Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Charlton squad out of contract for next season - who to keep?
Comments
-
His contract expires in 2025, so we can't let him go.Chris_from_Sidcup said:
He's just turned 19 and he's playing in a terrible side. How can you write him off already?RonnieMoore said:
Because he not done it at Colchester .. and won’t feature next season for us then if you are planning to be in the championship year after .. Mitchell won’t be anywhere near championship standard .. so let him go now and build his career , have a first refusal and big sell onChris_from_Sidcup said:
Sorry what?RonnieMoore said:Isted Stay
AMB go
Ward go
Jones Stay
Hector go
Thomas Stay
Ness go
Edun Stay
T Watson Stay
Mitchell go
Small Stay
Gillespie Stay
Chin go
Green Stay
Asiimwe Loan
Ramsey Stay
Dobson go
Fraser like him to stay think he would fit into Jones style of play
Payne go
DJ go
Camara return
Taylor Stay
Henry go
McGrandles go
Campbell go
Watson return
Bakinson return ( make offer )
Anderson stay
Coventry stay
Fiorini return
LuaLua ( 50/50 )
May Stay
Leaburn stay
Wickham (50/50)
Ladapo return
Aneke (50/50)
Kanu stay
Casey loan
Why would you get rid of one of our brightest young defenders who only just turned 19 and is under contract until 2025?
It's like Spurs saying let's release Harry Kane because he didn't do much on loan at Leicester in the championship.
1 -
Thierry Small - Keep IMMEDIATELY
Tyreeq Bakinson - Let go
Connor Wickham - probably let go unless pay as you play, trust Jones on this one.
Michael Hector - Let go far to error prone and people forget he was our most experienced CB
Panutche Camara - Looked incredible first appearance but not done much since let go
Terell Thomas - Keep i think he is underrated by a large portion of our fanbase
Lewis Ward - no strong opinion, i know we have a young GK from Chelsea so may be better exposing him to First team but as said not an isssue either way
Lucas Ness - Keep i think there is a player there but has been put in to a relatively poor defence, needs to play with an organised defence. Last season he was the mature head alongside Inniss so was always in trouble.
George Dobson - Academic, short if the Hungarians voiding his contract through financial mismanagement or incompetence he is GONE.
Jack Payne - Honestly let go but i wouldnalways welcome him back with other teams, his desire and work rate cant be question just purely his ability to play for a top end league 1 team.
Diallang Jaiyesimi - forgot he existed tbh LET GO
Richard Chin - KEEP one more season with exposure to first team with understanding it sink or swim time
0 -
DJ one goal and one sending off in his current loan spell so that’s not going well either. For me DJ and Payne in particular should never be near a Charlton team again.3
-
Thierry Small - Keep
Tyreeq Bakinson - Let go
Connor Wickham - Let go
Michael Hector - Let go
Panutche Camara - Let go
Terell Thomas - Keep if we are planning to play 352.
Lewis Ward - Let go
Lucas Ness - Let go. Not quick, not good in the air.
George Dobson - Keep if possibly
Jack Payne - Let go
Diallang Jaiyesimi - Let go
Richard Chin - Let go.
Tyreece Campbell- Keep
Also let go:
AMB, Edun, McGrandles, Aneke, Taylor, Fraser.
To keep (in addition to above)
Isted (back-up)
Watson
Asiimwe
Jones
Mitchell
Ramsay
REG
Coventry
Anderson
May
Kanu
Leaburn.
We need a left back, 2 centre halves, 2 central midfielders, maybe 3, 2 strikers if the plan is to play 352.
2 -
no point to letting Aneke go, we would have to pay him anyway, may aswell pay him and let him play his 90mins over the course of the seasonwmcf123 said:Thierry Small - Keep
Tyreeq Bakinson - Let go
Connor Wickham - Let go
Michael Hector - Let go
Panutche Camara - Let go
Terell Thomas - Keep if we are planning to play 352.
Lewis Ward - Let go
Lucas Ness - Let go. Not quick, not good in the air.
George Dobson - Keep if possibly
Jack Payne - Let go
Diallang Jaiyesimi - Let go
Richard Chin - Let go.
Tyreece Campbell- Keep
Also let go:
AMB, Edun, McGrandles, Aneke, Taylor, Fraser.
To keep (in addition to above)
Isted (back-up)
Watson
Asiimwe
Jones
Mitchell
Ramsay
REG
Coventry
Anderson
May
Kanu
Leaburn.
We need a left back, 2 centre halves, 2 central midfielders, maybe 3, 2 strikers if the plan is to play 352.3 -
Tad harsh on Payne, he just isnt good enough at this level over the course of a season. always showed lots of effort and ad some good moments.MintoHumbugs said:DJ one goal and one sending off in his current loan spell so that’s not going well either. For me DJ and Payne in particular should never be near a Charlton team again.1 -
Thierry Small, - KEEP
Tyreeq Bakinson (his Wednesday contract expires this summer), Bye Bye
Connor Wickham, - TBD
Michael Hector, - BYE BYE
Panutche Camara (his Ipswich contract expires this summer), BYE BYE
Terell Thomas, KEEP
Lewis Ward, BYE BYE
Lucas Ness, - KEEP
George Dobson, - KEEP if we can
Jack Payne, - BYE BYE
Diallang Jaiyesimi, - BYE BYE
Richard Chin. - BYE BYE - i like Richard a lot, but i think NL is actually his level right now.
0 -
Great post, Swis !Swisdom said:
I keep telling myself not to bite at the things you say. "Surely he can't actually believe the shit he spouts" is my internal monologueRonnieMoore said:Mitchell go
And then I read you think we should get rid of Zach Mitchell....and it all becomes apparent...you clearly are not wired up right!
Mitchell was one of their best players earlier in the season but, unsurprisingly, after 3 different managers in the season scraping at the bottom of League 2 survival is not proving to be a great place for a 19 year old making his way in the game.
That boy is a superb footballer and, provided this season hasn't adversely affected his confidence too much, will be in and around the first team with us next season.
Whereas you Ronnie, you're just a buffoon now and I dare say you will remain to be so next season!
Echo my thoughts completely.1 -
Do whatever it takes to keep Dobbo
sign up Small on a longer contract.Give TT a year
Move on the rest along with Fraser and McGrandles.2 -
How can we keep Dobson when he's already gone, having signed a pre-contract contract? We'd have to buy him.Dazzler21 said:Thierry Small, Keep
Tyreeq Bakinson (his Wednesday contract expires this summer), Keep
Connor Wickham,
Michael Hector,
Panutche Camara (his Ipswich contract expires this summer),
Terell Thomas, Keep
Lewis Ward,
Lucas Ness,
George Dobson, Keep
Jack Payne,
Diallang Jaiyesimi,
Richard Chin.2 -
Sponsored links:
-
I'm surprised that so many people don't want to keep TT. For me, he barely puts a foot wrong and has probably been our best defender this year. There's a reason he's played almost every minute under Jones.
We won't be signing anyone like Ricardo Santos or Cashin in the Summer, having a defender who can play all across the backline is invaluable to a squad.5 -
We cant, unless some how the hungarians void their commitment through incompetence or financial issues, he will be there player.AddicksAddict said:
How can we keep Dobson when he's already gone, having signed a pre-contract contract? We'd have to buy him.Dazzler21 said:Thierry Small, Keep
Tyreeq Bakinson (his Wednesday contract expires this summer), Keep
Connor Wickham,
Michael Hector,
Panutche Camara (his Ipswich contract expires this summer),
Terell Thomas, Keep
Lewis Ward,
Lucas Ness,
George Dobson, Keep
Jack Payne,
Diallang Jaiyesimi,
Richard Chin.0 -
Keep TT as a solid backup. Conor Wickham not enough game time yet to decide.
Ness, just see if he develops under a better squad environment , and Thierry small on the longest deal he’ll sign.1 -
Small and Dobson. Ness or Thomas possibly but only as back up. Depends how Wickham and Lua Lua perform, same with camara but he's running out of time after a year of injuries.0
-
2 years now.DOUCHER said:Small and Dobson. Ness or Thomas possibly but only as back up. Depends how Wickham and Lua Lua perform, same with camara but he's running out of time after a year of injuries.
We shouldn't be considering any offer to Camara IMHO.7 -
I’d say the same for Wickham - too much of a risk with Leaburn and Aneke the alternatives. One of our top priorities in the summer should be a physical striker with a good fitness record.North Lower Neil said:
2 years now.DOUCHER said:Small and Dobson. Ness or Thomas possibly but only as back up. Depends how Wickham and Lua Lua perform, same with camara but he's running out of time after a year of injuries.
We shouldn't be considering any offer to Camara IMHO.5 -
agreed - i'd say its the top priorityScoham said:
I’d say the same for Wickham - too much of a risk with Leaburn and Aneke the alternatives. One of our top priorities in the summer should be a physical striker with a good fitness record.North Lower Neil said:
2 years now.DOUCHER said:Small and Dobson. Ness or Thomas possibly but only as back up. Depends how Wickham and Lua Lua perform, same with camara but he's running out of time after a year of injuries.
We shouldn't be considering any offer to Camara IMHO.1 -
Small and TT.0
-
My view on this depends on who is available to come in and replace any player. For example although a window later, I would accept that Edmunds Green is an upgrade for Sean Clare as a versatile defender / defensive midfield option.
Clearly Small needs to be signed, potentially beyond the one year extension trigger. Like others I would keep Thomas. Unlike some I would also extend Hector's contract. I find it interesting that our defensive problems got worse after his injury. I think he would benefit from Jones.
I see Lua Lua , Wickham , Camara , Bakinson and Ladapo as all being effectively on trial and I will only give a view at the end of the season.
I think Ness should be allowed to move on and Fiorini and Louie Watson return to their parent clubs. I find it interesting that although he impressed many on here ( including me ) three managers have not played Louie.1 -
Just been watching Mansfield vs Colchester. The Colchester goalie Owen Goodman was immense. Don’t know if he’s like that every week but was very impressed0
-
Sponsored links:
-
3
-
Thierry Small, definitely keep (if he wants to stay)
Tyreeq Bakinson keep
Connor Wickham, depends on the Chuks situation
Michael Hector, keep
Panutche Camara let go
Terell Thomas, keep
Lewis Ward, let go
Lucas Ness keep
George Dobson, keep (depends on the 'Hungary pre contract')
Jack Payne, let go
Diallang Jaiyesimi,let go
Richard Chin. let go
2 -
I wonder what it would take to sign Viktor Johansson from Rotherham.Pelling1993 said:Just been watching Mansfield vs Colchester. The Colchester goalie Owen Goodman was immense. Don’t know if he’s like that every week but was very impressed
I'm guessing he'll end up somewhere like Sheffield United.1 -
It is interesting.carly burn said:
But of the guys who started on Monday, only Hector, Thomas and Dobson are out of contract at the end of this season. Dobson is presumably gone but you couldn't fault his effort on Monday and Thomas and Hector didn't look to me as if they had been told they wouldn't be offered a contract. So the only one who presumably knows he wont be here next year was Ladapo. And his performance may well have reflected that.
So its a bit hard to pin that awful display on players not caring because they know they won't be here next year.
1 -
Keep Hector, Small and Bakinson. Thomas at a push as versatile.0
-
Probably explains why Anderson has played so much while we haven’t see Camara, Fiorini, L Watson etc at all - Jones already knows we won’t sign any of them permanently.carly burn said:1 -
Pretty certain either Hector or Thomas said recently that conversations with players about next season haven't started yet which wouldn't surprise me. Jones is probably putting feelers out before deciding who he wants aroundFortune 82nd Minute said:
It is interesting.carly burn said:
But of the guys who started on Monday, only Hector, Thomas and Dobson are out of contract at the end of this season. Dobson is presumably gone but you couldn't fault his effort on Monday and Thomas and Hector didn't look to me as if they had been told they wouldn't be offered a contract. So the only one who presumably knows he wont be here next year was Ladapo. And his performance may well have reflected that.
So its a bit hard to pin that awful display on players not caring because they know they won't be here next year.
0 -
Keep these...
9 -
I don't want to be keeping players on the basis we might not do better. We need to do better.
You improve your first team and let the ones still here compete for a place or provide back up.
Looking at centre back, REG, Jones and Gillesphey are going nowhere, so we need to let at least two of Thomas, Ness and Hector go, if Jones is planning to stick with 3 at the back we need to at least sign two centre backs and they should be first choices. Hector isn't going to want to be 5th, 6th choice, and he'll be too expensive for that, so let him go. Maybe Thomas is a versatile option for that 5th choice spot so there's some merit in the argument to keep him, especially if it lets us loan Mitchell again so he gets a good amount of games.
1 -
Thierry Small - keep
Tyreeq Bakinson - offer a short term deal
Connor Wickham - let go
Michael Hector / Terell Thomas - offer one of these two a short term deal
Panutche Camara - let go
Lewis Ward - offer a short term deal (his value isn’t in his first team contributions)
Lucas Ness - let go, needs regular senior minutes, low ceiling
George Dobson - let go
Jack Payne - let go
Diallang Jaiyesimi - let go
Richard Chin - let go, needs regular senior minutes, low ceiling
5
