Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Rank Charlton's managers from 2007- onwards
cafcnick1992
Posts: 7,447
Just a silly little game to keep us amused between seasons. Curbishley will always remain a hero to all Charlton fans but we've had some weird and wonderful managers since he departed the shores of SE7. Based upon the quality of football played, style, their acquisitions (possibly not valid for last 3) relative to the budget, how would you rank them?
I've gone for:
1. Chris Powell
2. Phil Parkinson
3. José Riga
4. Guy Luzon
5. Bob Peeters
6. Alan Pardew
7. Iain Dowie
I've excluded Damien Matthews, Keith Peacock and poor Les
I've gone for:
1. Chris Powell
2. Phil Parkinson
3. José Riga
4. Guy Luzon
5. Bob Peeters
6. Alan Pardew
7. Iain Dowie
I've excluded Damien Matthews, Keith Peacock and poor Les
2
Comments
-
I agree with most of your rankings but would probably swap Pardew and Dowie2
-
1. Phil Parkinson
2. Jose Riga
3. Guy Luzon
4. Chris Powell
5. Bob Peters
6. Alan Pardew
7. Iain Dowie
8 -
Powell
Riga
Luzon
Dowie
Peters
Parkinson
Pardew
1 -
Can I be the first to say
"Move on"
: - )0 -
1. Jose Riga
2. Guy Luzon
3. Phil Parkinson
4. Chris Powell
5. Bob Peters
6. Alan Pardew
7. Iain Dowie
Really do think that Jose Riga coulda took us places5 -
1. Chris Powell
2. Riga
3. Parky
4. Guy Luzon
5. Bob Peeters
6. Dowie
7. Pardew0 -
1. Powell
2. Riga
3. Luzon
4. Parkinson
5. Peeters
6. Pardew
7. Dowie
Had Riga stayed for longer he could've been #1.2 -
DittoSELR_addicks said:1. Powell
2. Riga
3. Luzon
4. Parkinson
5. Peeters
6. Pardew
7. Dowie
Had Riga stayed for longer he could've been #1.
0 -
1 Powell
The rest
7 Dowie4 -
1. Chris Powell
2. Riga
3. Luzon
4. Parkinson
5. Bob Peeters
6. Dowie
7. Pardew0 -
Sponsored links:
-
1. Pardew (hero of mine)
2. Dowie (very close call between him and Pards)
The rest nowhere!8 -
1. José Riga
2. Guy Luzon
3. Chris Powell
4. Phil Parkinson
5. Bob Peeters
6. Iain Dowie
7. Alan Pardew0 -
1. Chris Powell
2. Jose Riga
3. Guy Luzon
4. Phil Parkinson
5. Bob Peeters
6. Iain Dowie
7. Alan Pardew
0 -
1. Chris Powell
2. Jose Riga
Guy Luzon - too early to call.
All the others are joint last and just a dreadfully inept group although give him his due Pardew has been successful since and I am sure Parky is a good bloke.
1 -
This for me. Hard to judge Luzon just yet but maybe switch him and a Powell actually.CAFCsayer said:1. José Riga
2. Guy Luzon
3. Chris Powell
4. Phil Parkinson
5. Bob Peeters
6. Iain Dowie
7. Alan Pardew1 -
1 Jose Riga
2 Guy Luzon
3 Chris Powell
4 Phil Parkinson
5 Bob Peters
Iain Dowie
Alan Pardew2 -
Powell
Riga
Luzon
Peeters
Parkinson
Dowie
Pardew
I genuinely think Peeters could have done good things. Revisionists praise Parkinson but he was part of Pardew's regime and barely won a match in his first 8 months1 -
In order, it's been
1. Iain Dowie
2. Alan Pardew
3. Phil Parkinson
4. Chris Powell
5. José Riga
6. Bob Peeters
7. Guy Luzon
8. Ivan Vukomanović
Who are these people who think Powell was manager before Pardew ??4 -
Only two off that list achieved anything of note CP, promotion and keeping us up, and Riga for turning our season around.1
-
As much as i love the guy, the football was pretty turgid under Chris.0
-
Sponsored links:
-
Riga
Powell
Luzon
Parkinson
Peeters
Shrek
Pardew0 -
Got Charlton out of its lowest point in recent history thoughThe_President said:As much as i love the guy, the football was pretty turgid under Chris.
4 -
1. Powell
2. Luzon
3. Riga
4. Parkinson
5. Peeters
6. Pardew
7. Dowie
This list brings back some depressing memories...1 -
Although excluding Powell, most people's lists roughly in reverse chronological order - so getting better? clutching at straws?1
-
Should the thread title not be.
RANK, Charlton's managers since 20074 -
Pardew and Dowie are the rank Charlton managers, the rest were okay or better.1
-
Based on this, I'd say that the only manager that we've had who's been good over a long period of time is Chris Powell. Jose Riga did better over a short period, but wasn't here long enough to judge properly. Guy Luzon is currently doing well. Let's hope that he can prove himself over a longer period.
Edit: Probably a bit harsh on Phil Parkinson wo deserves more credit than he gets.6 -
1. Chris Powell
2. Phil Parkinson
3. José Riga
4. Guy Luzon
5. Bob Peeters
6. Iain Dowie
7. Alan Pardew0 -
Phil Parkinson presided over the club's worst ever winless streak and relegation to league one. he was, rightly, fired and Charlton achieved promotion with SCP. Phil Parkinson is a competent league one manager, nothing more.8
-
I agree with this. Oddly, we're in a minorityc4fcdenmark said:Phil Parkinson presided over the club's worst ever winless streak and relegation to league one. he was, rightly, fired and Charlton achieved promotion with SCP. Phil Parkinson is a competent league one manager, nothing more.
0
