Attention: Please take a moment to consider our <a href="http://forum.charltonlife.com/home/termsofservice">terms and conditions</a> before posting.

Savings and Investments thread

1…439440442444445…449

Comments

  • Friend Or Defoe
    Friend Or Defoe Posts: 18,401
    I love reading all the nonsense on here about how it was just as hard to get on the housing ladder back than then it is today. I bought in the 00s with a 7% mortgage, saved for years, made loads of sacrifices, it wasn't easy then and it's never been easy, but it's far harder for young people today. 
  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 19,050
    edited October 23
    Rob7Lee said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    Lets frame this another way the people that lived in our house before us were able to buy this house as their first home he was a postman and she didnt work. They were able to have 3 kids be mortgage free in a couple decades and live here most of their lives.

    For us its a very different prospect, we both had to be working in high paid high demand roles fitting in the HENRY 60% tax trap category and still needed family help even after a decade of saving (outlined above). We needed over £100k saved to cover deposit, stamp duty, fees etc. plus more for initial works to make the house safe. 

    And that was for a standard 3 bed starter home in suburban south east london (hardly a sought after bit of town) that needed completely ripping out and fully rennovating. Finances are still a massive factor in whether we have kids or not. 

    That level of change in a generation for the same standard of living is wild. 
    You’re in danger of sounding like Gary.

    my postman George (at a guess early to mid 30’s) moved from a flat in Erith to a 3 bed semi in Eltham. He’s managed to buy a family home for him, his wife and young child.

    I do think it’s a shame that there is this narrative that getting on the housing ladder is difficult to impossible. Whilst is is (impossible) for some, and difficult for most, especially around the SE, far too many I feel give up too easily before they have begun. I know a number of people my wife works with who quote that narrative, yet (as I did with one) you go through the numbers and a 3-5 year plan (including managing spending!) you find it is possible (no one is saying easy).

    I work in an industry where there is no reason that 95% of the youngest that join at 18 or 21 can’t buy a place by around 25/26. Generally they all do eventually, just takes some a long longer to do so than others, those who start the saving with their second pay check (I generally tell them to blow the 1st) are good to go by 25, others only realise at 25 that they’ve spent the last 4-7 years wasting decent money.

    My daughter 26 and her boyfriend have saved enough to put down at least a 35% deposit on a £450k house. Yes helped by living at home with parents, but even if they hadn’t the last couple of years they would have still saved enough for a deposit.

    and no offence on this, but if you and your wife are both earning north of £100k each, saved for over a decade and got help (I assume you are talking about financial help) from family, what sort of mansion do you live in, in your surburbia starter home….. that needed work to make it safe!?! Time for @golfaddick
    I'll bet Georges wife is working too though. 

    I agree that its not impossible for a lot of people and that some do give up too easily. But equally dimishing the challenges and the clear intergenerational inequality being created by this inheritocracy system as a "narrative" when it is very real and being felt by a majority of people in that group is dangerous. Just look at the inequality protests happening across Europe right now. We should not dismiss those concerns. 

    On your last point there was obviously wage progression in that decade of saving, I thought that was clear by the earlier references to promotions. Much of that period we were on much lower grad scheme salaries while we saved. or even lower while we studied. It then took working through the levels as quickly as possible to get there. We both got there around the time we bought our house (think it might have been a little after for me) which was what enabled us to borrow enough. Its a standard 3 bed semi.


    As I always say on here none of my views are to benefit me personally. I'll be absolutely fine. I have a house, investments and 2 high incomes and a whole bunch of safety nets. At some point we will inherit decent sums from remaining grandparents and parents. I have no worries about me personally (well beyond the existential threats...). Its not about me. Its about society, people I know who are stuggling, people I dont know, single parents, disabled people, those in temporary housing, people in the care system. The people who "life happens to" and leaves them worse off through no fault of their own.
    No idea if his wife works or not. He's a bright lad, assume he does overtime as he's often the postie who delivers parcels in the van at the weekend, for all I know he may have another job as well.

    On intergenerational inequality and specifically wages - at 18 (1990/1991) I worked for a Lloyds syndicate, I remember it vividly as I started on £5016 the end of 1989 at 16 and then a bit over a year layer got almost a 20% rise putting me on exactly £6k. £6k in 1991 to today (BoE inflation calculator) becomes £14,880. We pay our 18 year old apprentices pretty much to the pound double that.

    I'm now somewhat confused by your own personal situation examples, 2 x £100k+ wages, a house, investments and a whole bunch of safety nets and planned inheritance, yet your finances are still a massive factor on whether to have kids or not?

    I do think there has become a widening gap for the young, mainly between themselves though and the vast difference (and I hate this term but gives the idea) of the haves and have nots. Unemployment for under 25's is out of control really and a lot needs to be done there or there will be a huge swathe of a whole generation struggling (as there is no way benefits can continue as they are). We also need to do much better than University being the main option at 18.

    We need to give the young opportunities, but as I often quote when I'm speaking to groups who come in for work experience days, equal opportunity doesn't automatically mean equal outcomes, one of the reasons I am not a fan of private education.
    Unfortunately anecdote =/= data. You are well aware that average salaries have not kept pace with inflation for decades as we've done this one plenty of times before.

    On my personal circumstances. It's like you've missed the point of the entire conversation and the meaning of the HENRY term. 

    High tax rates, plus graduate tax an extra 9%, plus repayment of masters loans for us both means that take home pay doesnt reflect headline salary. Last few pay rises for either of us have barely moved the take home. Ability to borrow is calculated off headline salary doesn't take into account deductions. A huge mortgage which its interest rate just more than trebled. Just drained savings and borrowed a bit to do this extension on the house, significantly more cash needed to finish other works on the house. Disposable income isn't enough to feel like we would be able to do justice to raising the next generation. We would be ineligible for any childcare scheme so the cost of that would be as much as a mortgage all over again per child, or one of us would have to drop at least 50% of our hours losing massive amounts of income. 

    Yes we have safety nets. Safety nets that others don't always have in the sense of family who would look after us or we could live with or in the sense of critical illness cover etc. I said "We will be fine" in the context of relative to people who are genuinely struggling. We will always have somewhere to live, never be at risk of homelessness and we have in demand skills so will always be able to get a job even in an AI world. 

    Unfortunately your last paragraph is a bit out of date. It's a 2004 talking point - thats when that line was actually being used in politics and it was at the time a gebuine conversation to be had. Things have moved so far since then. If you think there is anything close to equality of opportunities out there anymore you're delusional. Social mobility has dropped off a cliff in the last 20 years. In the vast majority of cases for a child born now their social class is decided the day they are born. And that is the fundamental problem.

    My last paragraph wasn't suggesting we have achieved equality of opportunity (in fact I was making the point we haven't, i.e. why I don't really agree with private education as it is probably the biggest stifle of equal opportunity for young people).

    People often assume equal opportunity results in equality of outcomes, it doesn't. I'm sure we all know many people who had equal opportunity/upbringing but have seen very different outcomes. I often talk to groups who come from underprivileged backgrounds, that point resonates with them, in that we can flip it to be just because they haven't had the same opportunity (i.e. education opportunity) as someone else doesn't mean they have to have worse outcomes. They may just have to do things differently to get to that place. We need to stop putting people in buckets based on accident of birth and saying that means they can't do well, yes as a society we need to do more but there is also personal responsibility.

    If you honestly both earn north of £100k and even take off gross your student loans (which at that level will be paid back pretty quickly), then no offence but at those salary levels (or even take 85% of) you should really be very well set up financially. You must be clearing towards a 5 figure sum between you a month, top of the DINKY's, so you shouldn't need worry about doing justice to raising children or need help with childcare.
    The bit in bold worries me a lot. Its become a Farage talking point in the last year or so and has been repeated in the likes of the mail and telegraph opinion pieces repeatedly. It makes out that the problem of social mobility is a psychological one and that if we would just stop talking about it suddenly people would be able to change their situations. And whilst there will always be a few anecdotes of where that might work in reality the problem is systemic. Areas with the most need have the worst infrastructure, worst service provision, worst schools, worst healthcare etc etc.

    If we look at it from my area of focus at work (health and welfare) your IMD decile at birth determines your life expectancy and more importantly healthy life expectancy. That then determines the number of years you are dependent on the NHS in later life (for the most deprived decile this is the last 3rd of their life) and therefore how much of your life you are able to work - for the most deprived decile this point comes 20 years before the least deprived and almost all of that falls when they are of working age. As a result of the systemic issues mentioned above these people experience the longest waits for planned care and the longer you spend on a waiting list the less likely you are to return to work (can't remember the stats off the top of my head but have quoted them on this thread before) and the more likely you are to develop mental health needs as well. Its a funnel that can catch people from all walks of life but some are being actively pushed towards it. We need to address these systemic issues before we can put it down to personal responsibility. And to solve those systemic issues we need to talk about it more not less!

    This talking point has been used to justify a lack of action on social mobility and even preventing actions.

    On my personal circumstances you've ignored the cost side of things. Huge mortgage and rates trebled. And yes obviously weve been saving but some tied up in pensions and investments and weve just emptied out savings into work on the house. A lot more needed on the house in the next 2 years too.

    And the childcare costs these are the same as a mortgage PER CHILD if you don't get the 30 hours free and still work full time. That's not affordable in the next 2 years if we want to finish the house. And that's before we talk about maternity pay. 

    You're also underestimating the student loan factor a lot. I remember you saying your daughters didn't need the system so understandable if you don't know how it works. Let me put it this way - I've paid back pretty much what I originally "borrowed" but now "owe" 19k more than I originally borrowed. It is a loan only in name, it is structured to be a 30(or 40 depending on age) year graduate tax other than for those with rich parents. I got particularly unlucky in that as my earnings grew interest rates were soaring and so it took me a hell of a long time and a wildly high salary to even cover the interest. Without lump sum early repayment I'll likely pay back 3-3.5 times what I borrowed depending on what rates do. Masters loan is another 6% graduate tax on top. Bit at least this one is whittling down and there is an end in sight. 

    Add these stealth taxes to income tax and NI plus factor in my work place pension contributions and my marginal take home is 8p in the £. 
  • clb74
    clb74 Posts: 10,877
    I always remember me dad's mate saying you're never understand another generation because you didnt live that time.
    I remember once me dad going on about younger generations getting into debt with credit cards.
    I said credit cards weren't about when he was 18 and if they were what would him and his mates been like with credit cards.
    Dad's reply was " probably worse than you're lot".
    I was moaning a couple of days ago about youngsters always being on the phone at work.
    Mobile phones weren't about when I was 18, No doubt though I'd of probably been on the phone at 18 if I'd of had access to a mobile phone.

    Im working with a bloke whose 40 and we were talking and his telling me earning £60000 a year isn't enough. 
    I came close to telling him, you having a laugh.
    The wife reckons it nosey to know what people earn and how they spend thier money.
    But I'd like to thank a couple of posters on this thread by opening up with thier finances as it helps me understand a bit more.
    I can knock other generations at times by ive no idea what thier going through.

  • Huskaris
    Huskaris Posts: 10,022
    edited October 24
    Lets frame this another way the people that lived in our house before us were able to buy this house as their first home he was a postman and she didnt work. They were able to have 3 kids be mortgage free in a couple decades and live here most of their lives.

    For us its a very different prospect, we both had to be working in high paid high demand roles fitting in the HENRY 60% tax trap category and still needed family help even after a decade of saving (outlined above). We needed over £100k saved to cover deposit, stamp duty, fees etc. plus more for initial works to make the house safe. 

    And that was for a standard 3 bed starter home in suburban south east london (hardly a sought after bit of town) that needed completely ripping out and fully rennovating. Finances are still a massive factor in whether we have kids or not. 

    That level of change in a generation for the same standard of living is wild. 
    This is more a response to the whole convo, which I've enjoyed reading!

    Similar situation to you, but not feeling the pinch too much. 

    Not sure how much over £100k you are but can sal sac into pension to £99,999 if it's not more than £60k and get that childcare/avoid the tax marginal tax trap and get the childcare hours. It's annoying but I've reflected that I wouldn't bother saving much into a pension without this tax trap and just spaff it all  :D 

    I read further and if I were you I would also be paying those student loans off faster than what's taken out of your salary if you're earning that much to maximise cashflow at £99,999. I'd even release equity in my mortgage given the comparable rates. 

    On generational differences. I feel like it can both be true that previous generations worked a lot harder and were a lot more driven on average (Canters you clearly have that work philosophy that's close to someone like Rob), but at the same time the salary to mortgage multiples, as well as the amount of things targeting for your hard earned (express restraint!) are much harder these days. I feel previous generations worked in an economy that was more favourable to them, and they worked harder, whereas the younger generations (especially Z) have an economy stacked against them as well as being far lazier, maybe the two are linked....

    The previous generation became accidentally wealthy without any real planning through house appreciation in a way that just won't happen again. That's why there's millions of people waiting for their parents to die to get on the housing ladder. 
  • shine166
    shine166 Posts: 14,818
    Rob7Lee said:
    shine166 said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    Lets frame this another way the people that lived in our house before us were able to buy this house as their first home he was a postman and she didnt work. They were able to have 3 kids be mortgage free in a couple decades and live here most of their lives.

    For us its a very different prospect, we both had to be working in high paid high demand roles fitting in the HENRY 60% tax trap category and still needed family help even after a decade of saving (outlined above). We needed over £100k saved to cover deposit, stamp duty, fees etc. plus more for initial works to make the house safe. 

    And that was for a standard 3 bed starter home in suburban south east london (hardly a sought after bit of town) that needed completely ripping out and fully rennovating. Finances are still a massive factor in whether we have kids or not. 

    That level of change in a generation for the same standard of living is wild. 
    You’re in danger of sounding like Gary.

    my postman George (at a guess early to mid 30’s) moved from a flat in Erith to a 3 bed semi in Eltham. He’s managed to buy a family home for him, his wife and young child.

    I do think it’s a shame that there is this narrative that getting on the housing ladder is difficult to impossible. Whilst is is (impossible) for some, and difficult for most, especially around the SE, far too many I feel give up too easily before they have begun. I know a number of people my wife works with who quote that narrative, yet (as I did with one) you go through the numbers and a 3-5 year plan (including managing spending!) you find it is possible (no one is saying easy).

    I work in an industry where there is no reason that 95% of the youngest that join at 18 or 21 can’t buy a place by around 25/26. Generally they all do eventually, just takes some a long longer to do so than others, those who start the saving with their second pay check (I generally tell them to blow the 1st) are good to go by 25, others only realise at 25 that they’ve spent the last 4-7 years wasting decent money.

    My daughter 26 and her boyfriend have saved enough to put down at least a 35% deposit on a £450k house. Yes helped by living at home with parents, but even if they hadn’t the last couple of years they would have still saved enough for a deposit.

    and no offence on this, but if you and your wife are both earning north of £100k each, saved for over a decade and got help (I assume you are talking about financial help) from family, what sort of mansion do you live in, in your surburbia starter home….. that needed work to make it safe!?! Time for @golfaddick
    The average couple of 26 year olds, are not saving 150k + in a 4/5 years period... especially if they dont live at home. Thats literally 50% of mine and my wife's income in that time frame and we are 39 & 43 years old. 

    We purchased our first home this year, the rent on the previous property was £1450 PM.
    Agreed, which is why I pointed out they were both at home (I do charge rent though 😉) and they didn’t need to save that amount (other than to lower costs).

    but they could buy a £250k flat rather than a £450k house, so would have needed say £35k saved between them, call it £18k each which in a 5 year period that’s £3,600 a year/£300 a month (or 25% less ie £240 a month if you put in a LISA). If you invested/obtained interest probably £200 ish a month each would have likely got there. My daughter saves that easily by not buying a Pret lunch or similar 20 days a month but instead takes in a packed lunch.

    of course different situations mean different things and many don’t/can’t live at home with parents (like I didn’t). But 2x people living with parents should be able to save 2-300 a month which will after 5 years easily get them on the property ladder.

    I have graduates who don’t live at home but rent a room and manage to save after 5 years to buy (yes often with a partner but not always, one lad who works for me started at 18, bought a flat in Chislehurst at 24 on his own and now at 30 is buying a house in Battersea with girlfriend)
    I think you live in a very different world than the average family tbh, nothing wrong with that but it changes your perspective on reality. Live at home until 25 and dont buy Pret, should be taught as financial advice at school :). 
  • Friend Or Defoe
    Friend Or Defoe Posts: 18,401
    Saying kids these days are lazy is also nonsense and has been said for as long as i can remember. When i was there age i was out cleaning chimneys... The irony of posting it during working hours isn't lost on me.
  • Huskaris
    Huskaris Posts: 10,022
    Saying kids these days are lazy is also nonsense and has been said for as long as i can remember. When i was there age i was out cleaning chimneys... The irony of posting it during working hours isn't lost on me.
    I am genuinely shocked at how people currently aged between 20-28 are (on average!!!!) compared to people who are my age (35).
  • Rob7Lee
    Rob7Lee Posts: 10,076
    shine166 said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    shine166 said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    Lets frame this another way the people that lived in our house before us were able to buy this house as their first home he was a postman and she didnt work. They were able to have 3 kids be mortgage free in a couple decades and live here most of their lives.

    For us its a very different prospect, we both had to be working in high paid high demand roles fitting in the HENRY 60% tax trap category and still needed family help even after a decade of saving (outlined above). We needed over £100k saved to cover deposit, stamp duty, fees etc. plus more for initial works to make the house safe. 

    And that was for a standard 3 bed starter home in suburban south east london (hardly a sought after bit of town) that needed completely ripping out and fully rennovating. Finances are still a massive factor in whether we have kids or not. 

    That level of change in a generation for the same standard of living is wild. 
    You’re in danger of sounding like Gary.

    my postman George (at a guess early to mid 30’s) moved from a flat in Erith to a 3 bed semi in Eltham. He’s managed to buy a family home for him, his wife and young child.

    I do think it’s a shame that there is this narrative that getting on the housing ladder is difficult to impossible. Whilst is is (impossible) for some, and difficult for most, especially around the SE, far too many I feel give up too easily before they have begun. I know a number of people my wife works with who quote that narrative, yet (as I did with one) you go through the numbers and a 3-5 year plan (including managing spending!) you find it is possible (no one is saying easy).

    I work in an industry where there is no reason that 95% of the youngest that join at 18 or 21 can’t buy a place by around 25/26. Generally they all do eventually, just takes some a long longer to do so than others, those who start the saving with their second pay check (I generally tell them to blow the 1st) are good to go by 25, others only realise at 25 that they’ve spent the last 4-7 years wasting decent money.

    My daughter 26 and her boyfriend have saved enough to put down at least a 35% deposit on a £450k house. Yes helped by living at home with parents, but even if they hadn’t the last couple of years they would have still saved enough for a deposit.

    and no offence on this, but if you and your wife are both earning north of £100k each, saved for over a decade and got help (I assume you are talking about financial help) from family, what sort of mansion do you live in, in your surburbia starter home….. that needed work to make it safe!?! Time for @golfaddick
    The average couple of 26 year olds, are not saving 150k + in a 4/5 years period... especially if they dont live at home. Thats literally 50% of mine and my wife's income in that time frame and we are 39 & 43 years old. 

    We purchased our first home this year, the rent on the previous property was £1450 PM.
    Agreed, which is why I pointed out they were both at home (I do charge rent though 😉) and they didn’t need to save that amount (other than to lower costs).

    but they could buy a £250k flat rather than a £450k house, so would have needed say £35k saved between them, call it £18k each which in a 5 year period that’s £3,600 a year/£300 a month (or 25% less ie £240 a month if you put in a LISA). If you invested/obtained interest probably £200 ish a month each would have likely got there. My daughter saves that easily by not buying a Pret lunch or similar 20 days a month but instead takes in a packed lunch.

    of course different situations mean different things and many don’t/can’t live at home with parents (like I didn’t). But 2x people living with parents should be able to save 2-300 a month which will after 5 years easily get them on the property ladder.

    I have graduates who don’t live at home but rent a room and manage to save after 5 years to buy (yes often with a partner but not always, one lad who works for me started at 18, bought a flat in Chislehurst at 24 on his own and now at 30 is buying a house in Battersea with girlfriend)
    I think you live in a very different world than the average family tbh, nothing wrong with that but it changes your perspective on reality. Live at home until 25 and dont buy Pret, should be taught as financial advice at school :). 
    Not at all, I’ve been in tough times, one pay check away from homelessness etc.

    only yesterday, I sat in my lunch hour with my new apprentice, first pay day explaining his pay slip (he had no idea what national insurance was). Explaining tax, how compound interest works 80/20 rule etc. helped him open a 212 ISA which whilst small he’s paying in £150 in the S&S and £100 into cash.

    there should absolutely be basic finance training in schools, currently in my experience there is none of any value.

    My point on Pret, most of the 18/21 year olds (more the 18 and those who live with parents) buy lunch in the city, anywhere between £10-12 a day, sometimes more. As a minimum that’s £200 a month. That alone over 5 years in a LISA with a bit of growth will be towards £20k. Many save much more (especially as salary progresses and bonuses etc). A lot of the grads are used to budgeting from Uni. I do a monthly lunch and learn where we go through things like this, it’s become a competition as to who’s had the most growth, all practical but also fun.

     I’ve 23/24 year olds (granted still at home) with more than £50k saved. Similar with the grads by a year or two older, some who also rent as not from around London originally.
  • Huskaris
    Huskaris Posts: 10,022
    Also, to all those talking about the budget and saying they think it will be a damp squib clearly haven't been paying attention to the news recently. 

    If my experience of being on buses/trains this year, fining morons £100 a pop for playing things out loud on their phones is going to give the chancellor at least £20bn in headroom ;)
  • Rob7Lee
    Rob7Lee Posts: 10,076
    Rob7Lee said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    Lets frame this another way the people that lived in our house before us were able to buy this house as their first home he was a postman and she didnt work. They were able to have 3 kids be mortgage free in a couple decades and live here most of their lives.

    For us its a very different prospect, we both had to be working in high paid high demand roles fitting in the HENRY 60% tax trap category and still needed family help even after a decade of saving (outlined above). We needed over £100k saved to cover deposit, stamp duty, fees etc. plus more for initial works to make the house safe. 

    And that was for a standard 3 bed starter home in suburban south east london (hardly a sought after bit of town) that needed completely ripping out and fully rennovating. Finances are still a massive factor in whether we have kids or not. 

    That level of change in a generation for the same standard of living is wild. 
    You’re in danger of sounding like Gary.

    my postman George (at a guess early to mid 30’s) moved from a flat in Erith to a 3 bed semi in Eltham. He’s managed to buy a family home for him, his wife and young child.

    I do think it’s a shame that there is this narrative that getting on the housing ladder is difficult to impossible. Whilst is is (impossible) for some, and difficult for most, especially around the SE, far too many I feel give up too easily before they have begun. I know a number of people my wife works with who quote that narrative, yet (as I did with one) you go through the numbers and a 3-5 year plan (including managing spending!) you find it is possible (no one is saying easy).

    I work in an industry where there is no reason that 95% of the youngest that join at 18 or 21 can’t buy a place by around 25/26. Generally they all do eventually, just takes some a long longer to do so than others, those who start the saving with their second pay check (I generally tell them to blow the 1st) are good to go by 25, others only realise at 25 that they’ve spent the last 4-7 years wasting decent money.

    My daughter 26 and her boyfriend have saved enough to put down at least a 35% deposit on a £450k house. Yes helped by living at home with parents, but even if they hadn’t the last couple of years they would have still saved enough for a deposit.

    and no offence on this, but if you and your wife are both earning north of £100k each, saved for over a decade and got help (I assume you are talking about financial help) from family, what sort of mansion do you live in, in your surburbia starter home….. that needed work to make it safe!?! Time for @golfaddick
    I'll bet Georges wife is working too though. 

    I agree that its not impossible for a lot of people and that some do give up too easily. But equally dimishing the challenges and the clear intergenerational inequality being created by this inheritocracy system as a "narrative" when it is very real and being felt by a majority of people in that group is dangerous. Just look at the inequality protests happening across Europe right now. We should not dismiss those concerns. 

    On your last point there was obviously wage progression in that decade of saving, I thought that was clear by the earlier references to promotions. Much of that period we were on much lower grad scheme salaries while we saved. or even lower while we studied. It then took working through the levels as quickly as possible to get there. We both got there around the time we bought our house (think it might have been a little after for me) which was what enabled us to borrow enough. Its a standard 3 bed semi.


    As I always say on here none of my views are to benefit me personally. I'll be absolutely fine. I have a house, investments and 2 high incomes and a whole bunch of safety nets. At some point we will inherit decent sums from remaining grandparents and parents. I have no worries about me personally (well beyond the existential threats...). Its not about me. Its about society, people I know who are stuggling, people I dont know, single parents, disabled people, those in temporary housing, people in the care system. The people who "life happens to" and leaves them worse off through no fault of their own.
    No idea if his wife works or not. He's a bright lad, assume he does overtime as he's often the postie who delivers parcels in the van at the weekend, for all I know he may have another job as well.

    On intergenerational inequality and specifically wages - at 18 (1990/1991) I worked for a Lloyds syndicate, I remember it vividly as I started on £5016 the end of 1989 at 16 and then a bit over a year layer got almost a 20% rise putting me on exactly £6k. £6k in 1991 to today (BoE inflation calculator) becomes £14,880. We pay our 18 year old apprentices pretty much to the pound double that.

    I'm now somewhat confused by your own personal situation examples, 2 x £100k+ wages, a house, investments and a whole bunch of safety nets and planned inheritance, yet your finances are still a massive factor on whether to have kids or not?

    I do think there has become a widening gap for the young, mainly between themselves though and the vast difference (and I hate this term but gives the idea) of the haves and have nots. Unemployment for under 25's is out of control really and a lot needs to be done there or there will be a huge swathe of a whole generation struggling (as there is no way benefits can continue as they are). We also need to do much better than University being the main option at 18.

    We need to give the young opportunities, but as I often quote when I'm speaking to groups who come in for work experience days, equal opportunity doesn't automatically mean equal outcomes, one of the reasons I am not a fan of private education.
    Unfortunately anecdote =/= data. You are well aware that average salaries have not kept pace with inflation for decades as we've done this one plenty of times before.

    On my personal circumstances. It's like you've missed the point of the entire conversation and the meaning of the HENRY term. 

    High tax rates, plus graduate tax an extra 9%, plus repayment of masters loans for us both means that take home pay doesnt reflect headline salary. Last few pay rises for either of us have barely moved the take home. Ability to borrow is calculated off headline salary doesn't take into account deductions. A huge mortgage which its interest rate just more than trebled. Just drained savings and borrowed a bit to do this extension on the house, significantly more cash needed to finish other works on the house. Disposable income isn't enough to feel like we would be able to do justice to raising the next generation. We would be ineligible for any childcare scheme so the cost of that would be as much as a mortgage all over again per child, or one of us would have to drop at least 50% of our hours losing massive amounts of income. 

    Yes we have safety nets. Safety nets that others don't always have in the sense of family who would look after us or we could live with or in the sense of critical illness cover etc. I said "We will be fine" in the context of relative to people who are genuinely struggling. We will always have somewhere to live, never be at risk of homelessness and we have in demand skills so will always be able to get a job even in an AI world. 

    Unfortunately your last paragraph is a bit out of date. It's a 2004 talking point - thats when that line was actually being used in politics and it was at the time a gebuine conversation to be had. Things have moved so far since then. If you think there is anything close to equality of opportunities out there anymore you're delusional. Social mobility has dropped off a cliff in the last 20 years. In the vast majority of cases for a child born now their social class is decided the day they are born. And that is the fundamental problem.

    My last paragraph wasn't suggesting we have achieved equality of opportunity (in fact I was making the point we haven't, i.e. why I don't really agree with private education as it is probably the biggest stifle of equal opportunity for young people).

    People often assume equal opportunity results in equality of outcomes, it doesn't. I'm sure we all know many people who had equal opportunity/upbringing but have seen very different outcomes. I often talk to groups who come from underprivileged backgrounds, that point resonates with them, in that we can flip it to be just because they haven't had the same opportunity (i.e. education opportunity) as someone else doesn't mean they have to have worse outcomes. They may just have to do things differently to get to that place. We need to stop putting people in buckets based on accident of birth and saying that means they can't do well, yes as a society we need to do more but there is also personal responsibility.

    If you honestly both earn north of £100k and even take off gross your student loans (which at that level will be paid back pretty quickly), then no offence but at those salary levels (or even take 85% of) you should really be very well set up financially. You must be clearing towards a 5 figure sum between you a month, top of the DINKY's, so you shouldn't need worry about doing justice to raising children or need help with childcare.
    The bit in bold worries me a lot. Its become a Farage talking point in the last year or so and has been repeated in the likes of the mail and telegraph opinion pieces repeatedly. It makes out that the problem of social mobility is a psychological one and that if we would just stop talking about it suddenly people would be able to change their situations. And whilst there will always be a few anecdotes of where that might work in reality the problem is systemic. Areas with the most need have the worst infrastructure, worst service provision, worst schools, worst healthcare etc etc.

    If we look at it from my area of focus at work (health and welfare) your IMD decile at birth determines your life expectancy and more importantly healthy life expectancy. That then determines the number of years you are dependent on the NHS in later life (for the most deprived decile this is the last 3rd of their life) and therefore how much of your life you are able to work - for the most deprived decile this point comes 20 years before the least deprived and almost all of that falls when they are of working age. As a result of the systemic issues mentioned above these people experience the longest waits for planned care and the longer you spend on a waiting list the less likely you are to return to work (can't remember the stats off the top of my head but have quoted them on this thread before) and the more likely you are to develop mental health needs as well. Its a funnel that can catch people from all walks of life but some are being actively pushed towards it. We need to address these systemic issues before we can put it down to personal responsibility. And to solve those systemic issues we need to talk about it more not less!

    This talking point has been used to justify a lack of action on social mobility and even preventing actions.

    On my personal circumstances you've ignored the cost side of things. Huge mortgage and rates trebled. And yes obviously weve been saving but some tied up in pensions and investments and weve just emptied out savings into work on the house. A lot more needed on the house in the next 2 years too.

    And the childcare costs these are the same as a mortgage PER CHILD if you don't get the 30 hours free and still work full time. That's not affordable in the next 2 years if we want to finish the house. And that's before we talk about maternity pay. 

    You're also underestimating the student loan factor a lot. I remember you saying your daughters didn't need the system so understandable if you don't know how it works. Let me put it this way - I've paid back pretty much what I originally "borrowed" but now "owe" 19k more than I originally borrowed. It is a loan only in name, it is structured to be a 30(or 40 depending on age) year graduate tax other than for those with rich parents. I got particularly unlucky in that as my earnings grew interest rates were soaring and so it took me a hell of a long time and a wildly high salary to even cover the interest. Without lump sum early repayment I'll likely pay back 3-3.5 times what I borrowed depending on what rates do. Masters loan is another 6% graduate tax on top. Bit at least this one is whittling down and there is an end in sight. 

    Add these stealth taxes to income tax and NI plus factor in my work place pension contributions and my marginal take home is 8p in the £. 
    With respect, absolutely your choices as to what you spend your money on, how big a house you buy/what work required, how big a mortgage etc. If you are hesitating as to if you can afford children, yet both earn north of £100k, I don't think you will get much empathy. And at that level of earnings I do not believe the government should be helping you with childcare costs.

    I know fully how the student loan system works plan 1/2 and 4/5 and post grad, another thing I often go through with the Grads when they wonder why they are getting deductions, one of my actuaries has built a spreadsheet they can complete to work it all out as their salary changes, how long to repay etc and if worth paying off more earlier with bonus's or more each month (95% of the time it is worthwhile for them because of the ridiculous interest rates). Maximum if you have both loans is 15% above the relevant threshold. If you are concerned how much you will ultimately pay back, check what your mortgage will actually costs over 25/30/35 years.

    8p in the pound, behave, so your £100k annual salary results in less than £700 a month.

    The point in bold has nothing to do with the likes of Farage, I made the point we need to stop putting young people in buckets, if we do so then don't be surprised the outcomes are as the data suggests it will be. Maybe if we helped the younger generation to see regardless of background there are opportunities we/they would see different outcomes. But as I also said, as a society we also need to do much more to try and even up those opportunities. I have a real mixture of apprentices, some come from affluent backgrounds, some from very poor backgrounds, some privately educated, some went to very poor state schools. My advice to them - you are all equal, you have the same opportunity, the outcomes now comes down to you (broadly). It's never lost on me that and whilst I am generalising, in the main those from the poorer backgrounds are the most hungry to succeed and often are the one's who do.

  • Sponsored links:



  • shine166
    shine166 Posts: 14,818
    edited October 24
    Rob7Lee said:
    shine166 said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    shine166 said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    Lets frame this another way the people that lived in our house before us were able to buy this house as their first home he was a postman and she didnt work. They were able to have 3 kids be mortgage free in a couple decades and live here most of their lives.

    For us its a very different prospect, we both had to be working in high paid high demand roles fitting in the HENRY 60% tax trap category and still needed family help even after a decade of saving (outlined above). We needed over £100k saved to cover deposit, stamp duty, fees etc. plus more for initial works to make the house safe. 

    And that was for a standard 3 bed starter home in suburban south east london (hardly a sought after bit of town) that needed completely ripping out and fully rennovating. Finances are still a massive factor in whether we have kids or not. 

    That level of change in a generation for the same standard of living is wild. 
    You’re in danger of sounding like Gary.

    my postman George (at a guess early to mid 30’s) moved from a flat in Erith to a 3 bed semi in Eltham. He’s managed to buy a family home for him, his wife and young child.

    I do think it’s a shame that there is this narrative that getting on the housing ladder is difficult to impossible. Whilst is is (impossible) for some, and difficult for most, especially around the SE, far too many I feel give up too easily before they have begun. I know a number of people my wife works with who quote that narrative, yet (as I did with one) you go through the numbers and a 3-5 year plan (including managing spending!) you find it is possible (no one is saying easy).

    I work in an industry where there is no reason that 95% of the youngest that join at 18 or 21 can’t buy a place by around 25/26. Generally they all do eventually, just takes some a long longer to do so than others, those who start the saving with their second pay check (I generally tell them to blow the 1st) are good to go by 25, others only realise at 25 that they’ve spent the last 4-7 years wasting decent money.

    My daughter 26 and her boyfriend have saved enough to put down at least a 35% deposit on a £450k house. Yes helped by living at home with parents, but even if they hadn’t the last couple of years they would have still saved enough for a deposit.

    and no offence on this, but if you and your wife are both earning north of £100k each, saved for over a decade and got help (I assume you are talking about financial help) from family, what sort of mansion do you live in, in your surburbia starter home….. that needed work to make it safe!?! Time for @golfaddick
    The average couple of 26 year olds, are not saving 150k + in a 4/5 years period... especially if they dont live at home. Thats literally 50% of mine and my wife's income in that time frame and we are 39 & 43 years old. 

    We purchased our first home this year, the rent on the previous property was £1450 PM.
    Agreed, which is why I pointed out they were both at home (I do charge rent though 😉) and they didn’t need to save that amount (other than to lower costs).

    but they could buy a £250k flat rather than a £450k house, so would have needed say £35k saved between them, call it £18k each which in a 5 year period that’s £3,600 a year/£300 a month (or 25% less ie £240 a month if you put in a LISA). If you invested/obtained interest probably £200 ish a month each would have likely got there. My daughter saves that easily by not buying a Pret lunch or similar 20 days a month but instead takes in a packed lunch.

    of course different situations mean different things and many don’t/can’t live at home with parents (like I didn’t). But 2x people living with parents should be able to save 2-300 a month which will after 5 years easily get them on the property ladder.

    I have graduates who don’t live at home but rent a room and manage to save after 5 years to buy (yes often with a partner but not always, one lad who works for me started at 18, bought a flat in Chislehurst at 24 on his own and now at 30 is buying a house in Battersea with girlfriend)
    I think you live in a very different world than the average family tbh, nothing wrong with that but it changes your perspective on reality. Live at home until 25 and dont buy Pret, should be taught as financial advice at school :). 
    Not at all, I’ve been in tough times, one pay check away from homelessness etc.

    only yesterday, I sat in my lunch hour with my new apprentice, first pay day explaining his pay slip (he had no idea what national insurance was). Explaining tax, how compound interest works 80/20 rule etc. helped him open a 212 ISA which whilst small he’s paying in £150 in the S&S and £100 into cash.

    there should absolutely be basic finance training in schools, currently in my experience there is none of any value.

    My point on Pret, most of the 18/21 year olds (more the 18 and those who live with parents) buy lunch in the city, anywhere between £10-12 a day, sometimes more. As a minimum that’s £200 a month. That alone over 5 years in a LISA with a bit of growth will be towards £20k. Many save much more (especially as salary progresses and bonuses etc). A lot of the grads are used to budgeting from Uni. I do a monthly lunch and learn where we go through things like this, it’s become a competition as to who’s had the most growth, all practical but also fun.

     I’ve 23/24 year olds (granted still at home) with more than £50k saved. Similar with the grads by a year or two older, some who also rent as not from around London originally.
    The lack of financial education in schools is bordering on neglect. Literally all i remember being taught at school is how to fill out a cheque when I was 11.

    All of my learning has been through mistakes, which is unfortunate as I should/ could have been at least a decade into a mortgage now. Luckily ive made some decent Art purchases over the years or id have absolutely no long term savings either.
  • Carter
    Carter Posts: 14,848
    shine166 said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    shine166 said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    shine166 said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    Lets frame this another way the people that lived in our house before us were able to buy this house as their first home he was a postman and she didnt work. They were able to have 3 kids be mortgage free in a couple decades and live here most of their lives.

    For us its a very different prospect, we both had to be working in high paid high demand roles fitting in the HENRY 60% tax trap category and still needed family help even after a decade of saving (outlined above). We needed over £100k saved to cover deposit, stamp duty, fees etc. plus more for initial works to make the house safe. 

    And that was for a standard 3 bed starter home in suburban south east london (hardly a sought after bit of town) that needed completely ripping out and fully rennovating. Finances are still a massive factor in whether we have kids or not. 

    That level of change in a generation for the same standard of living is wild. 
    You’re in danger of sounding like Gary.

    my postman George (at a guess early to mid 30’s) moved from a flat in Erith to a 3 bed semi in Eltham. He’s managed to buy a family home for him, his wife and young child.

    I do think it’s a shame that there is this narrative that getting on the housing ladder is difficult to impossible. Whilst is is (impossible) for some, and difficult for most, especially around the SE, far too many I feel give up too easily before they have begun. I know a number of people my wife works with who quote that narrative, yet (as I did with one) you go through the numbers and a 3-5 year plan (including managing spending!) you find it is possible (no one is saying easy).

    I work in an industry where there is no reason that 95% of the youngest that join at 18 or 21 can’t buy a place by around 25/26. Generally they all do eventually, just takes some a long longer to do so than others, those who start the saving with their second pay check (I generally tell them to blow the 1st) are good to go by 25, others only realise at 25 that they’ve spent the last 4-7 years wasting decent money.

    My daughter 26 and her boyfriend have saved enough to put down at least a 35% deposit on a £450k house. Yes helped by living at home with parents, but even if they hadn’t the last couple of years they would have still saved enough for a deposit.

    and no offence on this, but if you and your wife are both earning north of £100k each, saved for over a decade and got help (I assume you are talking about financial help) from family, what sort of mansion do you live in, in your surburbia starter home….. that needed work to make it safe!?! Time for @golfaddick
    The average couple of 26 year olds, are not saving 150k + in a 4/5 years period... especially if they dont live at home. Thats literally 50% of mine and my wife's income in that time frame and we are 39 & 43 years old. 

    We purchased our first home this year, the rent on the previous property was £1450 PM.
    Agreed, which is why I pointed out they were both at home (I do charge rent though 😉) and they didn’t need to save that amount (other than to lower costs).

    but they could buy a £250k flat rather than a £450k house, so would have needed say £35k saved between them, call it £18k each which in a 5 year period that’s £3,600 a year/£300 a month (or 25% less ie £240 a month if you put in a LISA). If you invested/obtained interest probably £200 ish a month each would have likely got there. My daughter saves that easily by not buying a Pret lunch or similar 20 days a month but instead takes in a packed lunch.

    of course different situations mean different things and many don’t/can’t live at home with parents (like I didn’t). But 2x people living with parents should be able to save 2-300 a month which will after 5 years easily get them on the property ladder.

    I have graduates who don’t live at home but rent a room and manage to save after 5 years to buy (yes often with a partner but not always, one lad who works for me started at 18, bought a flat in Chislehurst at 24 on his own and now at 30 is buying a house in Battersea with girlfriend)
    I think you live in a very different world than the average family tbh, nothing wrong with that but it changes your perspective on reality. Live at home until 25 and dont buy Pret, should be taught as financial advice at school :). 
    Not at all, I’ve been in tough times, one pay check away from homelessness etc.

    only yesterday, I sat in my lunch hour with my new apprentice, first pay day explaining his pay slip (he had no idea what national insurance was). Explaining tax, how compound interest works 80/20 rule etc. helped him open a 212 ISA which whilst small he’s paying in £150 in the S&S and £100 into cash.

    there should absolutely be basic finance training in schools, currently in my experience there is none of any value.

    My point on Pret, most of the 18/21 year olds (more the 18 and those who live with parents) buy lunch in the city, anywhere between £10-12 a day, sometimes more. As a minimum that’s £200 a month. That alone over 5 years in a LISA with a bit of growth will be towards £20k. Many save much more (especially as salary progresses and bonuses etc). A lot of the grads are used to budgeting from Uni. I do a monthly lunch and learn where we go through things like this, it’s become a competition as to who’s had the most growth, all practical but also fun.

     I’ve 23/24 year olds (granted still at home) with more than £50k saved. Similar with the grads by a year or two older, some who also rent as not from around London originally.
    The lack of financial education in schools is bordering on neglect. Literally all i remember being taught at school is how to fill out a cheque when I was 11.

    All of my learning has been through mistakes, which is unfortunate as I should/ could have been at least a decade into a mortgage now. Luckily ive made some decent Art purchases over the years or id have absolutely no long term savings either.
    Snap

    All my financial literacy has been done the hard way. This thread has been a lot of help, reading about money, listening to podcasts. All self-sourced. I recall the lesson about being taught how to write a cheque. 

    Something else you said pricked my ears up. You'd made some good art purchases which have risen in value presumably. My windfalls have been from similar gambles, mainly route 1 with rolls royce shares during covid and the non-priveleged problem that gave me was what to do with this sum of money I had available (apart from have to pay an extortionate amount of CGT). We don't really know what to do with it when we get it. Those who have been born into money or are used to having a lump of cash are much better versed in what to do other than spunk it, which is something the working class excel at and in fairness is the furnace if the economy. First time I got a unexpected tax rebate in the early 2000s, knowing what I know now I'd have fed it into premium bonds or found something sensible and longer-term beneficial. Nah, straight up to Oxford street and bought a stone island bomber jacket before getting my car resprayed 

    Thats why I cannot have nice things 
  • Friend Or Defoe
    Friend Or Defoe Posts: 18,401
    Huskaris said:
    Saying kids these days are lazy is also nonsense and has been said for as long as i can remember. When i was there age i was out cleaning chimneys... The irony of posting it during working hours isn't lost on me.
    I am genuinely shocked at how people currently aged between 20-28 are (on average!!!!) compared to people who are my age (35).
    What event occurred during the start of your career that made young people more lazy?

    Whilst you think it over, here's an article from 2011 claiming your generation are lazy.

    https://archive.nytimes.com/economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/05/31/the-laziest-generations/?eafs_enabled=false
  • Huskaris
    Huskaris Posts: 10,022
    edited October 24
    Huskaris said:
    Saying kids these days are lazy is also nonsense and has been said for as long as i can remember. When i was there age i was out cleaning chimneys... The irony of posting it during working hours isn't lost on me.
    I am genuinely shocked at how people currently aged between 20-28 are (on average!!!!) compared to people who are my age (35).
    What event occurred during the start of your career that made young people more lazy?

    Whilst you think it over, here's an article from 2011 claiming your generation are lazy.

    https://archive.nytimes.com/economix.blogs.nytimes.com/2011/05/31/the-laziest-generations/?eafs_enabled=false
    I said "how they are" rather than specifically saying lazy, but I do believe each generation has been a harder working, and more resilient generation than the one after it (and I include my generation in that). Some would say that's a sign of progress.
  • cantersaddick
    cantersaddick Posts: 19,050
    edited October 24
    Rob7Lee said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    Lets frame this another way the people that lived in our house before us were able to buy this house as their first home he was a postman and she didnt work. They were able to have 3 kids be mortgage free in a couple decades and live here most of their lives.

    For us its a very different prospect, we both had to be working in high paid high demand roles fitting in the HENRY 60% tax trap category and still needed family help even after a decade of saving (outlined above). We needed over £100k saved to cover deposit, stamp duty, fees etc. plus more for initial works to make the house safe. 

    And that was for a standard 3 bed starter home in suburban south east london (hardly a sought after bit of town) that needed completely ripping out and fully rennovating. Finances are still a massive factor in whether we have kids or not. 

    That level of change in a generation for the same standard of living is wild. 
    You’re in danger of sounding like Gary.

    my postman George (at a guess early to mid 30’s) moved from a flat in Erith to a 3 bed semi in Eltham. He’s managed to buy a family home for him, his wife and young child.

    I do think it’s a shame that there is this narrative that getting on the housing ladder is difficult to impossible. Whilst is is (impossible) for some, and difficult for most, especially around the SE, far too many I feel give up too easily before they have begun. I know a number of people my wife works with who quote that narrative, yet (as I did with one) you go through the numbers and a 3-5 year plan (including managing spending!) you find it is possible (no one is saying easy).

    I work in an industry where there is no reason that 95% of the youngest that join at 18 or 21 can’t buy a place by around 25/26. Generally they all do eventually, just takes some a long longer to do so than others, those who start the saving with their second pay check (I generally tell them to blow the 1st) are good to go by 25, others only realise at 25 that they’ve spent the last 4-7 years wasting decent money.

    My daughter 26 and her boyfriend have saved enough to put down at least a 35% deposit on a £450k house. Yes helped by living at home with parents, but even if they hadn’t the last couple of years they would have still saved enough for a deposit.

    and no offence on this, but if you and your wife are both earning north of £100k each, saved for over a decade and got help (I assume you are talking about financial help) from family, what sort of mansion do you live in, in your surburbia starter home….. that needed work to make it safe!?! Time for @golfaddick
    I'll bet Georges wife is working too though. 

    I agree that its not impossible for a lot of people and that some do give up too easily. But equally dimishing the challenges and the clear intergenerational inequality being created by this inheritocracy system as a "narrative" when it is very real and being felt by a majority of people in that group is dangerous. Just look at the inequality protests happening across Europe right now. We should not dismiss those concerns. 

    On your last point there was obviously wage progression in that decade of saving, I thought that was clear by the earlier references to promotions. Much of that period we were on much lower grad scheme salaries while we saved. or even lower while we studied. It then took working through the levels as quickly as possible to get there. We both got there around the time we bought our house (think it might have been a little after for me) which was what enabled us to borrow enough. Its a standard 3 bed semi.


    As I always say on here none of my views are to benefit me personally. I'll be absolutely fine. I have a house, investments and 2 high incomes and a whole bunch of safety nets. At some point we will inherit decent sums from remaining grandparents and parents. I have no worries about me personally (well beyond the existential threats...). Its not about me. Its about society, people I know who are stuggling, people I dont know, single parents, disabled people, those in temporary housing, people in the care system. The people who "life happens to" and leaves them worse off through no fault of their own.
    No idea if his wife works or not. He's a bright lad, assume he does overtime as he's often the postie who delivers parcels in the van at the weekend, for all I know he may have another job as well.

    On intergenerational inequality and specifically wages - at 18 (1990/1991) I worked for a Lloyds syndicate, I remember it vividly as I started on £5016 the end of 1989 at 16 and then a bit over a year layer got almost a 20% rise putting me on exactly £6k. £6k in 1991 to today (BoE inflation calculator) becomes £14,880. We pay our 18 year old apprentices pretty much to the pound double that.

    I'm now somewhat confused by your own personal situation examples, 2 x £100k+ wages, a house, investments and a whole bunch of safety nets and planned inheritance, yet your finances are still a massive factor on whether to have kids or not?

    I do think there has become a widening gap for the young, mainly between themselves though and the vast difference (and I hate this term but gives the idea) of the haves and have nots. Unemployment for under 25's is out of control really and a lot needs to be done there or there will be a huge swathe of a whole generation struggling (as there is no way benefits can continue as they are). We also need to do much better than University being the main option at 18.

    We need to give the young opportunities, but as I often quote when I'm speaking to groups who come in for work experience days, equal opportunity doesn't automatically mean equal outcomes, one of the reasons I am not a fan of private education.
    Unfortunately anecdote =/= data. You are well aware that average salaries have not kept pace with inflation for decades as we've done this one plenty of times before.

    On my personal circumstances. It's like you've missed the point of the entire conversation and the meaning of the HENRY term. 

    High tax rates, plus graduate tax an extra 9%, plus repayment of masters loans for us both means that take home pay doesnt reflect headline salary. Last few pay rises for either of us have barely moved the take home. Ability to borrow is calculated off headline salary doesn't take into account deductions. A huge mortgage which its interest rate just more than trebled. Just drained savings and borrowed a bit to do this extension on the house, significantly more cash needed to finish other works on the house. Disposable income isn't enough to feel like we would be able to do justice to raising the next generation. We would be ineligible for any childcare scheme so the cost of that would be as much as a mortgage all over again per child, or one of us would have to drop at least 50% of our hours losing massive amounts of income. 

    Yes we have safety nets. Safety nets that others don't always have in the sense of family who would look after us or we could live with or in the sense of critical illness cover etc. I said "We will be fine" in the context of relative to people who are genuinely struggling. We will always have somewhere to live, never be at risk of homelessness and we have in demand skills so will always be able to get a job even in an AI world. 

    Unfortunately your last paragraph is a bit out of date. It's a 2004 talking point - thats when that line was actually being used in politics and it was at the time a gebuine conversation to be had. Things have moved so far since then. If you think there is anything close to equality of opportunities out there anymore you're delusional. Social mobility has dropped off a cliff in the last 20 years. In the vast majority of cases for a child born now their social class is decided the day they are born. And that is the fundamental problem.

    My last paragraph wasn't suggesting we have achieved equality of opportunity (in fact I was making the point we haven't, i.e. why I don't really agree with private education as it is probably the biggest stifle of equal opportunity for young people).

    People often assume equal opportunity results in equality of outcomes, it doesn't. I'm sure we all know many people who had equal opportunity/upbringing but have seen very different outcomes. I often talk to groups who come from underprivileged backgrounds, that point resonates with them, in that we can flip it to be just because they haven't had the same opportunity (i.e. education opportunity) as someone else doesn't mean they have to have worse outcomes. They may just have to do things differently to get to that place. We need to stop putting people in buckets based on accident of birth and saying that means they can't do well, yes as a society we need to do more but there is also personal responsibility.

    If you honestly both earn north of £100k and even take off gross your student loans (which at that level will be paid back pretty quickly), then no offence but at those salary levels (or even take 85% of) you should really be very well set up financially. You must be clearing towards a 5 figure sum between you a month, top of the DINKY's, so you shouldn't need worry about doing justice to raising children or need help with childcare.
    The bit in bold worries me a lot. Its become a Farage talking point in the last year or so and has been repeated in the likes of the mail and telegraph opinion pieces repeatedly. It makes out that the problem of social mobility is a psychological one and that if we would just stop talking about it suddenly people would be able to change their situations. And whilst there will always be a few anecdotes of where that might work in reality the problem is systemic. Areas with the most need have the worst infrastructure, worst service provision, worst schools, worst healthcare etc etc.

    If we look at it from my area of focus at work (health and welfare) your IMD decile at birth determines your life expectancy and more importantly healthy life expectancy. That then determines the number of years you are dependent on the NHS in later life (for the most deprived decile this is the last 3rd of their life) and therefore how much of your life you are able to work - for the most deprived decile this point comes 20 years before the least deprived and almost all of that falls when they are of working age. As a result of the systemic issues mentioned above these people experience the longest waits for planned care and the longer you spend on a waiting list the less likely you are to return to work (can't remember the stats off the top of my head but have quoted them on this thread before) and the more likely you are to develop mental health needs as well. Its a funnel that can catch people from all walks of life but some are being actively pushed towards it. We need to address these systemic issues before we can put it down to personal responsibility. And to solve those systemic issues we need to talk about it more not less!

    This talking point has been used to justify a lack of action on social mobility and even preventing actions.

    On my personal circumstances you've ignored the cost side of things. Huge mortgage and rates trebled. And yes obviously weve been saving but some tied up in pensions and investments and weve just emptied out savings into work on the house. A lot more needed on the house in the next 2 years too.

    And the childcare costs these are the same as a mortgage PER CHILD if you don't get the 30 hours free and still work full time. That's not affordable in the next 2 years if we want to finish the house. And that's before we talk about maternity pay. 

    You're also underestimating the student loan factor a lot. I remember you saying your daughters didn't need the system so understandable if you don't know how it works. Let me put it this way - I've paid back pretty much what I originally "borrowed" but now "owe" 19k more than I originally borrowed. It is a loan only in name, it is structured to be a 30(or 40 depending on age) year graduate tax other than for those with rich parents. I got particularly unlucky in that as my earnings grew interest rates were soaring and so it took me a hell of a long time and a wildly high salary to even cover the interest. Without lump sum early repayment I'll likely pay back 3-3.5 times what I borrowed depending on what rates do. Masters loan is another 6% graduate tax on top. Bit at least this one is whittling down and there is an end in sight. 

    Add these stealth taxes to income tax and NI plus factor in my work place pension contributions and my marginal take home is 8p in the £. 
    With respect, absolutely your choices as to what you spend your money on, how big a house you buy/what work required, how big a mortgage etc. If you are hesitating as to if you can afford children, yet both earn north of £100k, I don't think you will get much empathy. And at that level of earnings I do not believe the government should be helping you with childcare costs.

    I know fully how the student loan system works plan 1/2 and 4/5 and post grad, another thing I often go through with the Grads when they wonder why they are getting deductions, one of my actuaries has built a spreadsheet they can complete to work it all out as their salary changes, how long to repay etc and if worth paying off more earlier with bonus's or more each month (95% of the time it is worthwhile for them because of the ridiculous interest rates). Maximum if you have both loans is 15% above the relevant threshold. If you are concerned how much you will ultimately pay back, check what your mortgage will actually costs over 25/30/35 years.

    8p in the pound, behave, so your £100k annual salary results in less than £700 a month.

    The point in bold has nothing to do with the likes of Farage, I made the point we need to stop putting young people in buckets, if we do so then don't be surprised the outcomes are as the data suggests it will be. Maybe if we helped the younger generation to see regardless of background there are opportunities we/they would see different outcomes. But as I also said, as a society we also need to do much more to try and even up those opportunities. I have a real mixture of apprentices, some come from affluent backgrounds, some from very poor backgrounds, some privately educated, some went to very poor state schools. My advice to them - you are all equal, you have the same opportunity, the outcomes now comes down to you (broadly). It's never lost on me that and whilst I am generalising, in the main those from the poorer backgrounds are the most hungry to succeed and often are the one's who do.
    Yes it's a choice and I'm not looking for sympathy. And I certainly didn't ask for any. I'm using an example to demonstrate the change in a generation because a couple pages back you told me that the statistics didn't matter because "you can look at statistics, but I don’t think they often tell the full lived story" so I'm giving in great personal detail my lived story. 

    I'm not after any sympathy at all but more demonstrating the change in the last 1 and a half generations. As I said our house is a standard zone 4/5 border south east london/kent 3 bed which was previously owned by a postie whose wife didn't work. That change is scary for a society no matter how you look at it. If your soluton is to just buy smaller or buy less or buy further out then that kinda demonstrates the point that what was achievable for the normal family is much harder to achieve even for top earners now. And again demonstrates the scale of the change in such a short period of time.

    I said MARGINAL take home. Surely after so long in the sector you know what that term means.

    It may not have anything to do with Farage but it's a  talking point he's been regularly repeating. As I said I think it's an incredibly dangerous narrative to pupport. You want young people to take personal responsibility for defying the odds that society has stacked against them. My point is that simply telling them to do it through hard work is not enough. You want them to take responsibility the best thing to do is to talk about it more, raise the profile of the issues and to show them what we are doing about it, show us we are investing in the community, their local services and their future. Give them something visible they can see is worth working for. Show them we are fixing the structural systemic issues that worsen their life chances and give them hope it'll actually be worth it! As I said if we are serious about  solving those systemic issues we need to talk about it more not less.
  • Rob7Lee
    Rob7Lee Posts: 10,076
    Rob7Lee said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    Rob7Lee said:
    Lets frame this another way the people that lived in our house before us were able to buy this house as their first home he was a postman and she didnt work. They were able to have 3 kids be mortgage free in a couple decades and live here most of their lives.

    For us its a very different prospect, we both had to be working in high paid high demand roles fitting in the HENRY 60% tax trap category and still needed family help even after a decade of saving (outlined above). We needed over £100k saved to cover deposit, stamp duty, fees etc. plus more for initial works to make the house safe. 

    And that was for a standard 3 bed starter home in suburban south east london (hardly a sought after bit of town) that needed completely ripping out and fully rennovating. Finances are still a massive factor in whether we have kids or not. 

    That level of change in a generation for the same standard of living is wild. 
    You’re in danger of sounding like Gary.

    my postman George (at a guess early to mid 30’s) moved from a flat in Erith to a 3 bed semi in Eltham. He’s managed to buy a family home for him, his wife and young child.

    I do think it’s a shame that there is this narrative that getting on the housing ladder is difficult to impossible. Whilst is is (impossible) for some, and difficult for most, especially around the SE, far too many I feel give up too easily before they have begun. I know a number of people my wife works with who quote that narrative, yet (as I did with one) you go through the numbers and a 3-5 year plan (including managing spending!) you find it is possible (no one is saying easy).

    I work in an industry where there is no reason that 95% of the youngest that join at 18 or 21 can’t buy a place by around 25/26. Generally they all do eventually, just takes some a long longer to do so than others, those who start the saving with their second pay check (I generally tell them to blow the 1st) are good to go by 25, others only realise at 25 that they’ve spent the last 4-7 years wasting decent money.

    My daughter 26 and her boyfriend have saved enough to put down at least a 35% deposit on a £450k house. Yes helped by living at home with parents, but even if they hadn’t the last couple of years they would have still saved enough for a deposit.

    and no offence on this, but if you and your wife are both earning north of £100k each, saved for over a decade and got help (I assume you are talking about financial help) from family, what sort of mansion do you live in, in your surburbia starter home….. that needed work to make it safe!?! Time for @golfaddick
    I'll bet Georges wife is working too though. 

    I agree that its not impossible for a lot of people and that some do give up too easily. But equally dimishing the challenges and the clear intergenerational inequality being created by this inheritocracy system as a "narrative" when it is very real and being felt by a majority of people in that group is dangerous. Just look at the inequality protests happening across Europe right now. We should not dismiss those concerns. 

    On your last point there was obviously wage progression in that decade of saving, I thought that was clear by the earlier references to promotions. Much of that period we were on much lower grad scheme salaries while we saved. or even lower while we studied. It then took working through the levels as quickly as possible to get there. We both got there around the time we bought our house (think it might have been a little after for me) which was what enabled us to borrow enough. Its a standard 3 bed semi.


    As I always say on here none of my views are to benefit me personally. I'll be absolutely fine. I have a house, investments and 2 high incomes and a whole bunch of safety nets. At some point we will inherit decent sums from remaining grandparents and parents. I have no worries about me personally (well beyond the existential threats...). Its not about me. Its about society, people I know who are stuggling, people I dont know, single parents, disabled people, those in temporary housing, people in the care system. The people who "life happens to" and leaves them worse off through no fault of their own.
    No idea if his wife works or not. He's a bright lad, assume he does overtime as he's often the postie who delivers parcels in the van at the weekend, for all I know he may have another job as well.

    On intergenerational inequality and specifically wages - at 18 (1990/1991) I worked for a Lloyds syndicate, I remember it vividly as I started on £5016 the end of 1989 at 16 and then a bit over a year layer got almost a 20% rise putting me on exactly £6k. £6k in 1991 to today (BoE inflation calculator) becomes £14,880. We pay our 18 year old apprentices pretty much to the pound double that.

    I'm now somewhat confused by your own personal situation examples, 2 x £100k+ wages, a house, investments and a whole bunch of safety nets and planned inheritance, yet your finances are still a massive factor on whether to have kids or not?

    I do think there has become a widening gap for the young, mainly between themselves though and the vast difference (and I hate this term but gives the idea) of the haves and have nots. Unemployment for under 25's is out of control really and a lot needs to be done there or there will be a huge swathe of a whole generation struggling (as there is no way benefits can continue as they are). We also need to do much better than University being the main option at 18.

    We need to give the young opportunities, but as I often quote when I'm speaking to groups who come in for work experience days, equal opportunity doesn't automatically mean equal outcomes, one of the reasons I am not a fan of private education.
    Unfortunately anecdote =/= data. You are well aware that average salaries have not kept pace with inflation for decades as we've done this one plenty of times before.

    On my personal circumstances. It's like you've missed the point of the entire conversation and the meaning of the HENRY term. 

    High tax rates, plus graduate tax an extra 9%, plus repayment of masters loans for us both means that take home pay doesnt reflect headline salary. Last few pay rises for either of us have barely moved the take home. Ability to borrow is calculated off headline salary doesn't take into account deductions. A huge mortgage which its interest rate just more than trebled. Just drained savings and borrowed a bit to do this extension on the house, significantly more cash needed to finish other works on the house. Disposable income isn't enough to feel like we would be able to do justice to raising the next generation. We would be ineligible for any childcare scheme so the cost of that would be as much as a mortgage all over again per child, or one of us would have to drop at least 50% of our hours losing massive amounts of income. 

    Yes we have safety nets. Safety nets that others don't always have in the sense of family who would look after us or we could live with or in the sense of critical illness cover etc. I said "We will be fine" in the context of relative to people who are genuinely struggling. We will always have somewhere to live, never be at risk of homelessness and we have in demand skills so will always be able to get a job even in an AI world. 

    Unfortunately your last paragraph is a bit out of date. It's a 2004 talking point - thats when that line was actually being used in politics and it was at the time a gebuine conversation to be had. Things have moved so far since then. If you think there is anything close to equality of opportunities out there anymore you're delusional. Social mobility has dropped off a cliff in the last 20 years. In the vast majority of cases for a child born now their social class is decided the day they are born. And that is the fundamental problem.

    My last paragraph wasn't suggesting we have achieved equality of opportunity (in fact I was making the point we haven't, i.e. why I don't really agree with private education as it is probably the biggest stifle of equal opportunity for young people).

    People often assume equal opportunity results in equality of outcomes, it doesn't. I'm sure we all know many people who had equal opportunity/upbringing but have seen very different outcomes. I often talk to groups who come from underprivileged backgrounds, that point resonates with them, in that we can flip it to be just because they haven't had the same opportunity (i.e. education opportunity) as someone else doesn't mean they have to have worse outcomes. They may just have to do things differently to get to that place. We need to stop putting people in buckets based on accident of birth and saying that means they can't do well, yes as a society we need to do more but there is also personal responsibility.

    If you honestly both earn north of £100k and even take off gross your student loans (which at that level will be paid back pretty quickly), then no offence but at those salary levels (or even take 85% of) you should really be very well set up financially. You must be clearing towards a 5 figure sum between you a month, top of the DINKY's, so you shouldn't need worry about doing justice to raising children or need help with childcare.
    The bit in bold worries me a lot. Its become a Farage talking point in the last year or so and has been repeated in the likes of the mail and telegraph opinion pieces repeatedly. It makes out that the problem of social mobility is a psychological one and that if we would just stop talking about it suddenly people would be able to change their situations. And whilst there will always be a few anecdotes of where that might work in reality the problem is systemic. Areas with the most need have the worst infrastructure, worst service provision, worst schools, worst healthcare etc etc.

    If we look at it from my area of focus at work (health and welfare) your IMD decile at birth determines your life expectancy and more importantly healthy life expectancy. That then determines the number of years you are dependent on the NHS in later life (for the most deprived decile this is the last 3rd of their life) and therefore how much of your life you are able to work - for the most deprived decile this point comes 20 years before the least deprived and almost all of that falls when they are of working age. As a result of the systemic issues mentioned above these people experience the longest waits for planned care and the longer you spend on a waiting list the less likely you are to return to work (can't remember the stats off the top of my head but have quoted them on this thread before) and the more likely you are to develop mental health needs as well. Its a funnel that can catch people from all walks of life but some are being actively pushed towards it. We need to address these systemic issues before we can put it down to personal responsibility. And to solve those systemic issues we need to talk about it more not less!

    This talking point has been used to justify a lack of action on social mobility and even preventing actions.

    On my personal circumstances you've ignored the cost side of things. Huge mortgage and rates trebled. And yes obviously weve been saving but some tied up in pensions and investments and weve just emptied out savings into work on the house. A lot more needed on the house in the next 2 years too.

    And the childcare costs these are the same as a mortgage PER CHILD if you don't get the 30 hours free and still work full time. That's not affordable in the next 2 years if we want to finish the house. And that's before we talk about maternity pay. 

    You're also underestimating the student loan factor a lot. I remember you saying your daughters didn't need the system so understandable if you don't know how it works. Let me put it this way - I've paid back pretty much what I originally "borrowed" but now "owe" 19k more than I originally borrowed. It is a loan only in name, it is structured to be a 30(or 40 depending on age) year graduate tax other than for those with rich parents. I got particularly unlucky in that as my earnings grew interest rates were soaring and so it took me a hell of a long time and a wildly high salary to even cover the interest. Without lump sum early repayment I'll likely pay back 3-3.5 times what I borrowed depending on what rates do. Masters loan is another 6% graduate tax on top. Bit at least this one is whittling down and there is an end in sight. 

    Add these stealth taxes to income tax and NI plus factor in my work place pension contributions and my marginal take home is 8p in the £. 
    With respect, absolutely your choices as to what you spend your money on, how big a house you buy/what work required, how big a mortgage etc. If you are hesitating as to if you can afford children, yet both earn north of £100k, I don't think you will get much empathy. And at that level of earnings I do not believe the government should be helping you with childcare costs.

    I know fully how the student loan system works plan 1/2 and 4/5 and post grad, another thing I often go through with the Grads when they wonder why they are getting deductions, one of my actuaries has built a spreadsheet they can complete to work it all out as their salary changes, how long to repay etc and if worth paying off more earlier with bonus's or more each month (95% of the time it is worthwhile for them because of the ridiculous interest rates). Maximum if you have both loans is 15% above the relevant threshold. If you are concerned how much you will ultimately pay back, check what your mortgage will actually costs over 25/30/35 years.

    8p in the pound, behave, so your £100k annual salary results in less than £700 a month.

    The point in bold has nothing to do with the likes of Farage, I made the point we need to stop putting young people in buckets, if we do so then don't be surprised the outcomes are as the data suggests it will be. Maybe if we helped the younger generation to see regardless of background there are opportunities we/they would see different outcomes. But as I also said, as a society we also need to do much more to try and even up those opportunities. I have a real mixture of apprentices, some come from affluent backgrounds, some from very poor backgrounds, some privately educated, some went to very poor state schools. My advice to them - you are all equal, you have the same opportunity, the outcomes now comes down to you (broadly). It's never lost on me that and whilst I am generalising, in the main those from the poorer backgrounds are the most hungry to succeed and often are the one's who do.
    Yes it's a choice and I'm not looking for sympathy. And I certainly didn't ask for any. I'm using an example to demonstrate the change in a generation because a couple pages back you told me that the statistics didn't matter because "you can look at statistics, but I don’t think they often tell the full lived story" so I'm giving in great personal detail my lived story. 

    I'm not after any sympathy at all but more demonstrating the change in the last 1 and a half generations. As I said our house is a standard zone 4/5 border south east london/kent 3 bed which was previously owned by a postie whose wife didn't work. That change is scary for a society no matter how you look at it. If your soluton is to just buy smaller or buy less or buy further out then that kinda demonstrates the point that what was achievable for the normal family is much harder to achieve even for top earners now. And again demonstrates the scale of the change in such a short period of time.

    I said MARGINAL take home. Surely after so long in the sector you know what that term means.

    It may not have anything to do with Farage but it's a  talking point he's been regularly repeating. As I said I think it's an incredibly dangerous narrative to pupport. You want young people to take personal responsibility for defying the odds that society has stacked against them. My point is that simply telling them to do it through hard work is not enough. You want them to take responsibility the best thing to do is to talk about it more, raise the profile of the issues and to show them what we are doing about it, show us we are investing in the community, their local services and their future. Give them something visible they can see is worth working for. Show them we are fixing the structural systemic issues that worsen their life chances and give them hope it'll actually be worth it! As I said if we are serious about  solving those systemic issues we need to talk about it more not less.
    Your personal choices (good or bad) with your finances don't show the change in a 1 and a half generations (well not the change you mean).

    You do know most people used to move further out (and most still do) to buy their first home? Or to a cheaper area, that really isn't anything new. I doubt either of my children would buy where we live now in their first few moves due to the cost (nor could I have lived in this area at their age). 

    But let's play this house/postman Gary's economics game of lived examples, when are we talking, what price did they pay for your now house and how much did the postman earn? (lets also not forget that they left it in a right old, unsafe state when you bought it from them).

    Let me try an example; Postman in 1980 earned around £3,000 a year. Around that time my parents bought a 3 bed semi in Eltham, SE9 (sounded similar to yours, needed lots of work, no central heating, falling out wooden windows etc etc), they paid just over £17,000 I think and borrowed an extra £3.5k to do 'stuff' but lets call it £20k. Would the postman and family income of £3k be able to afford that back then? Eltham not being exactly the most expensive area in zone 4/5. Depending on what of his £3k a year he saved up for the deposit, loan would likely have been 6x income and rates were well into the teens by then. By the way my late parents house may touch £525k now (or if you go back to the condition it was in back then more like £425k).

    I assume by marginal take home you are talking about the next £1+ you earn? So not how much you take home each of your £100k+ salaries which must be a tidy 5 figure sum between you, if so I still cannot see a way you would get to 8%. Your max student loan is 15%, max tax 62% for the 100 - 125k band otherwise 47% above that, what accounts of the other 15%/38%. Personal/workplace Pension contributions shouldn't be included in the marginal take home calc.

    That said there were income tax rates approaching 92% back in the 60's to 80's I believe.

    You have selected a small part of what I said, yes everyone has to take some personal responsibility, but thats not the entirety of what I said at all, is it. But thankfully those who come to our apprentice/intern/work experience days go away with a spring in their step after often walking in like rabbits in headlights and some get through onto the scheme the following year as they see it's worth working for. For them we can't change the past and the cards they were dealt, good or bad, anymore than we could have for you and I.
    Same on university, we should be showing the 17 year olds there are very viable alternatives and it isn't the be all and end all in life (anymore than not being a grade A student). Most of my apprentices by 21 are earning more than the 21 year old grads coming in, have zero Uni debt, have money saved and importantly have 3 years work experience and relevant exams behind them.
  • https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/cm4g1zrl2nrqo

    Changing the subject slightly - whilst everyone knows I am opposed to drilling for new oil and gas and opposed to the Jackdaw approval announced yesterday - there are some interesting bits of information coming out with the announcements at the moment. 

    This article got my attention. I welcome the creation of the energy wealth fund for investing the reciepts from North sea oil and gas - though in reality this is far too little and 50 years late. The bit that really got my ears up was around the analysis of what could have been if we had done this since we started drilling in the north sea. The Treasury analysis estimates that this would be around £1tn if it had been done from the start. However this for me misses the key point that is the biggest issue with how the north sea resources have been used. The analysis only includes the receipts the UK government did actually recieve from North Sea oil and gas - not what they were actually worth. Rights were sold to private compaies for around 20% of their actual value. If we had adopted the Norway model and had a state owned energy production and supply company that would operate these for us and thus recive 100% of the benefits. As such the estimate of the £1tn wealth fund is an underestimate by a factor of 3 or 4 once costs are taken into account. This shows the real cost the short term decision making that prevailed in the 80s, 90s and early 2000's. Its a huge shame and missed opportunity. 

    Same goes for housing. If 20% of the money raised from selling council houses under right to buy was reingfenced to be re-invested in council housing Ad infinitum then we would be sitting on another £1tn asset. 

    Shame.
    So much
    Such poor short term thinking with vast long term consequences 
  • CAFCsayer
    CAFCsayer Posts: 11,034
    I love reading all the nonsense on here about how it was just as hard to get on the housing ladder back than then it is today. I bought in the 00s with a 7% mortgage, saved for years, made loads of sacrifices, it wasn't easy then and it's never been easy, but it's far harder for young people today. 
    It's definitely harder, but to play devils advocate, I'm 32 and out of my close group of 12 mates from school, 9 of them own properties, half of them have kids and a couple have 2 kids. Some of them definitely wouldn't be in the category of top 5% earners and have bought places on their own.

    It's doable, I think this generation have just had to live at home for a bit longer than they would probably like to to get the deposit together.
  • Rob7Lee
    Rob7Lee Posts: 10,076
    edited October 25
    CAFCsayer said:
    I love reading all the nonsense on here about how it was just as hard to get on the housing ladder back than then it is today. I bought in the 00s with a 7% mortgage, saved for years, made loads of sacrifices, it wasn't easy then and it's never been easy, but it's far harder for young people today. 
    It's definitely harder, but to play devils advocate, I'm 32 and out of my close group of 12 mates from school, 9 of them own properties, half of them have kids and a couple have 2 kids. Some of them definitely wouldn't be in the category of top 5% earners and have bought places on their own.

    It's doable, I think this generation have just had to live at home for a bit longer than they would probably like to to get the deposit together.
    Someone will be along shortly to let you know that none of that could possibly have happened.

    Staying at home longer I'm sure is true and is the most obvious answer for those where it is possible. For different people, different jobs it will take different lengths of time to save that 75% of the deposit needed.
  • clb74
    clb74 Posts: 10,877
    edited October 25
    So have I got this right?
    Before the 90s most women didnt work full time?
    Couples would get man 3.5 times there's wages and 1.5 for women for a mortgage.
    Womens was lower because it was deemed they'd kids and stay at home to look after them.
    When I was born in 74 me dad was a labourer and me mum done a little bit of part time work.

  • Sponsored links:



  • Rob7Lee
    Rob7Lee Posts: 10,076
    clb74 said:
    So have I got this right?
    Before the 90s most women didnt work full time?
    Couples would get man 3.5 times there's wages and 1.5 for women for a mortgage.
    Womens was lower because it was deemed they'd kids and stay at home to look after them.
    When I was born in 74 me dad was a labourer and me mum done a little bit of part time work.
    Not sure if pre 90 or earlier, but certainly when I was a boy (born two years before you) there wasn't really childcare facilities (such as nurseries) so generally most mum's didn't work or worked part time around school or husbands job. My mum once I went to school did the dinner lady, school secretary etc, a lot of the dinner ladies she worked with did the night shift at the then newly opened Sainsbury's in Chislehurst or Eltham. (Think Bob M earlier mentioned something similar with his wife doing the late/night shift in a supermarket).

    Different times, different solutions. Don't think nurseries became a thing until late 80's ish.

    My wife gave up work when the second came along (was 3 days a week prior to that), then started to work weekends in mothercare/early learning centre to help with the family running costs. Later volunteered at a school and has been a teaching assistant for about the last 12 years (my daughters are now 26 & 23). Keep trying to get her to retire but she feels she's needed to help the kids! (Think she misses being a mum with young children). But it's hard graft for little cash and means our Holidays remain expensive due to being in school holidays, I joke it costs me money her working  :D
  • Friend Or Defoe
    Friend Or Defoe Posts: 18,401
    Rob7Lee said:
    CAFCsayer said:
    I love reading all the nonsense on here about how it was just as hard to get on the housing ladder back than then it is today. I bought in the 00s with a 7% mortgage, saved for years, made loads of sacrifices, it wasn't easy then and it's never been easy, but it's far harder for young people today. 
    It's definitely harder, but to play devils advocate, I'm 32 and out of my close group of 12 mates from school, 9 of them own properties, half of them have kids and a couple have 2 kids. Some of them definitely wouldn't be in the category of top 5% earners and have bought places on their own.

    It's doable, I think this generation have just had to live at home for a bit longer than they would probably like to to get the deposit together.
    Someone will be along shortly to let you know that none of that could possibly have happened.

    Staying at home longer I'm sure is true and is the most obvious answer for those where it is possible. For different people, different jobs it will take different lengths of time to save that 75% of the deposit needed.
    Thankfully everyone can stay home for longer and no issues arise from it. 
  • golfaddick
    golfaddick Posts: 37,169
    clb74 said:
    So have I got this right?
    Before the 90s most women didnt work full time?
    Couples would get man 3.5 times there's wages and 1.5 for women for a mortgage.
    Womens was lower because it was deemed they'd kids and stay at home to look after them.
    When I was born in 74 me dad was a labourer and me mum done a little bit of part time work.
    When I started in the business in 1991 (adviser & mortgage broker) the norm was 3.5x sole or 2.5 x joint. 

    The starting figure now is around 4.5x joint, with a lot of lenders going up to 5x joint. I have seen 6xjoint for professionals/high earners (doctors, lawyers etc)

    But its mostly done on affordability now. No good lending at 5x joint if the borrower is paying £500pm in a car loan and £500pm in childcare. 
  • Rob7Lee
    Rob7Lee Posts: 10,076
    Rob7Lee said:
    CAFCsayer said:
    I love reading all the nonsense on here about how it was just as hard to get on the housing ladder back than then it is today. I bought in the 00s with a 7% mortgage, saved for years, made loads of sacrifices, it wasn't easy then and it's never been easy, but it's far harder for young people today. 
    It's definitely harder, but to play devils advocate, I'm 32 and out of my close group of 12 mates from school, 9 of them own properties, half of them have kids and a couple have 2 kids. Some of them definitely wouldn't be in the category of top 5% earners and have bought places on their own.

    It's doable, I think this generation have just had to live at home for a bit longer than they would probably like to to get the deposit together.
    Someone will be along shortly to let you know that none of that could possibly have happened.

    Staying at home longer I'm sure is true and is the most obvious answer for those where it is possible. For different people, different jobs it will take different lengths of time to save that 75% of the deposit needed.
    Thankfully everyone can stay home for longer and no issues arise from it. 
    Some can, but equally some can't for varying reasons, whether thats not getting on with parents or for specific job opportunities.

    My PA's daughter has just moved back in with her from Uni, along with boyfriend and new born, now thats a serious challenge I wouldn't want to be dealing with.

    clb74 said:
    So have I got this right?
    Before the 90s most women didnt work full time?
    Couples would get man 3.5 times there's wages and 1.5 for women for a mortgage.
    Womens was lower because it was deemed they'd kids and stay at home to look after them.
    When I was born in 74 me dad was a labourer and me mum done a little bit of part time work.
    When I started in the business in 1991 (adviser & mortgage broker) the norm was 3.5x sole or 2.5 x joint. 

    The starting figure now is around 4.5x joint, with a lot of lenders going up to 5x joint. I have seen 6xjoint for professionals/high earners (doctors, lawyers etc)

    But its mostly done on affordability now. No good lending at 5x joint if the borrower is paying £500pm in a car loan and £500pm in childcare. 
    Are you suggesting you are able to borrow a much higher multiplier now than 30 years ago?  ;)

    I first borrowed in 93/94 and because I was staff at a building society we were allowed 4x sole (joint remained 2.5).
  • Arsenetatters
    Arsenetatters Posts: 6,505
    edited October 26
    I've got a S & S ISA with fidelity which I wanted to change to one of their 'ready made' S and S ISAs but am having trouble sorting it and each time I phone I get a different answer. I'm getting fed up with them so am thinking of transferring it to a cash ISA somewhere else. I've already used up this year's allowance but am I OK to transfer and still keep the tax benefits from this one?
    Edit - it's got over £20,000 in it
  • Rob7Lee
    Rob7Lee Posts: 10,076
    edited October 26
    I've got a S & S ISA with fidelity which I wanted to change to one of their 'ready made' S and S ISAs but am having trouble sorting it and each time I phone I get a different answer. I'm getting fed up with them so am thinking of transferring it to a cash ISA somewhere else. I've already used up this year's allowance but am I OK to transfer and still keep the tax benefits from this one?
    Edit - it's got over £20,000 in it
    As long as you do as a transfer it remains in the ISA wrapper. Just check the receiving ISA allows transfers in and transfers from stocks and shares to cash.

    tgat said fidelity should be quite easy to make that change. It’s just switching your investments to what they choose as your profile multi asset fund.
  • Arsenetatters
    Arsenetatters Posts: 6,505
    Rob7Lee said:
    I've got a S & S ISA with fidelity which I wanted to change to one of their 'ready made' S and S ISAs but am having trouble sorting it and each time I phone I get a different answer. I'm getting fed up with them so am thinking of transferring it to a cash ISA somewhere else. I've already used up this year's allowance but am I OK to transfer and still keep the tax benefits from this one?
    Edit - it's got over £20,000 in it
    As long as you do as a transfer it remains in the ISA wrapper. Just check the receiving ISA allows transfers in and transfers from stocks and shares to cash.

    tgat said fidelity should be quite easy to make that change. It’s just switching your investments to what they choose as your profile multi asset fund.
    Thank you 🙏 
  • bobmunro
    bobmunro Posts: 22,238
    I've got a S & S ISA with fidelity which I wanted to change to one of their 'ready made' S and S ISAs but am having trouble sorting it and each time I phone I get a different answer. I'm getting fed up with them so am thinking of transferring it to a cash ISA somewhere else. I've already used up this year's allowance but am I OK to transfer and still keep the tax benefits from this one?
    Edit - it's got over £20,000 in it

    To build on @Rob7Lee you will probably have to sell your investments and convert them to cash before you can transfer the funds to a Cash ISA with another provider. Also, as you have already used up this year's allowance you need to open a Cash ISA elsewhere that doesn't require 'new' money in order to open it, just the transfer.

    Investec are offering 4.95% fixed for one year which is about the best out there at the moment - you can transfer in without needing new money to open it.

    (I mention Investec so much, anyone would think I;m on commission! They really are good though.)
  • Arsenetatters
    Arsenetatters Posts: 6,505
    bobmunro said:
    I've got a S & S ISA with fidelity which I wanted to change to one of their 'ready made' S and S ISAs but am having trouble sorting it and each time I phone I get a different answer. I'm getting fed up with them so am thinking of transferring it to a cash ISA somewhere else. I've already used up this year's allowance but am I OK to transfer and still keep the tax benefits from this one?
    Edit - it's got over £20,000 in it

    To build on @Rob7Lee you will probably have to sell your investments and convert them to cash before you can transfer the funds to a Cash ISA with another provider. Also, as you have already used up this year's allowance you need to open a Cash ISA elsewhere that doesn't require 'new' money in order to open it, just the transfer.

    Investec are offering 4.95% fixed for one year which is about the best out there at the moment - you can transfer in without needing new money to open it.

    (I mention Investec so much, anyone would think I;m on commission! They really are good though.)
    Thank you, I’ve sold all the investments, just waiting for them to settle. So can I transfer the whole amount (which is now over £20,000? ) to the new cash ISA? 
  • Rob7Lee
    Rob7Lee Posts: 10,076
    edited October 26
    bobmunro said:
    I've got a S & S ISA with fidelity which I wanted to change to one of their 'ready made' S and S ISAs but am having trouble sorting it and each time I phone I get a different answer. I'm getting fed up with them so am thinking of transferring it to a cash ISA somewhere else. I've already used up this year's allowance but am I OK to transfer and still keep the tax benefits from this one?
    Edit - it's got over £20,000 in it

    To build on @Rob7Lee you will probably have to sell your investments and convert them to cash before you can transfer the funds to a Cash ISA with another provider. Also, as you have already used up this year's allowance you need to open a Cash ISA elsewhere that doesn't require 'new' money in order to open it, just the transfer.

    Investec are offering 4.95% fixed for one year which is about the best out there at the moment - you can transfer in without needing new money to open it.

    (I mention Investec so much, anyone would think I;m on commission! They really are good though.)
    Investec are good, I’m doing quite well on their shares and also in process of switching banking to them. But check as they refer to switching a cash ISA.

    On fidelity, answers these simple questions, note down the suggested fund and ‘switch’ what you have to that fund:

    https://www.fidelity.co.uk/ready-made-isa/?ef_id=CjwKCAjw9PvWBhAxEiwAddzYyV6-io61jXH9Es53FtIdC4pLHWcJY_VowW8iI8wc7iG4N5jxG5J5KhoC8LkQAvD_BwE:G:s&s_kwcid=AL!8153!3!786808512429!p!!g!!fidelity%20ready-made%20isa!23328986789!191231735964&utm_source=google&utm_medium=paid_search&utm_campaign=uk_brand_2026_ready-made-isa_orders&gclsrc=aw.ds&gad_source=1&gad_campaignid=23328986789&gbraid=0AAAAAD_DS9f1x2ai3tLpEy32Pm3yL4mLI&gclid=CjwKCAjw9PvWBhAxEiwAddzYyV6-io61jXH9Es53FtIdC4pLHWcJY_VowW8iI8wc7iG4N5jxG5J5KhoC8LkQAvD_BwE