO 15:00

1…468910

Comments

  • Siv_in_Norfolk
    Siv_in_Norfolk Posts: 4,198
    Todds_right_hook said:
    Siv_in_Norfolk said:
    *The sun was in Mannion's eyes for the goal*

    This is something I've frequently thought and occasionally posted  - around the 2 equinoxes we should be kicking to Covered End 1st half when sunny. Seriously. It's a thing. 

    Look at him shading his eyes in the buildup and look at the length - and direction -of shadows on all players. He reacts late as the sun messed with him due to him looking right at it when the player shoots. 

    We need to be smarter about the choice of which way to kick and not always go for CE in 2nd half. 


    Why don’t keepers wear caps anymore. Thats a simple solution
    When the angle is low enough even a cap won't help. Avoid the issue by kicking the other way and give the oppo the problem 
  • Croydon
    Croydon Posts: 13,277
    fenaddick said:
    Croydon said:
    fenaddick said:
    king addick said:
    se9addick said:
    king addick said:
    JoshAddick said:
    The scapegoating of TC is an absolute disgrace. During ‘academy week’ aswell.

    Chants of ‘fucking useless’ and ‘he’s fucking shit’, whilst also getting booed when he wasn’t subbed, and jeered when he was subbed. It’s embarrassing.

    This is a lad who joined our academy at the age of 8 and has stayed with us throughout, massively contributing to our promotion last season. Give your head a wobble if you’re one of the ones giving him stick week in week out
    Mate come on....he was crap today. Walking back, looking non plussed apart from the last 15.

    He needs time out the team and then come on to make the difference and get some confidence.

    I don't join in with chants like that but he just wasnt good and hasn't been for a few games and it's okay to see that, it's not scapegoating 
    Are you joking? Once moved to his actual position he was our most effective attacking outlet, again. People can say what they like about TC, and they often do, but anyone that watches us every match can see that he’s about the only thing we have that relieves the pressure on our defence match in and match out. 

    If it wasn’t for TC we’d be in a much worse position than we are now. 
    No I'm not joking. He was terrible.

    There is something to be said about playing him in the right position which I have previously said but as a striker, he is poor.

    I am fed up of the outlet argument though. Having speed to get up the pitch but have no output is pointless. Dykes is a much more effective outlet when he holds up the ball.

    As for last statement, that's the joke. I think Carey, Jones would argue that point. As would 6 goal Kelman and Dykes, who has 2 goals and 3 assists in 13 games than Campbells 3 goals 2 assists in 39 games.
    He put in the cross for our best chance of the game, completed the most dribbles of anyone on the pitch, had the joint second most shots, created the joint second most chances, was only beaten on crosses for us by Carey (set pieces) and Clarke (lots of second balls from his throws) and won us countless corners. All while at times being surrounded by 3/4 yellow shirts

    Maybe you thought he was terrible but he was one of our most effective attacking players on the pitch and was a decent outlet. Maybe it’s time the players around him got on the end of his crosses and put them in the back of the net. 
    Not picking on TC, but this shows how meaningless some of these stats are. I think he had one shot which wasn't blocked by someone directly in front of him, and even that one hit a defender and never troubled the goal.
    He had 3 but my point was less about him really and more about the fact that no one else really got going either but aren’t getting criticised. Lyndon Dykes didn’t take a single shot all game for example 
    Agree with you, but my point wasn't about him at all it's about how pointless some stats are. 3 blocked shots with 2 of them blocked within 3 yards of the strike shouldn't be given as much weight as they are in stats imo. 
  • Henry Irving
    Henry Irving Posts: 85,924
    Best team won.

    Yes, we hit the bar and should have had a pen but for all our hard graft we weren't as good as Norwich.

    Take the loss, take the break, come back fresh and take the three points we need to stay up.
  • killerandflash
    killerandflash Posts: 71,400
    A strange game. Norwich were way better than us in the first half. A really poor display, considering they played on Wednesday, and we had the week off. 

    After the first change, bringing on Miles up front and shifting TC to the left, TC was transformed, and we looked dangerous. Frustrating that we didn't score, but we weren't given a clear penalty, plus chances keep falling to the wrong players. We finished with Dykes, Miles and Kelman up front, but none of them has a sniff of goal, whereas Clarke missed yet another good chance, JRC failed to deflect Carey's shot in (a tough chance but one a poacher like Kelman might have taken), and Ramsay hit the bar.

    Ridiculous that only 5 minutes was added on. Penalties can be a matter of interpretation, but that 5 minutes was simply wrong, when you consider the long injury break, subs and time wasting.

    Some slightly random subs today. I'm not sure anyone would have expected Fevrier to replace Coventry for example. Kelman and JRC coming on very late, and Coady having starred in the win at Boro hasn't featured at all in the next 2 games. 
  • KiwiValley
    KiwiValley Posts: 3,486
    I think a loss today was always the most likely outcome, which is why that 7 points last week was so important. I do understand that points at the end of the season are worth as many at the start of the season, but in a way, last week was probably the most important 7 points of the season. 
  • CharltonManor1966
    CharltonManor1966 Posts: 454
    PragueAddick said:
    valleynick66 said:
    cafc_se7 said:
    JoshAddick said:
    The scapegoating of TC is an absolute disgrace. During ‘academy week’ aswell.

    Chants of ‘fucking useless’ and ‘he’s fucking shit’, whilst also getting booed when he wasn’t subbed, and jeered when he was subbed. It’s embarrassing.

    This is a lad who joined our academy at the age of 8 and has stayed with us throughout, massively contributing to our promotion last season. Give your head a wobble if you’re one of the ones giving him stick week in week out
    Add to that his first full season at this level. I get the frustrations around areas of his game but the abuse is disgraceful! No wonder he doesn’t celebrate with the fans when he scores, I wouldn’t. 
    I can’t see this conclusion. 

    He simply doesn’t score enough (none of his team mates either)  to claim any sort of pattern to how he celebrates.

    FWIW I’d not be surprised if he’s had his head turned and he’s off in the summer. 
    “Having his head turned”. As in his agent being able to say, “look Tyreece you really dont need to take that shit from your own fans each week. Let me get you a move to a club in League 1 or 2 that wants to play you as a winger”. 

    ? 

    I hate agents, but could hardly blame this one for saying that to his client.

  • stjohnshill
    stjohnshill Posts: 80
    LoOkOuT said:
    Can Will Mannion stop shots??? It comes up time and time again despite the fact that he keeps pulling off great saves. Can we put this one to bed? He’s a very good keeper that controls his area and stops shots. No keeper’s perfect, but he’s been excellent and very much deserves his run in the side.
    Mannion is better at goal kicks and he comes and claims the ball well.

    TK is a better shot stopper and has a far greater ability at reading the game and playing out with his feet. Which we saw today Mannion struggle with, putting us in some sticky situations and wasting/ giving away possession. Personally think Mannion should have done better with their goal today. He gets a weak hand on it and the shot was not right in the corner. He also struggled last season from long range.

    TK hasn't help himself with some inconsistent performances, which he has admitted himself, but overall TK is a better GK. And most importantly that is the wide opinion within the Charlton camp too because they see them train every day. 

  • Alwaysneil
    Alwaysneil Posts: 14,250
    TK has very variable distribution with his feet imo, often struggles to get the ball over the half way line and frequently takes an age even when there is an out ball thereby ensuring there isnt.

    I do agree that Mannion should probably have saved the shot today though, should have anticipated the defenders not doing their job even though in most games they have been excellent.

    I personally do not believe TK is a better all round keeper than Mannion, his inability to command his area, to talk to his defence and that he dies not appear able to catch are larger issues than an occasional worldy save
  • Chunes
    Chunes Posts: 18,148
    Very generous scores for Dykes in the player marks thread. I like the guy but didn't think he offered anything today. 33% pass accuracy is outrageous.
  • Mortimerwasgod
    Mortimerwasgod Posts: 592
    All about midfield for me today. McClean looked like prime Pirlo but that was due to no pressure all game. Shame as when we actually passed it we looked decent but mostly long punts swallowed up. Onwards to Bristol City.

  • Sponsored links:



  • ParkinsonOut
    ParkinsonOut Posts: 1,560
    PWR

    I was working this afternoon so didn’t see the (illegal) stream or follow the updates here, so have no idea what the game was like. But the first thing that sprang to mind after I checked the result on the BBC app was - WTF did Jones wait until the 87th minute to bring Kelman on when we needed to score? 
  • MarcusH26
    MarcusH26 Posts: 9,429
    Was quite an interesting quote from NJ in his post match about us being outbid for a couple of the Norwich side in the summer. Wonder who we might have been after as a lot of their signings were from abroad bar Jacob Wright who came on and obviously Makama who's injured. 
  • Major
    Major Posts: 1,089
    edited March 22
    Oh well, can't win 'em all. We ain't going down.
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 17,200
    edited March 22
    MarcusH26 said:
    Was quite an interesting quote from NJ in his post match about us being outbid for a couple of the Norwich side in the summer. Wonder who we might have been after as a lot of their signings were from abroad bar Jacob Wright who came on and obviously Makama who's injured. 
    Sam Field in January was who I think he meant
  • swords_alive
    swords_alive Posts: 4,763
    BexhillAddick said:
    Fortune 82nd Minute said:
    BexhillAddick said:
    On train back to Newark feeling pretty despondent.
    Very poor first half and Norwich looked a class above. Can,t fault our effort and work rate but that will only get you so far in this league. We were better second half but always felt that they could step up a gear. Other thoughts:
    - that was a clear penalty 
    - their time wasting should have been punished, not least by adding at least 10mins
    - it was clear that TC and Dykes don't work together. Should have started Kelman
    - our defence is awesome and is the main reason we are in the position we are 
    - Mannion is our number 1
    - atmosphere was flat but I guess that's what happens when you concede so early with the knowledge that a draw is the best we can hope for.
    Despite what some people think I really don't think we are out of trouble yet. We need to to grind out at least one more win and a few draws to be safe.
    And I'm going to add to your despondency - you've got on the wrong train.

    The Newark train won't take you to Bexhill! :-)
    If I could change my username I would! Have lived in Worcester, Cornwall, Lincoln and Newark since we left Bexhill. And we are going to move again soon! Keep meaning to re register with a name that is not location specific! Meanwhile back to the post match comments....
    Why not just move back to Bexhill??
  • jimmymelrose
    jimmymelrose Posts: 10,061
    redbuttle said:
    JoshAddick said:
    The scapegoating of TC is an absolute disgrace. During ‘academy week’ aswell.

    Chants of ‘fucking useless’ and ‘he’s fucking shit’, whilst also getting booed when he wasn’t subbed, and jeered when he was subbed. It’s embarrassing.

    This is a lad who joined our academy at the age of 8 and has stayed with us throughout, massively contributing to our promotion last season. Give your head a wobble if you’re one of the ones giving him stick week in week out
    It really doesn't matter if he's from our academy if he isn't good enough is it.
    So if a player isn't good enough, you boo and sing insulting songs against him? 
    Why hadn't I thought of that as the solution? Oh hang on, explain first how that works.
  • Dave Rudd
    Dave Rudd Posts: 2,970
    edited March 22
    Are our match reports being written by AI?

    Addicks fall to narrow defeat against Norwich


    Charlton fell to a narrow defeat to Norwich City in SE7 on Saturday afternoon, despite a spirited second-half performance from Nathan Jones' men.

    Addicks fall to narrow defeat to Wrexham


    Charlton fell to a narrow defeat to play-off hopefuls Wrexham on Saturday, despite an encouraging showing at The Valley. 

    Addicks fall to narrow defeat against Derby


    The Addicks suffered a narrow 2–1 defeat to Derby County at The Valley on Tuesday evening in the Sky Bet Championship.



    I wonder who else we will fall to a narrow defeat against, despite blah, blah blah.


  • Callumcafc
    Callumcafc Posts: 65,809
    edited March 22
    PragueAddick said:
    Mendonca In Asdas said:
    RonnieMoore said:
    Been told that Steve Brown let rip about Campbell today why is it only NJ can’t see it 
    Er, he picks the team?
    Colin is talking out of his arse as usual. Brownie said there are aspects of his game he needs to work on, in order to get the best from his game; and then he qualified it by saying that he is a young player and that’s a perfectly normai situation. 
    Yeah he’s talking out of his back side. There was one moment where he pointed out his back tracking at a particular point (rather than in general) but otherwise was fairly complimentary as per usual.
  • wolfgang
    wolfgang Posts: 688
    Patronising Norwich TV commentator:
    ==After they had scored, talked about their upcoming fixtures than added "Mind you, Norwich haven't won this one yet". This was after 10 minutes play.
    ==In second half, "Charlton don't have much goal-threat on their bench. Just Leaburn and Kelman and they are both off-form." Then 30 seconds later, when camera shows Kelman, "Norwich will have to keep an eye on him, he's been in goal-scoring form lately."

  • Sponsored links:



  • Amos on the wing
    Amos on the wing Posts: 1,824
    edited March 22
    Lost to a better side especially in midfield who were quicker and technically better on the ball.  

    Can never question the work rate of our players we just lack the quality at this level to create or finish chances. 

    Charlie should have come on instead of Leaburn when the change was made and I would have made changes to the middle 3 much earlier in the 2nd half. 

    The usual piss poor performance from officials again. We will be ok and I think will pick up another 7-10 points by the end of the season (wins or draws against Bristol City, Preston, Sheffield Wednesday, Watford) .


  • MarcusH26
    MarcusH26 Posts: 9,429
    fenaddick said:
    MarcusH26 said:
    Was quite an interesting quote from NJ in his post match about us being outbid for a couple of the Norwich side in the summer. Wonder who we might have been after as a lot of their signings were from abroad bar Jacob Wright who came on and obviously Makama who's injured. 
    Sam Field in January was who I think he meant
    Oh yes of course that would be the obvious one!

    Although Makama would probably be a Nathan Jones dream striker. 
  • Steven81
    Steven81 Posts: 1,300
    edited March 22
    It's a bit damning tbh that a player so polarised in view was our most dangerous player yesterday,our midfield was a joke compared to theirs.
  • se9addick
    se9addick Posts: 32,585
    Steven81 said:
    It's a bit damning tbh that a player so polarised in view was our most dangerous player yesterday,our midfield was a joke compared to theirs.
    We have to get some creativity into the side in the summer. It’s a must. I’m pretty close to thinking we need to upgrades on all three of our starting midfield players. 
  • golfaddick
    golfaddick Posts: 35,333
    Callumcafc said:
    Fairly convinced that TC would look far more dangerous on a regular basis if there were other dangerous players the oppo had to occupy themselves with.

    So often he’s getting into those positions high and wide but he often can’t cut in and impact like he did in L1 because sides are cheating a midfielder over to that side to block up his dribbling lanes.

    Having a genuine right sided threat opposite him would stretch out the pitch and give the opposing side less opportunities to double / triple up on him.
    It's called playing with wingers. Ain't going to happen. 
  • ForeverAddickted
    ForeverAddickted Posts: 98,781
    edited March 22
    Callumcafc said:
    Fairly convinced that TC would look far more dangerous on a regular basis if there were other dangerous players the oppo had to occupy themselves with.

    So often he’s getting into those positions high and wide but he often can’t cut in and impact like he did in L1 because sides are cheating a midfielder over to that side to block up his dribbling lanes.

    Having a genuine right sided threat opposite him would stretch out the pitch and give the opposing side less opportunities to double / triple up on him.
    I think if you look back, the last time that it was felt that TC was being really effective, was around the Cambridge game last season, before Small got injured. 
    Been saying it a few times this season, how when that was an option, TC would be harder to double mark, because we'd switch the ball to the other, so we'd give the opposition something else to think about as we'd have pace on both flanks. 
    I guess Apter was the attempted answer to replicate that, but defensively couldn't manage... Whilst Fevrier is a good backup, but isn't the answer at this level... If we persist with TC (Which Jones will), then its something I'd like to see corrected in the summer. But then does that involve us going after someone that isnt Clarke or Bree. 
  • MarcusH26
    MarcusH26 Posts: 9,429
    se9addick said:
    Steven81 said:
    It's a bit damning tbh that a player so polarised in view was our most dangerous player yesterday,our midfield was a joke compared to theirs.
    We have to get some creativity into the side in the summer. It’s a must. I’m pretty close to thinking we need to upgrades on all three of our starting midfield players. 
    Absolutely it's got to be the main focus , get some creativity and some physicality into the midfield. I'm fine with Carey if he learns to actually pass and the jury is still out on Knibbs with his injury  but the other 2 slots would be up for grabs with me. Hopefully PC has been racking up the air miles looking for the right type of player that can drive us forward. 
  • ForeverAddickted
    ForeverAddickted Posts: 98,781
    edited March 22
    golfaddick said:
    Callumcafc said:
    Fairly convinced that TC would look far more dangerous on a regular basis if there were other dangerous players the oppo had to occupy themselves with.

    So often he’s getting into those positions high and wide but he often can’t cut in and impact like he did in L1 because sides are cheating a midfielder over to that side to block up his dribbling lanes.

    Having a genuine right sided threat opposite him would stretch out the pitch and give the opposing side less opportunities to double / triple up on him.
    It's called playing with wingers. Ain't going to happen. 
    Of course its not going to happen; Jones throughout his Managerial career has always been about Wing-Backs
    Its difficult to continue to argue against it this season as well, given how its been working
  • Simonsen
    Simonsen Posts: 5,637
    It's been a grim watch this season and yesterday was no exception. 

    The team deserve much credit for their willingness to defend well and try hard hard but on the ball, it's often hard to imagine we are watching Championship football. 

    The Campbell up front thing hasn't worked at all and Kelman must be massively frustrated that he doesn't get the nod. Campbell must also be frustrated that he is asked to do a job that he clearly can't do and is now perhaps showing signs that he doesn't really want to do. 

    It's a shame that a lot of our very few chances, seem to fall to Clarke. He's a decent player but he's missed every one so far. 

Categories

“Marketplace”