Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Options

No All male panels on BBC

2

Comments

  • Options
    Accepted.
  • Options
    Riviera said:

    PaddyP17 said:

    As long as these women have huge tits who cares?

    Poetic. Now head on back to the 1950s with toss like that.
    Good lord!

    What is wrong with everyone today?

    If Alan Davies had said that everyone would be marvelling at his wonderful ironic comedy.
    If it WAS ironic, my apologies. Sarcasm via text isn't exactly clear. If not - then I simply don't take kindly to casual misogyny.

    PaddyP17 said:

    As long as these women have huge tits who cares?

    Poetic. Now head on back to the 1950s with toss like that.
    Pure CL...

    ;0)
    Hah. Damned if you do, damned if you don't. You're bigoted - that's apparently okay; you call out bigotry - you're typical CL for calling it out.
  • Options
    edited February 2014
    To be fair SELR, I implied it. She doesn't make me laugh. Whilst there are other people who don't make me laugh, I can often see that they've got something even if it doesn't appeal to me. I haven't had that feeling about Miranda since she played the baby shop owner in Lead Balloon. I genuinely can't help but think that a lot of women like her because she's gawky and awkward - there's a sense that she has a wide level of support presicely because she doesn't come across as the stereotypical female tv personality.

    Where I differ from Huskaris is that no amount of positive discrimination would turn a black transgender lesbian me into a multi millionaire.
  • Options
    Huskaris said:

    I am all for women being included, but on merit. So often I watch a BBC comedy show and see people kind of laughing out of sympathy with so many female comedians.

    The only funny female comedian on TV is Katie Hopkins.

  • Options
    I agree in all aspects of life the key words are "on merit" this also applies to men.
  • Options
    Stig said:

    To be fair SELR, I implied it. She doesn't make me laugh. Whilst there are other people who don't make me laugh, I can often see that they've got something even if it does't appeal to me. I haven't had that feeling about Miranda since she played the baby shop owner in Lead Balloon. I genuinely can't help but think that a lot of women like her because she's gawky and awkward - there's a sense that she has a wide level of support presicely because she doesn't come across as the stereotypical female tv personality.

    Where I differ from Huskaris is that no amount of positive discrimination would turn a black transgender lesbian me into a multi millionaire.

    Honestly, I don't see the appeal myself. But there are many male comics I can't really stand either that have a huge amount of appeal towards a demographic i'm not in. For example Russell Howard with the teen audience.
  • Options
    edited February 2014

    Stig said:

    To be fair SELR, I implied it. She doesn't make me laugh. Whilst there are other people who don't make me laugh, I can often see that they've got something even if it does't appeal to me. I haven't had that feeling about Miranda since she played the baby shop owner in Lead Balloon. I genuinely can't help but think that a lot of women like her because she's gawky and awkward - there's a sense that she has a wide level of support presicely because she doesn't come across as the stereotypical female tv personality.

    Where I differ from Huskaris is that no amount of positive discrimination would turn a black transgender lesbian me into a multi millionaire.

    Honestly, I don't see the appeal myself. But there are many male comics I can't really stand either that have a huge amount of appeal towards a demographic i'm not in. For example Russell Howard with the teen audience.
    the bbc have stated that there must be a certain amount of comics that have bonk eyes as to not offend the people who suffer with the same problem
  • Options
    Stig said:

    Tio be fair SELR, I implied it. She doesn't make me laugh. Whilst there are other people who don't make me laugh, I can often see that they've got something even if it does't appeal to me. I haven't had that feeling about Miranda since she played the baby shop owner in Lead Balloon. I genuinely can't help but think that a lot of women like her because she's gawky and awkward - there's a sense that she has a wide level of support presicely because she doesn't come across as the stereotypical female tv personality.

    Where I differ from Huskaris is that no amount of positive discrimination would turn a black transgender lesbian me into a multi millionaire.

    This argument would never have happened if there were more female moderators........

  • Options
    Huskaris said:

    Huskaris said:

    Would prefer if they didn't release this kinda stuff publicly. Just put more women on panel shows without the fanfare of 'Look at how progressive we are!'

    It just makes the women seem like token panel members only there because they have to be, even if they're deserving.

    But most the time they are. Don't tell me you think people like Sarah Milican and Miranda Hart are there on merit...
    Miranda makes more money than most of the men, which is kinda the aim of a comedian.
    Ok she makes more money but that's because shes the benefactor of positive discrimination. I would be a multi millionaire comedian if I was a black transgender lesbian...
    She's the benefactor of positive discrimination? So she financially contributes to the very thing you're alleging she benefits from?

    If you're going to use words that you think highlight your specious arguments, at least use them in the correct context.
  • Options
    Imagine being on a show just because of your sex, what an insult to woman.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Options
    Wonder if itv will allow males to be part of the loose women panel.. Doubt it
  • Options
    Perhaps women like different comedians/ennes to men? Don't see what's wrong with giving women what they want, not my fault if some/most men don't know how to do it ;-)
  • Options
    Greenie said:

    Imagine being on a show just because of your sex, what an insult to woman.

    The implication of the statement is that there are plenty of female options for panel shows, hence "no excuse". Sure, he's never going to say "the quality of female comedy is not high enough" even if it's true. I watched a room full of women laugh maniacally watching Miranda, so I really wouldn't trust this site's demographic to get to the bottom of the debate!
  • Options
    Huskaris said:

    Huskaris said:

    Would prefer if they didn't release this kinda stuff publicly. Just put more women on panel shows without the fanfare of 'Look at how progressive we are!'

    It just makes the women seem like token panel members only there because they have to be, even if they're deserving.

    But most the time they are. Don't tell me you think people like Sarah Milican and Miranda Hart are there on merit...
    Miranda makes more money than most of the men, which is kinda the aim of a comedian.
    Ok she makes more money but that's because shes the benefactor of positive discrimination.
    I agree. She is about as funny as being at a loved ones funeral.
    I understand people have different senses of humour, but there is nothing funny about her, just cringey material.
  • Options

    Huskaris said:

    Huskaris said:

    Would prefer if they didn't release this kinda stuff publicly. Just put more women on panel shows without the fanfare of 'Look at how progressive we are!'

    It just makes the women seem like token panel members only there because they have to be, even if they're deserving.

    But most the time they are. Don't tell me you think people like Sarah Milican and Miranda Hart are there on merit...
    Miranda makes more money than most of the men, which is kinda the aim of a comedian.
    Ok she makes more money but that's because shes the benefactor of positive discrimination. I would be a multi millionaire comedian if I was a black transgender lesbian...
    She's the benefactor of positive discrimination? So she financially contributes to the very thing you're alleging she benefits from?

    If you're going to use words that you think highlight your specious arguments, at least use them in the correct context.
    Oops, my mistake! Been reading a lot of Roman stuff lately and clearly misinterpreted what a "benefactor" was!

    But I stand by my point. If Miranda Hart was a man she wouldn't have ever been heard of.
  • Options
    Problem with female comedians is they think they're moaning is funny. Why buy a ticket to hear a woman go on about about being fat/on her period/unattractive/not having kids when you can just listen to your missus for free
  • Options
    Huskaris said:

    Huskaris said:

    Would prefer if they didn't release this kinda stuff publicly. Just put more women on panel shows without the fanfare of 'Look at how progressive we are!'

    It just makes the women seem like token panel members only there because they have to be, even if they're deserving.

    But most the time they are. Don't tell me you think people like Sarah Milican and Miranda Hart are there on merit...
    Miranda makes more money than most of the men, which is kinda the aim of a comedian.
    Ok she makes more money but that's because shes the benefactor of positive discrimination. I would be a multi millionaire comedian if I was a black transgender lesbian...
    This is the first time I have ever been flagged. Clearly there are many people on here who have no sense of humour, presumably that goes hand in hand with being a Miranda fan, you just laugh because the tinned laughter says you should.
  • Options
    PaddyP17 said:

    As long as these women have huge tits who cares?

    Poetic. Now head on back to the 1950s with toss like that.
    Have a break mate.

    image
  • Options
    edited February 2014
    .
  • Options
    Huskaris said:

    Huskaris said:

    Huskaris said:

    Would prefer if they didn't release this kinda stuff publicly. Just put more women on panel shows without the fanfare of 'Look at how progressive we are!'

    It just makes the women seem like token panel members only there because they have to be, even if they're deserving.

    But most the time they are. Don't tell me you think people like Sarah Milican and Miranda Hart are there on merit...
    Miranda makes more money than most of the men, which is kinda the aim of a comedian.
    Ok she makes more money but that's because shes the benefactor of positive discrimination. I would be a multi millionaire comedian if I was a black transgender lesbian...
    This is the first time I have ever been flagged. Clearly there are many people on here who have no sense of humour, presumably that goes hand in hand with being a Miranda fan, you just laugh because the tinned laughter says you should.
    You got all of that from nothing more than a JPEG of a tiny flag? That's impressive.
  • Sponsored links:


  • Options
    Huskaris said:

    Huskaris said:

    Huskaris said:

    Would prefer if they didn't release this kinda stuff publicly. Just put more women on panel shows without the fanfare of 'Look at how progressive we are!'

    It just makes the women seem like token panel members only there because they have to be, even if they're deserving.

    But most the time they are. Don't tell me you think people like Sarah Milican and Miranda Hart are there on merit...
    Miranda makes more money than most of the men, which is kinda the aim of a comedian.
    Ok she makes more money but that's because shes the benefactor of positive discrimination. I would be a multi millionaire comedian if I was a black transgender lesbian...
    This is the first time I have ever been flagged. Clearly there are many people on here who have no sense of humour, presumably that goes hand in hand with being a Miranda fan, you just laugh because the tinned laughter says you should.
    Yeah, I've got no argument with that. She's about as funny as a bus timetable.
  • Options

    Huskaris said:

    Huskaris said:

    Huskaris said:

    Would prefer if they didn't release this kinda stuff publicly. Just put more women on panel shows without the fanfare of 'Look at how progressive we are!'

    It just makes the women seem like token panel members only there because they have to be, even if they're deserving.

    But most the time they are. Don't tell me you think people like Sarah Milican and Miranda Hart are there on merit...
    Miranda makes more money than most of the men, which is kinda the aim of a comedian.
    Ok she makes more money but that's because shes the benefactor of positive discrimination. I would be a multi millionaire comedian if I was a black transgender lesbian...
    This is the first time I have ever been flagged. Clearly there are many people on here who have no sense of humour, presumably that goes hand in hand with being a Miranda fan, you just laugh because the tinned laughter says you should.
    Yeah, I've got no argument with that. She's about as funny as a bus timetable.
    Thank God you steered clear of saying "rail timetable" there Leroy, which I'm guessing was a conscious choice on your part. Otherwise there would've been claret everywhere, and nobody likes spilling good claret, by Jove!
  • Options
    OK fellas, time for the Neanderthal chauvinists to rip Sandi Toksvig apart. I've got bored with the Miranda stuff............................
  • Options
    Surely the BBC would chase the ratings.
    So they should put the panel on that makes most people happy.
    Male, female, Emu, Mr Blobby whoever makes most people laugh.
    Why impose an artificial restriction?
    I just don't get it.
  • Options

    OK fellas, time for the Neanderthal chauvinists to rip Sandi Toksvig apart. I've got bored with the Miranda stuff............................

    This thread is no place for a Could'Ya

  • Options

    OK fellas, time for the Neanderthal chauvinists to rip Sandi Toksvig apart.

    I like her a lot.
  • Options
    does this include M O T Day ? .. and the FL show ?
  • Options

    Surely the BBC would chase the ratings.
    So they should put the panel on that makes most people happy.
    Male, female, Emu, Mr Blobby whoever makes most people laugh.
    Why impose an artificial restriction?
    I just don't get it.

    Restriction? Women are 50% of the population. Maybe they're chasing ratings by encouraging them to watch.
  • Options
    51% actually.
  • Options

    Surely the BBC would chase the ratings.
    So they should put the panel on that makes most people happy.
    Male, female, Emu, Mr Blobby whoever makes most people laugh.
    Why impose an artificial restriction?
    I just don't get it.

    Restriction? Women are 50% of the population. Maybe they're chasing ratings by encouraging them to watch.
    In which case they would already be there on merit, wouldn't they?
    No quota would be necessary, and if such a quota is imposed, then the final product will not be as popular as it would have been without it.
    Just a thought.
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!