Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

MATCH THREAD (+post p20) : Charlton Athletic V Bromley : BSM Trophy : Tues 12 November 2024 KO 19:00

11920222425

Comments

  • clive said:
    Is the commentary on CAFC TV tonight?
    Addicks worldwide can tune into live audio commentary of the clash from CharltonTV's Smith and Stubley, while those in the UK and Ireland can watch the game live on Sky Sports+.
    https://www.charltonafc.com/news/watch-bromley-cup-clash-live-charltontv
    I’ve not even got Sky, let alone Sky Sports or Sky Sports + 
    Terry and Greg for me.
    I didn’t know you had it in you. 
  • 1 shot on target each I reckon. 
    One more than our usual. 
  • Dear, dear, dear! About as inspiring as a wet fart!
    11 days till we play again, 11 days to sort the entire squad out, it's just awful week after week!
    NJ has loads of work to do! 

    sam3110 said:
    What's the actual formation?
    1-0 win played at 60% to avoid injuries …. could have been 2/3 but we win the group 100% record and most important no further injuries … good experience for a few young players .. well
    done boys 

    So some teams play 2 at home and 1 away and others the opposite?

  • The U21 teams nearly all losing, Man City U21s getting hammered 5-0 by you assume a less than full strength Lincoln side, does raise a few interesting questions.

    Which questions ?
  • fenaddick said:
    Average age ability of the team on the pitch must be very low 
    Fixed
  • The U21 teams nearly all losing, Man City U21s getting hammered 5-0 by you assume a less than full strength Lincoln side, does raise a few interesting questions.

    Which questions ?
    Maybe they're playing at 60% too?
  • Chunes said:
    If they fine Berry a week's wages for that performance, I don't think he could argue
    I'd have subbed him as soon as he made that "pass" in the first half, and then fine him. I'm still annoyed by it.
  • WHAddick said:
    The U21 teams nearly all losing, Man City U21s getting hammered 5-0 by you assume a less than full strength Lincoln side, does raise a few interesting questions.

    Which questions ?
    Maybe they're playing at 60% too?
    That's right, it's to avoid injuries. That's why City have lost 4 in a row (5 if you include tonight)
  • Sponsored links:


  • Chunes said:
    If they fine Berry a week's wages for that performance, I don't think he could argue
    First teamers were told not to get injured .. clear we played at 60% tonight 
    Probably right. 
  • Turgid stuff. I now believe in reincarnation as I must have done something bad in a previous life to have suporting Charlton inflicted on me.
  • I had it on for petrol head (honestly) and fell asleep on and off watching it 
    did the crap commentator keep saying Ahadme had been subbed , naming the wrong player and even talked up Leaburns goal , wasn’t that a big deflection 🤷‍♂️
    what was NJ sent off for , for controlling the ball an inch outside his technical area and speeding the game up rather than letting it bounce in To the crowd ,  all very weird 
  • Dear, dear, dear! About as inspiring as a wet fart!
    11 days till we play again, 11 days to sort the entire squad out, it's just awful week after week!
    NJ has loads of work to do! 

    sam3110 said:
    What's the actual formation?
    1-0 win played at 60% to avoid injuries …. could have been 2/3 but we win the group 100% record and most important no further injuries … good experience for a few young players .. well
    done boys 

    Bloody hell, "well done boys!" Really? It was an awful offering, I'm nearly 70 and could've moved the ball quicker, sharper and more accurately!
    1-0 win against a League 2 reserve side!
    You must take off those 'rose-tinted' glasses, and accept it was a borefest, poor football, and uninspiring. 
    Finally, if I was a youngster being given my opportunity to play in the 1st team, there is no-way I would've just played to 60%, I would've given 100% to make an impression on NJ!


  • Didn't watch the game but from the comments on here and from the highlights it might be that Kai Enslin offers more of a creative attacking midfield threat than the other options we've tried. At least he seems to be able to beat a player without simply relying on pace.
  • Davo55 said:
    Didn't watch the game but from the comments on here and from the highlights it might be that Kai Enslin offers more of a creative attacking midfield threat than the other options we've tried. At least he seems to be able to beat a player without simply relying on pace.
    I’d like to see him making the squad for the next few league games. He’d add pace and the ability to run with the ball, something we lack across the team in most positions.

    It’ll be interesting to see where Jones sees him playing. He’s mainly played LWB for the u21s, but been a RW in the past along with filling in at CB and CM. Could make a case for most of those positions as he has a bit of everything to his game without being outstanding in one or two areas. 
  • Thoroughly unimpressed by anything on show last night if i'm honest - how we have constructed a squad with such a lack of attacking ability or pace is quite something. I genuinely have no idea what our route to goal is supposed to be in any of the formations we play. If Jones, Ramsey and Campbell aren't back very soon, i struggle to see how we will grind out another win.  
  • Rob said:
    Chunes said:
    If they fine Berry a week's wages for that performance, I don't think he could argue
    First teamers were told not to get injured .. clear we played at 60% tonight 
    Probably right. 
    Agreed. People only lol the post because it’s ronnie

    the change in shape, style and some youngsters getting game time suggests that the game was taken as a glorified friendly
  • Sponsored links:


  • So am I correct in saying that jones got sent off for kicking the ball when it was still on the pitch?

    I haven’t seen the replay, did he! 
  • So am I correct in saying that jones got sent off for kicking the ball when it was still on the pitch?

    I haven’t seen the replay, did he! 
    That’s what it was for but I would be surprised if that’s actually what happened
  • So am I correct in saying that jones got sent off for kicking the ball when it was still on the pitch?

    I haven’t seen the replay, did he! 
    Impossible, to tell if ball was still in play.
    Incident occurs at about 30 seconds in this film.
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V1oe4mklkdE
  • I’ve only seen it once 
    no one was anywhere near the ball which was going to bounce out of play and probably in to the crowd he stepped out of his technical area one foot and controlled it and left it there prolly on the line or partially over the line at most if at all , genuinely speeding the game up , no one complained ,seemed really nit picky if it was for that .
  • It was hard to fully understand the Jones incident from the stream, the commentator seemed to me to be watching in a studio somewhere and was a second behind the action throughout (maybe picture and audio mismatch), but from what I could discern the referee told Nathan Jones off for something, but it was Jones reaction to the initial censure that escalated it to a sending off, because after the referee bit, Jones apparently went pleading and moaning to the fourth official.
    Admittedly that is my take, and others might have a clearer idea about what happened.
  • Having endured (there really is no other word for it) watching the game, I was so disappointed that the highly skilful, entertaining & future Charlton legend Allan Campbell didn’t get any game time





















  • Well it was better than Hollyoaks and Eastenders that my wife was watching, mind you that not a hard bar to crawl over.
  • I’ve only seen it once 
    no one was anywhere near the ball which was going to bounce out of play and probably in to the crowd he stepped out of his technical area one foot and controlled it and left it there prolly on the line or partially over the line at most if at all , genuinely speeding the game up , no one complained ,seemed really nit picky if it was for that .
    Just seen the replay and was going to say the same. It’s not like he broke up a Bromley attack or kept the ball to prevent a quick counter. The ball was either out nearly out, not a single player near him. This is where refs need to have brains and not be robots.

    im wondering if jones than mouthed back after his telling off
  • Why not have a word with Jones and maybe book him. But to send him off shows a lack of common sense. My son is a ref and doing well and I had a good discussion with him last night. I said that I felt the game is trying to remove common sense from refs, maybe to make decisions accross the piece more consistent and he agreed but said he would always apply common sense as a cornerstone to how he refs. I said that could hold him back and he said basically, if it does it does but he doesn't want to ref like a robot.

    Having said that, we discussed the handball rule and he has to apply the laws but he does speak to sides afterwards and say he doesn't like doing it but that is what the laws of the game are now. My belief which I won't go into is the people at the top of the game are idiots and VAR could have been introduced so that it works much better, just stop trying to make it perfect which is impossible, and apply those magic words, common sense to everything. Maybe they don't think there are enough people with common sense to go round.
  • Its official, we are the kings of the south London derby, just give us the trophy now!
Sign In or Register to comment.

Roland Out Forever!