Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.
Charlton Summer Transfer Rumours 2024
Comments
-
🤞Starinnaddick said:
Are you still sticking to this?golfaddick said:
I've said I'm done if he goes.....and will only return once Nathan Jones leaves.ButtleJR said:https://x.com/natediazisking/status/1801318245544112479?t=VI0t42nyAfS--cQ9V1IzOA&s=19
Some people are rather dramatic aren't they... Not the first I've seen either.1 -
I fully understand the 'angst' over Alfie, I also understand that in some quarters people don't trust or have faith in NJ and/or the new owners. However everytime I open CL there are numerous unread posts on the RUMOURS thread. I open it in eager anticipation of a rumour or even of a 'signing imminent' only to find ongoing discussions on Alfie, and his 'unkown' situation. Now I also get a few people want to express their opinions, BUT, it's the same stuff being regurgitated.
Let's wait and see what, if anything, transpires and perhaps in the meantime get back to rumours etc. Nothing anyone on here is saying is going to change whatever the outcome is.
C'mon guys, believe me, life's to short!15 -
It's funny how at the beginning of transfer windows, you get a lot of LOLs and criticism for negativity.golfaddick said:We get the same trope every season. Players will be fitter & better than last year.
Who was it that had the players fitter than ever as they had noticed that they were running out of steam after 70 mins...Holden ?? How did THAT go last season.
And then the perennial "wait until the window closes before assessing the squad...". Thing is, once the window closes it's too late to do anything. At least Jones realises that. It just depends on whether the SMT/Andy Scott really do want to back him or just want to square the books.
If you take May out of the team you have to find 20+ goals from somewhere. Be it another 20+ striker (doubt it) or goals from elsewhere. Berry might chip in with more than Dobbo/Fraser/Bakinson did, but you still need to find those extra goals from somewhere.....and we haven't yet replaced CBT contribution either.
As the window progresses, your posts start to get more and more likes, and by the end of the window everyone is singing from your hymn sheet.
Every time.11 -
yes sir-ee. I'll obviously still follow the club, post on here & maybe even go to a couple of away games (for my son's sake) but I can't get my head around selling the Leagues top goal scorer when last season he was about the only player who knew where the goal was. Take away his and CBT's goals (who has also left the club & yet to be replaced) and where would we be.Starinnaddick said:
Are you still sticking to this?golfaddick said:
I've said I'm done if he goes.....and will only return once Nathan Jones leaves.ButtleJR said:https://x.com/natediazisking/status/1801318245544112479?t=VI0t42nyAfS--cQ9V1IzOA&s=19
Some people are rather dramatic aren't they... Not the first I've seen either.2 -
So, if Alfie goes, apart from following the club, posting on here, and going to games, you are done...🤔🤷♂️golfaddick said:
yes sir-ee. I'll obviously still follow the club, post on here & maybe even go to a couple of away games (for my son's sake) but I can't get my head around selling the Leagues top goal scorer when last season he was about the only player who knew where the goal was. Take away his and CBT's goals (who has also left the club & yet to be replaced) and where would we be.Starinnaddick said:
Are you still sticking to this?golfaddick said:
I've said I'm done if he goes.....and will only return once Nathan Jones leaves.ButtleJR said:https://x.com/natediazisking/status/1801318245544112479?t=VI0t42nyAfS--cQ9V1IzOA&s=19
Some people are rather dramatic aren't they... Not the first I've seen either.30 -
Yes....eastterrace6168 said:
So, if Alfie goes, apart from following the club, posting on here, and going to games, you are done...🤔🤷♂️golfaddick said:
yes sir-ee. I'll obviously still follow the club, post on here & maybe even go to a couple of away games (for my son's sake) but I can't get my head around selling the Leagues top goal scorer when last season he was about the only player who knew where the goal was. Take away his and CBT's goals (who has also left the club & yet to be replaced) and where would we be.Starinnaddick said:
Are you still sticking to this?golfaddick said:
I've said I'm done if he goes.....and will only return once Nathan Jones leaves.ButtleJR said:https://x.com/natediazisking/status/1801318245544112479?t=VI0t42nyAfS--cQ9V1IzOA&s=19
Some people are rather dramatic aren't they... Not the first I've seen either.
12 -
,0
-
What if we sell Alfie, use the cash to improve the squad as a whole are top at Christmas? Still not coming to games until NJ leaves?golfaddick said:
yes sir-ee. I'll obviously still follow the club, post on here & maybe even go to a couple of away games (for my son's sake) but I can't get my head around selling the Leagues top goal scorer when last season he was about the only player who knew where the goal was. Take away his and CBT's goals (who has also left the club & yet to be replaced) and where would we be.Starinnaddick said:
Are you still sticking to this?golfaddick said:
I've said I'm done if he goes.....and will only return once Nathan Jones leaves.ButtleJR said:https://x.com/natediazisking/status/1801318245544112479?t=VI0t42nyAfS--cQ9V1IzOA&s=19
Some people are rather dramatic aren't they... Not the first I've seen either.
Yes it would seem a strange decision but if it turns out to be the decision that allows us to improve and achieve our goals then surely its the right one?
Reactionary nonsense as usual.11 -
That would depend on who was playing in place of them, surely?golfaddick said:
yes sir-ee. I'll obviously still follow the club, post on here & maybe even go to a couple of away games (for my son's sake) but I can't get my head around selling the Leagues top goal scorer when last season he was about the only player who knew where the goal was. Take away his and CBT's goals (who has also left the club & yet to be replaced) and where would we be.Starinnaddick said:
Are you still sticking to this?golfaddick said:
I've said I'm done if he goes.....and will only return once Nathan Jones leaves.ButtleJR said:https://x.com/natediazisking/status/1801318245544112479?t=VI0t42nyAfS--cQ9V1IzOA&s=19
Some people are rather dramatic aren't they... Not the first I've seen either.I doubt they’d get as many goals though, whoever they were, but it wouldn’t be zero.0 -
Peterborough had a 20-30 goal striker at their club and barely started him last season.
They scored more goals as a team (89) last season than they did in either of the two previous seasons at this level where they relied on him for over 36% of their goals (31 of 83 & 26 of 75).
Football is a simple game in most ways but that doesn’t mean it’s as simple as taking out one player’s goal contributions and you can predict how a team will perform without them.BEFORE ANYONE JUMPS ON THIS TO SAY I’M BLAMING ALFIE FOR THE TEAM UNDERPERFORMING : I really am not, I’m trying to show that there is life in a football team with or without your previously profilic forward.23 - Sponsored links:
-
Suppose we’re flying high and sweeping everyone aside ? Wouldn’t you just be cutting you nose to spite your face and looking pretty foolish ?golfaddick said:
yes sir-ee. I'll obviously still follow the club, post on here & maybe even go to a couple of away games (for my son's sake) but I can't get my head around selling the Leagues top goal scorer when last season he was about the only player who knew where the goal was. Take away his and CBT's goals (who has also left the club & yet to be replaced) and where would we be.Starinnaddick said:
Are you still sticking to this?golfaddick said:
I've said I'm done if he goes.....and will only return once Nathan Jones leaves.ButtleJR said:https://x.com/natediazisking/status/1801318245544112479?t=VI0t42nyAfS--cQ9V1IzOA&s=19
Some people are rather dramatic aren't they... Not the first I've seen either.2 -
The fact of the matter is this is a gamble, Jones has to make his decisions then live and die by them.RoanRedNY said:Yann897 said:
It wouldn’t surprise me, heard rumours as soon as Jones came in that he wasn’t a fan of May and I think that was confirmed by the amount of times he was subbed and the signing of Wickham. Just have to trust the process at this point but I’d like to start seeing these signings come in.TheHerminator said:I'm going to stick my neck out and say that there's no way the seemingly rational new ownership, and our new manager who openly talks about getting promoted will sell Alfie.
Also why genuinely would Alfie want to go to another league one side? Because he knows the manager? I doubt they'll be offering him shed loads more than we are paying, and it would mean uprooting his family again
I’m not a professional football manager looking to rebuild a career that stalled at Southampton and stoke but if this is true it is a worry. Alfie scored more goals in 1 season than Wickham managed in 9 years. I wish jones all the best but “not liking” a guy whose goals kept us up despite being played wide right, attacking midfield and up front and always gave 100% was the sweetcorn in a pile of shite last year.
If we sell Alfie and sign two big lumps who arent prolific but we go up, the truth is, most fans wont even be talking about Alfie come June next year.
If he does sell him and we don't go up then quite rightly fans will be asking major questions.
Where as if we keep alfie and dont go up, then Jones will still be questioned. he probably thinks it best to either succeed or fail on his own terms, which as much as i like Alfie, is something i admire in Jones.2 -
ShootersHillGuru said:
Suppose we’re flying high and sweeping everyone aside ? Wouldn’t you just be cutting you nose to spite your face and looking pretty foolish ?golfaddick said:
yes sir-ee. I'll obviously still follow the club, post on here & maybe even go to a couple of away games (for my son's sake) but I can't get my head around selling the Leagues top goal scorer when last season he was about the only player who knew where the goal was. Take away his and CBT's goals (who has also left the club & yet to be replaced) and where would we be.Starinnaddick said:
Are you still sticking to this?golfaddick said:
I've said I'm done if he goes.....and will only return once Nathan Jones leaves.ButtleJR said:https://x.com/natediazisking/status/1801318245544112479?t=VI0t42nyAfS--cQ9V1IzOA&s=19
Some people are rather dramatic aren't they... Not the first I've seen either.
When you reach reality and reason, stop diggin' mate...waste of time0 -
Someone above alluded to the fact that FFP rules are different in the Championship to L1. If board are injecting equity to front load a promotion push, fair play.
Is a 32yo Alfie likely to be effective if we are promoted? No. The scenario only works if we buy strikers who can perform at a higher level. We will see.1 -
Like it.Oh Eddie Youds... said:If Alfie May goes and we’re not winning our first home game by 4 or more goals at HT, then I think we should chuck 3000 Alfie May beach balls on the pitch in the second half.
Blue Sky thinking right there.
Mind you if the first game is an away loss, the Beach Balls should commence at the first whistle at the home game.1 -
It's a good point, im sure ill get agg for saying it but we got relegated from the Prem with one of the most prolific strikers in the division.Callumcafc said:Peterborough had a 20-30 goal striker at their club and barely started him last season.
They scored more goals as a team (89) last season than they did in either of the two previous seasons at this level where they relied on him for over 36% of their goals (31 of 83 & 26 of 75).
Football is a simple game in most ways but that doesn’t mean it’s as simple as taking out one player’s goal contributions and you can predict how a team will perform without them.BEFORE ANYONE JUMPS ON THIS TO SAY I’M BLAMING ALFIE FOR THE TEAM UNDERPERFORMING : I really am not, I’m trying to show that there is life in a football team with or without your previously profilic forward.1 -
Ryan Hardie had 17 in all comps when Plymouth got promoted, there top goal scorer…0
-
Edwards doneross1 said:I keep reading that a player had a medical yesterday and other players the deal is done. When will we be told who and when the players have signed?1 -
sillav nitram said:Can May I just say, Alfie, so, that I can be part of the frenzy?1
-
Sammy Szmodicz had 20 for blackburn = finished 19thAberystwythAddick said:Ryan Hardie had 17 in all comps when Plymouth got promoted, there top goal scorer…
Morgan Whitaker 17 for plymouth = 21st
And last but not least Andy Johnson 20+ for Palace = still relegated.1 - Sponsored links:
-
I can't back this point enough.Callumcafc said:Peterborough had a 20-30 goal striker at their club and barely started him last season.
They scored more goals as a team (89) last season than they did in either of the two previous seasons at this level where they relied on him for over 36% of their goals (31 of 83 & 26 of 75).
Football is a simple game in most ways but that doesn’t mean it’s as simple as taking out one player’s goal contributions and you can predict how a team will perform without them.BEFORE ANYONE JUMPS ON THIS TO SAY I’M BLAMING ALFIE FOR THE TEAM UNDERPERFORMING : I really am not, I’m trying to show that there is life in a football team with or without your previously profilic forward.
Firstly I don't want Alfie to leave, not only because of his goals contribution, but his energy and personality as well - he is a player I just love to see and around that team.
But I just think football is much more nuanced than this and that ultimately no one knows if it is a good or bad decision until the season has finished.
If we sell Alfie, and get promoted with a 23 year old striker instead who can then perform in the Championship (which is what Jones vision is) then it is the right decision.
If we miss out, and it's because of goal contribution and not defence (which has been the problem the last two years), then it was a poor decision.
Until then, it is fine to have differing points, and having different points are not having an 'agenda' - but making sweeping views based on this one decision is just silly.
6 -
Brilliant post. Spot onCallumcafc said:Peterborough had a 20-30 goal striker at their club and barely started him last season.
They scored more goals as a team (89) last season than they did in either of the two previous seasons at this level where they relied on him for over 36% of their goals (31 of 83 & 26 of 75).
Football is a simple game in most ways but that doesn’t mean it’s as simple as taking out one player’s goal contributions and you can predict how a team will perform without them.BEFORE ANYONE JUMPS ON THIS TO SAY I’M BLAMING ALFIE FOR THE TEAM UNDERPERFORMING : really am not, I’m trying to show that there is life in a football team with or without your previously profilic forward.
2 -
What we need are goals spread out amongst the entire team a lot more - Ridiculous how our second top scorer didn't get into double figures last season, if my memory serves me right.Callumcafc said:Peterborough had a 20-30 goal striker at their club and barely started him last season.
They scored more goals as a team (89) last season than they did in either of the two previous seasons at this level where they relied on him for over 36% of their goals (31 of 83 & 26 of 75).
Football is a simple game in most ways but that doesn’t mean it’s as simple as taking out one player’s goal contributions and you can predict how a team will perform without them.BEFORE ANYONE JUMPS ON THIS TO SAY I’M BLAMING ALFIE FOR THE TEAM UNDERPERFORMING : I really am not, I’m trying to show that there is life in a football team with or without your previously profilic forward.0 -
“As long as” doing a shit load of heavy lifting there.eastterrace6168 said:
That's fine, as long as the club aren't also clueless...🤦♂️redbuttle said:I think it's actually quite good that us fans are clueless regarding transfers in or out this season until the club make announcements.0 -
@Admin, someone’s hacked into @Redmidland account.Redmidland said:I fully understand the 'angst' over Alfie, I also understand that in some quarters people don't trust or have faith in NJ and/or the new owners. However everytime I open CL there are numerous unread posts on the RUMOURS thread. I open it in eager anticipation of a rumour or even of a 'signing imminent' only to find ongoing discussions on Alfie, and his 'unkown' situation. Now I also get a few people want to express their opinions, BUT, it's the same stuff being regurgitated.
Let's wait and see what, if anything, transpires and perhaps in the meantime get back to rumours etc. Nothing anyone on here is saying is going to change whatever the outcome is.
C'mon guys, believe me, life's to short!#TooPostive #Cantbehim 😉3 -
Callum, I respect you a lot, you make some really good and interesting contributions to this forum.Callumcafc said:Peterborough had a 20-30 goal striker at their club and barely started him last season.
They scored more goals as a team (89) last season than they did in either of the two previous seasons at this level where they relied on him for over 36% of their goals (31 of 83 & 26 of 75).
Football is a simple game in most ways but that doesn’t mean it’s as simple as taking out one player’s goal contributions and you can predict how a team will perform without them.BEFORE ANYONE JUMPS ON THIS TO SAY I’M BLAMING ALFIE FOR THE TEAM UNDERPERFORMING : I really am not, I’m trying to show that there is life in a football team with or without your previously profilic forward.
But you might want to get your phone fixed, as it looks like the Caps lock button is stuck.2 -
I try and steer clear of reading too much about Charlton between the seasons as its mainly gossip and hysterics around rumours. However I've succumbed to looking with the bonkers rumour that May may go !If this is the case this really does round of a hatrick of f*** ups from CBT, Dobbo going and now May really?I can't get my head around why NJ wouldn't want a proven goal machine in the team and a player who runs his socks off for the team.However ultimately the only test which matters is next May, 2025we May be promoted, we May be in Play offs, We May be middle table, We May be even worse....4
-
The mental gymnastics on show trying to justify losing the league's top scorer are quite something.24
-
I am critical of the owners when they have been in the wrong, but for once we have decent ownership, that are trying to make this work, but for what ever reason, fans still have a negative outlook on it. The owners don’t want to sell May, but Jones can’t offer him a starting place week in week out, but apparently that’s the owners fault!JohnnyH2 said:
Would you like to tell me where I have done this?DubaiCAFC said:
That’s the attitude.. go to games, sit on your hands and moan all afternoon!!JohnnyH2 said:
Season not even started and already telling those who go on how they should supportDubaiCAFC said:
Positivity does have a huge impact on the way the team plays.. yes they need to give the crowd a lift, but negative atmosphere certainly impacts performance and players!Henry Irving said:
We all HOPE next season will be a good season but none of us know.DubaiCAFC said:Let’s face it, the squad hasn’t been good enough for last 3 seasons, and they included fan favourites, like it or not, they are haven’t been good enough for promotion, that is either ability or mentality or both! My comments not everyone will agree, but that is a fact. Personally I am excited by that changes behind the scenes, the attitude of jones, and the fact the clubs attitude is no one is bigger than the club.
negative people will always find holes they are not happy with.. this will be a good season, and will be a busy couple of weeks!
Im a big fan of NJ and think in him we potentially have a very good fit for our club. I'm cautiously optimistic about next season, with or without May.
But that doesn't mean your two statements aren't contradictory, because clearly they are.
Either players CAN be improved and their performance and that of the team improved or they are to be judged only on the teams finishing position.
No amount of positivity from fans changes that.Don’t see how they are contradictory, facts are, the players haven’t been good enough, so doesn’t both me if they go, and the ones that stay, need to do better!
You carry on spreading your messages and if it does not work this season ensure any blame gets pointed at all directions other than your source of your info, me I will carry on going/paying to go to games and supporting the team/club.As I have said, I pay for a season ticket still, plus Charlton TV so my opinion as valued as yours10 -
Not exactly mental gymnastics to understand the manager might want something different.Croydon said:The mental gymnastics on show trying to justify losing the league's top scorer are quite something.
No point scoring 2 goals a game if you're conceding 3. We have hardly any assets of value and if selling Alfie helps us reinvest across the board then I can get on board with it. Alfie is a fantastic player and I'd love to keep him, but how many times did we concede from set pieces this year? And more importantly, how many did we score? A bigger #9 is Nathan's previously preferred choice and helps at both ends of the pitch.2
This discussion has been closed.
