Phillips: 7 - kept us in it Lockyer: 6 - Best Center half Pearce: 5 - I wish he’d stop grabbing players Sarr: 6 - One of his better days Solly: 5 - really poor Pratley: 3 - anonymous Gallagher: 6 - Better second half Doughty: 5 - looked lost Purrington: 6 - did ok Leko: 4 - was he playing ? Bonne: 5 - no service
Phillips: 7 Lockyer: 5.5 Pearce: 6 Sarr: 5.5 Solly: 5 minus a point for weak clearance that gave them 3 points Pratley: 4.5 Gallagher: 6 Doughty: 5.5 Purrington: 4.5 Leko: 4 Bonne: 4 Referee: 5
Phillips: 6.5 - a couple good saves. Maybe could have done better with the goal as it was hit literally directly down the middle of the goal.
Lockyer: 5.5 - did more complaining and throwing his hands up than actual defending
Pearce: 6 - tried to show some heart, and decent defending at times. But as a Captain we need more from him.
Sarr: 4.5 - serious question marks surrounding his defending. He would bomb forward on a run then jog bag slowly. He would go to ground to slide tackle then get up all slow. Also some really awful passing. Tries to force a pass in constantly.
Solly: 7 - our best player tonight but he is at fault for the goal. His half arse clearance was directly at the oppo which led to the cross for the Hudds goal. He was probably absolutely gassed out there, but that one mistake cost us a point tonight.
Pratley: 5.5 - no creativity at center park. Might be better suited for CB. Won a lot of headers but no aim. Not sure if it ever crossed his mind to control a high ball and pass out of the back.
Gallagher: 5 - worst first half of football ive seen out of him. Turned right into a Hudds player at awful points of the pitch multiple times. Second half was much better, but still a poor game by his standards.
Doughty: 5- cant trap a football or run with a football properly. would turn without the ball and easily turn it over.
Purrington: 4.5 - didnt notice him for 60 mins. Then i was like, oh Purrington is playing, blimey! what has he done tonight, nothing!
Leko: 5 - CAM? what position was he playing? Found some decent space to run into but he didnt produce much from it Bonne: 4.5 - for a striker he doesnt get many touches. would like to see him check into midfield every once in a while, just to get a touch on the ball. Sick of watching him constantly begging for that perfect ball over the top. Needs to be on a platter for him to finish.
Phillips: 6 Lockyer: 6 Pearce: 6 Sarr: 7 stupid prick fans digging him out for everything when he had a decent game Solly: 5 not good enough Pratley: 6 Gallagher: 6 Doughty: 5 Purrington: 5 Leko: 6 should never have been taken off should have been bonne Bonne: 5 Referee: 2
Phillips: 6.5 couple of decent saves, no chance on the goal.
Lockyer: 5.5 beaten too often, a few unnecessary fouls. Pearce: 6 this was his kind of rough and tumble game. Sarr: 6.5 started much too slowly better in the final 20-30 minutes. Solly: 6.5 loses half a point for costing us the game.
Pratley: 5 poor today, give him a rest. Gallagher: 5.5 works so hard, needs to look for passes more often as shots are now expected and regularly blocked. Doughty: 6 thought he did well, tired second half. Purrington: 5.5 poor first half, improved second. Rate Doughty higher.
Leko: 6 Looked like a proper team player tonight, couple of overworked efforts lost the ball. Bonne: 5.5 Improved as they tired, not sure how he was yellowed.
Referee: 4 - Decent first half, bit too happy to blow his whistle against Charlton.
Taylor: n/a we look more dangerous with him. Vennings: n/a good game, possibly lost his man for the goal.
Phillips: 6.5 couldn't tell if he could have saved the goal Lockyer: 7 some duff passes but defended well Pearce: 7.5 did his job, idk about the goal, benefit of doubt Sarr: 7 defended well and drove us forward nicely with some good passing, winner denied by bastard linesman, a couple of duff passes but that's what you get from a playmaker Solly: 6.5 good game until he messed up for the winner Pratley: 4.5 last season's Pratley again, except worse. Was Cullen that important for him? Gallagher: 6.5 looked to make something happen, even if it didn't Doughty: 6 good effort and a couple of bright moments, tough job though Purrington: 5 completely superfluous, should have come off Leko: 6 a proper shift for no reward Bonne: 5.5 seems to have regressed the last couple? needs a break Referee: 8 good ref. bastard lino
Taylor: n/a gave us so much more Vennings: n/a lovely touch, needs to work on awareness
Phillips: 7 - Should have a clean sheet, made two wonder saves (Remind me, wasnt he supposed to be a liability at this level?) Lockyer: 6 - Good to have him back, along with Pearce they did well to nulify Grant and his pace Pearce: 6 - Better performance today, same as Lockyer when dealing with Grant Sarr: 7 - Much better today Naby!!! Solly: 5 - Loses a mark for the mistake that led to the goal, his best performance as a Wing-Back for me Pratley: 6 - Got to remember, he isnt just doing his job but trying to guide the likes of Doughty and Vennings too Gallagher: 6 - Improved as the game continued but its easier for the opposition to target him now he's our main midfielder Doughty: 5 - Too many hot and cold moments, he'll learn in time Purrington: 6 - Thought he did well today Leko: 5 - Another game where there just wasnt the effort Bonne: 6 - Fed off scraps, battled well
Taylor: N/A (6) - His hold up play changed the game in our favour till the goal Vennings: N/A (5) - His inexperience showed against a strong Huddersfield midfield
Phillips: 5 couldnt do much about goal,some good saves but poor distribution at times Lockyer: 6 decent Pearce: 4 below parr Sarr: 5 Solly:3 struggling Pratley: 4 not good enough Gallagher:4 ditto Doughty: 6 Purrington: 4 Leko:5 Bonne: 4 Referee: 2
Taylor:6 really lifted the whole place,but sadly to no avail Vennings:3 out of his depth
Phillips 7. Kept us in it. Lockyer 5. Some howlers among the good stuff. Hung out to dry by Sarr and Pearce a few times. Pearce 5. Bull in a china shop. Sarr 6. Though he was decent tonight until a couple of late howlers cost Lockyer a booking and nearly cost a goal. Solly 5. Was probably our best player then sadly lost us the match. Pratley 4.5. Had his boots on the wrong feet tonight Gallagher 4. Rubbish in the first half. Ran about a bit more in the second but he’s lost without Cullen Doughty 5. Not sure where he was supposed to be playing. Neither was he. Tried hard and is a prospect. Purrington 4. His middle name is “Backwards”. Not up to championship level. Leko 2. Disgraceful performance. Hid. I’m a fan of his but this should not be tolerated again. Probably knackered. Bonne 4. I’m not really feeling the love. Sure he’s ploughing a lonefurrow but he couldn’t trap a bag of cement.
Taylor 6. Cheered us up. Didn’t do very much. Needs to get match fit Vennings n/a. Shouldn’t have been on. Out of his depth.
Ref 6 Ok. Couple of howlers for both teams but generally passable.
Phillips: 6 one good save in the second half. Found the touchline too often with some of his clearances. Lockyer: 6 Solid. Pearce: 6 Battled. Sarr: 3 two glaring occasions where he gave the ball away in his own half. Looks like an accident waiting to happen every game. Solly: 4 awful clearance gave them the late winner. Pratley: 5 clumsy. Gallagher: 6 Got found out wanting too much time on the ball. Doughty: 6 actually looked alright but would have been more effective down the wing. Purrington: 5 useless. Leko: 5 Lazy. Bonne: 5 Zero service.
Phillips: 6.5 Lockyer: 6 Pearce: 5.5 I can’t have him at all Sarr: 5.5 Solly: 5 At fault for the goal Pratley: 5 One of his worst performances in a Charlton shirt. Gallagher: 6 Getting frustrated and another stupid booking. Lucky it wasn’t a red. Doughty: 6 Purrington: 5 Leko: 5 Bonne: 5 No service Referee: 4
Phillips: 7 kept us in the game. 2 good saves in the second half. Probably makes more saves per game than we have shots on target. Lockyer: 6.5 best CB Pearce: 5 effort is there. Ability and pace isn’t Sarr: 6.5 I know he’s a scapegoat, but he actually had a decent game. Got forward well. Covered for Purrington a lot and scored a goal Solly: 5 poor Pratley: 5 poor Gallagher: 5.5 better second half. Lost the ball too often. Didn’t think he’d last 90 mins. Thought he would see red Doughty: 6 I don’t think he knew where he was meant to be playing. 10/10 for effort. He’ll be a very good player Purrington: 3 poor. Did not give 100%. Sarr covered for him a hell of a lot, as did Doughty Leko: 2 gave up running on countless occasions. Did not give 100% Bonne: 4 did not give 100%. Got better when taylor came on Referee: 7 -1 for the disallowed goal... although that wasn’t his call. Thought he had a good game
Taylor: n/a good to see him back Vennings: n/a not ready. Strange choice to bring him on. One for the future though. Didn’t shy away from the ball
Phillips: 5 by God his kicking is getting worse, and on a blustery night for some reason he decided to kick it long more than he has all season Lockyer: 6.5 played pretty well tonight Pearce: 5 jittery in possession and too handsy out of it Sarr: 6.5 was great in the second half, average in the first Solly: 3 was having an ok game but fuck me that "clearance" at the end cost us 3 points so I've deducted 3 points from his score in petulant retaliation Pratley: 6 tried hard Gallagher: 3 looks off the pace and disinterested Doughty: 6 battled hard and got the ball in promising places Purrington: 4 looks all out of sorts Leko: 2 Fosu mk 2, pass it you greedy so and so, and actually run about so you're not offside when we have the ball Bonne: 5 no service and didn't hold up the ball very well but we didn't play the ball into the channels for him Referee: 5 meh
at the Valley, on Sky red button or a live stream your marks please
Phillips: 6.5 lost 0.5 of a mark for a shit clearance at the end that gave them the ball & led to their goal Lockyer: 7 Pearce: 5 Sarr: 5 Solly: 4 - not a wingback Pratley: 5 Gallagher: 6.5 Doughty: 6 Purrington: 5 - not a wngback Leko: 6.5 Bonne: 6 Referee:
Comments
Lockyer: 4
Pearce: 5
Sarr: 5
Solly: 5.5
Pratley: 4.5
Gallagher: 4
Doughty: 4
Purrington: 4.5
Leko: 4.5
Bonne: 4
Referee: 7
Lockyer: 6.5
Pearce: 6.5
Sarr: 7
Solly: 5.5
Pratley: 7
Gallagher: 5
Doughty: 6.5
Purrington: 6
Leko: 6.5
Bonne: 6
Referee:
Phillips: 7 - kept us in it
Lockyer: 6 - Best Center half
Pearce: 5 - I wish he’d stop grabbing players
Sarr: 6 - One of his better days
Solly: 5 - really poor
Pratley: 3 - anonymous
Gallagher: 6 - Better second half
Doughty: 5 - looked lost
Purrington: 6 - did ok
Leko: 4 - was he playing ?
Bonne: 5 - no service
Referee: 7
Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 6
Pearce: 5
Sarr: 5
Solly: 2
Pratley: 4
Gallagher: 4
Doughty: 4
Purrington: 4
Leko: 1
Bonne: 4
Absolute fucking shambles other than Phillips they should all be ashamed of themselves.
Lockyer: 5.5
Pearce: 6
Sarr: 5.5
Solly: 5 minus a point for weak clearance that gave them 3 points
Pratley: 4.5
Gallagher: 6
Doughty: 5.5
Purrington: 4.5
Leko: 4
Bonne: 4
Referee: 5
Taylor: n/a
Vennings: n/a
Lockyer: 5.5 - did more complaining and throwing his hands up than actual defending
Pearce: 6 - tried to show some heart, and decent defending at times. But as a Captain we need more from him.
Sarr: 4.5 - serious question marks surrounding his defending. He would bomb forward on a run then jog bag slowly. He would go to ground to slide tackle then get up all slow. Also some really awful passing. Tries to force a pass in constantly.
Solly: 7 - our best player tonight but he is at fault for the goal. His half arse clearance was directly at the oppo which led to the cross for the Hudds goal. He was probably absolutely gassed out there, but that one mistake cost us a point tonight.
Pratley: 5.5 - no creativity at center park. Might be better suited for CB. Won a lot of headers but no aim. Not sure if it ever crossed his mind to control a high ball and pass out of the back.
Gallagher: 5 - worst first half of football ive seen out of him. Turned right into a Hudds player at awful points of the pitch multiple times. Second half was much better, but still a poor game by his standards.
Doughty: 5- cant trap a football or run with a football properly. would turn without the ball and easily turn it over.
Purrington: 4.5 - didnt notice him for 60 mins. Then i was like, oh Purrington is playing, blimey! what has he done tonight, nothing!
Leko: 5 - CAM? what position was he playing? Found some decent space to run into but he didnt produce much from it
Bonne: 4.5 - for a striker he doesnt get many touches. would like to see him check into midfield every once in a while, just to get a touch on the ball. Sick of watching him constantly begging for that perfect ball over the top. Needs to be on a platter for him to finish.
Lockyer: 6
Pearce: 6
Sarr: 7 stupid prick fans digging him out for everything when he had a decent game
Solly: 5 not good enough
Pratley: 6
Gallagher: 6
Doughty: 5
Purrington: 5
Leko: 6 should never have been taken off should have been bonne
Bonne: 5
Referee: 2
Phillips: 6.5 couldn't tell if he could have saved the goal
Lockyer: 7 some duff passes but defended well
Pearce: 7.5 did his job, idk about the goal, benefit of doubt
Sarr: 7 defended well and drove us forward nicely with some good passing, winner denied by bastard linesman, a couple of duff passes but that's what you get from a playmaker
Solly: 6.5 good game until he messed up for the winner
Pratley: 4.5 last season's Pratley again, except worse. Was Cullen that important for him?
Gallagher: 6.5 looked to make something happen, even if it didn't
Doughty: 6 good effort and a couple of bright moments, tough job though
Purrington: 5 completely superfluous, should have come off
Leko: 6 a proper shift for no reward
Bonne: 5.5 seems to have regressed the last couple? needs a break
Referee: 8 good ref. bastard lino
Taylor: n/a gave us so much more
Vennings: n/a lovely touch, needs to work on awareness
Lockyer: 6.5
Pearce: 7
Sarr: 6.5
Solly: 4.5
Pratley: 5
Gallagher: 6.5
Doughty: 5
Purrington: 5
Leko: 6.5
Bonne: 5
Referee: 7
Lockyer: 6 - Good to have him back, along with Pearce they did well to nulify Grant and his pace
Pearce: 6 - Better performance today, same as Lockyer when dealing with Grant
Sarr: 7 - Much better today Naby!!!
Solly: 5 - Loses a mark for the mistake that led to the goal, his best performance as a Wing-Back for me
Pratley: 6 - Got to remember, he isnt just doing his job but trying to guide the likes of Doughty and Vennings too
Gallagher: 6 - Improved as the game continued but its easier for the opposition to target him now he's our main midfielder
Doughty: 5 - Too many hot and cold moments, he'll learn in time
Purrington: 6 - Thought he did well today
Leko: 5 - Another game where there just wasnt the effort
Bonne: 6 - Fed off scraps, battled well
Taylor: N/A (6) - His hold up play changed the game in our favour till the goal
Vennings: N/A (5) - His inexperience showed against a strong Huddersfield midfield
Referee: 7 - One of the better ones this season
Lockyer 6
Pearce 6
Sarr 6
Solly 5.5
Pratley 6
Gallagher 6
Doughty 5.5
Purrington 6
Leko 5.5
Bonne 5.5
Taylor 6
Vennings 5
Ref 6
Lockyer: 6 decent
Pearce: 4 below parr
Sarr: 5
Solly:3 struggling
Pratley: 4 not good enough
Gallagher:4 ditto
Doughty: 6
Purrington: 4
Leko:5
Bonne: 4
Referee: 2
Taylor:6 really lifted the whole place,but sadly to no avail
Vennings:3 out of his depth
Lockyer 5. Some howlers among the good stuff. Hung out to dry by Sarr and Pearce a few times.
Pearce 5. Bull in a china shop.
Sarr 6. Though he was decent tonight until a couple of late howlers cost Lockyer a booking and nearly cost a goal.
Solly 5. Was probably our best player then sadly lost us the match.
Pratley 4.5. Had his boots on the wrong feet tonight
Gallagher 4. Rubbish in the first half. Ran about a bit more in the second but he’s lost without Cullen
Doughty 5. Not sure where he was supposed to be playing. Neither was he. Tried hard and is a prospect.
Purrington 4. His middle name is “Backwards”. Not up to championship level.
Leko 2. Disgraceful performance. Hid. I’m a fan of his but this should not be tolerated again. Probably knackered.
Bonne 4. I’m not really feeling the love. Sure he’s ploughing a lonefurrow but he couldn’t trap a bag of cement.
Taylor 6. Cheered us up. Didn’t do very much. Needs to get match fit
Vennings n/a. Shouldn’t have been on. Out of his depth.
Ref 6 Ok. Couple of howlers for both teams but generally passable.
Lockyer: 6 decent
Pearce: 5
Sarr: 5.5
Solly:4 sluggish, slow to pass
Pratley: 4
Gallagher:7 for effort
Doughty: 5
Purrington: 5
Leko:5.5
Bonne: 3 didn’t move, drop deep, couldn’t keep the ball, not strong enough
Taylor:6
Vennings:3
Lockyer: 6 Solid.
Pearce: 6 Battled.
Sarr: 3 two glaring occasions where he gave the ball away in his own half. Looks like an accident waiting to happen every game.
Solly: 4 awful clearance gave them the late winner.
Pratley: 5 clumsy.
Gallagher: 6 Got found out wanting too much time on the ball.
Doughty: 6 actually looked alright but would have been more effective down the wing.
Purrington: 5 useless.
Leko: 5 Lazy.
Bonne: 5 Zero service.
Lockyer: 6
Pearce: 5.5
Sarr: 4.5
Solly: 5
Pratley: 5
Gallagher: 5
Doughty: 5
Purrington: 5
Leko: 4.5
Bonne: 5
Referee: 6
I'd score it exactly the same to be frank.
Lockyer: 6
Pearce: 5.5 I can’t have him at all
Sarr: 5.5
Solly: 5 At fault for the goal
Pratley: 5 One of his worst performances in a Charlton shirt.
Gallagher: 6 Getting frustrated and another stupid booking. Lucky it wasn’t a red.
Doughty: 6
Purrington: 5
Leko: 5
Bonne: 5 No service
Referee: 4
Taylor: n/a
Vennings: n/a No where near ready
Lockyer: 6.5 best CB
Pearce: 5 effort is there. Ability and pace isn’t
Sarr: 6.5 I know he’s a scapegoat, but he actually had a decent game. Got forward well. Covered for Purrington a lot and scored a goal
Solly: 5 poor
Pratley: 5 poor
Gallagher: 5.5 better second half. Lost the ball too often. Didn’t think he’d last 90 mins. Thought he would see red
Doughty: 6 I don’t think he knew where he was meant to be playing. 10/10 for effort. He’ll be a very good player
Purrington: 3 poor. Did not give 100%. Sarr covered for him a hell of a lot, as did Doughty
Leko: 2 gave up running on countless occasions. Did not give 100%
Bonne: 4 did not give 100%. Got better when taylor came on
Referee: 7 -1 for the disallowed goal... although that wasn’t his call. Thought he had a good game
Taylor: n/a good to see him back
Vennings: n/a not ready. Strange choice to bring him on. One for the future though. Didn’t shy away from the ball
Lockyer: 6.5 played pretty well tonight
Pearce: 5 jittery in possession and too handsy out of it
Sarr: 6.5 was great in the second half, average in the first
Solly: 3 was having an ok game but fuck me that "clearance" at the end cost us 3 points so I've deducted 3 points from his score in petulant retaliation
Pratley: 6 tried hard
Gallagher: 3 looks off the pace and disinterested
Doughty: 6 battled hard and got the ball in promising places
Purrington: 4 looks all out of sorts
Leko: 2 Fosu mk 2, pass it you greedy so and so, and actually run about so you're not offside when we have the ball
Bonne: 5 no service and didn't hold up the ball very well but we didn't play the ball into the channels for him
Referee: 5 meh
Phillips: 7
Lockyer: 6
Pearce: 5.5
Sarr: 5.5
Solly: 5
Pratley: 6
Gallagher: 7
Doughty: 6
Purrington: 5
Leko: 5.5
Bonne: 5.5
Referee: 7
Lockyer: 6
Pearce: 6
Sarr: 5
Solly: 5
Pratley: 6
Gallagher: 5
Doughty: 6
Purrington: 5
Leko: 5
Bonne: 5
Referee: 7
Lockyer: 6
Pearce: 4.5 he’s done
Sarr: 5.5
Solly: 5
Pratley: 6
Gallagher: 6
Doughty: 7
Purrington: 3
Leko: 5
Bonne: 5