Henderson 5 could have done better Solly 4 boring, negative and poor Bauer 5 should have scored the diving header, poor decisions in clearing the ball etc Sarr 4 positional play is all wrong Fox 2 hauled at half time, will only pay again when THD is injured Diarra 7 does simple things well Cousins 6 lots of energy, touch lets him down Holmes-Dennis 7 good footballer, positive and exciting, opposite of Solly Berg Gudmundsson 5 needs to actually shoot instead of setting up and then shifting sideways Makienok 4 easily wound up, nearly got sent off and didn't offer an attacking threat Lookman 7 enjoy him while you can, his runs with the ball have purpose other than to make himself look good (unlike TWatt) Vaz Te 7 dangerous, could have had a couple of goals, will end up top scorer
Henderson - 6 TBH if Pope had let 3 in he'd be getting slated. Should have gone for the head tennis first one as Ipswich's players would always outjump ours. Solly - 4.5 none of the defence emerge with much credit today as they were asleep for the 2nd and overrun for the 3rd. Bauer - 4 Sarr - 4 Fox - 4 Diarra - 5.5 could do with more leadership from him, defo missed Jacko on the pitch Cousins - 5.5 active, but not great today Holmes-Dennis - 6.5 constructive, played in 3 positions, not perfect by any chance, but clearly has talent and hasn't had it Charltoned out of him yet Berg Gudmundsson - 5 clearly has talent, but looked Charltonised today Makienok - 4 why hoof it up to him, he won't get it? Lookman - 7 exciting. More please Vaz Te - 7 looked up for it, nearly scored. Worked well with Reza, who also looked a lot better
Henderson 6 - Goals weren't his fault. Solly 4 - Defence as a whole shocking but he did get forward a bit. Bauer 4 Sarr 2 shit Fox 2 shit Diarra 6 Cousins 6 - Holmes-Dennis 6 - Berg Gudmundsson 5 - Makienok 1 -useless and to think Watts gone joke. Lookman 8 sadly won't be here long Vaz Te 7 -
Henderson - 7 Good game and could not do much about the goals. Solly -7 Maybe not fully recovered from his knock (he was a substitute) good shift. Fouled for the second goal which was clearly highlighted by Sky. Bauer -6 Tough game for him - against some good and quick forwards. Sarr -5 Not his best. Fox -4 Not his best again.... Diarra -7 Good effort. Cousins -6 Effort but did not really happen this game. Holmes-Dennis -8 Excellent performance. Should play regularly now fo sure! Berg Gudmundsson -6 Still not performing as he can. Makienok -2 Puts his heart into it but is not capable at this level for now at least. Will go back after the loan period I am sure. Lookman -7 Great prospect. Much better team player than TWWW sadly. Vaz Te -7 Encouraging stint and can only get better and sharper.
Jackson n/a Big blow for us when he went off. Reza n/a Marmite player......
Karel - Losing JJ was a blow to his plans. Did the best with the players available but maybe should have taken big Simon off earlier. I am sure that he would have liked some loan reinforements but I think that he was right to say that he has the players needed to keep confidence up from the lows under Guy.
Henderson - 6 A bit of a nothing game from our stopper today Solly - 5 I think Darryl Murphy rubs his hands every time he sees Solly's name of the teamsheet Bauer - 5.5 Solid at times, un-done at others Sarr - 6 Kept waiting for mistakes, but few came Fox - 4 Nothing good about his performance today Diarra - 6.5 Tried hard but it didn't quite work for Alou today Cousins - 6.5 Gave his all once more but nothing he tried seemed to work Holmes-Dennis - 7 Can be proud of his play in all three positions he covered; must work on his crossing though Berg Gudmundsson - 5.5 Saw plenty of ball but everything he played was short today Makienok - 4 Big Simon had a pretty poor day - got a very sore hand and a funny song sung against him Lookman - 7 (MoM) Always available, but not everything worked, tired in last 20 and his head dropped too Vaz Te - 6 Wanted it and unlucky not to score
Undone by better tactics - that's what you get from decent, experienced, managers in this league KM!
Henderson - 5 could've made a greater presence and punch the ball and players for first goal. Solly - 3 extremely poor, lost confidence and interest. Bauer - 4 tired hard in my opinion but not great Sarr - 4 ditto Fox - 4 believe there is a player in there, confidence shot to pieces. Diarra - 5 needed more leadership Cousins - 4 don't get the hype, a lot of huff and puff, lacks quality. Holmes-Dennis - 7 played 3 different positions, willing to get forward, few decent crosses - no one in box. Berg Gudmundsson - 5 a lot of the ball, been worked out, no right foot. Makienok - 2 dreadful. Lookman - 7.5 wanted the ball, direct and made things happen. Vaz Te - 7 has to start. Watched him for u21s in the week, wants the ball, clever with the ball and will score goals.
Jackson n/a Reza n/a
Best bit of the day during 2% protest was the bovril brigade shouting 'sittttt darnn'
Henderson - 8 Solly - 5 Bauer - 5 Sarr -3 Fox -3 Diarra -5 Cousins -3 Holmes-Dennis -9 Berg Gudmundsson -5 Makienok -0 I was crying out for a big targetman. It ain't Mak, send him back Lookman - 8 Vaz Te -8
Henderson -6 i hope the second goal was a deflection Solly - 5 couldn't make a difference. Bauer - 5 seem to be carrying an injury from 20 minutes in Sarr -5 i'm the only person who seemed to see him make some tackles. Fox -5 look shaky with the whole defense Diarra -6 tried to hold the wobbly team together. Cousins -5.5 covered every blade of grass( in a Pritchard type of way) tried hard. Holmes-Dennis -7 played decent in 3 positions. Berg Gudmundsson -6 played ok, Makienok -3.5 had a shocker,struggled to win a header, didn't attack the 6 yard box ? everyone should be allowed, 1 mare a season. Lookman -7.5 lot's of talent and confidence. never as easy scoring in the 1st team Vaz Te -6.5 unlucky not to score at least one goal.
Henderson - 6 poor positioning for the 2nd Solly - 4.5 a couple of decent attacking moments. Bauer - 4 possibly the worst game I have seen him play for us. Sarr - 3.5 slightly worse than his CH partner Fox - 3.5 embarrassingly slow, which earned him his yellow. Diarra - 5 nowhere near the level he has shown Cousins - 5 a lot of huff & puff. Not a lot of quality or end result. Holmes-Dennis - 8 one of the few positives. Bright, quick, good defender, good attacking player & a helluva shot on him... Berg Gudmundsson - 5...as JBG knows. Poor game. Corners & free kicks that rarely, if ever beat the first man. A shadow. Makienok - 3 dreadful performance. Shortest 6' 7" ever as he didn't win a header that mattered all game...or even look like he wanted to. Lookman - 7.5 the other positive. Scared their defenders when running at them. Great control & link ups with THD. Vaz Te - 6 obviously not up to speed yet, but had a go and at least tried to make things happen (take note Simon)
Jackson n/a. Fell apart without him Reza n/a came on and made more impact than Makienok in 2 minutes
Henderson 7 Solly 5.5 Bauer 6 Sarr 3 awful Fox 3 was he out on the piss last night? Diarra 6 Cousins 5 Holmes-Dennis 7 Berg Gudmundsson 6 Makienok 4 Lookman 8.5 class Vaz Te 7 looks useful
Henderson - 6 Solly 5 - not fit Bauer 5 - very poor Sarr 4 too young needs more coaching before being considered at this , where was he for the 2nd goal it was his side?? Fox 4.5 - lightweight Diarra 5 Cousins 4.5 - lightweight Holmes-Dennis 7 - decent Berg Gudmundsson 4 - shadow of last season , has suffered for not having a buyens type player along side him Makienok 1 - slated by the pundits on sky and wanted him desperately to do something to shut that wanker Goodman up , but hate to say it they were right , quite simply the worst I've ever seen a Charlton player perform in 37/years of being a fan , he should be docked a months wages unforgivable display Lookman 7.5 - lively Vaz Te 6 promising.
Comments
Henderson - 6
Solly - 5
Bauer - 4
Sarr - 3
Fox - 4
Diarra - 6
Cousins - 5
Holmes-Dennis - 7
Berg Gudmundsson - 5
Makienok - 1 ...and that's generous, woeful
Lookman - 7.5
Vaz Te - 7
Solly - 6
Bauer - 6.5
Sarr - 6
Fox - 5
Diarra - 5.5
Cousins - 5
Holmes-Dennis - 7
Berg Gudmundsson - 6
Makienok - 2
Lookman - 7.5
Vaz Te - 7
(I was at the game)
Solly - 4.5
Bauer - 5
Sarr - 4.5
Fox - 4
Diarra -6
Cousins - 5.5
Holmes-Dennis -7
Berg Gudmundsson - 6
Makienok - 5
Lookman - 6.5
Vaz Te - 6.5
Jackson n/a
Reza n/a
Solly - 3
Bauer - 5
Sarr - 5
Fox - 3
Diarra - 6.5
Cousins - 5
THD - 7
JBG - 5
Makienok - 4
Lookman - 7.5 (Belgian clowns will no doubt be hawking him round as I write)
Vaz Te - 7
Solly - 4
Bauer - 4
Sarr - 4
Fox - 3
Diarra - 4
Cousins - 4
Holmes-Dennis - 4
Berg Gudmundsson - 5
Makienok - 3
Lookman - 6
Vaz Te - 6
Jackson n/a
Reza n/a
Solly 6
Bauer 6
Sarr 4.5
Fox 4
Diarra 6
Cousins 6
Holmes-Dennis 7.5 (played in 3 different postions)
Berg Gudmundsson 6
Makienok 3.5
Lookman 7
Vaz Te 6.5
Jackson n/a
Reza n/a
Solly - 4.5 none of the defence emerge with much credit today as they were asleep for the 2nd and overrun for the 3rd.
Bauer - 4
Sarr - 4
Fox - 4
Diarra - 5.5 could do with more leadership from him, defo missed Jacko on the pitch
Cousins - 5.5 active, but not great today
Holmes-Dennis - 6.5 constructive, played in 3 positions, not perfect by any chance, but clearly has talent and hasn't had it Charltoned out of him yet
Berg Gudmundsson - 5 clearly has talent, but looked Charltonised today
Makienok - 4 why hoof it up to him, he won't get it?
Lookman - 7 exciting. More please
Vaz Te - 7 looked up for it, nearly scored. Worked well with Reza, who also looked a lot better
Henderson 6 - Goals weren't his fault.
Solly 4 - Defence as a whole shocking but he did get forward a bit.
Bauer 4
Sarr 2 shit
Fox 2 shit
Diarra 6
Cousins 6 -
Holmes-Dennis 6 -
Berg Gudmundsson 5 -
Makienok 1 -useless and to think Watts gone joke.
Lookman 8 sadly won't be here long
Vaz Te 7 -
Jackson n/a
Reza n/a
Henderson - 7 Good game and could not do much about the goals.
Solly -7 Maybe not fully recovered from his knock (he was a substitute) good shift. Fouled for the second goal which was clearly highlighted by Sky.
Bauer -6 Tough game for him - against some good and quick forwards.
Sarr -5 Not his best.
Fox -4 Not his best again....
Diarra -7 Good effort.
Cousins -6 Effort but did not really happen this game.
Holmes-Dennis -8 Excellent performance. Should play regularly now fo sure!
Berg Gudmundsson -6 Still not performing as he can.
Makienok -2 Puts his heart into it but is not capable at this level for now at least. Will go back after the loan period I am sure.
Lookman -7 Great prospect. Much better team player than TWWW sadly.
Vaz Te -7 Encouraging stint and can only get better and sharper.
Jackson n/a Big blow for us when he went off.
Reza n/a Marmite player......
Karel - Losing JJ was a blow to his plans. Did the best with the players available but maybe should have taken big Simon off earlier. I am sure that he would have liked some loan reinforements but I think that he was right to say that he has the players needed to keep confidence up from the lows under Guy.
Solly - 5
Bauer - 4
Sarr - 2.5
Fox - 4
Diarra - 6
Cousins - 5
Holmes-Dennis - 6.5
Berg Gudmundsson - 6
Makienok - 2
Lookman - 6.5
Vaz Te - 6.5
Solly - 6
Bauer - 6
Sarr -4
Fox -5
Diarra - 6.5
Cousins - 5
Holmes-Dennis - 6.5
Berg Gudmundsson - 6
Makienok - 4
Lookman - 7
Vaz Te - 7
Solly - 5 I think Darryl Murphy rubs his hands every time he sees Solly's name of the teamsheet
Bauer - 5.5 Solid at times, un-done at others
Sarr - 6 Kept waiting for mistakes, but few came
Fox - 4 Nothing good about his performance today
Diarra - 6.5 Tried hard but it didn't quite work for Alou today
Cousins - 6.5 Gave his all once more but nothing he tried seemed to work
Holmes-Dennis - 7 Can be proud of his play in all three positions he covered; must work on his crossing though
Berg Gudmundsson - 5.5 Saw plenty of ball but everything he played was short today
Makienok - 4 Big Simon had a pretty poor day - got a very sore hand and a funny song sung against him
Lookman - 7 (MoM) Always available, but not everything worked, tired in last 20 and his head dropped too
Vaz Te - 6 Wanted it and unlucky not to score
Undone by better tactics - that's what you get from decent, experienced, managers in this league KM!
Solly - 6
Bauer - 6
Sarr - 5.5
Fox - 5
Diarra - 6
Cousins - 6
Holmes-Dennis - 7
Berg Gudmundsson - 5
Makienok - 5
Lookman - 8
Vaz Te - 6.5
Solly - 5
Bauer - 5
Sarr -4.5
Fox - 4
Diarra - 5
Cousins - 5
Holmes-Dennis - 6
Berg Gudmundsson - 5
Makienok - 2
Lookman - 7
Vaz Te - 7
Solly -4
Bauer -5
Sarr -4
Fox -4
Diarra -5
Cousins -5
Holmes-Dennis -7
Berg Gudmundsson -4
Makienok -4
Lookman -7
Vaz Te -7
Solly 5.5
Bauer 6
Sarr 4- woefully at fault for goal 2
Fox 2- dreadful
Cousins 5
Diarra 6
Gudmundsson 6
T H-D 6
Makienok 1
Lookman 7
Vaz Te 7
Solly - 3 extremely poor, lost confidence and interest.
Bauer - 4 tired hard in my opinion but not great
Sarr - 4 ditto
Fox - 4 believe there is a player in there, confidence shot to pieces.
Diarra - 5 needed more leadership
Cousins - 4 don't get the hype, a lot of huff and puff, lacks quality.
Holmes-Dennis - 7 played 3 different positions, willing to get forward, few decent crosses - no one in box.
Berg Gudmundsson - 5 a lot of the ball, been worked out, no right foot.
Makienok - 2 dreadful.
Lookman - 7.5 wanted the ball, direct and made things happen.
Vaz Te - 7 has to start. Watched him for u21s in the week, wants the ball, clever with the ball and will score goals.
Jackson n/a
Reza n/a
Best bit of the day during 2% protest was the bovril brigade shouting 'sittttt darnn'
See you at Brighton
Solly - 5
Bauer - 5
Sarr -3
Fox -3
Diarra -5
Cousins -3
Holmes-Dennis -9
Berg Gudmundsson -5
Makienok -0 I was crying out for a big targetman. It ain't Mak, send him back
Lookman - 8
Vaz Te -8
Solly - 5 couldn't make a difference.
Bauer - 5 seem to be carrying an injury from 20 minutes in
Sarr -5 i'm the only person who seemed to see him make some tackles.
Fox -5 look shaky with the whole defense
Diarra -6 tried to hold the wobbly team together.
Cousins -5.5 covered every blade of grass( in a Pritchard type of way) tried hard.
Holmes-Dennis -7 played decent in 3 positions.
Berg Gudmundsson -6 played ok,
Makienok -3.5 had a shocker,struggled to win a header, didn't attack the 6 yard box ? everyone should be allowed, 1 mare a season.
Lookman -7.5 lot's of talent and confidence. never as easy scoring in the 1st team
Vaz Te -6.5 unlucky not to score at least one goal.
Solly 5
Bauer 6
Sarr 6
Fox 4
Diarra 5
Cousins 5
Holmes-Dennis 6.5
Berg Gudmundsson 4
Makienok 3
Lookman 7
Vaz Te 7
Jackson n/a
Reza n/a
Solly 6
Bauer 6
Sarr 4
Fox 4
Diarra 6
Cousins 6
Holmes-Dennis 7
Berg Gudmundsson 6
Makienok 3
Lookman 8
Vaz Te 7
Jackson n/a
Reza n/a
Solly - 4.5 a couple of decent attacking moments.
Bauer - 4 possibly the worst game I have seen him play for us.
Sarr - 3.5 slightly worse than his CH partner
Fox - 3.5 embarrassingly slow, which earned him his yellow.
Diarra - 5 nowhere near the level he has shown
Cousins - 5 a lot of huff & puff. Not a lot of quality or end result.
Holmes-Dennis - 8 one of the few positives. Bright, quick, good defender, good attacking player & a helluva shot on him...
Berg Gudmundsson - 5...as JBG knows. Poor game. Corners & free kicks that rarely, if ever beat the first man. A shadow.
Makienok - 3 dreadful performance. Shortest 6' 7" ever as he didn't win a header that mattered all game...or even look like he wanted to.
Lookman - 7.5 the other positive. Scared their defenders when running at them. Great control & link ups with THD.
Vaz Te - 6 obviously not up to speed yet, but had a go and at least tried to make things happen (take note Simon)
Jackson n/a. Fell apart without him
Reza n/a came on and made more impact than Makienok in 2 minutes
Solly 5
Bauer 4
Sarr 2
Fox 2
Diarra 5
Cousins 6
Holmes Dennis 7
Gudmundsson 5
Makienok 2
Lookman 7
Vaz Ta 7
Solly 5.5
Bauer 6
Sarr 3 awful
Fox 3 was he out on the piss last night?
Diarra 6
Cousins 5
Holmes-Dennis 7
Berg Gudmundsson 6
Makienok 4
Lookman 8.5 class
Vaz Te 7 looks useful
Henderson - 6.5
Solly - 6
Bauer - 6
Sarr - 6
Fox - 4.5
Diarra - 6.5
Cousins - 6.5
Holmes-Dennis - 8
Berg Gudmundsson - 7
Makienok - 4.5
Lookman - 8
Vaz Te - 7
Solly - 5
Bauer - 5
Sarr - 5
Fox - 5
Diarra - 6
Cousins - 5
Holmes-Dennis - 7
Berg Gudmundsson - 5
Makienok - 4
Lookman - 7
Vaz Te - 6
Henderson - 6
Solly 5 - not fit
Bauer 5 - very poor
Sarr 4 too young needs more coaching before being considered at this , where was he for the 2nd goal it was his side??
Fox 4.5 - lightweight
Diarra 5
Cousins 4.5 - lightweight
Holmes-Dennis 7 - decent
Berg Gudmundsson 4 - shadow of last season , has suffered for not having a buyens type player along side him
Makienok 1 - slated by the pundits on sky and wanted him desperately to do something to shut that wanker Goodman up , but hate to say it they were right , quite simply the worst I've ever seen a Charlton player perform in 37/years of being a fan , he should be docked a months wages unforgivable display
Lookman 7.5 - lively
Vaz Te 6 promising.