Attention: Please take a moment to consider our terms and conditions before posting.

Charlton back up for sale - Guardian article comment from Gavin Carter p18

1212224262729

Comments

  • Henry Irving
    Henry Irving Posts: 86,827
    fenaddick said:
    TeeC said:
    With the oddities of WSL football finance, how much do we think the women’s promotion has maybe increased the urgency of this sale?

    It might have lessened our transfer budget on what matters most, the mens team.
    It’s brought £4m or so into the club so I doubt it 
    Would love to say that’s correct but don’t believe the figure is anywhere near that. A £65M deal over five years for the total WSL was announced in 2024.
    IIRC £4m was the maximum owners can put in over and above earned income.
  • Crispywood
    Crispywood Posts: 2,565
    If the owners are open to selling it’s not an issue. The only way it becomes a problem is if they start downing tools to actively maximise a profit 
  • fattmatt
    fattmatt Posts: 685
    We supposedly have billionaire owners who now in order to “progress” us need to find some more money from someone else. Sounds very much like they are unwilling to spend any more over and above their current levels and agreed commitments. Can’t say I’m enthusiastic about this current closing of the wallet.
    And how do you think billionaires become billionaires?

    Throwing millions of £ at tin pot football clubs isn't really on their bingo card. 
    What? They're buying Millwall too?
  • Covered_End_Lad
    Covered_End_Lad Posts: 6,056
    If the owners are open to selling it’s not an issue. The only way it becomes a problem is if they start downing tools to actively maximise a profit 
    Billionaires aren’t stupid, they will fully recognise the value of their asset will diminish massively if we get relegated
  • TeeC
    TeeC Posts: 327
    fenaddick said:
    TeeC said:
    With the oddities of WSL football finance, how much do we think the women’s promotion has maybe increased the urgency of this sale?

    It might have lessened our transfer budget on what matters most, the mens team.
    It’s brought £4m or so into the club so I doubt it 
    Would love to say that’s correct but don’t believe the figure is anywhere near that. A £65M deal over five years for the total WSL was announced in 2024.
    But am I right to assume that all told with required level of spending we’ll be worse off in the WSL than in WSL2?
  • Rothko
    Rothko Posts: 19,459
    Didn’t Matt Slater make up the £20m figure in March, all of which was going to be spent this window 
  • Jints
    Jints Posts: 3,643
    If the owners are open to selling it’s not an issue. The only way it becomes a problem is if they start downing tools to actively maximise a profit 
    More like minimise losses
  • sam3110
    sam3110 Posts: 24,270
    Rothko said:
    Didn’t Matt Slater make up the £20m figure in March, all of which was going to be spent this window 
    Is Matt Slater posting on here as Ronnie?!
  • Croydon
    Croydon Posts: 13,591
    Rothko said:
    So as Carter said, all businesses have a price, and if someone matches it, then cool
    When did he say that? 
  • Rothko
    Rothko Posts: 19,459
    Croydon said:
    Rothko said:
    So as Carter said, all businesses have a price, and if someone matches it, then cool
    When did he say that? 
    Early in the Cawley interview 

  • Sponsored links:



  • fenaddick said:
    TeeC said:
    With the oddities of WSL football finance, how much do we think the women’s promotion has maybe increased the urgency of this sale?

    It might have lessened our transfer budget on what matters most, the mens team.
    It’s brought £4m or so into the club so I doubt it 
    Really ? The women’s team have brought in £4m, how ? 
  • up_the_valley
    up_the_valley Posts: 4,635
    edited August 4
    If the owners are open to selling it’s not an issue. The only way it becomes a problem is if they start downing tools to actively maximise a profit 
    Billionaires aren’t stupid, they will fully recognise the value of their asset will diminish massively if we get relegated
    But equally  if they just want to get rid they can afford to, to prevent any further expenditure. 
  • sam3110
    sam3110 Posts: 24,270
    fenaddick said:
    TeeC said:
    With the oddities of WSL football finance, how much do we think the women’s promotion has maybe increased the urgency of this sale?

    It might have lessened our transfer budget on what matters most, the mens team.
    It’s brought £4m or so into the club so I doubt it 
    Really ? The women’s team have brought in £4m, how ? 
    It won't have brought in that much, but it will bring in substantially increased revenue compared to last season through TV money, ticket and merchandise sales and sponsorship stuff.
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 21,113
    sam3110 said:
    fenaddick said:
    TeeC said:
    With the oddities of WSL football finance, how much do we think the women’s promotion has maybe increased the urgency of this sale?

    It might have lessened our transfer budget on what matters most, the mens team.
    It’s brought £4m or so into the club so I doubt it 
    Really ? The women’s team have brought in £4m, how ? 
    It won't have brought in that much, but it will bring in substantially increased revenue compared to last season through TV money, ticket and merchandise sales and sponsorship stuff.
    Yeah I've already copped up to getting my numbers muddled. The grant for the pitch often goes forgotten too
  • Off_it
    Off_it Posts: 29,426
    sam3110 said:
    fenaddick said:
    TeeC said:
    With the oddities of WSL football finance, how much do we think the women’s promotion has maybe increased the urgency of this sale?

    It might have lessened our transfer budget on what matters most, the mens team.
    It’s brought £4m or so into the club so I doubt it 
    Really ? The women’s team have brought in £4m, how ? 
    It won't have brought in that much, but it will bring in substantially increased revenue compared to last season through TV money, ticket and merchandise sales and sponsorship stuff.
    But how much has it cost?

    "Bringing money in" is all fine, but if it's costing double what it brings in (just as an example) then it's still loss making!
  • fenaddick
    fenaddick Posts: 21,113
    Off_it said:
    sam3110 said:
    fenaddick said:
    TeeC said:
    With the oddities of WSL football finance, how much do we think the women’s promotion has maybe increased the urgency of this sale?

    It might have lessened our transfer budget on what matters most, the mens team.
    It’s brought £4m or so into the club so I doubt it 
    Really ? The women’s team have brought in £4m, how ? 
    It won't have brought in that much, but it will bring in substantially increased revenue compared to last season through TV money, ticket and merchandise sales and sponsorship stuff.
    But how much has it cost?

    "Bringing money in" is all fine, but if it's costing double what it brings in (just as an example) then it's still loss making!
    The men's side is loss making to the tune of £16m odd to be fair, the women's side can't be that bad!
  • DOUCHER
    DOUCHER Posts: 8,943
    wolfgang said:
    DOUCHER said:
    Be a lot easier if the current billionaire investors asked their wives if they wanted to buy in  
    That did not work well with Sandgaard.

    Was joking - why on earth would multi billionaires be looking for investors ? Maybe the new improved hospitality access from the west stand seats hasn’t generated the expected revenue bounce 🤷‍♂️
  • oohaahmortimer
    oohaahmortimer Posts: 34,894
    fenaddick said:
    Off_it said:
    sam3110 said:
    fenaddick said:
    TeeC said:
    With the oddities of WSL football finance, how much do we think the women’s promotion has maybe increased the urgency of this sale?

    It might have lessened our transfer budget on what matters most, the mens team.
    It’s brought £4m or so into the club so I doubt it 
    Really ? The women’s team have brought in £4m, how ? 
    It won't have brought in that much, but it will bring in substantially increased revenue compared to last season through TV money, ticket and merchandise sales and sponsorship stuff.
    But how much has it cost?

    "Bringing money in" is all fine, but if it's costing double what it brings in (just as an example) then it's still loss making!
    The men's side is loss making to the tune of £16m odd to be fair, the women's side can't be that bad!
    If the opportunity to be part of losing £16m doesn’t tempt all those bidders in next week I’ll be very surprised , please form an orderly queue to buy this incredible business of these extremely clever billionaires 
  • golfaddick
    golfaddick Posts: 36,413
    SDAddick said:

    Are Charlton going to have new owners soon?  Brener & Friedman have been looking for help/an exit for ages. They’ve got a new broker They’re looking for £50m+ but there are lots of clubs on market (that don’t involve dealing w/ Duchatelet!). Non-binding bids due next week.

    Matt Slater
    Senior news reporter
    @TheAthleticFC, ex BBC & Press Association.





    So in the end everybody was kind of right. They're looking for investors or a takeover overall. Bids apparently due next week. Wouldn't be surprised if that gets pushed back given they've been at this for a year or so apparently. 

    The question becomes what happens if they don't get bids, especially no bids for further investment (because I don't think they're going to get takeover bids)? Will they continue to invest in the squad this summer and beyond? Only time will tell.
    I think they will continue to "pay the bills" but anything above that then No. Imo any new player purchases will have to be funded by player sales. Hence why the midfielder & right winger that NJ talked about last week have failed to materialise. 

     I believe that they feel they have been sold a pup and are looking to get some of their money back. Either by an injection of capital from a new investor or by being bought out. 
    ..
  • As usual, the truth lies somewhere in the middle. The club hasn't denied that it's up for sale, but then every club is likely up for sale, at the right price!

    What I don't understand is this. Friedman & Brener are supposedly worth a combined sum in the region of $5.5 Billion.
    Why on earth do they even need to be seeking additional investment ?


  • Sponsored links:



  • Raith_C_Chattonell
    Raith_C_Chattonell Posts: 6,087
    edited August 5
    fenaddick said:
    fenaddick said:
    TeeC said:
    With the oddities of WSL football finance, how much do we think the women’s promotion has maybe increased the urgency of this sale?

    It might have lessened our transfer budget on what matters most, the mens team.
    It’s brought £4m or so into the club so I doubt it 
    Would love to say that’s correct but don’t believe the figure is anywhere near that. A £65M deal over five years for the total WSL was announced in 2024.
    Yeah I may have misremembered. I've had a mooch through a few WSL teams accounts over the last few years and broadcast revenue for non UEFA teams and I've found numbers of 500k, 750k & 1.7m which is quite broad. None of them are insignificant and will cover the transfer costs of the Women's team easily but I will put myself in finance jail for the night nonetheless!
    .
  • gringo
    gringo Posts: 1,333
    As usual, the truth lies somewhere in the middle. The club hasn't denied that it's up for sale, but then every club is likely up for sale, at the right price!

    What I don't understand is this. Friedman & Brener are supposedly worth a combined sum in the region of $5.5 Billion.
    Why on earth do they even need to be seeking additional investment ?

    Isnt it the case that they have $billions under their management but that its not actually their own money to spunk up a wall in SE7 as they choose?
  • Rothko
    Rothko Posts: 19,459
    Yep, Friedman runs the fund, it’s not all his cash, he’s wealthy, but he’s managing a lot of wealth. Berner wealth is around $600m from what I’ve seen, he’s always seemed closer to the club on a day to day basis. 
  • TheHerminator
    TheHerminator Posts: 1,330
    SDAddick said:

    Are Charlton going to have new owners soon?  Brener & Friedman have been looking for help/an exit for ages. They’ve got a new broker They’re looking for £50m+ but there are lots of clubs on market (that don’t involve dealing w/ Duchatelet!). Non-binding bids due next week.

    Matt Slater
    Senior news reporter
    @TheAthleticFC, ex BBC & Press Association.





    So in the end everybody was kind of right. They're looking for investors or a takeover overall. Bids apparently due next week. Wouldn't be surprised if that gets pushed back given they've been at this for a year or so apparently. 

    The question becomes what happens if they don't get bids, especially no bids for further investment (because I don't think they're going to get takeover bids)? Will they continue to invest in the squad this summer and beyond? Only time will tell.
    I think they will continue to "pay the bills" but anything above that then No. Imo any new player purchases will have to be funded by player sales. Hence why the midfielder & right winger that NJ talked about last week have failed to materialise. 

     I believe that they feel they have been sold a pup and are looking to get some of their money back. Either by an injection of capital from a new investor or by being bought out. 
    ..
    Based on what? Carter has come out and said the budget this year is the same as last for the right players. You believe he’s just lying? 
  • Chris_from_Sidcup
    Chris_from_Sidcup Posts: 37,645
    boggzy said:
    Just had a peep on the Spanners forum.

    Someone posted this. When it's laid out like this, it is absolutely fucking unbelievable really....


    They are with Owners like Watford are with Managers

    Belgium owner having them as a Feeder club to 2nd Division Belgium teams, sold the club for £1 (the buyers were robbed) without the Stadium and Training Ground
    Range Rover and Expensive Flat freeloading Owners complete with a Fake Sheikh, lasted a few months, robbed the club blind and piled up debt.
    American Danish Guitar playing Stoat fucking Medical equipment fraudster, now in the pokey in America
    Now some yanks who bought a League One club, sold the 5 year plan, but looking to flip the club at first opportunity now in the Championship

    And all since 2020
    Not had the best of luck with owners have we?

    It's actually a miracle that we've never gone into administration.

    In their defence though, the current owners have not been bad at all. Under their ownership (3 years) we've got out of league one and survived the first season in the championship. There are many clubs with good owners that haven't done that.

    Plus last summer we spent (wasted) about 11m on transfers and then spent another 1.5m in January for Sichenje.
  • TheHerminator
    TheHerminator Posts: 1,330
    As usual, the truth lies somewhere in the middle. The club hasn't denied that it's up for sale, but then every club is likely up for sale, at the right price!

    What I don't understand is this. Friedman & Brener are supposedly worth a combined sum in the region of $5.5 Billion.
    Why on earth do they even need to be seeking additional investment ?

    You do know they don’t actually have £5b right?

    Their assets and investments could be worth that much at any given time if they liquidated everything. 

    They could also be worth a lot less if the market turned on them.

    Very few people in the world are cash billionaires. 
  • CaptainRobbo
    CaptainRobbo Posts: 2,488
    Rothko said:
    Yep, Friedman runs the fund, it’s not all his cash, he’s wealthy, but he’s managing a lot of wealth. Berner wealth is around $600m from what I’ve seen, he’s always seemed closer to the club on a day to day basis. 
    Why can't we find some proper billionaires?
  • Chris_from_Sidcup
    Chris_from_Sidcup Posts: 37,645
    Rothko said:
    Didn’t Matt Slater make up the £20m figure in March, all of which was going to be spent this window 
    I've definitely missed this, but who is Matt Slater?
  • BigDiddy
    BigDiddy Posts: 1,475
    The current owners do not seem to want to put more money in and I can’t see how the club is worth that much when it has a relatively low value squad, no ground ownership and no other physical assets.

    The club is also losing money like most EFL clubs.

    Cant see how they will sell, unless at a real low price, especially if we have a bad season and NJ loses interest.

    Other than a lot of hope value, how much is our club really worth?
  • The Red Robin
    The Red Robin Posts: 28,442
    Rothko said:
    Didn’t Matt Slater make up the £20m figure in March, all of which was going to be spent this window 
    I've definitely missed this, but who is Matt Slater?
    Journalist at The Athletic