Andrew Shinnie - (Ed. joined Livingston)

letthegoodtimesroll said:

Callumcafc said:

One of very few players to not have a highlights compilation on YouTube!

If a player needs a couple of minutes of clips from his career in order to attract the attention of another club then he’s not made much of an impression on his fellow pros, opposing managers or clubs scouts when he’s played 

You can bet your life that a player like Shinnie has impressed Bowyer when we've played Luton.
He'll remember that.

A few years ago, I remember Chris Powell telling us he rebuilt the squad that summer with many players who'd impressed as opponents, when they'd played against us the season before.

Did wonder why we left the number 9 free

Sillybilly said:

Dazzler21 said:

Sillybilly said:

Didn’t he get sent off for Luton at the Valley the day we broke their humungous unbeaten run?   Seem to remember he was rubbish that day but hey ho, we need bodies. Can’t offer any less than Oztumer. 

Bit harsh judging him by a game where we out played their entire team. How does an individual stand out in that situation? 

He was no worse than the rest of his team that day. First yellow I think was quite questionable. Red card didn't affect the game at all.

I didn’t say he was rubbish. I said he was rubbish “that day”. I’m well aware of Shinnie from his days in Scottish football. I’m interested in why he’s having to take a downward step at this stage. Maybe all Covid situation related or maybe he’s just past his best. Or maybe he’s not and we’ve nabbed a bargain. Only time will tell. 

Your comment of 'hey ho, we need bodies.' suggested that you felt he was rubbish more than just on that day, especially coupled with the line 'Can't offer any less than Oztumer'.

jacob_CAFC said:

Chunes said:

Did wonder why we left the number 9 free

Think Bogle was meant to have it but cos of Bonne being at the club he couldn't take it

But didn't they register the shirts after Bonne left? I'd have thought they could've swapped it.

I'd be very surprised if we ended up with five strikers to be honest. 

Chunes said:

jacob_CAFC said:

Chunes said:

Did wonder why we left the number 9 free

Think Bogle was meant to have it but cos of Bonne being at the club he couldn't take it

But didn't they register the shirts after Bonne left? I'd have thought they could've swapped it.

I'd be very surprised if we ended up with five strikers to be honest. 

Davison is a rookie, Smyth isn't really a striker.  Even Aneke sees himself as more of an attacking No 10

Redhenry said:

Might be my last post, talking to a striker on a free, certainly not done atm

 Ignore the haters @Redhenry

Your input is always welcome as far as I'm concerned.

Redhenry said:

Might be my last post, talking to a striker on a free, certainly not done atm

Like many have already said Redhenry, please do not stop with any rumours or knowledge you may have, some of us understand that not every piece of information comes true, but you do have a good score. No, I have not looked at Dazzler21's ITK thread 

Dazzler21 said:

killerandflash said:

Chunes said:

jacob_CAFC said:

Chunes said:

Did wonder why we left the number 9 free

Think Bogle was meant to have it but cos of Bonne being at the club he couldn't take it

But didn't they register the shirts after Bonne left? I'd have thought they could've swapped it.

I'd be very surprised if we ended up with five strikers to be honest. 

Davison is a rookie, Smyth isn't really a striker.  Even Aneke sees himself as more of an attacking No 10

Aneke did say he wanted to become our main striker when Taylor refused to return. 

And Bowyer has said more than once he doesn't think he is. Time will tell.

Of course Aneke can play there, I don't think Bowyer will play him there regularly unless he has to. 

Cafc43v3r said:

Dazzler21 said:

killerandflash said:

Chunes said:

jacob_CAFC said:

Chunes said:

Did wonder why we left the number 9 free

Think Bogle was meant to have it but cos of Bonne being at the club he couldn't take it

But didn't they register the shirts after Bonne left? I'd have thought they could've swapped it.

I'd be very surprised if we ended up with five strikers to be honest. 

Davison is a rookie, Smyth isn't really a striker.  Even Aneke sees himself as more of an attacking No 10

Aneke did say he wanted to become our main striker when Taylor refused to return. 

And Bowyer has said more than once he doesn't think he is. Time will tell.

Of course Aneke can play there, I don't think Bowyer will play him there regularly unless he has to. 

Yeah, Bowyer said when Aneke first signed, after scoring something like 19 goals for MKD the season before, that he actually saw him as a '10' playing behind the main striker.

Something like that. You know what my memory's like these days!


#managerdesperateforamidfielderwhoscoresgoals

Redhenry said:

Might be my last post, talking to a striker on a free, certainly not done atm

All the best at Cardiff Dills, I get how hard it'll be to get info about Charlton from South Wales though, maybe you can change your name to BlueDaffyd and offer snippets on Bywyd Caerdydd?

Rave review of Shinnie by Nathan Jones - https://www.lutontoday.co.uk/sport/football/luton-town/jones-pays-wonderful-shinnie-glowing-tribute-after-he-makes-loan-move-charlton-3008308

Cafc43v3r said:

Dazzler21 said:

Bowyer may have said that on signing him, doesn't mean he still feels that way. If he did, surely he wouldn't keep playing him up top?

Either way I think he's huge benefit to have in the squad, but I don't think we've seen him behind the two yet. 

Apart from almost every game he played last season, all be it not many. 

That’s not true, about half and half I’d say.