Really bad players.

Peakey4Rocket

 Penney
Bonne
Fraser 
CBT
Payne

 
out of those tonight I genuinely don’t get how they’re good enough for the football league. There seems a lot of players who back in the late 90’s /00’s would have only been good enough for the conference and Isthmian currently in this squad

superclive98

Penney yes, the rest no.

CafcWest

superclive98 said:

Penney yes, the rest no.

Penney not great but tried...Bonne so bad its unbelieveable.  CBT and Fraser weren't great tonight.  Thought Payne had a good game.

Peakey4Rocket

superclive98 said:

Penney yes, the rest no.

How, Bonne is a disgrace, no first touch and can’t watch the line.
CBT, great athlete, absolute zero of a football brain. Poor.
Payne huffs and puffs but nothing
Fraser, genuinely don’t get the hype. Loads of dreadful touches and gets carried.
Have seen a lot better than those down the leagues 

esseffect

I guess you’ve only watched the 1 game this season?

Peakey4Rocket

esseffect said:

I guess you’ve only watched the 1 game this season?

Missed a few, at most. 

Enlighten me what you’ve seen that’s different. 

Am genuinely interested what you’ve seen? 

superdulvertonred

Penney and Bonne can’t disagree Payne below average CBT OK but inconsistent Fraser one of our better players IMO

eaststandmike

esseffect said:

I guess you’ve only watched the 1 game this season?

If the five players he has named are part of our team next season we will be mid table again. 

Leuth

Fraser was fantastic until about 5 games ago. Seems to have bodyswapped with Lepoint or something since then. Getting increasingly hard to defend him 

Leuth

Penney, however... I have few words, none nice 

Scoham

Peakey4Rocket said:

esseffect said:

I guess you’ve only watched the 1 game this season?

Missed a few, at most. 

Enlighten me what you’ve seen that’s different. 

Am genuinely interested what you’ve seen? 

A mid table League 1 squad on their way to a mid table finish?

ValleyGary

Bonne is actually worse than when he moved up a level. For a player that got championship coaching he’s regressed. 

Peakey4Rocket

eaststandmike said:

esseffect said:

I guess you’ve only watched the 1 game this season?

If the five players he has named are part of our team next season we will be mid table again. 

It’s only those 5 I’m questioning. Nowhere near good enough to claim to be ‘pros’. Embarrassing to other pros I’d say 

stockportaddick

Bonne is awful.

cafctom

Penney and Bonne are in a league of their own when it comes to this. The likes of CBT and Fraser, even on their weaker days, shouldn’t be lumped in with them.

Croydon

Payne is one of the most ineffective players I've ever seen play. At least Bonne and Penney are so shit that they do something amusing every now and then. 

Scoham

eaststandmike said:

esseffect said:

I guess you’ve only watched the 1 game this season?

If the five players he has named are part of our team next season we will be mid table again. 

I'd rather we bring in some real quality (I know it's not looking likely as things stand) than try to replace the entire squad. Having some of them as back up won't be what stops us getting promoted next season. Both our last two promotion squads included mid table L1 players who got plenty of game time.

esseffect

Fraser is a decent player.

I don’t think we see enough of Payne to even comment 

Jayajosh

ValleyGary said:

Bonne is actually worse than when he moved up a level. For a player that got championship coaching he’s regressed. 

Played 8 and scored 0. Be interested to see how many shots on target he’s had in those 8 games. I bet it’s not more than 1 per game.

Dazzler21

Jayajosh said:

ValleyGary said:

Bonne is actually worse than when he moved up a level. For a player that got championship coaching he’s regressed. 

Played 8 and scored 0. Be interested to see how many shots on target he’s had in those 8 games. I bet it’s not more than 1 per game.

I have a feeling it's 3/4 total. I hoped he'd do something when we had the extra man. Can't be bothered to defend that shit anymore.

Callumcafc

Only players from tonight I'd want to see in a Charlton shirt next season are AMB, Ness, Sess, Dobson, Rak-Sakyi and Leaburn.

In reality we'll be lucky to hang on to three of them.


The rest of the players involved tonight are welcome to find a new side... Clare, Inniss, Hector, Penney, Fraser, Payne, Bonne aren't going to get us promoted. Some will stay and can help fill a squad but not heartbroken if they go. Might as well give up by mid-September if they're regular starters.

SELR_addicks

Callumcafc said:

Only players from tonight I'd want to see in a Charlton shirt next season are AMB, Ness, Sess, Dobson, Rak-Sakyi and Leaburn.

In reality we'll be lucky to hang on to three of them.


The rest of the players involved tonight are welcome to find a new side... Clare, Inniss, Hector, Penney, Fraser, Payne, Bonne aren't going to get us promoted.

Fixed it for you. 

Rest are gone in the summer. 

PeanutsMolloy

Penney, Bonne and Clare.
Can’t split them - all rank.

Athletico Charlton

Penny, Bonne, Clare, Innis, Lavelle, Thomas, Morgan, Payne, Aneke, Kirk... Would be wonderful to get rid of the lot in the summer.  
Some might get another L1 gig, most would have to drop to L2 imo.

ValleyGary

SELR_addicks said:

Callumcafc said:

Only players from tonight I'd want to see in a Charlton shirt next season are AMB, Ness, Sess, Dobson, Rak-Sakyi and Leaburn.

In reality we'll be lucky to hang on to three of them.


The rest of the players involved tonight are welcome to find a new side... Clare, Inniss, Hector, Penney, Fraser, Payne, Bonne aren't going to get us promoted.

Fixed it for you. 

Rest are gone in the summer. 

Yep, let’s be honest, unless something changes at the top then we are in for the same old shit next season. We can attract average players that will get us 14th, which is even more frustrating because with the right owner that would change to playoffs. Until that changes, what’s the fucking point.

Peakey4Rocket

esseffect said:

Fraser is a decent player.

I don’t think we see enough of Payne to even comment 

esseffect said:

Fraser is a decent player.

I don’t think we see enough of Payne to even comment 

esseffect said:

Fraser is a decent player.

I don’t think we see enough of Payne to even comment 

Easily please Essefect. Clearly never played the game either. He’s reasonable 2 in 5. Tonight:attrocious

Oh Eddie Youds...

I’d trigger the option to extend CBTs contract for another year personally.

Part of the reason we didn’t look like scoring tonight was because a) one of our biggest goal threats was on the bench for over an hour (in CBT) & b) the only other goal threat we have (Rak-Sakyi) was played out of position for a similar period of time.

We never look like scoring when we play 352. This squad suits 433.

ken_shabby

I can barely criticise Bonne as I barely notice him. CBT for example gets a lot of ball and attacks, passes, defends and shoots with a wide margin of success. Bonne is just a player the ball bounces off occasionally, usually to a defender. We have players at the club currently that Welling would be looking to offload in the summer.

Peakey4Rocket

Callumcafc said:

Only players from tonight I'd want to see in a Charlton shirt next season are AMB, Ness, Sess, Dobson, Rak-Sakyi and Leaburn.

In reality we'll be lucky to hang on to three of them.


The rest of the players involved tonight are welcome to find a new side... Clare, Inniss, Hector, Penney, Fraser, Payne, Bonne aren't going to get us promoted. Some will stay and can help fill a squad but not heartbroken if they go. Might as well give up by mid-September if they're regular starters.

I’d start those 5 and patch it up with youth for the rest of the season. Seriously doubting my sanity following these everywhere this season. 

I

Fortune 82nd Minute

cafctom said:

Penney and Bonne are in a league of their own when it comes to this. The likes of CBT and Fraser, even on their weaker days, shouldn’t be lumped in with them.

Is the correct answer to the original question.

Bonne is truly awful. It will be a miracle if he scores in the rest of the season. His shot, from a reasonable position, that he put out for a throw sums him up.

If Bonne is awful, Penney is just truly comical. He cant control the ball without it going 5 yards away from him. And his attempted tackle when he fell over and the ball went through his legs just sums him up. 

How did we sign either of them?

LargeAddick

Penney plays like he’s got two left feet. He’s absolute toilet.