Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Best ever first 11 in Charlton colours

SouthLondonisRedSouthLondonisRed
in General Charlton
Was with a Charlton mate in the pub last night and he said to me what is my best 11 players I've seen in Charlton colours.
It was a good 20 minutes till I got a team up so here it is.

            Kiely
 Young Rufus Gomez H.H
           Holland 
     Parker   Jenson 
           Lookman
      Euell       D.Bent

Be interesting to see what you CharltonLifers think of that team?


«13

Comments

  • PopIconPopIcon
    Kinsella over Lookman all day and night...
    Costa for Gomez.
  • TalalTalal
    Powell for HH
  • wmcf123wmcf123
    SouthLondonisRed said:
    Was with a Charlton mate in the pub last night and he said to me what is my best 11 players I've seen in Charlton colours.
    It was a good 20 minutes till I got a team up so here it is.

                Kiely
     Young Rufus Gomez H.H
               Holland 
         Parker   Jenson 
               Lookman
          Euell       D.Bent

    Be interesting to see what you CharltonLifers think of that team?


    I love Jason for his loyalty to us in bad times as coach , but his first touch was so poor.  Matt Holland doesn’t belong in there either; again- great guy 
  • paulie8290paulie8290
    Kerm ahead of Euell
  • SoundAsa£SoundAsa£
    Any team that doesn’t include Stuart Leary is meaningless.
  • EveshamAddickEveshamAddick
    Bolder
    Humphrey
    Rufus
    Webster
    SCP


    Robert Lee
    Kinsella
    Graeme Stuart
    John Robinson

    Hales
    Kermogant

  • RobRob
    SoundAsa£ said:
    Any team that doesn’t include Stuart Leary is meaningless.
    Yes but probably the OP has never seen him which was his criteria.
  • SouthLondonisRedSouthLondonisRed
    Really like the players who you Lifers have replaced them with the players I picked.
    There is so many first 11's I could have picked.
    @EveshamAddick how could I forget about Johnny Robinson, definitely in the top 5 favourite players of mine. 
    @wmcf123 Had to put Euelly in as he is my favourite all time player to put on the Charlton colours in my life time.
  • iainmentiainment
    No Mendonca?
  • EveshamAddickEveshamAddick
    iainment said:
    No Mendonca?
    On the bench.
  • Sponsored links:


  • grumpyaddickgrumpyaddick
    Hales  Powell, Robinson, Jensen, Parker, Horsefield, Peacock ?
  • SouthLondonisRedSouthLondonisRed
    EveshamAddick said:
    iainment said:
    No Mendonca?
    On the bench.
    EveshamAddick said:
    iainment said:
    No Mendonca?
    On the bench.
    Agree
  • ValleyFredValleyFred
    edited October 2019
    Started going to watch Charlton when I was about 15, in 2011, so can't really comment on before then, but thought I'd add my best of the last decade:

    GK: Hamer/Elliot
    RB: Solly 
    CB: Morrison 
    CB: Bauer (Gomez possibly considering what he's gone on to, but probably didn't play enough games for us)
    LB: Wiggins
    RM: Gudmonsson
    CM: Gallagher
    CM: Poyet (in that POTY winning year)
    LM: Lookman
    ST: Kermogant
    ST: Taylor/BWP

    Could say Gallagher hasn't played enough games yet, so maybe Stephens? 
  • MemoriesofMortimerMemoriesofMortimer
    I stated going in 1988 but missed 2009-2013 while working down under.

    my team

    gk Kiely
    rb humphrey 
    cb rufus
    cb fish
    lb minto 
    rm lee
    cm jenson
    cm kinsella
    lm mortimer (no choice given my username)
    cf mendonca
    cf bent 

    i agonised over a few who didn’t make it but I seriously rated the following...

    JJ
    d whyte
    powell
    brown
    robinson
    parker and many more
  • Richard JRichard J
    Different era but here goes 

    Gk Carson

    RB Humphrey
    LB Powell

    CB Rufus
    CB Costa

    RM Simonsen
    CM Parker
    CM Bowyer 
    LM Reid 

    ST Bent
    ST Di Canio 
  • masicatmasicat
    Kiely

    Young Gomez Costa Powell

    Jensen Parker Bowyer Lee

    Simonsen.  Bent

    8 England internationals in this. But a bit low sided.
    11 full internationals
  • SouthLondonisRedSouthLondonisRed
    masicat said:
    Kiely

    Young Gomez Costa Powell

    Jensen Parker Bowyer Lee

    Simonsen.  Bent

    8 England internationals in this. But a bit low sided.
    11 full internationals
    I would of loved to seen a Parker/Bowyer in the middle of the park
  • SouthLondonisRedSouthLondonisRed
    Richard J said:
    Different era but here goes 

    Gk Carson

    RB Humphrey
    LB Powell

    CB Rufus
    CB Costa

    RM Simonsen
    CM Parker
    CM Bowyer 
    LM Reid 

    ST Bent
    ST Di Canio (Shame we couldn't get him for another year)
  • ricky_ottoricky_otto
    edited October 2019
    Tough one, but:

    Bolder
    Humphrey
    M Reid
    Rufus
    Shirtliff
    Kinsella
    Parker
    Bowyer
    Mortimer
    D Bent
    Mendonca 

    Subs:
    Kiely
    Gomez
    Lee
    Simonsen
    Di Canio
    Kermogant
    Taylor
  • Sponsored links:


  • killerandflashkillerandflash
    Dominated by our PL side, but then as that's the highest finishing side since the Jimmy Seed days, that feels right.

    GK Bolder
    RB Young
    LB Powell
    CB Rufus
    CB Costa
    RM Robert Lee
    CM Parker
    CM Bowyer
    LM Jensen
    ST D Bent
    ST Di Canio (I don't think Hales or Mendonca would work as a strike partner to Bent)

  • SydneyaddickSydneyaddick
    Kiely
    Humphrey
    Rufus
    Costa
    Powell
    Lee
    Kinsella
    Jensen
    Mortimer
    Mendonca
    Bent

    not a bad team!! 
  • wmcf123wmcf123
    SouthLondonisRed said:
    Really like the players who you Lifers have replaced them with the players I picked.
    There is so many first 11's I could have picked.
    @EveshamAddick how could I forget about Johnny Robinson, definitely in the top 5 favourite players of mine. 
    @wmcf123 Had to put Euelly in as he is my favourite all time player to put on the Charlton colours in my life time.
    Fair play. If you’d said favourite, I wouldn’t have commented 
  • cafcdave123cafcdave123
    are we picking them based on how good they were when with us?

    for example Lee Bowyer went on to be a much better player at Leeds and John Barnes went on to be a much worse player at Charlton
  • thai malaysia addickthai malaysia addick
    Johnny Haynes has to play
  • SouthLondonisRedSouthLondonisRed
    cafcdave123 said:
    are we picking them based on how good they were when with us?

    for example Lee Bowyer went on to be a much better player at Leeds and John Barnes went on to be a much worse player at Charlton
    Just the best 11 you have seen that would put on your team mate... Hope I've made it clear enough
  • Richard JRichard J
    cafcdave123 said:
    are we picking them based on how good they were when with us?

    for example Lee Bowyer went on to be a much better player at Leeds and John Barnes went on to be a much worse player at Charlton
    That is why Barnes doesn't make my team. Jesper Blomqvist is another option if we change the rules  

    Bowyer was Outstanding at Charlton. Connor Gallagher may take his place if he carries on in his current vein of form. 
  • SouthLondonisRedSouthLondonisRed
    wmcf123 said:
    SouthLondonisRed said:
    Really like the players who you Lifers have replaced them with the players I picked.
    There is so many first 11's I could have picked.
    @EveshamAddick how could I forget about Johnny Robinson, definitely in the top 5 favourite players of mine. 
    @wmcf123 Had to put Euelly in as he is my favourite all time player to put on the Charlton colours in my life time.
    Fair play. If you’d said favourite, I wouldn’t have commented 
    Even though he is my favourite player mate, I still think he was decent for us.
    Isn't he still our highest paid player?
  • wmcf123wmcf123
    SouthLondonisRed said:
    wmcf123 said:
    SouthLondonisRed said:
    Really like the players who you Lifers have replaced them with the players I picked.
    There is so many first 11's I could have picked.
    @EveshamAddick how could I forget about Johnny Robinson, definitely in the top 5 favourite players of mine. 
    @wmcf123 Had to put Euelly in as he is my favourite all time player to put on the Charlton colours in my life time.
    Fair play. If you’d said favourite, I wouldn’t have commented 
    Even though he is my favourite player mate, I still think he was decent for us.
    Isn't he still our highest paid player?
    He did well for us but personally not near a top XI
  • I_RiserAddickI_RiserAddick
               Kiely
    Humphrey Elliott Costa Powell

      Lee  Kinsella Parker Barnes


    Simonsen DiCanio
    Subs.
    Bolder
    Rufus
    Bumstead
    Leary
    P.Walsh

Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!