Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Charlton back up for sale - Guardian article comment from Gavin Carter p18

13468929

Comments

  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 21,112
    WSS said:
    fenaddick said:
    I don't necessarily think this is new news. When the £20m investment was first sought, there was an article which said we have asked MSD bank to find investors. They weren't the only ones. We had asked a fuckload of people in the banking/sports finance industry to get investment. As you do in something that is heavily commision-based. I know the director of one company that was asked, and he told me that as well as seeking £20m for 20%, the owners would also entertain offers for the whole shebang. Albeit he said there was no way we were worth £80m. My thoughts are that someone in this Oakwell group are merely passing on that same info.
    Asking for £80m would be mental
    That’s only 23 Harry Clarkes
    “We all dream of a club worth 23 Harry Clarkes”
  • balham red
    balham red Posts: 1,371
    follett said:
    Well this is far from ideal.
    The club has so much potential though, let’s hope any potential owners see that and we get someone decent and willing to invest 
    What potential do you mean? In the Championship we will be losing what, 15-20m per year?

    If we want to be challenging for promotion we need to spend even more on transfer fees.

    I don't blame these or any owners that don't fancy that. Its well known Methven sold it to them with a ridiculously optimistic turnaround plan.

    The business of football is a joke these days.
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 21,112
    Swisdom said:
    I know it’s easy to say in theory…but if you’re a billionaire then a few extra million is like you or I spending another £20 on something.  It’s fly dirt.

    So it’s worth more than when they bought it - fair enough.  But one extra step up and it’s worth £10x more.

    just seems strange to bail now.  It’s almost as though they didn’t do the research on what it costs once you get to The Championship.

    I was asked a year ago if i knew anybody who might be interested in buying into the club - not necessarily outright but that was also on the table as an option.  

    Apparently one of the owners looked at Scienza of Southampton and asked “why we don’t have someone like that”

    when he was told he would need to cough up around £10m and £50k a week he went very quiet.  I figured then that this present arrangement would not last long.
    Hilarious if accurate. What on earth did they think they were getting into?
  • fenaddick said:
    I don't necessarily think this is new news. When the £20m investment was first sought, there was an article which said we have asked MSD bank to find investors. They weren't the only ones. We had asked a fuckload of people in the banking/sports finance industry to get investment. As you do in something that is heavily commision-based. I know the director of one company that was asked, and he told me that as well as seeking £20m for 20%, the owners would also entertain offers for the whole shebang. Albeit he said there was no way we were worth £80m. My thoughts are that someone in this Oakwell group are merely passing on that same info.
    Asking for £80m would be mental
    That's what they valued it at when the investment call went out. Now we have survived our first season back, they may want more. FWIW the director I mentioned valued us at £47.5m-£52.5m if we stayed up...which we did. 
  • EastTerrace
    EastTerrace Posts: 4,104
    What we need is stability Sam not another set of owners (apart from the 10% chance they are really good).
    Terrible timing for this to break too.
  • ct_addick
    ct_addick Posts: 4,702
    sam3110 said:
    The outpouring of "we're doomed" "we're going down" "we're fucked" "we're skint" "Jones is gonna walk" "no wonder players want to leave/won't sign new contracts" in the past hour has just confirmed to me that there's a lot of Charlton fans on here that revel in misery and chaos, and can't wait to see the worst in everything
    Based upon the last 10 years or so who can blame the fans for being so pessimistic….we nearly lost our club 
  • SantaClaus
    SantaClaus Posts: 7,998
    Welcome back Roland we've missed you. 
  • cabbles
    cabbles Posts: 15,802
    The owners have got to be careful not to pull back all investment in the team.  It’s a lot easier to sell a team that is competing in the championship- doesn’t have to be chasing the playoffs, but does have to be a team not embroiled in a relegation scrap.  If the owners pull back all investment now and leave us with loans and frees for the remainder of the window, then there’s a very real chance they’ll be trying to sell an unattractive league one club who have to get out of that league once again.  

    If they have any understanding about the game and aren’t just a bunch of wealthy businessmen that have made a silly purchase, they should be doing all they can to help us stay up this season and protecting their investment and hope of a decent sale price 

  • Sponsored links:



  • Airman Brown
    Airman Brown Posts: 15,922
    The only “event” here is the leaking of a document. There hasn’t been a new decision to sell.


    Did you leak it ? If not who ? 
    If I’d had it I would certainly have published it myself. I didn’t but the fact that they were approaching people to try to sell the club isn’t new. 
  • sam3110
    sam3110 Posts: 24,270
    sam3110 said:
    The outpouring of "we're doomed" "we're going down" "we're fucked" "we're skint" "Jones is gonna walk" "no wonder players want to leave/won't sign new contracts" in the past hour has just confirmed to me that there's a lot of Charlton fans on here that revel in misery and chaos, and can't wait to see the worst in everything
    Strange take 
    Look at it across 4 different posts on here, so many comments about how we're already relegated or "no wonder players aren't signing new contracts" the hyperbole is absolutely insane
  • OhMyGodden
    OhMyGodden Posts: 414
    When I win Power Ball tonight it'll all be fine
  • FishCostaFortune
    FishCostaFortune Posts: 11,336
    The only “event” here is the leaking of a document. There hasn’t been a new decision to sell.


    Did you leak it ? If not who ? 
    If I’d had it I would certainly have published it myself. I didn’t but the fact that they were approaching people to try to sell the club isn’t new. 
    So why has it been leaked now?
  • panther10
    panther10 Posts: 396
    Can see a few players wanting out after this news 
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 21,112
    fenaddick said:
    I don't necessarily think this is new news. When the £20m investment was first sought, there was an article which said we have asked MSD bank to find investors. They weren't the only ones. We had asked a fuckload of people in the banking/sports finance industry to get investment. As you do in something that is heavily commision-based. I know the director of one company that was asked, and he told me that as well as seeking £20m for 20%, the owners would also entertain offers for the whole shebang. Albeit he said there was no way we were worth £80m. My thoughts are that someone in this Oakwell group are merely passing on that same info.
    Asking for £80m would be mental
    That's what they valued it at when the investment call went out. Now we have survived our first season back, they may want more. FWIW the director I mentioned valued us at £47.5m-£52.5m if we stayed up...which we did. 
    £80m would cover their costs with a little bit of profit. I know that’s what they’re asking for and I get why buts it’s naive. Then again, who thought TS could get £15m for us?
  • Rossman92
    Rossman92 Posts: 3,859
    sam3110 said:
    The outpouring of "we're doomed" "we're going down" "we're fucked" "we're skint" "Jones is gonna walk" "no wonder players want to leave/won't sign new contracts" in the past hour has just confirmed to me that there's a lot of Charlton fans on here that revel in misery and chaos, and can't wait to see the worst in everything
    I’m in the top 5% of happy clappers and I currently feel like I want to throw up

    Of course we need to wait and see and not jump to conclusions but the timing of this is just not good for the mind
  • golfaddick
    golfaddick Posts: 36,413
    That Cawley Substack about to come in handy 
    Save your £5. You might need it to help buy the club when a "fans consortium" is launched  !
  • 21cws
    21cws Posts: 240
    follett said:
    Well this is far from ideal.
    The club has so much potential though, let’s hope any potential owners see that and we get someone decent and willing to invest 
    What potential do you mean? In the Championship we will be losing what, 15-20m per year?

    If we want to be challenging for promotion we need to spend even more on transfer fees.

    I don't blame these or any owners that don't fancy that. Its well known Methven sold it to them with a ridiculously optimistic turnaround plan.

    The business of football is a joke these days.
    Well if that’s the case then may as well fold now and be done with football. 
  • oohaahmortimer
    oohaahmortimer Posts: 34,894
    Same old shit
    investment bollox 
    no twat is making a profit out of us ever 
    its just loss making , get to the prem and you will have to spunk fortunes to stay there as much as the money that comes in and more .
    expect to lose , only come in if you’re prepared to burn your money and have an ego trip (a shit one really ) 
    fucking clowns 
    pretty obvious with the guffageness of this window 
    thanks , for your time now fuck off and let’s get someone who wants to spend longer than 5 mins here .

  • Sponsored links:



  • luke1
    luke1 Posts: 207
    At least it’s pretty hard to be sold to another bunch of chancers. The current owners can’t flog us cheap and keep the stadium/training ground etc. if they want their money back then they are probably looking close to 50 mil. No chancers are paying that. I cannot see them getting an offer to make it viable. 
  • 2121
    2121 Posts: 1,699
    Nows the time as a fanbase to keep the positivity up in the ground 
  • Airman Brown
    Airman Brown Posts: 15,922
    The only “event” here is the leaking of a document. There hasn’t been a new decision to sell.


    Did you leak it ? If not who ? 
    If I’d had it I would certainly have published it myself. I didn’t but the fact that they were approaching people to try to sell the club isn’t new. 
    So why has it been leaked now?
    At the risk of stating the bleeding obvious, someone wanted it out there. Could be all sorts of motives for that.
  • oohaahmortimer
    oohaahmortimer Posts: 34,894
    Along will come the next set of fruit loops and the usual fawning over whoever owns us will begin 
    Groundhog Day 
    load of bollox 
    if you own us you’re losing money 
    we have minimal support , we’re  not a big club 
    just accept you’re gonna have to dig deep and spunk dough to see any success 
  • charltonbob
    charltonbob Posts: 8,836
    WTF brilliant timing, no wonder these "billionaires" aren't supporting NJ, Come on Jones we gave you a few million last year what do you mean you want to buy more players ? Well I've only read the first article, 6 pages to go through but while this lot have kept us turning over I've never been convinced about their intentions. They're obviously not crooks but I've never had the feeling that they were really "all in". Better pour myself a big drink & get reading.  :/
  • gringo
    gringo Posts: 1,333
    2121 said:
    Nows the time as a fanbase to keep the positivity up in the ground 
    any one know where we can quickly get loads of small balls to throw on the pitch?
  • closet_addick
    closet_addick Posts: 435
    Fuck's sakes.
    Well, here's to hoping our future owners care about the club and are willing to invest big time. 

    Ain't gonna lie, I'm a bit nervous for the new season now. 


  • AFKABartram
    AFKABartram Posts: 59,092
    21cws said:
    Someone ask Eddie Hearn to get on the blower to daddy Turki 👀😂
    I would genuinely hate that 
  • kimbo
    kimbo Posts: 3,023
    Oh FfS 
  • DoctorCharlton
    DoctorCharlton Posts: 2,533
    I know there are mentions of this document being leaked and that article states it has been seen by the Guardian…. but has anybody here seen it and is there anywhere we can see it?