Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Players Marks: Burton Albion v Charlton Athletic (Closes Wednesday evening)

24

Comments

  • Amos; 6
    Matthews: 6
    Gunter: 5
    Pratley: 5
    Maatsen: 5
    Watson: 5
    Gilbey: 6
    Shinnie: 6
    Maddison: 5
    Bogle: 5
    Smyth: 5
    Aneke: 8
    Washington: 6
    Morgan: 7.5
    Referee: 6
  • Amos; 5
    Matthews: 6 
    Gunter: 4
    Pratley: 5
    Maatsen: 4 
    Watson: 5
    Gilbey: 5
    Shinnie: 6
    Maddison: 4 
    Bogle: 5
    Smyth: 6
    Aneke: 8
    Washington: 6 
    Morgan: 8
    Referee: 5
  • our marks please 0.5 to 10 in whole or half marks:

    Amos; 3 poor at fault for 2nd
    Matthews: 4 don’t think any of his crosses found a man in red
    Gunter: 2 piss poor
    Pratley: 3 so much backwards and sideways. Needed our captain to fire us to a better performance.
    Maatsen: 2 his worst game for us by a million miles
    Watson: 4 slowed us down, though he did pull off some golden crossfield balls
    Gilbey: 3 absent first half slightly better second 
    Shinnie: 3 went missing second half
    Maddison: 3 so slow to release the ball; when he does put a cross in early doors it flies high and out
    Bogle: 4 didn’t do much wrong. Didn’t do much good either.
    Smyth: 5 good scrappy goal. Nothing else.
    Aneke: 7 we looked much better when he came on
    Washington: 6 would’ve scored if he’d avoided Aneke. A few times he could’ve slipped someone in for a goal though and chose to shoot.
    Morgan: 7 motm made a huge difference when he came on
    Referee: 4 too card happy

    Williams: n/a why bother

  • Amos: 5
    Matthews: 6
    Gunter: 4
    Pratley: 5
    Maatsen: 5.5
    Watson: 5
    Gilbey: 5
    Shinnie: 5
    Maddison: 5
    Bogle: 5
    Smyth: 5.5
    Aneke: 7.5
    Washington: 6.5
    Morgan: 8
    Referee: 5
  • Amos; 3
    Matthews: 5
    Gunter: 2
    Pratley: 1
    Maatsen: 2
    Watson: 4
    Gilbey: 4
    Shinnie: 4
    Maddison: 1
    Bogle: 2
    Smyth: 4.5
    Aneke: 6
    Washington: 5
    Morgan: 7
    Referee: 3
  • edited November 2020
    Amos: 4.5 - One mistake to pass to their bloke, another to punch the ball straight at the man in front of him. 
    Matthews: 6 - Too many crosses got past him today, but otherwise steady. 
    Gunter: 4 - Poor game, too often too far from his partner. Major mistake for the first.
    Pratley: 4 - As above
    Maatsen: 5 - Not as bad as people are making out, should have remained more defensive as defence could have used his pace. 
    Watson: 6 - Not at fault, tried to drive us on.
    Gilbey: 4 - Started very poorly, grew into the game, was still poor.
    Shinnie: 6 - Needs to do more, but not at fault for any problems, tried to keep us ticking over.
    Maddison: 5 - Not that bad. Not that good. Some dangerous balls into the box, Bogle didn't read them, can bet Aneke would have.
    Bogle: 5 - Not as bad as is being made out. Not good enough either.
    Smyth: 6 - Needs to play with Aneke
    Aneke: 7.5 - Game Changer 1 - What a goal
    Washington: 6.5 - Wasted a good opportunity but played in Albie for his assist. 
    Morgan: 8 - The kid's delivery is a step above. Needs to play in the first team now, he's proven himself over his last 5 appearances (all comps)
    Referee: 4.5 Some of those decisions were farcical... Not at fault for the result though.

    Bowyer 2. +2 for getting the subs right. Rest of his set up was shocking. All this talk of brilliant shape work and how good we looked over the break? 
  • edited November 2020
    Amos; 4
    Matthews: 6
    Gunter: 4
    Pratley: 6
    Maatsen: 4
    Watson: 5
    Gilbey: 5
    Shinnie: 5
    Maddison: 4
    Bogle: 4
    Smyth: 6
    Aneke: 6
    Washington: 6
    Morgan: 6
    Referee: 5

    Burton :   9 out of 10   very impressed and they deserve the plaudits 
  • Amos; 5
    Matthews: 5
    Gunter: 4
    Pratley: 4
    Maatsen: 5
    Watson: 6
    Gilbey: 6
    Shinnie: 6
    Maddison: 4
    Bogle: 4
    Smyth: 5
    Aneke: 7
    Washington: 7
    Morgan: 7.5
    Referee: 5
  • Amos: 4 cost us a goal, conceded 4 tonight, can't remember any saves he made, no understanding (understandably so) with the defenders in front of him
    Matthews: 5 best of an awful back 4
    Gunter: 2.5 not been a great couple of games for him really, if he's not careful he won't get his 100th Wales cap
    Pratley: 3 overrun all night, doesn't need a rest but needs a break from CB
    Maatsen: 2.5 think we saw tonight why he's been sent to cut his teeth with us, very poor tonight compounded by falling over every 5 minutes
    Watson: 4 another booking although very harsh, only thing he did of any note
    Gilbey: 4 benefit of the doubt for returning from injury, but poor
    Shinnie: 4.5 totally anonymous, which considering the performance might not be a bad thing
    Maddison: 3.5 that magic left foot that launched a ball into orbit, summed it up for him
    Bogle: 3 not at it, got the Purrington at qpr treatment, a lot to prove at the weekend 
    Smyth: 6 little extra for his goal, had some good ball control
    Aneke: 8 wonder goal, and a nuisance as usual, in the minority of players in credit tonight
    Washington: 6 should've scored, not his fault he didn't. One of only 2 strikers we have who knows how to shoot on sight
    Morgan: 8 game changer, showed the senior players how its done, must play more, he's young and his body can take it
    Referee: 6 not every foul is a booking, but ok generally compared to the wankstain on Saturday 
  • edited November 2020
    Amos; 3
    Matthews: 5
    Gunter: 4
    Pratley: 5
    Maatsen: 5
    Watson: 5
    Gilbey: 5
    Shinnie: 6
    Maddison: 5
    Bogle: 3
    Smyth: 5
    Aneke: 7
    Washington: 6
    Morgan: 6.5
    Referee: 5

    Williams: n/a
  • Sponsored links:


  • edited November 2020
    Amos 5 Terrible mistake for the 2nd goal, but was on a hiding to nothing with our so called defence tonight.
    Matthews 6 Defended ok apart from the 4th goal. His final attacking ball was poor. 
    Gunter 3 Absolutely awful. My fault for saying pre Gillingham, he hadn't made a serious mistake all season
    Pratley: 4.5 A poor game, but he's not a centre half.
    Maatsen 4 A very poor performance, but he put in 100% effort. I felt sorry for him.
    Watson: 4.5 Strolled around, didn't run once & pinged the ball mainly sideways and backwards.
    Gilbey 4 Did nothing of note & wasn't fit.
    Shinnie 4.5 Did nothing of note, not good enough if he's fit.
    Maddison 5 Looked poor & unfit, but put a number of dangerous balls into the box, that someone should be on to.
    Bogle: 5 Standard static performance.
    Smyth 5.5 Extra 0.5 for the goal.
    Aneke 7.5 Great performance, one of two pluses.
    Washington 6.5 Made himself busy, got into good positions, not good enough to take the chances.
    Morgan 8 MOM. Excellent performance. Perhaps he can give the others a lesson in how to pass a ball forwards.
    Referee 6 Better than many in L1. 
  • Amos; 4
    Matthews: 5
    Gunter: 4
    Pratley: 3.5
    Maatsen: 3.5
    Watson: 5.5
    Gilbey: 5.5
    Shinnie: 6
    Maddison: 4
    Bogle: 4
    Smyth: 5.5
    Aneke: 7.5
    Washington: 7
    Morgan: 7.5
    Referee: 4
  • Amos; 5 Loses a point for the second goal
    Matthews: 6 Our best defender
    Gunter: 5 Loses a point for the first goal 
    Pratley: 5 Loses a point for the fourth goal 
    Maatsen: 5 By far his worst game for us . Maybe play Purrington at the weekend 
    Watson: 5 Felt he didn't get going
    Gilbey: 5 Showed flashes of ability .
    Shinnie: 5 Didn't look as effective as previously .
    Maddison: 6 Felt he showed some promise in flashes 
    Bogle: 6 I suspect he was injured . Didn't deserve to be subbed so early 
    Smyth: 6 A well taken goal 
    Aneke: 8 Changed things when he came on . Would be interested to see him play with Bogle when we are chasing a game 
    Washington: 6 Looked interested 
    Morgan: 7 We improved when he came on 
  • Amos; 4
    Matthews: 6
    Gunter: 4
    Pratley: 4
    Maatsen: 5
    Watson: 4
    Gilbey: 5
    Shinnie: 6
    Maddison: 4
    Bogle: 4
    Smyth: 5
    Aneke: 7
    Washington: 6.5
    Morgan: 7
    Referee: 6

  • Amos; 2
    Matthews: 3
    Gunter: 1
    Pratley: 3
    Maatsen: 3
    Watson: 5
    Gilbey: 4
    Shinnie: 5
    Maddison: 3
    Bogle: 2
    Smyth: 5
    Aneke: 5
    Washington: 6.5
    Morgan: 6
    Referee: 5
    Piss poor

  • Amos: 5
    Matthews: 5
    Gunter: 3
    Pratley: 3
    Maatsen: 4
    Watson: 5
    Gilbey: 5
    Shinnie: 5
    Maddison: 3
    Bogle: 5
    Smyth: 6
    Aneke: 7
    Washington: 7
    Morgan: 8
    Referee: 6

    Williams: n/a
  • Amos; 5
    Matthews: 6
    Gunter: 4
    Pratley: 5
    Maatsen: 5
    Watson: 6
    Gilbey: 4
    Shinnie: 5
    Maddison: 4
    Bogle: 4
    Smyth: 6
    Aneke: 7
    Washington: 6
    Morgan: 7
    Referee: 5
  • Amos; 5
    Matthews: 6.5 - OK - tried to be constructive
    Gunter: 4.5 - oh dear - first goal give away led the whole performance downhill
    Pratley: 5 - Needs to play alongside a proper centre back
    Maatsen: 4.5 - A bit all over the place- needs to focus on a bit of composure
    Watson: 5 - some good passing but didn't protect back 4, booking not his fault this time 
    Gilbey: 5.5 - 
    Shinnie: 5.5 Midfield did not gel well together
    Maddison: 5.5 - some good moments but doesn't look part of the team yet
    Bogle: 5 - 
    Smyth: 5.5 - scored
    Aneke: 7 - great goal 
    Washington -6 left his shooting boots at home: 
    Morgan: 7 - made a real difference when he came on. One of few bright points 
    Referee: 5 - didn't send off Charlton player but then booked every Charlton player for virtually every foul committed in the second half

    Williams: n/a
  • Amos; 4 worst game of the season  At fault
    for the second 
    Matthews: 5 still not fully match sharp
    Gunter: 3 more misplaced passes than accurate. At fault for the first. 
    Pratley: 3.5 slightly better than Gunter. 
    Maatsen: 3.5 the one positive is he didn’t hide. Maybe needs a break. 
    Watson: 4.5 not great 
    Gilbey: 4 not match fit
    Shinnie: 5 hid for large parts 
    Maddison: 3.5 walked straight down the tunnel when subbed for Morgan who put his performance to shame
    Bogle: 4 Came out on Twitter a couple
    of days ago about being a scapegoat and then puts a performance in like that.
    Smyth: 5 not his game. Tbf the ball never got as far forward as him
    Aneke: 6.5 great goal. Was a handful
    Washington: 6.5 played well when he came on
    Morgan: 8 changed the game and have us a chance. Done what was asked of him. Can’t complain with that 
    Referee: 4 Some really weird decisions followed by cards knocks a mark off
  • Amos; 5 - Made a few saves and got no help from his defenders
    Matthews: 4 - Best defender but why didn't he make a tackle for the 4th goal
    Gunter: 2 - Needs a rest, looked totally lost at CH. Lucky not to be sent off
    Pratley: 2 - Didn't win a header and looked totally lost at CH
    Maatsen: 3 - Can't believe how backwards he has gone
    Watson: 5 - Made a few decent tackles (including one to stop a 5th) & should never have been booked
    Gilbey: 3 - Looks way off the pace and worse than he was a Gills
    Shinnie: 5 - Tried to play football but nothing came off
    Maddison: 1 - What a shocking performance, showed no effort, sulked when subbed off - where is the player we were all hoping for.
    Bogle: 2 - Can't head, control or pass a football at present. 
    Smyth: 5 - At least he scored but when you don't get the ball its hard to be effective.
    Aneke: 7 - Great goal, made a difference but -1 for blocking Washingtons shot on the line
    Washington: 6 - His energy made a difference, could have scored 3 goals -1 for not scoring from 1 yard from the Aneke cross
    Morgan: 7.5 - Star player after coming on, always looked to go forward when he got the ball. -0.5 for not making a tackle in the build up to the 4th goal
    Referee: 3 - Got so many decisions wrong, let Burton time waste & booked our players but not theirs for similar fouls
  • Sponsored links:


  • Amos; 4
    Matthews: 5
    Gunter: 4
    Pratley: 4
    Maatsen: 5
    Watson: 4
    Gilbey: 5
    Shinnie: 6
    Maddison: 3
    Bogle: 4
    Smyth: 5
    Aneke: 7
    Washington: 6
    Morgan: 7
    Referee: 6
  • Amos; 6
    Matthews: 6
    Gunter: 5
    Pratley: 4
    Maatsen: 6
    Watson: 5
    Gilbey: 6
    Shinnie: 6
    Maddison: 4
    Bogle: 3
    Smyth: 5
    Aneke: 7
    Washington: 7
    Morgan: 7
  • Amos; 3.5 poor
    Matthews: 4.5 best defender, still not good
    Gunter: 3.5 
    Pratley: 3.5 
    Maatsen: 3.5 got better 2nd half but showed his inexperience 
    Watson: 4.5 mainly anonymous, unfairly booked 
    Gilbey: 4 anonymous
    Shinnie: 4.5
    Maddison: 4
    Bogle: 4 
    Smyth: 5 extra for the goal
    Aneke: 7.5
    Washington: 7 
    Morgan: 7.5 streets ahead of every other player in midfield. Looked like he wanted to win. Should start Saturday
    Referee: 3.5 he was crap, card happy, fussy but at least better than Saturday. I suppose we have to get used to the variable standard of refereeing. It would be nice to think the ref on Saturday might be able to make his own decisions without the 4th official opposition manager making them for him
  • Amos: 5
    Matthews: 5
    Gunter: 4
    Pratley: 4
    Maatsen: 4
    Watson: 5
    Gilbey: 4,5
    Shinnie: 4.5
    Maddison: 4
    Bogle: 4
    Smyth: 6
    Aneke: 7.5
    Washington: 6
    Morgan: 7
    Referee: 5
  • edited November 2020
    Amos; 4.5 not his fault for the 1st but 2nd !
    Matthews: 5.5 average
    Gunter: 4 poor but out of position
    Pratley: 4 poor but out of position
    Maatsen: 4 never hid and did keep going but...
    Watson: 4. one paced and got his yellow.
    Gilbey: 5.5 better 2nd half but poor 1st half
    Shinnie: 5 disappeared
    Maddison: 5 one decent shot but so disappointing on a night I thought  he would shine.
    Bogle: 4 hooked but no worse than several others.
    Smyth: 6 extra point for goal.
    Aneke: 7.5 great goal but did he block Conor's shot ?
    Washington: 6.5 he gets into goal scoring positions. Not his night but so nearly scored 2.
    Morgan: 7.5 his form is so good. He must start Saturday.
    Referee: 6 bloody average but better than 11 of our players out of 14 !!!


  • Amos: 4
    Matthews: 5
    Gunter: 4
    Pratley: 4
    Maatsen: 4
    Watson: 5
    Gilbey: 4.5
    Shinnie: 5.5
    Maddison: 3
    Bogle: 3
    Smyth: 6
    Aneke: 7.5
    Washington: 6
    Morgan: 7.5
  • Amos; 6
    Matthews: 5
    Gunter: 4
    Pratley: 4
    Maatsen: 4
    Watson: 5
    Gilbey: 5
    Shinnie: 6
    Maddison: 4
    Bogle: 4
    Smyth: 6
    Aneke: 7

    Washington: 6
    Morgan: 7

    Referee: 5
  • Amos; 5
    Matthews: 6.5
    Gunter: 4
    Pratley: 6
    Maatsen: 5.5
    Watson: 5
    Gilbey: 5
    Shinnie: 5
    Maddison: 4
    Bogle: 5
    Smyth: 5.5
    Aneke: 7
    Washington: 6
    Morgan: 7.5

    Referee: 6
  • Amos; 6

    Matthews: 6

    Gunter: 5.5 Don't like marking a man down playing out of position but tonight was poor

    Pratley: 5.5 As Gunter

    Maatsen: 5.5 Sort your studs out!

    Watson: 5.5 back to his customary booking

    Gilbey: 5.5 Anonymous and rarely helped Maatsen out

    Shinnie: 5.5 Anonymous. Worst I've seen from him

    Maddison: 5 loses 0.5 for petulance in going down the tunnel when not injured

    Bogle: 6 Not too sure why he was singled out amongst a sea of crap. That said (touchwood) Chuks didn't get injured having played so much longer than he's used to.

    Smyth: 6 gains .5 for his goal otherwise pretty anonymous like too many others.

    Aneke: 7.5 plus 1 for that outstanding goal

    Washington:  6 Tried but should have scored at least once so loses .5.

    Morgan:  7.5 Created more in the first couple of minutes he was on than the rest of the midfield together. My MOM

    Referee: 6
  • Amos; 4 Worst game yet
    Matthews: 6 Probably our best defender
    Gunter: 4 Needs a rest
    Pratley: 5  
    Maatsen: 4 Didn’t think he played well against the Gills, this was even worse
    Watson: 5
    Gilbey: 4.5 Clearly not match ready. Shouldn’t be starting games. 
    Shinnie: 5 Largely anonymous 
    Maddison: 4 Didn’t seem to be trying too hard 
    Bogle: 5 Still sulking over the penalty on Saturday?
    Smyth: 6 
    Aneke: 8 Good typical performance we come to expect
    Washington: 6.5 Unlucky not to score
    Morgan: 8 MOM. Why didn’t he start?
    Referee: 5 Loves dishing out unwarranted yellow cards. Probably going for the most yellows dished out
    per season
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!