Referee for Saturday

Rock Spectacle

Keith Stroud

clive

Wigan Athletic v Charlton Athletic (17:30)
ADAM HERCZEG
Bradley Hall and Conor Brown
Fourth Official : Richard Eley
https://www.efl.com/news/2024/august/05/referee-appointments--9-11-august/

lancashire lad

Herczeg reffed our away game at Oxford last season with a mark of 3.73

doronron

lancashire lad said:

Herczeg reffed our away game at Oxford last season with a mark of 3.73

3.73,sounds about right ,we hardly ever get good refs in div 1

Leuth

I'm sure if we'd won with the exact same decisions it'd be a 6 or 7

clive

Charlton Athletic v Birmingham City (19:45)
ALEX CHILOWICZ
Andrew Hickman and Daniel Bonneywell
Fourth Official : Aaron Farmer
https://www.efl.com/news/2024/august/05/referee-appointments--carabao-cup-round-one/

lancashire lad

Leuth said:

I'm sure if we'd won with the exact same decisions it'd be a 6 or 7

from my experience it does not work out like that, OK if we win the mark might be slightly higher but that's all - Leuth I think you exaggerate

lancashire lad

clive said:

Charlton Athletic v Birmingham City (19:45)
ALEX CHILOWICZ
Andrew Hickman and Daniel Bonneywell
Fourth Official : Aaron Farmer
https://www.efl.com/news/2024/august/05/referee-appointments--carabao-cup-round-one/

Reffed last season Oxford at home with a mark of 6.75
Leuth please note we lost 1-2 

Starinnaddick

lancashire lad said:

clive said:

Charlton Athletic v Birmingham City (19:45)
ALEX CHILOWICZ
Andrew Hickman and Daniel Bonneywell
Fourth Official : Aaron Farmer
https://www.efl.com/news/2024/august/05/referee-appointments--carabao-cup-round-one/

Reffed last season Oxford at home with a mark of 6.75
Leuth please note we lost 1-2 

36 year old Yank tipped for the Premier League by fat man Steve. 

clive

Charlton Athletic v Leyton Orient (12:30)
EDWARD DUCKWORTH
Paul Kelly and Daniel D'Urso
Fourth Official : Paul Howard

Rothko

Andy D'urso son running the line 

clive

Charlton Athletic v Bolton Wanderers (15:00)
LEE SWABEY
David Harrison and Adrian Tranter
Fourth Official : Wayne Cartmel
https://www.efl.com/news/2024/august/20/referee-appointments--23-25-august/

lancashire lad

last season we saw Mr Swabey 3 times:
Posh A lost 1-0 with 4.66
Burton H 1-1 with 5.73
Wigan H 2-2 with 4.06

Ferryman

Although only death and taxes are guaranteed, we're surely guaranteed that he'll be better than last weeks ref.

eastterrace6168

lancashire lad said:

last season we saw Mr Swabey 3 times:
Posh A lost 1-0 with 4.66
Burton H 1-1 with 5.73
Wigan H 2-2 with 4.06

Oh dear, don't sound great with his marks does it!...🤞

ForeverAddickted

eastterrace6168 said:

lancashire lad said:

last season we saw Mr Swabey 3 times:
Posh A lost 1-0 with 4.66
Burton H 1-1 with 5.73
Wigan H 2-2 with 4.06

Oh dear, don't sound great with his marks does it!...🤞

Given the referees at this level, those marks would probably be considered quite good

clive

Reading v Charlton Athletic (15:00)
THOMAS KIRK
Andrew Aylott and Ryan Williams
Fourth Official : Richie Watkins

Chippycafc

clive said:

Reading v Charlton Athletic (15:00)
THOMAS KIRK
Andrew Aylott and Ryan Williams
Fourth Official : Richie Watkins

Appleton was pleased with him last year....Look who scored for Cambridge.

Charlton Athletic boss Michael Appleton: Referee had a shocker – he couldn’t wait to give penalty – South London News (londonnewsonline.co.uk)

clive

Charlton Athletic v Rotherham United (15:00)
SIMON MATHER
Damith Bandara and Anthony Da Costa
Fourth Official : David Rock
https://www.efl.com/news/2024/september/02/referee-appointments--7-12-september/

clive

Shrewsbury Town v Charlton Athletic (15:00)
SEBASTIAN STOCKBRIDGE
Oliver Bickle and Thomas Cooke
Fourth Official : Ben Wyatt

Cambridge United v Charlton Athletic (19:00)
CARL BROOK
Daniel Smith and Andrew Hickman
Fourth Official : Ryan Whitaker

lancashire lad

Brook: 23/24 home Fleetwood 3.30
Stockbridge: n/a

clive

Charlton Athletic v Blackpool (15:00)
CHARLES BREAKSPEAR
Daniel Bonneywell and James Hurst
Fourth Official : James Durkin
https://www.efl.com/news/2024/september/17/referee-appointments--20-25-september/

lancashire lad

Breakspear officiated our home game against Bristol Rovers at the beginning of last season which we lost 1-2 and his mark was 5.09

Macronate

In relation to the appointment of Breakspear, all I can say is that some are born great, some achieve greatness, and some have greatness thrust upon them.

Billy_Mix

Macronate said:

In relation to the appointment of Breakspear, all I can say is that some are born great, some achieve greatness, and some have greatness thrust upon them.

Macronate old chum, which bit of that quotation relates in any way whatever to the woefully erratic and inept Charles Breakspear?

clive

Stevenage v Charlton Athletic (15:00)
SCOTT TALLIS
Jonathon Block and Callum Gough
Fourth Official : Daniel Middleton

Bristol Rovers v Charlton Athletic (19:45)
DAVID ROCK
Ravel Cheosiaua and Thomas Harty
Fourth Official : Wayne Cartmel
https://www.efl.com/news/2024/september/25/referee-appointments--27-september-2-october/

lancashire lad

Tallis did not officiate us last season
Rock did: Exeter home, won 4-1 mark 6.29 & Lincoln home 1-1 mark 5.81

clive

Charlton Athletic v Birmingham City (15:00)
BENJAMIN SPEEDIE
Michael Webb and Jacob Lehane
Fourth Official : Sam Mulhall
https://www.efl.com/news/2024/october/02/referee-appointments--4-8-october/

golfaddick

I thought the ref last night did alright. Better than most we've had this season. 

Bedsaddick

golfaddick said:

I thought the ref last night did alright. Better than most we've had this season. 

The ref at Stevenage was good as well . It was just us that was shit .