Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Ref Today
Clem_Snide
Posts: 11,739
Inept, clueless, woeful.....a cheat? Never seen so many consistantly dreadful decisions. Booking for Solly? Booking for Diarra!?! He was peacemaker. Not one word with Camp or a single Rotherham carthorse (refuse to call them players) for blatent time-wasting.
The bloke was a disgrace.
Are clubs able to formally report refs anymore?
The bloke was a disgrace.
Are clubs able to formally report refs anymore?
16
Comments
-
When their keeper had the ball, he was holding it for 15 secs at a time, not once did the ref speak to him.
As for the free kick that led to their goal, was never one, as much as it wasn't a corner.5 -
Was a disgrace.2
-
Plus I'm glad to see it he missed sending Ba off, after Mattock tripped him off the ball, Ba turned round and pushed his head forwards.
Had Mattock been European he would have fallen to the ground and a red could have been issued.
Just a shocking performance from someone of Premier League standard!!
i.e. Cousins ran free at the end of the first half, you could clearly see by his running style that he was being held back and was ignored0 -
C#*t1
-
Keith Stroud is always like that when in charge of our games. Absolute disgrace of a referee , little ****3
-
-
I thought he was awful. Contributed to making the game nightly by failing to clamp down on shirt pulling. The incident where Solly was spoken to after the crunching but fair tackle was a case in point.
Of course the corner decision was a joke and you could see how quickly he distanced himself from the players at the restart.
Reminded me of an inept supply teacher in the second half. Trying to assert authority by having one on one conversations with players while mayhem erupted around him.
3 -
Keith Stroud and Mick Russell. It's personal against us from both of those dishonest criminals.3
-
Feel bad for laughing at that one @Addickted2TheReds1
-
A hopeless ref but I thought his ineptitude and negligence balanced itself out as between the two sides.0
- Sponsored links:
-
Can't believe he left the fella unmarked at the far post for their goal
And Camp took no longer than Pope or Henderson in similar circumstances
Yes he was pony but I thought he was consistently pony either way6 -
Shame on you for laughing @Callumcafc. I was merely posting the screenshot to highlight how outrageous that twitter account is ........ :-)Callumcafc said:Feel bad for laughing at that one @Addickted2TheReds
1 -
oohaahmortimer said:
Can't believe he left the fella unmarked at the far post for their goal
And Camp took no longer than Pope or Henderson in similar circumstances
Yes he was pony but I thought he was consistently pony either way
You obviously missed the Rotherham forward who went up in front of the scorer and feigned to handball it in. That's ungentlemanly conduct, because it puts players off.
3 -
He should have booked Solly in the first half and didn't.0
-
Not for the tackle, that was a great one.cafcnick1992 said:He should have booked Solly in the first half and didn't.
3 -
This content has been removed.
-
I'm glad someone else has mentioned that. I was trying to tell my mate that is why the defence froze, he wasn't having it.PragueAddick said:oohaahmortimer said:
Can't believe he left the fella unmarked at the far post for their goal
And Camp took no longer than Pope or Henderson in similar circumstances
Yes he was pony but I thought he was consistently pony either way
You obviously missed the Rotherham forward who went up in front of the scorer and feigned to handball it in. That's ungentlemanly conduct, because it puts players off.
1 -
Tackle of the match for meguinnessaddick said:
Not for the tackle, that was a great one.cafcnick1992 said:He should have booked Solly in the first half and didn't.
0 -
I must need a new glasses prescription because I actually thought it was a corner and wasn't at all surprised to see it given6
-
I think one of our players should have run over and headbutted the ref as punishment after awarding the goal.1
- Sponsored links:
-
Solly's tackle was immense but was borne out of frustration that the earlier shirt pulling had been allowed to occur.
I thought the ref saw it as fair until the lino flagged?
Fox was taken out soon after and no conversation was had.
2 -
You're right Pope or Henderson would do the same, however it's the ref's job to ensure it doesn't happen. He didn't have a single word with their keeper.oohaahmortimer said:
Can't believe he left the fella unmarked at the far post for their goal
And Camp took no longer than Pope or Henderson in similar circumstances
Yes he was pony but I thought he was consistently pony either way7 -
Pope was booked the first time he took a little while over a goal kick against Hull. The ref never once hurried Camp or any Rotherham player along today.guinnessaddick said:
You're right Pope or Henderson would do the same, however it's the ref's job to ensure it doesn't happen. He didn't have a single word with their keeper.oohaahmortimer said:
Can't believe he left the fella unmarked at the far post for their goal
And Camp took no longer than Pope or Henderson in similar circumstances
Yes he was pony but I thought he was consistently pony either way2 -
Keith Stroud demonstrating why he isn't good enough for the premier league. He was arrogant, inconsistent and inept. Very disappointing, although we should have defended the corner properly amd he wasn't helped out by the two abysmal linesmen. The foul for Solly's booking was a joke, not because of the magnitude of the offence, but by the fact that Stroud didn't give the foul until their manager shouted for it.
The corner decision was unforgivable though, it was as clear as anything that it was a goal kick, even the Rotherham players were running back to their half.
The most unfortunate thing is he'll go out and do another game next week as if nothing has happened. That is just not right.4 -
Ba was lucky not to be sent off. The corner was a joke especially the Rotherham player's attempted handball.0
-
Rotherham player should have been sporting and said, no it's a goal kick. How hard is it for these footballers to show a bit of respect towards each other and the game.4
-
Against Hull... I cant remember who it was but a Charlton player was subbed and before it happened, they walked right over to the East Stand so it would take longer to get off the pitch, the ref promptly booked him for it.Clem_Snide said:
Pope was booked the first time he took a little while over a goal kick against Hull. The ref never once hurried Camp or any Rotherham player along today.guinnessaddick said:
You're right Pope or Henderson would do the same, however it's the ref's job to ensure it doesn't happen. He didn't have a single word with their keeper.oohaahmortimer said:
Can't believe he left the fella unmarked at the far post for their goal
And Camp took no longer than Pope or Henderson in similar circumstances
Yes he was pony but I thought he was consistently pony either way
Today their No. 25 did exactly the same (And was awarded an Oscar for signalling to Lee Camp that he wanted to be the target for the goal kick, all this he did within seconds to fool the ref), we made our sub and then their No. 25 was also subbed so he had to stroll across the whole pitch to come off... Referee completely ignored it all... Where is the bloody consistency.
(As mentioned it was the same when Nick Pope was booked for time wasting a few weeks ago)0 -
The referee was complete crap, full stop. Even his linesman bottled their decisions. The 4th official was the only one who did his job, his stoppage times wet spot on.
Interesting to see disability jokes in this thread, wonder if the usual copper-bottomed bores just as Boringmouth Addick will make an appearance.2 -
The corner decision was a pure guess based on probability IMO - they saw it had come off someone in the wall and there were more Charlton than Rotherham players there, so from their point of view, having not seen it properly, it was "probably" a corner.1
-
But he did book Solly in the first half.cafcnick1992 said:He should have booked Solly in the first half and didn't.
The tackle was right in front of me and as clean as a whistle, albeit full blooded. The second challenge was shoulder to shoulder and I have no idea why the Lino flagged. Pretty sure he actually got booked for dissent, which is always stupid, albeit understandable in the circumstances.0
